Eddie Spears? Britney Vedder? Ed Lip Syncs too!!!

Fahka

........

jimed14

pjtaper wrote:

Liam finn is awesome, I hope he tours, I would love to see a show or two of his!

He is touring ...

http://pollstar.com/tour/searchall.pl?Content=A-LIAFIN&By=All&PSKey=Y&StartSearch.x=7&StartSearch.y=15

ledvedderman

pjtaper wrote:

I will say this, he played Man of the Hour all three nights, and I wish he would have played it 3 times at each show... WOW!!!! That was the highlight for me...
Man of the Hour each night were by far the best versions ever, and Throw Your Arms Around me with Liam were my favorite versions of those also... Porch was cool. Anything with Ben Harper is AMAZING and I was lucky enough to meet him after the show. Liam finn is awesome, I hope he tours, I would love to see a show or two of his!
Arc was crazy each time, gave me goosebumps, I'd love to somehow play all the different arcs at the same time, that would be grrrrrrrrrreat!

Now you are talking.

pjtaper

FUCKING AWESOME!
http://www.thewalnutroom.com/
May 9th, I'm seeing Neil Finn!

Man, I wish he would have played fucking Parting Ways at least one of the nights... I LOVE THAT SONG!!!!!!!!

blondieblue227

is what you're saying.........

he sang it in LA and used a machine to record background vocals.
big deal.

LikeAnOpeningBandForTheSun

pearl jam fans scare me...

seattlerockguy

You are a loser :(

pjtaper wrote:

sorry about that double post... NOT really!

ed vedder does NOT sing lead vocals on Hard Sun...

Also, there are at least 50 other PJ songs he could have played, I was not thrilled about these setlists!

LBC? In Hiding? I yelled Who You Are after Last Kiss w/Jack... and wtf? Last Kiss with Jack Irons? WEAK!

Lizard

sweet adeline wrote:

-meeting pjtaper and finding out he isn't a psycho like he appears to be on the message board (thanks for the beer).

--still sticking to this story???!!!

patrickredeyes wrote:

Anybody could have gone to these shows. We drove a 1000 miles each way and got tickets.

but you still have to have the freedom to up and leave your family/kids/job...........

Cosmo

I thought that was the whole idea of the Reel-to-Reel and the, 'SCIENCE' remark prior to 'Hard Sun'. You know, the parts being recorded and the live music played over it. Kind of like the way 'The Who' would play the keyboard parts for 'Baba O'Riley' and 'Won't Get Fooled Again' because pete was busy with the guitar parts.
...
So... it was a live show. It would have been more like a Britney spears show if Ed danced around with his big belly sticking out.

Given to...

mjb wrote:

DUDE! He wasn't exactly hiding it! He used an old reel to reel tape player that had the backing music (without lyrics) - Him and Liam played and sung over it. It was part of the effect...the "experiment" if you will...and it was awesome.

word

Lizard

Cosmo wrote:

...
if Ed danced around with his big belly sticking out.

Now THAT would have been a-m-a-z-i-n-g!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ledbetterman10

Zanne wrote:

Ed made it pretty obvious (as if it wasn't already) that he used a pre-recorded track for Hard Sun and accompanied it. This would have been impossible to reproduce with just him, a drummer and a back-up singer in the way that it was originally recorded.

then I'd argue that he shouldn't have played it then. dubbing prerecorded strings when playing live (Floyd's The Wall tour for instance) is one thing but when your dubbing drums, bass, and backing vocals.......you should probably just leave it off the set.

patrickredeyes

Lizard wrote:

but you still have to have the freedom to up and leave your family/kids/job...........

Yea that's true and I know alot that do that come tour time. Some more then others. If you really wanna do something there is always a way.

SilverSeed

If you were at SDII last night you would have seen Ed rush to the mic to get the first lyrics in. The main vocals were his, the backing vocals dubbed. Liam was playing some drums, but some were dubbed. I had a tough time trying to separate live from reel-to-reel, but I could tell certainly that Ed was singing and playing guitar, and Liam at least played some of the drums.

Cosmo

Ledbetterman10 wrote:

then I'd argue that he shouldn't have played it then. dubbing prerecorded strings when playing live (Floyd's The Wall tour for instance) is one thing but when your dubbing drums, bass, and backing vocals.......you should probably just leave it off the set.

...
Liam was playing the drums and singing backup... E.J. was singing backups and playing tamborine... Ed was playing guitar and singing lead.
And it's was a nice song to end the show on. I would say that the vast majority of the people at the shows liked it and had a good time... so, no harm done.

Ledbetterman10

Cosmo wrote:

...
Liam was playing the drums and singing backup... E.J. was singing backups and playing tamborine... Ed was playing guitar and singing lead.
And it's was a nice song to end the show on. I would say that the vast majority of the people at the shows liked it and had a good time... so, no harm done.

well what exactly was overdubbed then? the thread starter is claiming that most of the song was prerecorded.

12345AGNST1

You think Eddie got lip sincing lessons from her? I heard Britney took lip syncing lessons at LA's School for the Rich and Untalented.

Cosmo

Ledbetterman10 wrote:

well what exactly was overdubbed then? the thread starter is claiming that most of the song was prerecorded.

...
The rhythm guitar and bass... you know... the guitar intro to 'Hard Sun'. I don't know about the drums... I was sitting in the forth row (although there were only 2 rows in front of us) in front of the drums... and I could hear the drums, the tamborine and that cowbell thing, Liam, E.J. and Ben (Harper) singing pretty clearly.
too bad wecan't just hear what's on that tape and put this non-issue to rest.
...
It was a fun song and everyone was on their feet and happy. Doesn't that count for something?

Ledbetterman10

Cosmo wrote:

...

...
It was a fun song and everyone was on their feet and happy. Doesn't that count for something?

sure

norm

Ledbetterman10 wrote:

well what exactly was overdubbed then? the thread starter is claiming that most of the song was prerecorded.

the thread starter doesn't know shit!! everything cosmo said is correct....ignore the thread starter....he was too high to know what was going on (at least at la1)