Getting kicked out of a band is one thing. Getting kicked out of a business that would never have you worry about money ever again is a different story.
I don’t think that tweet is bad. He wants to play a show with his old band. Not unusual.
yeah, I don't get the judgment dave gets constantly from this fan base of "move on". would you move on if basically millions of dollars were kind of snatched away from you in an instant? this isn't pining over an ex girlfriend. as you said, it's also the business side of it. missing out on touring the world, seeing exotic locations, playing in front of thousands of people every night.
Exactly.
Not to mention the popularity and legacy of the band was built upon the sound for which he was provided the rhythm and life force like blood flowing through veins.
Given To Fly type of songs isn’t want shot the band to the moon.
Dave A was not responsible for the popularity of Pearl Jam. Jesus Christ.
Getting kicked out of a band is one thing. Getting kicked out of a business that would never have you worry about money ever again is a different story.
I don’t think that tweet is bad. He wants to play a show with his old band. Not unusual.
yeah, I don't get the judgment dave gets constantly from this fan base of "move on". would you move on if basically millions of dollars were kind of snatched away from you in an instant? this isn't pining over an ex girlfriend. as you said, it's also the business side of it. missing out on touring the world, seeing exotic locations, playing in front of thousands of people every night.
Exactly.
Not to mention the popularity and legacy of the band was built upon the sound for which he was provided the rhythm and life force like blood flowing through veins.
Given To Fly type of songs isn’t want shot the band to the moon.
Dave A was not responsible for the popularity of Pearl Jam. Jesus Christ.
He wasn't either. I think his counterpart, Little Nicky, may have played a larger part than Jesus.
Also what memorable acts has Dave been in since Pearl Jam?
Guns N' Roses.
Riddle me this Batman -- Name another Pearl Jam member who has been in a band as memorable as Guns N' Roses?
Guns N' Roses memorable for sure, but not always for the right reasons. Enlighten me this Spiritual Chaos --- Wasn't late 90's more memorable for GnRs for not making music and being late or no shows for concerts than anything else? Also wasn't Jack Irons more substantial for RHCP (who actually created music throughout their career vs. GnR) in their early years than Dave was after PJ fired him?
Late 90s was more memorable for GoldenEye on the Nintendo 64, The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill, the last theatrical outing in the franchise: Hellraiser: Bloodline and Axl Rose being so hurt by Dave A leaving he had to destroy an aquarium.
No one remembers late 90's GnRs with Dave A. Lauryn Hill killed it then. Radiohead's OK Computer was revolutionizing the industry. Hell, even Marcy's Playground and The Verve were doing better things than GnRs at that point. Goldeneye was the best videogame at the time. Also Yield killed it with Jack Irons! Axl Rose was just hurt by his own massive ego. Dude I love listening to old bootlegs with Dave A behind the kit. But he's not the reason why this band is still incredible to listen to to this day. With or without their flaws.
Getting kicked out of a band is one thing. Getting kicked out of a business that would never have you worry about money ever again is a different story.
I don’t think that tweet is bad. He wants to play a show with his old band. Not unusual.
yeah, I don't get the judgment dave gets constantly from this fan base of "move on". would you move on if basically millions of dollars were kind of snatched away from you in an instant? this isn't pining over an ex girlfriend. as you said, it's also the business side of it. missing out on touring the world, seeing exotic locations, playing in front of thousands of people every night.
Exactly.
Not to mention the popularity and legacy of the band was built upon the sound for which he was provided the rhythm and life force like blood flowing through veins.
Given To Fly type of songs isn’t want shot the band to the moon.
Dave A was not responsible for the popularity of Pearl Jam. Jesus Christ.
Dave was one of many drummers who auditioned for GnR when it was Axl reassembling a band.
Apparently at the time he wanted to “obtain a sound between Nine Inch Nails and Pearl Jam“ which makes sense why he called members of those bands to audition.
