I’m Sorry But Gigaton Is A Major Dissapointment

Ukuleddie Vegger · March 2020

Not what I expected. Great album!

Ledbetterman10 · March 2020

drakeheuer14 said:

Of the Earth is half a song as far as I am concerned. It doesn’t fit anywhere.

Plus it’s like 10 years old. I’m surprised people are still hoping for it. It’s not like a recorded version would be better than it is live anyway.

bigbiggzy · March 2020

To each their own - but I think this is among their best work.

goldrush · March 2020

drakeheuer14 said:

Of the Earth is half a song as far as I am concerned. It doesn’t fit anywhere.

It would fit better as a standalone Christmas single than on an album

ArriveLikeButterflyz · March 2020

Can't agree with you.
Gigaton is a great album. I can't get enough of it.
Give it a listen.
And be safe everyone!

THEBIBLEISTEN · March 2020

Great album. Except for Buckle Up, this thing is solid

TJ25487 · March 2020

bigbiggzy said:

To each their own - but I think this is among their best work.

Time to make a custom playlist. Done!

mrussel1 · March 2020

THEBIBLEISTEN said:

Spiritual_Chaos said:

THEBIBLEISTEN said:

If you are a Pearl Jam “fan” and only like one song on gigaton then something is wrong with you. I really like this record a lot. 8/10

Speaking of "trolling".

Haha, wrong but thanks for playing Becky. I forgot about all the winners that come out of the woodwork when an album is released and piss and moan that even flow wasn’t re released. Have a good day complaining on here Becky!

Yeah, who is this @Spiritual_Chaos and did just join today?

mrussel1 · March 2020

Spiritual_Chaos said:

mcgruff10 said:

Spiritual_Chaos said:

mcgruff10 said:

Spiritual_Chaos said:

PJNB said:

Eilian said:

PJNB said:

The one thing I do not get from the small minority that dislike the album is the fact they are happy when others agree with them. Comments like "I am glad I am not the only one" and "thank you" when someone else replies with a similar opinion. I was not a huge fan of Backspacer when it came out or now for that matter. There is no way however that I would be happy or show joy that someone else did not like it either. I would hope that everyone else loved it and I was the odd duck. I guess it is really strange to me seeing people showing a positive reaction to a negative thought towards a band I assume we all love or loved at one point or another.

An above poster summed it up well. It is unfortunate for those that do not like the album and a plus for us that are blown away by it or are liking it. I would rather be on the blown away side any day of the week over the other side.

If you derive absolutely no pleasure from finding like-minded people, I’m not sure what you get out this place.

You take pleasure in people not enjoying the new album?

If thinking Skyfall is way overrated. I don't see how people could find it off one would find (quantum of) solace in other sharing that experience.

How could that be surprising.

Great for people loving Skyfall. But if people fucking shared my view (to a Kill), the franchise would have gone in a better direction.

You thought skyfall was overrated?

PJNB said:

Spiritual_Chaos said:

PJNB said:

Eilian said:

PJNB said:

The one thing I do not get from the small minority that dislike the album is the fact they are happy when others agree with them. Comments like "I am glad I am not the only one" and "thank you" when someone else replies with a similar opinion. I was not a huge fan of Backspacer when it came out or now for that matter. There is no way however that I would be happy or show joy that someone else did not like it either. I would hope that everyone else loved it and I was the odd duck. I guess it is really strange to me seeing people showing a positive reaction to a negative thought towards a band I assume we all love or loved at one point or another.

An above poster summed it up well. It is unfortunate for those that do not like the album and a plus for us that are blown away by it or are liking it. I would rather be on the blown away side any day of the week over the other side.

If you derive absolutely no pleasure from finding like-minded people, I’m not sure what you get out this place.

You take pleasure in people not enjoying the new album?

If thinking Skyfall is way overrated. I don't see how people would find it off one would find (quantum of) solace in other sharing that experience.

How could that be surprising.

Great for people loving Skyfall. But if people fucking shared my view (to a KIll) the franchise would have gone in a better direction.

I actually liked Skyfall!

I liked Skyfall.

But it was not the best Bond-movie since Yield.

You day drinking again?

Lets just agree over a nice glass of vegan wine, that Quantum of Solace is underrated out of the Craig movie. Tight. A classic bond-plot with a decent bond villain. I don’t remember any boring Ethan Hunt/Jason Bourne having to go rouge yet again BS plot thing that took up time.

