Project #10 - The Ascending Road Ahead: No Code Live

myra

electricxlovex wrote:

But I do like Wishlist (before Myra loses it )

Don't worry about it. I lost all hope for both of you anyway.

myra

tremors wrote:

Wishlist is nice

I compared the Hamburg Hail Hail to the Seattle, and I really liked Hamburg! Good choice - my vote goes to Hamburg.

I also compared the two In My Tree contenders, and I got a lot more from Berlin (existing) - I really enjoyed the performance, and it sounded great - Buffalo I enjoyed the performance, but was let down by the SQ, and I felt it would not stand up well amongst the others we have

My main reason for questioning In My Tree was that I couldn't remember being affected by it - but the reason for that was it wasn't on my CD! So, I am happy with the current selection of Berlin

Phew.
*relieved*

tremors

myra wrote:

Can't find anything even remotely relevant for the bonus section.

No complete version of Hunger strike, even though that from Berlin is nice. Longest, if I'm not mistaken, is from Dublin but it's so much of a sing-along that you actually hear the crowd more than anything else. Still fun though.

All versions of Young Man Blues are very very bad in SQ.

There's two Black Red Yellow, one almost inaudible (Hungary, if I recall correctly). The other one is also from a low SQ boot (Portugal, Night 1), but not as bad.

And ....

That's it.


Yep.

It sucks.

Somebody please tell me I missed something.

I believe you.

What to do, what to do??

What about for our last full album project some other PJ numbers which we haven't yet featured on any projects?? B-sides etc??

PilateOfTheStorm

Habit Suggestions:

Randall's Island, 29/09/1996 - very clean, tight version. Like the Speaking as the child of a child part Sounds great in the outro

Civic Theatre, Augusta 26/09/1996 - Love this one too. A great version - sounds great, the band is very punchy. Ed's voice is great in this one. Outro is great too. One of the highlights amongst all of the other Habits. "speaking as an individual determined to see the year 2000"

North Charleston Coliseum, Charleston 05/10/1996 - Another great one. More grittier and punkier than the others, I like it a lot. "Speaking as an individual in a band who has never been in this town before"



and I had some more but I forgot which ones, so I'll have to have another listen (I should have written it down :x :roll: )

TheRealDanPatch

tremors wrote:

:shock: Do we really have a 13 minute version of I'm Open!?? Or is it just me?? I couldn't read the whole thread properly before, because my laptop power lead was on the blink - I had a new one delivered today, so I am happier!

Only the last three minutes or so of I'm Open from soundcheck are going to be used.

myra

tremors wrote:

myra wrote:

Can't find anything even remotely relevant for the bonus section.

No complete version of Hunger strike, even though that from Berlin is nice. Longest, if I'm not mistaken, is from Dublin but it's so much of a sing-along that you actually hear the crowd more than anything else. Still fun though.

All versions of Young Man Blues are very very bad in SQ.

There's two Black Red Yellow, one almost inaudible (Hungary, if I recall correctly). The other one is also from a low SQ boot (Portugal, Night 1), but not as bad.

And ....

That's it.


Yep.

It sucks.

Somebody please tell me I missed something.

I believe you.

What to do, what to do??

What about for our last full album project some other PJ numbers which we haven't yet featured on any projects?? B-sides etc??

I was looking for all this. everything. anything. (except Footsteps & SOLAT for obvious reasons and Wash because I felt it'd be awkward in a No Code compilation)

tremors

electricxlovex wrote:

Habit Suggestions:

Randall's Island, 29/09/1996 - very clean, tight version. Like the Speaking as the child of a child part Sounds great in the outro

Civic Theatre, Augusta 26/09/1996 - Love this one too. A great version - sounds great, the band is very punchy. Ed's voice is great in this one. Outro is great too. One of the highlights amongst all of the other Habits. "speaking as an individual determined to see the year 2000"

North Charleston Coliseum, Charleston 05/10/1996 - Another great one. More grittier and punkier than the others, I like it a lot. "Speaking as an individual in a band who has never been in this town before"



and I had some more but I forgot which ones, so I'll have to have another listen (I should have written it down :x :roll: )

Myra takes notes. You'll have to try harder if you want to beat her!

Do you have a final vote on Habit?



I also notice The Immigrant Song in your sig :thumbup:

tremors

Cameron4President wrote:

tremors wrote:

:shock: Do we really have a 13 minute version of I'm Open!?? Or is it just me?? I couldn't read the whole thread properly before, because my laptop power lead was on the blink - I had a new one delivered today, so I am happier!

Only the last three minutes or so of I'm Open from soundcheck are going to be used.

Figures! I had worked out something like this from reading the thread back. When I loaded them up this morning I was not looking at the length etc - then I had a 13 minute I'm Open trip in the middle of my journey! Was pretty cool actually

TheRealDanPatch

I have noticed that all of you have been listening to the "rough draft' via streaming. This is alright with me, but let me know what changes need to be made to the current 'rough draft' tracklist on the front page before I edit it and piece it together.

Give me a rundown of songs you want changed and I will update the frontpage.

tremors

Cameron4President wrote:

I have noticed that all of you have been listening to the "rough draft' via streaming. This is alright with me, but let me know what changes need to be made to the current 'rough draft' tracklist on the front page before I edit it and piece it together.