DC '03 - Reading '04 - Philly '05 - Camden 1 '06 - DC '06 - E. Rutherford '06 - The Vic '07 - Lollapalooza '07 - DC '08 - EV DC 1 & 2 '08 (Met Ed!!) - EV Baltimore 1 & 2 '09 - EV NYC 1 '11 (Met Ed!) - Hartford '13 - GCF '15 - MSG 2 '16 - TOTD MSG '16 - Boston 1 & 2 '18 - SHN '21 - EV NYC 1 & 2 '22 - MSG '22
Hugh Freaking Dillon is currently out of the office, returning sometime in the fall after a very restful summer exploring the Great Canadian Wilderness and beaches, listening to Pearl Jam, Headstones, Watchmen, Queens of the Stone Age, and many others.
In my absence, please refer to the following for any reasoned debate on any given matter (please note this list is not exhaustive):
Getting kicked out of a band is one thing. Getting kicked out of a business that would never have you worry about money ever again is a different story.
I don’t think that tweet is bad. He wants to play a show with his old band. Not unusual.
yeah, I don't get the judgment dave gets constantly from this fan base of "move on". would you move on if basically millions of dollars were kind of snatched away from you in an instant? this isn't pining over an ex girlfriend. as you said, it's also the business side of it. missing out on touring the world, seeing exotic locations, playing in front of thousands of people every night.
Exactly.
Not to mention the popularity and legacy of the band was built upon the sound for which he was provided the rhythm and life force like blood flowing through veins.
Given To Fly type of songs isn’t want shot the band to the moon.
Dave A was not responsible for the popularity of Pearl Jam. Jesus Christ.
That’s not what he said. There’s a lot to be said for how much energy he helped deliver in those early shows. Next to Ed, there’s really no one more important in that aspect.
What I find much odder than Dave A’s hangup, is the vitriol directed at him.
Getting kicked out of a band is one thing. Getting kicked out of a business that would never have you worry about money ever again is a different story.
I don’t think that tweet is bad. He wants to play a show with his old band. Not unusual.
yeah, I don't get the judgment dave gets constantly from this fan base of "move on". would you move on if basically millions of dollars were kind of snatched away from you in an instant? this isn't pining over an ex girlfriend. as you said, it's also the business side of it. missing out on touring the world, seeing exotic locations, playing in front of thousands of people every night.
Exactly.
Not to mention the popularity and legacy of the band was built upon the sound for which he was provided the rhythm and life force like blood flowing through veins.
Given To Fly type of songs isn’t want shot the band to the moon.
Dave A was not responsible for the popularity of Pearl Jam. Jesus Christ.
That’s not what he said. There’s a lot to be said for how much energy he helped deliver in those early shows. Next to Ed, there’s really no one more important in that aspect.
What I find much odder than Dave A’s hangup, is the vitriol directed at him.
I think it goes both ways. On my videos that I post, there are countless posts extolling Dave and hammering MC. To me, he had his time and place and it was great. But that's over. PJ decided either (or both) 1. That couldn't get along with Dave and his views 2. They wanted to be a guitar driven band, and the drums Dave played were the driving force, with Ed's lyrics. That's not their style and maybe they didn't want it to be that way.
My impression was that was always about personality and zero about style. But I'm not a member of PJ, so I suppose my impression means very little. lol
Hugh Freaking Dillon is currently out of the office, returning sometime in the fall after a very restful summer exploring the Great Canadian Wilderness and beaches, listening to Pearl Jam, Headstones, Watchmen, Queens of the Stone Age, and many others.
In my absence, please refer to the following for any reasoned debate on any given matter (please note this list is not exhaustive):
My impression was that was always about personality and zero about style. But I'm not a member of PJ, so I suppose my impression means very little. lol
Well we know that MC can lead a band, he certainly does in plenty of SG songs. And everyone has commented/noticed how different his style is in PJ vs SG. I had always assumed that was deliberate and how the band wanted it to be.
My impression was that was always about personality and zero about style. But I'm not a member of PJ, so I suppose my impression means very little. lol
Well we know that MC can lead a band, he certainly does in plenty of SG songs. And everyone has commented/noticed how different his style is in PJ vs SG. I had always assumed that was deliberate and how the band wanted it to be.
I mean about Dave being fired. Are you saying they fired Dave A because they had Matt lined up because they preferred his style?
