Purpose for USA??

pandora

Wow all I have to say is the Op is one brave person, I really admire that.
I've enjoyed the read and the positive proud our OP always gives us.
An example of the very good America has to offer.
Thank you!

Am I hearing jealousy in the responses? I try to identity the emotion because it is clearly
not an unemotional debate. There seems to be some insults even :?
this really speaks for itself.

fear4freedom

pandora wrote:

Wow all I have to say is the Op is one brave person, I really admire that.
I've enjoyed the read and the positive proud our OP always gives us.
An example of the very good America has to offer.
Thank you!

Am I hearing jealousy in the responses? I try to identity the emotion because it is clearly
not an unemotional debate. There seems to be some insults even :?
this really speaks for itself.

Im getting tired here defending the good things of the world....so im off to THE TRAINS LOUNGE CAR, then THE CABOOSE for awhile!

Moonpig

Some of you really need to step outside of your bubbles. I have travelled all over the world, seen many places, and I can say with certainty that I am not jealous of anything your country has to offer. I mean that doesn't even make sense, but I suppose that amounts to the debating skills of some on here.

Is it at all possible that America is nothing more, nor less, than another country. Nationalistic people all over the world believe their country is the best, so this type of crap is nothing new. So please enough of the tired old rhetoric, please educate yourself on other cultures before you pass judgment.

pandora

fear4freedom wrote:

pandora wrote:

Wow all I have to say is the Op is one brave person, I really admire that.
I've enjoyed the read and the positive proud our OP always gives us.
An example of the very good America has to offer.
Thank you!

Am I hearing jealousy in the responses? I try to identity the emotion because it is clearly
not an unemotional debate. There seems to be some insults even :?
this really speaks for itself.

Im getting tired here defending the good things of the world....so im off to THE TRAINS LOUNGE CAR, then THE CABOOSE for awhile!

:thumbup:

Hugh Freaking Dillon

pandora wrote:

Wow all I have to say is the Op is one brave person, I really admire that.
I've enjoyed the read and the positive proud our OP always gives us.
An example of the very good America has to offer.
Thank you!

Am I hearing jealousy in the responses? I try to identity the emotion because it is clearly
not an unemotional debate. There seems to be some insults even :?
this really speaks for itself.

again, no one is jealous of the US. if we were, we'd move there. and I don't want to and never will.

and as to your last statement, many find the lies that people tell about how great the US is to the rest of the world insulting. that really speaks for itself.

fear4freedom

Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:

pandora wrote:

Wow all I have to say is the Op is one brave person, I really admire that.
I've enjoyed the read and the positive proud our OP always gives us.
An example of the very good America has to offer.
Thank you!

Am I hearing jealousy in the responses? I try to identity the emotion because it is clearly
not an unemotional debate. There seems to be some insults even :?
this really speaks for itself.

again, no one is jealous of the US. if we were, we'd move there. and I don't want to and never will.

and as to your last statement, many find the lies that people tell about how great the US is to the rest of the world insulting. that really speaks for itself.

NOONE? how can you speak for others feelings?
Move there? Many do and many want to, especially all the border jumpers!
Lies? Ever think that half of the lies you hear....might be true? Just a thought
Insulting? Look the only reason we stick up for the USA so much on AMT, is cause USA gets torn down the most

someone has to do it....i mean what would the train be like without people like us? It would be boring!

Im sure everything we say isnt a lie....therefore we bring legitamacy to this train. Without us....its a big biased train with no balance! So thank us once in awhile! LOL

Hugh Freaking Dillon

fear4freedom wrote:

Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:

pandora wrote:

Wow all I have to say is the Op is one brave person, I really admire that.
I've enjoyed the read and the positive proud our OP always gives us.
An example of the very good America has to offer.
Thank you!

Am I hearing jealousy in the responses? I try to identity the emotion because it is clearly
not an unemotional debate. There seems to be some insults even :?
this really speaks for itself.

again, no one is jealous of the US. if we were, we'd move there. and I don't want to and never will.

and as to your last statement, many find the lies that people tell about how great the US is to the rest of the world insulting. that really speaks for itself.