Yes it is sad Amy Winehouse couldnt do the theme and that they rejected Shirley Basseys song - but come on now. And yeah. the camera shakes. deal with it like a grownup people.

*high five*

With ice?

405OK · March 2020

eboweddie said:

Gigaton will find a place in this drawer!!! When i get it. I love it.

Classic humble brag right here..

mcgruff10 · March 2020

mrussel1 said:

Spiritual_Chaos said:

mcgruff10 said:

Spiritual_Chaos said:

mcgruff10 said:

Spiritual_Chaos said:

PJNB said:

Eilian said:

PJNB said:

The one thing I do not get from the small minority that dislike the album is the fact they are happy when others agree with them. Comments like "I am glad I am not the only one" and "thank you" when someone else replies with a similar opinion. I was not a huge fan of Backspacer when it came out or now for that matter. There is no way however that I would be happy or show joy that someone else did not like it either. I would hope that everyone else loved it and I was the odd duck. I guess it is really strange to me seeing people showing a positive reaction to a negative thought towards a band I assume we all love or loved at one point or another.

An above poster summed it up well. It is unfortunate for those that do not like the album and a plus for us that are blown away by it or are liking it. I would rather be on the blown away side any day of the week over the other side.

If you derive absolutely no pleasure from finding like-minded people, I’m not sure what you get out this place.

You take pleasure in people not enjoying the new album?

If thinking Skyfall is way overrated. I don't see how people could find it off one would find (quantum of) solace in other sharing that experience.

How could that be surprising.

Great for people loving Skyfall. But if people fucking shared my view (to a Kill), the franchise would have gone in a better direction.

You thought skyfall was overrated?

PJNB said:

Spiritual_Chaos said:

PJNB said:

Eilian said:

PJNB said:

The one thing I do not get from the small minority that dislike the album is the fact they are happy when others agree with them. Comments like "I am glad I am not the only one" and "thank you" when someone else replies with a similar opinion. I was not a huge fan of Backspacer when it came out or now for that matter. There is no way however that I would be happy or show joy that someone else did not like it either. I would hope that everyone else loved it and I was the odd duck. I guess it is really strange to me seeing people showing a positive reaction to a negative thought towards a band I assume we all love or loved at one point or another.

An above poster summed it up well. It is unfortunate for those that do not like the album and a plus for us that are blown away by it or are liking it. I would rather be on the blown away side any day of the week over the other side.

If you derive absolutely no pleasure from finding like-minded people, I’m not sure what you get out this place.

You take pleasure in people not enjoying the new album?

If thinking Skyfall is way overrated. I don't see how people would find it off one would find (quantum of) solace in other sharing that experience.

How could that be surprising.

Great for people loving Skyfall. But if people fucking shared my view (to a KIll) the franchise would have gone in a better direction.

I actually liked Skyfall!

I liked Skyfall.

But it was not the best Bond-movie since Yield.

You day drinking again?

Lets just agree over a nice glass of vegan wine, that Quantum of Solace is underrated out of the Craig movie. Tight. A classic bond-plot with a decent bond villain. I don’t remember any boring Ethan Hunt/Jason Bourne having to go rouge yet again BS plot thing that took up time.

Yes it is sad Amy Winehouse couldnt do the theme and that they rejected Shirley Basseys song - but come on now. And yeah. the camera shakes. deal with it like a grownup people.

*high five*

With ice?

Oh hells yes with ice!!

Red Mosqito · March 2020

KN219077 said:

CO278952 said:

Arguing over whether it is ok for the OP to create a separate thread is kinda silly. I wouldn’t have been reading what he posted unless it was right at the top. The only way I view the forum is by going to Recent Discussions every time. I don’t spend my life on here and know all the etiquette but it is one of the few sites I visit daily.

The magic of the early records is they captured lightning in a bottle. Obviously the original songs are classics. The song writing on the first 5 records is great. Most of us became fans in the early years and were along for the ride as their style expanded. The first record that felt stale to me was Avacado. The Brendan O’Brien remix breathed much needed life into it.

