***The Official Philadelphia Phillies 2013 Thread***

JK_Livin

I loved him and he helped us win a championship but he wasn't the strongest game manager. If he gets credit for winning a championship, he must take some of the blame for losing.

Jearlpam0925

He always gets the blame for when they lose, but less credit when they win. It's the opposite.

As I've simmered, and am listening to this presser, it makes sense what they're doing. Charlie's a standup guy, but he knows he's getting it right in the ass.

pjhawks

see ya' Charlie. can't believe anyone thinks this guy is underrated. yes he won one title but should have been at least 2 and probably 3. best team in baseball two years in a row and flamed out in the playoffs against two inferior teams. and don't get me started on the fucking disaster decisions on pedro in 2009. Charlie cost the phils the 2009 series and the next two years brutal losses to much worse teams, especially the giants.

Jearlpam0925

Aaaaaaannnnnnd case in point.

pjhawks

Jearlpam0925 wrote:

Aaaaaaannnnnnd case in point.

and you blame the 1st basemen even though this team has never had a better record without him the lineup at any stretch. fuck Charlie.

edit: and regardless of the feelings on Charlie this was the right move if you weren't planning on bringing Charlie back next year. find out as much as you can about Sandberg now and decide at the end of the year if he is the right guy. right move.

Jearlpam0925

I blame the 1st baseman constantly? I think you've got me confused with someone else. I'm just realistic.

Last I checked the players play, not the manager.

But I digress, as there's certain people I do not argue or have conversation with anymore on here - you being one of them there, Mr. Philly.com

Remember to breath with your nose, not your mouth.

jamminpearls

Jearlpam0925 wrote:

Aaaaaaannnnnnd case in point.

I'll ask again since you obviously didn't see my comment. Have you and the fixer ever talked about how you feel abut Charlie? Not being a dick just curious.

pjhawks

jamminpearls wrote:

Jearlpam0925 wrote:

Aaaaaaannnnnnd case in point.

I'll ask again since you obviously didn't see my comment. Have you and the fixer ever talked about how you feel abut Charlie? Not being a dick just curious.

nope, but I know we have tended to agree on the coaches. Charlie was overrated, andy reid underrated, chip Kelly destined to fail.

jamminpearls

pjhawks wrote:

jamminpearls wrote:

Jearlpam0925 wrote:

Aaaaaaannnnnnd case in point.

I'll ask again since you obviously didn't see my comment. Have you and the fixer ever talked about how you feel abut Charlie? Not being a dick just curious.

nope, but I know we have tended to agree on the coaches. Charlie was overrated, andy reid underrated, chip Kelly destined to fail.

I meant JP.

Jearlpam0925

jamminpearls wrote:

Jearlpam0925 wrote:

Aaaaaaannnnnnd case in point.

I'll ask again since you obviously didn't see my comment. Have you and the fixer ever talked about how you feel abut Charlie? Not being a dick just curious.

Is this directed to me, or Mouth Breather?

pjhawks

Jearlpam0925 wrote:

I blame the 1st baseman constantly? I think you've got me confused with someone else. I'm just realistic.

Last I checked the players play, not the manager.

But I digress, as there's certain people I do not argue or have conversation with anymore on here - you being one of them there, Mr. Philly.com

Remember to breath with your nose, not your mouth.

exactly: the players play and Charlie won because of the talent BUT with all the talent this team had didn't win enough. that's why I think he is highly overrated. no doubt this franchise should have won more than one title in the 5 year period. and the same thing happened with Charlie in Cleveland.

Jearlpam0925

There we go.

He knows I'm not on his shit like he is, so no we don't see eye to eye. But can you believe this? We don't slurp each other's viewpoints.

He says a lot of the shit he says here for a reaction/get a lot of you dudes fired up.

I just like to stop on in and talk Philly shit - any and all - and then decipher who can carry a valid argument/conversation from there.

jamminpearls

Jearlpam0925 wrote:

jamminpearls wrote:

Jearlpam0925 wrote:

Aaaaaaannnnnnd case in point.

I'll ask again since you obviously didn't see my comment. Have you and the fixer ever talked about how you feel abut Charlie? Not being a dick just curious.

Is this directed to me, or Mouth Breather?

You. I know you too get along and was curious. As he hates everyone not named Andy Reid.

jamminpearls

Jearlpam0925 wrote:

There we go.

He knows I'm not on his shit like he is, so no we don't see eye to eye. But can you believe this? We don't slurp each other's viewpoints.