NOONE? how can you speak for others feelings?
Move there? Many do and many want to, especially all the border jumpers!
Lies? Ever think that half of the lies you hear....might be true? Just a thought
Insulting? Look the only reason we stick up for the USA so much on AMT, is cause USA gets torn down the most

someone has to do it....i mean what would the train be like without people like us? It would be boring!

Im sure everything we say isnt a lie....therefore we bring legitamacy to this train. Without us....its a big biased train with no balance! So thank us once in awhile! LOL

I wasn't speaking for everyone. I was speaking for myself and for those in this thread. if' I'm incorrect, I'm sure they'll correct me.

no one needs to be knocked from their tower if they weren't shouting from it in the first place. think about that.

Moonpig

fear4freedom wrote:

Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:

pandora wrote:

Wow all I have to say is the Op is one brave person, I really admire that.
I've enjoyed the read and the positive proud our OP always gives us.
An example of the very good America has to offer.
Thank you!

Am I hearing jealousy in the responses? I try to identity the emotion because it is clearly
not an unemotional debate. There seems to be some insults even :?
this really speaks for itself.

again, no one is jealous of the US. if we were, we'd move there. and I don't want to and never will.

and as to your last statement, many find the lies that people tell about how great the US is to the rest of the world insulting. that really speaks for itself.

NOONE? how can you speak for others feelings?
Move there? Many do and many want to, especially all the border jumpers!
Lies? Ever think that half of the lies you hear....might be true? Just a thought
Insulting? Look the only reason we stick up for the USA so much on AMT, is cause USA gets torn down the most

someone has to do it....i mean what would the train be like without people like us? It would be boring!

Im sure everything we say isnt a lie....therefore we bring legitamacy to this train. Without us....its a big biased train with no balance! So thank us once in awhile! LOL

Man you have to give this wounded animal crap a rest. Nearly everyone on here has stated more than once that they do not hate america. And yet you persist with it.

How do you define greatest country, because by most verifiable sources America ranks pretty poorly when looking at healthcare, standard of living, education etc etc

Now these are facts, not emotions, or how I feel, but substansiated fact.

pandora

Listen... it sounds like hate. :?

pandora

fear4freedom wrote:

NOONE? how can you speak for others feelings?
Move there? Many do and many want to, especially all the border jumpers!
Lies? Ever think that half of the lies you hear....might be true? Just a thought
Insulting? Look the only reason we stick up for the USA so much on AMT, is cause USA gets torn down the most

someone has to do it....i mean what would the train be like without people like us? It would be boring!

Im sure everything we say isnt a lie....therefore we bring legitamacy to this train. Without us....its a big biased train with no balance! So thank us once in awhile! LOL

Another positive post! Takes it and turns it just the right way
thank you this, it is a blessing for us all.
Your heart is great just cancels the negativity

Hugh Freaking Dillon

pandora wrote:

Listen... it sounds like hate. :?

what hate?

fear4freedom

Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:

pandora wrote:

Listen... it sounds like hate. :?

what hate?

I apologize if I ever used the word HATE cause its a strong word and it defines others with a negative tone. I will definately try harder in 2013 to not use negative words with such powerful meaning. Im gonna spend one month trying to lift up other nations right now....it will be a good thing for me to do....as I have spent too much time defending America....time to change up....it will be nice to do for awhile

Hugh Freaking Dillon

fear4freedom wrote:

Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:

pandora wrote:

Listen... it sounds like hate. :?

what hate?

I apologize if I ever used the word HATE cause its a strong word and it defines others with a negative tone. I will definately try harder in 2013 to not use negative words with such powerful meaning. Im gonna spend one month trying to lift up other nations right now....it will be a good thing for me to do....as I have spent too much time defending America....time to change up....it will be nice to do for awhile

you don't have to lift up other nations, just as you don't have to defend america. no one is trashing america. people question the government's motives and practices, that is ALL. I do the same with my own government, but for the most part, if it's not about america on this website, or the mid east, it's generally not discussed.

that's just the way it is.