Hugh Freaking Dillon is currently out of the office, returning sometime in the fall after a very restful summer exploring the Great Canadian Wilderness and beaches, listening to Pearl Jam, Headstones, Watchmen, Queens of the Stone Age, and many others.
In my absence, please refer to the following for any reasoned debate on any given matter (please note this list is not exhaustive):
My impression was that was always about personality and zero about style. But I'm not a member of PJ, so I suppose my impression means very little. lol
Well we know that MC can lead a band, he certainly does in plenty of SG songs. And everyone has commented/noticed how different his style is in PJ vs SG. I had always assumed that was deliberate and how the band wanted it to be.
I mean about Dave being fired. Are you saying they fired Dave A because they had Matt lined up because they preferred his style?
My impression was that was always about personality and zero about style. But I'm not a member of PJ, so I suppose my impression means very little. lol
Well we know that MC can lead a band, he certainly does in plenty of SG songs. And everyone has commented/noticed how different his style is in PJ vs SG. I had always assumed that was deliberate and how the band wanted it to be.
I mean about Dave being fired. Are you saying they fired Dave A because they had Matt lined up because they preferred his style?
My impression was that was always about personality and zero about style. But I'm not a member of PJ, so I suppose my impression means very little. lol
Well we know that MC can lead a band, he certainly does in plenty of SG songs. And everyone has commented/noticed how different his style is in PJ vs SG. I had always assumed that was deliberate and how the band wanted it to be.
I mean about Dave being fired. Are you saying they fired Dave A because they had Matt lined up because they preferred his style?
They hired Matt after Jack left, no?
sorry, yes, I misspoke. lol
Hugh Freaking Dillon is currently out of the office, returning sometime in the fall after a very restful summer exploring the Great Canadian Wilderness and beaches, listening to Pearl Jam, Headstones, Watchmen, Queens of the Stone Age, and many others.
In my absence, please refer to the following for any reasoned debate on any given matter (please note this list is not exhaustive):
My impression was that was always about personality and zero about style. But I'm not a member of PJ, so I suppose my impression means very little. lol
Well we know that MC can lead a band, he certainly does in plenty of SG songs. And everyone has commented/noticed how different his style is in PJ vs SG. I had always assumed that was deliberate and how the band wanted it to be.
I mean about Dave being fired. Are you saying they fired Dave A because they had Matt lined up because they preferred his style?
No... not A+B. I'm saying there could be more than just the personality issue behind the move. It may have been a dissatisfaction with the style considering it changed so dramatically after he left (live shows).
There seems to be a clear reason why his drumming career didn't continue to flourish after the band. Since his departure, I'm sure there are hundreds of bands that could have used a new drummer, and one who used to be in the biggest band in the world. Pretty sure it has to do with Dave...and not his skillset.
There seems to be a clear reason why his drumming career didn't continue to flourish after the band. Since his departure, I'm sure there are hundreds of bands that could have used a new drummer, and one who used to be in the biggest band in the world. Pretty sure it has to do with Dave...and not his skillset.
This is something I've always found so confusing. it's pretty rare for a musician to get fired or quit a massive band and not get picked up somewhere else. but don't you think, if it is what you are suggesting, it would be kind of a well known opinion, and not just conjecture on our part?
Hugh Freaking Dillon is currently out of the office, returning sometime in the fall after a very restful summer exploring the Great Canadian Wilderness and beaches, listening to Pearl Jam, Headstones, Watchmen, Queens of the Stone Age, and many others.
In my absence, please refer to the following for any reasoned debate on any given matter (please note this list is not exhaustive):
There seems to be a clear reason why his drumming career didn't continue to flourish after the band. Since his departure, I'm sure there are hundreds of bands that could have used a new drummer, and one who used to be in the biggest band in the world. Pretty sure it has to do with Dave...and not his skillset.
This is something I've always found so confusing. it's pretty rare for a musician to get fired or quit a massive band and not get picked up somewhere else. but don't you think, if it is what you are suggesting, it would be kind of a well known opinion, and not just conjecture on our part?