He says a lot of the shit he says here for a reaction/get a lot of you dudes fired up.

I just like to stop on in and talk Philly shit - any and all - and then decipher who can carry a valid argument/conversation from there.

Good enough. Thanks for replying.

The Fixer

One down, one to go.

Amaro crying in public is a perfect synopsis of this team's current and future situation. What a skirt

The Fixer

jamminpearls wrote:

Jearlpam0925 wrote:

It's bullshit. Should've been given his choice to stay, unless he WANTED out now.

Most underrated manager/coach in this city in the past 25+ years.

Amaro should be the one being bounced.

Have you had this talk with The Fixer?

You spend an awful lot of time thinking about me. It's pretty creepy

For the record, manuel was not a good manager. He was in right place at right time with good players. I think he cost the phils legit runs at multiple titles (especially starting oswalt over halladay in 2011 game 4 vs STL -- which would have allowed lee to pitch in game 5 instead of seeing him warm up in the bullpen)...still one of the dumbest things I have ever seen. Pedro Martinez in games 2 and 6 of the 09 WS is a close runner up).

The GM should have been fired first, but I think they both should have been fired a long time ago. This franchise is always slow to adapt...they are too loyal. It's no coincidence that when they finally decided to bring in an outsider to fill the key organizational role (gillick), that they ended up having success. When Gillick left, it was back to the circle of ineptitude and amaro was given the job, which we all know has been an unmitigated disaster that won't end for a few more years because that's the way the phillies operate. Like fools

jamminpearls

Jearlpam0925 wrote:

There we go.

He knows I'm not on his shit like he is, so no we don't see eye to eye. But can you believe this? We don't slurp each other's viewpoints.

He says a lot of the shit he says here for a reaction/get a lot of you dudes fired up.

I just like to stop on in and talk Philly shit - any and all - and then decipher who can carry a valid argument/conversation from there.

I never thought Charlie was a good BASEBALL manager. He was a good CLUB HOUSE manager. But it's fucked up how they did him.

The Fixer

jamminpearls wrote:

You. I know you too get along and was curious. As he hates everyone not named Andy Reid.

Wrong as usual. I like laviolette a lot (always have). I also like the sixers new hire based on what I have read about him (I don't pretend to be familiar with him before the last few months)

Ledbetterman10

The Fixer wrote:

jamminpearls wrote:

Jearlpam0925 wrote:

It's bullshit. Should've been given his choice to stay, unless he WANTED out now.

Most underrated manager/coach in this city in the past 25+ years.

Amaro should be the one being bounced.

Have you had this talk with The Fixer?

You spend an awful lot of time thinking about me. It's pretty creepy

For the record, manuel was not a good manager. He was in right place at right time with good players. I think he cost the phils legit runs at multiple titles (especially starting oswalt over halladay in 2011 game 4 vs STL -- which would have allowed lee to pitch in game 5 instead of seeing him warm up in the bullpen)...still one of the dumbest things I have ever seen. Pedro Martinez in games 2 and 6 of the 09 WS is a close runner up).

The GM should have been fired first, but I think they both should have been fired a long time ago. This franchise is always slow to adapt...they are too loyal. It's no coincidence that when they finally decided to bring in an outsider to fill the key organizational role (gillick), that they ended up having success. When Gillick left, it was back to the circle of ineptitude and amaro was given the job, which we all know has been an unmitigated disaster that won't end for a few more years because that's the way the phillies operate. Like fools

I agree with most of this but ya gotta give Charlie a little credit. I mean, it's not like the 2008 team was THAT great. We've seen better teams than them not win the World Series. They might have just kept floundering around just outside the postseason with Bowa or somebody different.

The Fixer

jamminpearls wrote:

Jearlpam0925 wrote:

There we go.

He knows I'm not on his shit like he is, so no we don't see eye to eye. But can you believe this? We don't slurp each other's viewpoints.

He says a lot of the shit he says here for a reaction/get a lot of you dudes fired up.

I just like to stop on in and talk Philly shit - any and all - and then decipher who can carry a valid argument/conversation from there.

I never thought Charlie was a good BASEBALL manager. He was a good CLUB HOUSE manager. But it's fucked up how they did him.

he was great at being a nice guy. sucked at everything else. That's not exactly the description of who I want running my favorite team

he was gone at end of year anyway. they did him a favor by letting him hang around for so long. it's not like he was thriving at his job