Moonpig

fear4freedom wrote:

Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:

pandora wrote:

Listen... it sounds like hate. :?

what hate?

I apologize if I ever used the word HATE cause its a strong word and it defines others with a negative tone. I will definately try harder in 2013 to not use negative words with such powerful meaning. Im gonna spend one month trying to lift up other nations right now....it will be a good thing for me to do....as I have spent too much time defending America....time to change up....it will be nice to do for awhile

:fp:

do yourself a favor, travel to a few other countries, get a chance to experience their culture.

Utterly utterly astounding

fear4freedom

I apologize if I ever used the word HATE cause its a strong word and it defines others with a negative tone. I will definately try harder in 2013 to not use negative words with such powerful meaning. Im gonna spend one month trying to lift up other nations right now....it will be a good thing for me to do....as I have spent too much time defending America....time to change up....it will be nice to do for awhile[/quote]

:fp:

do yourself a favor, travel to a few other countries, get a chance to experience their culture.

Utterly utterly astounding[/quote]

I would love to visit Austrailia and New Zealand and The Phillippines! Africa and Europe are also on my list.
I dont have the money to do so, but I would agree there is alot out there.

I have good friends from all over the world. I live in DC and much of the cultures of the world come here and I get to see and learn alot right here.

Drowned Out

fear4freedom wrote:

NOONE? how can you speak for others feelings?
Move there? Many do and many want to, especially all the border jumpers!
Lies? Ever think that half of the lies you hear....might be true? Just a thought
Insulting? Look the only reason we stick up for the USA so much on AMT, is cause USA gets torn down the most

Esp the border jumpers? Same shit here....black and white (red/white/blue) thinking.
Do you think Mexicans have much choice when determining which country they're going to go to when their lives become bad enough at home? And - do you see no corelation between US policy and immigration? All the same patterns - destroyed agricultural industries and all the refugees this creates. Backing of 'terrorist' organizations to further US/Western interests - in Mexico's case the 'terrorists' are drug cartels - so...one of the US's most successful exports - the war on drugs - helps to make your bed in regards to illegal immigration. Those are only two examples of causes from the last few decades. Immigration is not proof of US exceptionalism. It's proof that there is more work, and better conditions for the poor than in Mexico. yay USA.
Why do tens of thousands of americans immigrate to Canada every year? Did god determine that Canada is blessed, just not quite as blessed, because we have a constitutional monarchy?

It seems like you want to focus on the postitive to the point that you're willing to overlook your role in the negative.
You didn't start this thread to defend america....you started it with the intent of setting america apart...now you cry that people are singling you out. You didn't ask for positive opinions about the US...you began with the premise of exceptionalism, even divinity - to most people outside your country, that is the exact cause of labels like 'ugly americans' or 'american arrogance'.

As hugh touched on, we approach this from different angles. You're coming at this from a position of a nationalist supporter of the state, its leaders and their ideologies......while others approach this from the position of critic of all of those things, from all countries, NOT just yours. The US is the dominant world power, so it follows that criticism of the US will dominate discussion. Can't help but be amused that some of you take it so personally (then have the nerve to call us jealous )......if you criticize the government of Canada for it's human rights violations, it's unfair trade policies, it's treatment of aboriginals, it's environmental crimes, etc etc, I would not sit here complaining that people are picking on my country. It is our job to criticize our governments and stand up to injustice. But look! rainbows and lollipops....

chadwick

usa is a huge pain in the fucking keester for many countries.

we waste so much materials & food goods in this country it is unreal. some say we take care of the poor & hungry all around the globe. what about our own fucking people? we have a huge problem. it's called, "dumb as fuck" we are ran by bullshit artists in DC and state capitals & the like. they are out of touch; a great deal of the folks in politics haven't a clue about being poor or not having money to pay their bills. the elected officials in the united states of america are professional scam artists, professional bullshit & horse shit artists & they do not give a fat fuck about much of anything unless it benefits them & their cronies.