People with class don't talk about the negatives of another musician like that, out in the open. Now, plenty of people don't have class, so sure, maybe more would be in the public ear about it, but mostly I'd guess it's the kind of thing where you just choose not to engage and keep it moving. That's my guess for why, if that's also part of why he wasn't in any other successful bands, why we might not hear about it if it was his personality or his playing or both.
Definitely seems that's why PJ rarely comments on it and never talks about negatives in ages... At the time of his departure though, of course questions are going to be asked and obviously something was wrong, or else why make the change. But what the details were, and how it's seen now, and why he didn't get picked up by other successful bands.... who knows, but musicians with class won't comment on it publicly.
Dave A is a sweet guy and I don't get why any PJ fan has anything negative to say about him. Dave was so nice to fans so how about lets just drop this. I would love to see him sit in one day. If you don"t have something nice to say about him just keep it to yourself its not like anything posted here is going to make a difference in the matter anyway.
1st. Cant believe this thread made it to 5 pages. 2nd and this constantly comes up with the regs on fan board- always reminiscing, taking for granted all we have. We are LUCKY to have Matt.
Comments
Dave A was not responsible for the popularity of Pearl Jam. Jesus Christ.
http://www.hi5sports.org/ (Sports Program for Kids with Disabilities)
http://www.livefootsteps.org/user/?usr=3652
Uncle rico
astoria 06
albany 06
hartford 06
reading 06
barcelona 06
paris 06
wembley 07
dusseldorf 07
nijmegen 07
this song is meant to be called i got shit,itshould be called i got shit tickets-hartford 06 -
In my absence, please refer to the following for any reasoned debate on any given matter (please note this list is not exhaustive):
@mrussel1 , @Go Beavers , @tbergs, @mickeyrat, @brianlux, @PJ_Soul, @The Juggler, @Gern Blansten
What I find much odder than Dave A’s hangup, is the vitriol directed at him.
In my absence, please refer to the following for any reasoned debate on any given matter (please note this list is not exhaustive):
@mrussel1 , @Go Beavers , @tbergs, @mickeyrat, @brianlux, @PJ_Soul, @The Juggler, @Gern Blansten
In my absence, please refer to the following for any reasoned debate on any given matter (please note this list is not exhaustive):
@mrussel1 , @Go Beavers , @tbergs, @mickeyrat, @brianlux, @PJ_Soul, @The Juggler, @Gern Blansten
There are no kings inside the gates of eden
In my absence, please refer to the following for any reasoned debate on any given matter (please note this list is not exhaustive):
@mrussel1 , @Go Beavers , @tbergs, @mickeyrat, @brianlux, @PJ_Soul, @The Juggler, @Gern Blansten
www.cluthelee.com
www.cluthe.com
In my absence, please refer to the following for any reasoned debate on any given matter (please note this list is not exhaustive):
@mrussel1 , @Go Beavers , @tbergs, @mickeyrat, @brianlux, @PJ_Soul, @The Juggler, @Gern Blansten
Definitely seems that's why PJ rarely comments on it and never talks about negatives in ages... At the time of his departure though, of course questions are going to be asked and obviously something was wrong, or else why make the change. But what the details were, and how it's seen now, and why he didn't get picked up by other successful bands.... who knows, but musicians with class won't comment on it publicly.
The Golden Age is 2 months away. And guess what….. you’re gonna love it! (teskeinc 11.19.24)
1998: Noblesville; 2003: Noblesville; 2009: EV Nashville, Chicago, Chicago
2010: St Louis, Columbus, Noblesville; 2011: EV Chicago, East Troy, East Troy
2013: London ON, Wrigley; 2014: Cincy, St Louis, Moline (NO CODE)
2016: Lexington, Wrigley #1; 2018: Wrigley, Wrigley, Boston, Boston
2020: Oakland, Oakland: 2021: EV Ohana, Ohana, Ohana, Ohana
2022: Oakland, Oakland, Nashville, Louisville; 2023: Chicago, Chicago, Noblesville
2024: Noblesville, Wrigley, Wrigley, Ohana, Ohana; 2025: Pitt1, Pitt2
its not like anything posted here is going to make a difference in the matter anyway.
If you don't agree with me, how about this - don't post.
This place is always good for some laughs.