the 2013 Fan Club 45rpm record...opinions?

Ledbetterman10

lastexit wrote:

dimitrispearljam wrote:

lotsalemon wrote:

Here's my thought on what would have been a better song combo for this year's xmas single, just to keep with the collaborative theme they had going this year:

Side A: Comfortably Numb from the 12-12-12 benefit concert

Side B: 99 Problems with Jay-Z (with the full W.M.A)

I understand that Jay-Z is relevant in the current music scene. I don't have a problem with that. But make that the B-side to the chilling version of Comfortably Numb with Roger Waters from 12-12-12.

im pretty sure Comfortably Numb cant happen ,cos someone else has the copyrights

Just like "Someday at Christmas", "Little Sister" and "Love, Reign O'er Me" didn't happen.

He doesn't mean copyrights to the song. This particular performance might be copyrighted because it was released on a Benefit CD for Sandy Relief.

lastexit

Well, now that's a different issue, isn't it?

lotsalemon

Regardless of who owns the copyright, anything can be worked out for the right amount of money right?

dimitrispearljam

Ledbetterman10 wrote:

lastexit wrote:

dimitrispearljam wrote:

[
im pretty sure Comfortably Numb cant happen ,cos someone else has the copyrights

Just like "Someday at Christmas", "Little Sister" and "Love, Reign O'er Me" didn't happen.

He doesn't mean copyrights to the song. This particular performance might be copyrighted because it was released on a Benefit CD for Sandy Relief.

thanks

lastexit

Thank you so much!

lastexit

lastexit wrote:

Thank you so much!

So, so much!

PJ5a1

The decision maker on this one has some explaining to do. Worst Christmas vinyl they've ever released.

Haywood Yablomee

I'm so disgusted I have to have anything with Jay-Z in my collection or even in my home for that matter. He is just the epitome of greed & capitalism. Didn't he retire?? You can't understand a thing he's saying/rapping except for the chorus...

What's next year's Xmas single gonna be? A selection from his wife's "accidental" $1 million payday concert for Muammar Gaddafi??

Dr. Delight

Again, the past several X-Mas singles have sucked, another reason to go digital.

vaggar99

Dr. Delight wrote:

Again, the past several X-Mas singles have sucked, another reason to go digital.

Yes, they have sucked hard. But they don't have to! Please pearl jam, make this right next year!

pjradio

vaggar99 wrote:

Dr. Delight wrote:

Again, the past several X-Mas singles have sucked, another reason to go digital.

Yes, they have sucked hard. But they don't have to! Please pearl jam, make this right next year!

i said the same thing....3yrs ago!!!

And by the way...where has my "*Limited Edition Membership Item – Something new each year!" been?

cp3iverson

It's not even about Eddie missing from the mic. The '97 single was Michael Stipe singing on one side and Jack Irons on the other and that's one of my favs.

Nami

Dr. Delight wrote:

Again, the past several X-Mas singles have sucked, another reason to go digital.

last 3yrs have been solid imo except for this one.

fallin down/ no jeremy :thumbup:
better things/devil doll its ok...
in the moonlight/ all night. :thumbup:


Jay Zzzzzz :thumbdown:
Basic instinct :fp:

as others have said here i pay for a PJ single... so i'd like a pj single.

Oh and SBM is bad.

back to the game....

DURP

HesCalledDyer wrote:

DURP wrote:

Who the fuck is the chic on the shifty side B song??????

Jeanne Tripplehorn. She's an actress. Starred in Basic Instinct, The Firm, Waterworld, Criminal Minds, etc.

Never seen any of those movies. But i'll take everyone's word

lanoisseforp

No Jeremy was a surprise one even tho I heard it on bootleg many years ago... and it was a great 10 inch record released by the band

Nami wrote:

Dr. Delight wrote:

Again, the past several X-Mas singles have sucked, another reason to go digital.

last 3yrs have been solid imo except for this one.

fallin down/ no jeremy :thumbup:
better things/devil doll its ok...
in the moonlight/ all night. :thumbup:


Jay Zzzzzz :thumbdown:
Basic instinct :fp:

as others have said here i pay for a PJ single... so i'd like a pj single.

Oh and SBM is bad.

back to the game....

E.K

Dr. Delight wrote:

Again, the past several X-Mas singles have sucked, another reason to go digital.

I changed my membership to Digital two years ago and it's one of the best things I've ever done.

Ed's guitar playing and the "shadoobies" are cute but Tripplehorn's part is embarrassing

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6VLAGhOetAk

lastexit

lastexit wrote:

lastexit wrote:

Thank you so much!

So, so much!

So much thank you. I typically roll with the punches when it comes to x-mas singles but this one, hmmm. I would've gladly paid $40 to ensure they didn't release this. Oh well. Maybe someday we'll look back and see the joke.

High Fidelity 2000

lanoisseforp wrote:

Still a fine looking lass at the age of 50

Jeanne Tripplehorn

[/quote]

I think that's an older picture. When I watched the video I thought she looked pretty old compared to how I remembered her. Of course, not as old as most 50 year olds... But just different.

High Fidelity 2000

Ledbetterman10 wrote:

I think to not appreciate 99 Problems as the single is to take for granted all the official bootlegs. There's a sense of entitlement people seem to have for every live recording and they tend to want new studio recordings for stuff like the Xmas singles. Long gone are the days of stuff like "Smile" LIVE in 1996 meaning anything to fans.

Uploading a video on the band's youtube channel is cool. It's cool. It's a good, fun performance. It just, to me, doesn't belong on this 2013 single. And it is a little Seth McFarlaneish of Eddie to think "alright, the majority of my fans will hate this..but I THINK IT'S FUNNY so it's coming out."

To quote Tenacious D... "That's True..."

"That's also true."

I remember getting that live Smile in 96... Wow, a live version of a song, how cool! We are spoiled. Even when one show doesn't come out, like MIA (ok, more than one, PJ20, Wrigley, etc) everyone complains about it. Which is even more reason to give us a song we might actually LIKE and/or APPRECIATE for the once a year fan club single... Instead of a joke at a private fund raiser. Yah it's kinda cute and funny, but give me a real song. Give me Jingle Bells 2 if you want, something...

Pap

dimitrispearljam wrote:

again,eddie solo work,not other band memebrs..is like the tickets,they dont selll 10c tickets to any side project,only to eddie shows..

They also sold tickets for the BRAD and RNDM tours.