they are in postions of authority hundreds of years old & very corrupt & maybe just maybe every once in awhile one or two of them are what we the people truly need

the u.s.a. is a bullshit act. but it's home & we have to try & make the best of it. in the process some may do well, some may get by, others may suffer from poverty or illnesses untreated due to lack of insurance and or capital.

unless you got greenbacks you are a nobody in the good ol' u. s. of a

trust 'em in D.C.
they have your priorities in line & are working on them first & foremost.
they are not corrupt in the slightest....

fear4freedom

just for the record I agree with many of you in some way! I love many countries, Canada, Austrailia, New Zealand, Philippines, Japan, and many many others. I do however believe that there are truly evil intended nations. I just dont see how some people can give true evil a pass, yet they point out some of what the USA does as evil. North Korea is evil! FACT! Iran's leaders have evil intentions, just listen to their speeches. Words from them prove who they are, how they think and what they seek. Venezuela could go either way....after Hugo is gone, they will have a choice...and I pray they go the good way and embrace freedom and human rights. Cuba could also go either way. Russia does alot behind the scenes that is very questionable. Im sure the policies of the USA are questionable to many of you, however we are the force of good for this world! If we were truly evil, you know for a fact we would have done many things that would have blown the entire world's mind away. We could have taken Cuba, Mexico and Canada! You know we could have taken much of the world and called it ours....but we didnt even take a little enemy just off the coast of Florida, cause we try to lead by example. If Taiwan had nukes and threatened to shoot them at China, you think China would leave them alone? You think Russia would allow a Cuba near them? NO

Also, noone nation is perfect, and I think if you are on the stage that the USA is on, there will be inherent observations of negative perceptions, no matter what. You cant make everyone happy and not everyone pays attention enough to understand whats even going on.

chadwick

so what is the united states of americas purpose? the same as any other country. better its people & world. do not use up natural resources like there is no tomorrow, better the planet & reach out to others in need & build relationships with distant lands.

we do those things & we also do horrorific bullshit. and sometimes not such horrorific acts but none the less bad bad things.

the cia & fbi could tell us nightmarish tales 24x7 for years to come.

mickeyrat

fear4freedom wrote:

Im asking all those who are from other countries what they think about this philosophy! Dont think of your country in particular, think of all the weak, poor nations here. If you are from the US, sit back and watch this thread for once! Dont sabatoge it! Also, if you dont believe in God, thats fine, read on anyways.

I believe that God's intentions for all of mankind is for his children to have Individual Liberty and Freedom to pursue their own Individual Salvation and their own identity. We as the United States have formed a country that empowers the individuals and states to control and hold to account the central govt. The US is blessed by God to have the unique opportunity and responsibility to defend the weak and poor, promote Liberty and Freedom, stand for "The People" over any centralized power or govt. within that nation. We are to stand on these principles and values to help the people who are oppressed by their govt! The weak, poor and sick people of the world have hope that we are fighting for them on many different levels. We are blessed to have the capability to do what we do! We acknowledge that blessing and are thankful for having that unique responsibilty and opportunity. This is what I have learned and envision to be American Exceptionalism!

Again, for all you haters out there....we are thankful and blessed for this opportunity, this is not us being "prideful"

This is us understanding our role and being grateful for it!

Your thoughts?

please , as a fellow american, speak only for yourself.

IMO its the height of human ego to claim to know the will of god. The ideas of democracy and liberty etc , did not originate with the founding rich guys of their day.

this country was founded upon stolen ideas from others, land stolen from another people, built up on the backs of slaves.

I believe the world would be better served if the US stayed home and shut the fuck up in the process.

I view as suspicious anything or anyone who shows up with their hand out saying "we're here to help you"

So please OP speak only for yourself and not for me.