I think Josh Evans did a great job with this record capturing a lot of takes and moments that give these new songs life. DOTC is great, love who ever said and quick escape. (That meme above is hilarious.) These songs don’t sound overly rehearsed or stale on Gigaton. Like the song a lot but not sure why there are so many words crammed into the verses of 7 o’clock. At least the verses have life to them (it sounds like an early take of the vocals that wasn’t already sung over and over to get perfectly right). Never destination to me feels like a stage rocker similar to Lightning Bolt that they will have fun playing live. Take the long way is cool. Just would like another louder more powerful song somewhere near the back end of the record. I don’t have the patience to get through River Cross. Seems a little self indulgent. Like retrograde. All in all I like gigaton for me is their best since riot act. Funny how now songs like Green Disease which weren’t the highlight of the album back then now feel like amazing PJ songs when looking back over the last 18 years.

That’s not because Green Disease is a great song, it’s because the songs after it were just not great (on the average, save for a couple of standout tracks on each album)

Well, actually it is a great song but I also think their songs take on a new life once they're played live which allows these songs to grow on us over time.

Red Mosqito · March 2020

Here's my two cents. It's late Monday night and I'm on my 31st listen of the album, to say I can't get enough of it would be an understatement. The only other album I gravitated to immediately like this was Yield, and that speaks volumes for me. Binaural, Riot Act, Avocado, Backspacer & Lightning Bolt were all great albums with a bunch of good songs on them, but I think it took seeing some of the songs live first before I could go back and listen to any of those albums from beginning to end with a greater appreciation.

Gigaton on the other hand is a stunning piece of work as a whole right from the get go for me. From the opening chords of Who Ever Said to the closing notes of River Cross this album takes you on an musical journey. The bands sound feels fresh but strangely familiar at times with every song perfectly intertwining with the next and Ed's lyrics are so masterfully crafted and filled with nods to his hero's all throughout the album, he'll have you lost in Google searches for days.

It's true folks, we've got a masterpiece on our hands with this one. And to do it at this stage in their career is pretty remarkable when you think about it. Most bands who've been around as long as they have (or longer) aren't putting out quality music like this that's for sure as most of them are riding the nostalgia, 401k tour circuit gravy train with make shift lineups that have maybe one or two original members at best nowadays.

ConorKavanagh · March 2020

The fact that we are still getting new material is one of the reasons that I love this band so much. If anyone doesn't like it, just listen to the other records.

vito · March 2020

Red Mosqito said:

Here's my two cents. It's late Monday night and I'm on my 31st listen of the album, to say I can't get enough of this album would be an understatement. The only other album I gravitated to immediately like this was Yield, and that speaks volumes for me. Binaural, Riot Act, Avocado, Backspacer & Lightning Bolt were all great albums with a bunch of good songs on them, but I think it took seeing some of the songs live first before I could go back and listen to any of those albums from beginning to end with a greater appreciation.

Gigaton on the other hand is a stunning piece of work as a whole right from the get go for me. From the opening chords of Who Ever Said to the closing notes of River Cross this album takes you on an musical journey. The bands sound feels fresh but strangely familiar at times with every song perfectly intertwining with the next and Ed's lyrics are so masterfully crafted and filled with nods to his hero's all throughout the album, he'll have you lost in Google searches for days.

It's true folks, we've got a masterpiece on our hands with this one. And to do it at this stage in their career is pretty remarkable when you think about it. Most bands who've been around as long as they have (or longer) aren't putting out quality music like this that's for sure as most of them are riding the nostalgia, 401k tour circuit gravy train with make shift lineups that have maybe one or two original members at best nowadays.

AMEN!

ConorKavanagh · March 2020

BUBBA YOU SAID IT PERFECT!

Peacefrog1975 · March 2020

ConorKavanagh said:

The fact that we are still getting new material is one of the reasons that I love this band so much. If anyone doesn't like it, just listen to the other records.

This!

eboweddie · March 2020

New pearl jam and Brian fallon lp landed thr same day. 2 top lps. Gigaton is fantastic. Its very uplifting I think. Great lp for a 55 minute run!!!

ConorKavanagh · March 2020

@Peacefrog1975 People seem to take it really personally if things aren't made to their exact specifications and/or others don't feel the same way!!!

RoleModelsinBlood31 · March 2020

One thing I do miss is the quirky guitar parts a la stone, like in In Hiding. These are more polished and finished sounding but I miss those twangy unrefined riffs a bit.

I’m Sorry But Gigaton Is A Major Dissapointment

Comments

Categories