American Horror Story

Mamasan23 wrote:

rrivers wrote:

But it completely saves Ben from having to hide/explain her being in LA to his wife. You are probably right about her becoming a ghost in the house. It was just lame all around to me, especially the end with his wife bringing him iced tea and hugging on the gazebo. Ugh! I hope the show proves me wrong!

Think about it though, if Ben's wife had found out, she would have left him no doubt about it. Then where would the show go? They have to stay in that house. I do agree though that that was a great storyline and I don't want it to be over yet, so probably the only way to continue it would be to make the girlfriend a ghost.

Good point about Ben's wife finding out about it and leaving him would kill the storyline as well. I'm not a 100% sure she would have left him just because she saw the girl. She's pregnant now and was rationalizing staying with him to her daughter.

My point isn't that I necessarily wanted the wife to find out, I just liked them having to sneak around. I liked the possibility of her or the daughter finding out. It just added another spice to an already boiling pot. I'm fine with them ending the storyline, but don't just have her walk outside and get smacked in the face by a shovel in broad daylight! To me it seemed like they said "Let's bring the girlfriend over from Boston!" which they did but then realized it wasn't the best idea so now they are pressing reset.
Good debate though! You make some excellent points!

get hooked and then directv is gonna cut the channel
this could be the last week i get to watch this show. not to mention always sunny and the league :evil:
damn you fox news. damn you straight to hell.

When I started seeing the ads for this before it aired I figured it would either wind up being very good or very bad. It's definitely very good. I had to watch the 2nd episode after I saw the 3rd because it wasn't available on demand until the day after the 3rd episode aired so I was a little confused about what the mother and daughter were talking about in the 3rd episode until the next day but it wasn't enough to ruin the episode. I'll just have to make a point of remembering to watch it when it airs from now on. That shouldn't be a problem because it's already become one of those must-see shows for me the way a bunch of HBO's Sunday shows have been.

MayDay10 wrote:

I am pretty sure those bones were the maid's.

I think they were. There was the little bit of the maid outfit with them, and Constantine said something like "now you are stuck here forever" to the maid when Ben was pouring concrete over the site.

Well I've been caught up to episode 3 (Murder House) last night. Which I thought was fantastic. And I'll see Halloween pt 1 tonight to be officially caught up on the show.

After episode 3 I'm wondering if the Detective and the Doctor was real and even if Haden was real. Or just a mind play by the maid trying to get Ben to discover her body in the backyard.

Vivian & Constantine were just fantastic in this episode. Although Constantine is fantastic in every episode.

Anyone happen to notice that the stain glass window in the background of Ben's office looks like the backyard of the house with the new gazebo added?

or the realtor mispronouncing Vivians last name as Hormone in stead of Harmon? In the first episode her doctor put her on a experimental Hormone...

I almost wonder and this is a far far stretch out shot here if all this ties back to the original owner the doctor and his experiments and if Vivians Doctor is related in someway. How is that for crazy!

I swear you have to watch each episode two or three times.

Monster Rain wrote:

This week's episode was very creepy. I can't wait for the 2nd part of it next week. I wonder if Tate is the one who was in the S&M suit in the first episode and if he was the one behind the daughter when the burned guy was banging on the door or if there's something else going on with that thing.

Im thinking its Tate in that suit for sure.
And I think it was him in that suit in the 2nd episode who had sex w/ Vivian, not Ben. And now Im wondering if Tate, in the suit, was the one who killed both the gay guys who were the previous owners. I hope they can manage to connect all the dots eventually. I hate it when a show comes up w/ a bunch of crazy stories that end up leading to nothing.

And im really ticked off that I'm not going to be able to watch this show next week... :x What a cliffhanger! Damn you Directv! I hope they work something out before Nov. 1. I really would rather watch this show on my nice TV than my shitty laptop.

Mamasan23 wrote:

twisted thoughts wrote:

Monster Rain wrote:

This week's episode was very creepy. I can't wait for the 2nd part of it next week. I wonder if Tate is the one who was in the S&M suit in the first episode and if he was the one behind the daughter when the burned guy was banging on the door or if there's something else going on with that thing.

Im thinking its Tate in that suit for sure.
And I think it was him in that suit in the 2nd episode who had sex w/ Vivian, not Ben. And now Im wondering if Tate, in the suit, was the one who killed both the gay guys who were the previous owners. I hope they can manage to connect all the dots eventually. I hate it when a show comes up w/ a bunch of crazy stories that end up leading to nothing.

And im really ticked off that I'm not going to be able to watch this show next week... :x What a cliffhanger! Damn you Directv! I hope they work something out before Nov. 1. I really would rather watch this show on my nice TV than my shitty laptop.

I think you're right about Tate & Vivian...so that must be Tate's demon baby inside of her, right??!! If I miss next week because of Directv I am sending a very angry letter!!!!


!

Do you think that we'd still be able to download the FX shows on demand or is our only hope watching on hulu? I need to look into that more. I know NBC shows dont go up on hulu for like a whole week after it initially airs on tv. wonder if fx is the same. Plus, I could always get hulu on my xbox, but i think you have to pay a monthly subscription fee for that and with my luck, as soon as i signed up for that direct and fx would come up w a deal and i'd have a useless hulu subscription that im paying for. this sux.

The maid is definitely dead. I think Tate is dead and I'm 50/50 on Jessica Lange's character being alive or dead. There's definitely something creepy about her.

All Those Yesterdays wrote:

Episode 4 Halloween pt 1.

...also was awesome. I sort of assumed the "Thing" in the basement was the child of the original owners. Alright so maybe Mr. Crispy isn't a figment of Ben's imagination. The Haden deal at the end of the show was fantastic. Answer the door, it's her, Creepy smile, and he slams the door on her. That's just great. I think I laugh at scenes in the show more then I'm suppose to laugh at them. And the return of the gimp suit. Awesome....

So who is really dead on this shown now?