Supernova

they really thought josh did a great job?!?i thought it was awful....and they give lukas a hard time?!?

Creep sucked so bad.

pjalive21 wrote:

Lukas just regainded the thrown as the one to beat....that was real good

by the way for the comment above Josh isnt that bad he just doesnt fit the mold for this band, Josh is pure rock/funk...ive been to multiple shows of his in Manchester, NH and he is good/talented

that's what i meant...i can't take away from josh's talent,but for supernova??

Magni was simply amazing tonight. Dolphins Cry is fairly decent song with a full band - to get up there by yourself and simply own the entire place with your voice and your guitar and a song that is just pretty good... wow. I think that was the stand out performance of the night.


HOWEVER, Lukas did great with Creep. He almost lost me at the beginning but just shocked the hell out of me (in a good way) with the end third of the song. It was great. And he's such an freakin rockstar every other night - overindulgent, a bit cocky, everything I typically hate about rockstars, but I like him for some reason.

My picks - 1) I think this is Lukas' to lose... I think he best fits what this band will probably create musically 2) I hated her the first week, but I think Dilana is so increbily unique, and so comforatable on stage, that if they do pick a female, they'll definately go with her 3) For the darkhorse, I pick Magni. I think they will pass on him simply because they won't want to deal with him missing his family... I love the guy, I love that he's from Iceland, but I don't think Supernova will love it when he has an off night because he misses his family. But... you never know. He's great vocally.

Anyway, that's just my two cents. (P.S. Supernova really should spare the viewing audience and get rid of Zayra, Jill, and Ryan Starr this week. The first two simply cannot sing, and Ryan is just too much of a nut job to do anything useful.)

I do not think I can handle Dilana's voice anymore. It has gotten old fast. I did not like her singing the last 2 weeks. The 3 packs a day voice is wearing very thin on me.
Storm's personality is annoying as hell.
Jill sang Mother Mother good, but she does not fit.
Patrice is just plain bad.
We all know Zayra is there for potential shock value and entertainment...what will she do next...
I thought Toby did an awesom rendition of Burning Down the House
Magni was legit. I have been waitng for him to do Live.
Lukas...I can take it or leave it with him.
Josh sounds so nasal to me. I thought he sucked doing Nirvana in the early weeks and I think he did rather poor trying to do STP. I was down on it anyway because I hate when a band covers a song and puts 3 guitars where only one should be.
Ryan...well, I was surprised when they did not rip him tonight...

IMO, the bottom 3 this week should be Dilana, Josh and Zayra

I think its Dilana, Magne (sp), Lukas or Toby FTW.

LedZepFan wrote:

I liked Toby's performance tonight-he took a song I dislike and made me like it which is big in my book.

i'm not getting the toby love...seriously.he's really average at best for me.

for you dilana fans, get the wool off your eyes (err ears) ... she totally butchered another song, and this time it was a classic ... a classic that she never heard before. she "does her own thing", but it is horrible. please, stop the love, close your eyes and really listen ...

final 4 ... dilana (though not my choice), magni, ryan and lukas

look for a multi-axe this week ... time to get rid of the dead weight and move the show forward.

harrymanback wrote:

look for a multi-axe this week ... time to get rid of the dead weight and move the show forward.

can they do that??i didn't really watch the 1st season...if so,what the fuck have they waited for??

OK, is it just me, or was this the first week where Supernova did not universally rip on any one perfomance?

It seemed like everyone was getting loved on tonight with very few exceptions.