Give me a rundown of songs you want changed and I will update the frontpage.

I downloaded the whole thing from Pjbootlegs.org

I think the main suggestion so far is to switch Hail Hail from Seattle to Hamburg.

Am I right?

PilateOfTheStorm

Randall's Island, 29/09/1996

Civic Theatre, Augusta 26/09/1996

North Charleston Coliseum, Charleston 05/10/1996

1996-11-22 Anoeta Velodrome, San Sebastian, Spain

1996-09-22 John F. Savage Hall, Toledo, OH, USA

1996-09-24 Merriweather Post Pavilion, Columbia, MD, USA

so far those are the stand out Habits for me, I'm going to have another check in a bit - I need to look into this more, don't want to do it half heartedly

edit: added 2 more

I feel like all of those are cool, so you guys can listen and pick your favourite, or I can whittle it down even more.

myra

electricxlovex wrote:

Randall's Island, 29/09/1996

Civic Theatre, Augusta 26/09/1996

North Charleston Coliseum, Charleston 05/10/1996

1996-11-22 Anoeta Velodrome, San Sebastian, Spain

1996-09-22 John F. Savage Hall, Toledo, OH, USA

1996-09-24 Merriweather Post Pavilion, Columbia, MD, USA

so far those are the stand out Habits for me, I'm going to have another check in a bit - I need to look into this more, don't want to do it half heartedly

edit: added 2 more

I feel like all of those are cool, so you guys can listen and pick your favourite, or I can whittle it down even more.

I will, in a minute (put you out of your Habit misery ).

I'm just trying to figure out where we are at now. :crazy:

myra

tremors wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

I have noticed that all of you have been listening to the "rough draft' via streaming. This is alright with me, but let me know what changes need to be made to the current 'rough draft' tracklist on the front page before I edit it and piece it together.

Give me a rundown of songs you want changed and I will update the frontpage.

I downloaded the whole thing from Pjbootlegs.org

I think the main suggestion so far is to switch Hail Hail from Seattle to Hamburg.

Am I right?

And change Habit. And the whole (or maybe not, or maybe so) bonus section.

We're keeping the current In my tree, right ? And Who you are ?

PilateOfTheStorm

myra wrote:

tremors wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

I have noticed that all of you have been listening to the "rough draft' via streaming. This is alright with me, but let me know what changes need to be made to the current 'rough draft' tracklist on the front page before I edit it and piece it together.

Give me a rundown of songs you want changed and I will update the frontpage.

I downloaded the whole thing from Pjbootlegs.org

I think the main suggestion so far is to switch Hail Hail from Seattle to Hamburg.

Am I right?

And change Habit. And the whole (or maybe not, or maybe so) bonus section.

We're keeping the current In my tree, right ? And Who you are ?

yes I think so

Habit needs to get changed

Bonus section - :( I like all of what we have so far, I still can't find anything else to add. We may just have to settle for what we've got but like tremors suggested, change the order of them.

myra

Cameron4President wrote:

I have noticed that all of you have been listening to the "rough draft' via streaming.

I'm not, I'm basically relying on the feedback. :?

myra

electricxlovex wrote:

Randall's Island, 29/09/1996

Civic Theatre, Augusta 26/09/1996

North Charleston Coliseum, Charleston 05/10/1996

1996-11-22 Anoeta Velodrome, San Sebastian, Spain

1996-09-22 John F. Savage Hall, Toledo, OH, USA

1996-09-24 Merriweather Post Pavilion, Columbia, MD, USA

so far those are the stand out Habits for me, I'm going to have another check in a bit - I need to look into this more, don't want to do it half heartedly

edit: added 2 more

I feel like all of those are cool, so you guys can listen and pick your favourite, or I can whittle it down even more.

I vote Toledo :thumbup:
'so you guys have class tomorrow ? I don't'

Edit : Columbia as a runner up.

PilateOfTheStorm

bonus section :
someone suggested using stuff from Eddie's solo gig in Rome

I haven't listened to this one, familiar with it but never got round to listen so i don't have an opinion on it other than it's just Eddie and not the whole band

PilateOfTheStorm

myra wrote:

electricxlovex wrote:

Randall's Island, 29/09/1996

Civic Theatre, Augusta 26/09/1996

North Charleston Coliseum, Charleston 05/10/1996

1996-11-22 Anoeta Velodrome, San Sebastian, Spain

1996-09-22 John F. Savage Hall, Toledo, OH, USA

1996-09-24 Merriweather Post Pavilion, Columbia, MD, USA

so far those are the stand out Habits for me, I'm going to have another check in a bit - I need to look into this more, don't want to do it half heartedly

edit: added 2 more

I feel like all of those are cool, so you guys can listen and pick your favourite, or I can whittle it down even more.

I vote Toledo :thumbup:
'so you guys have class tomorrow ? I don't'

Edit : Columbia as a runner up.

good choices - not sure if I completely agree as of yet - need to listen again because I really liked the Randall's Island one and the Civic theatre one
so i'll have another listen

tremors

electricxlovex wrote:

bonus section :
someone suggested using stuff from Eddie's solo gig in Rome

I haven't listened to this one, familiar with it but never got round to listen so i don't have an opinion on it other than it's just Eddie and not the whole band

We don't want to be sharing EV solo stuff - it goes against the band's policy

myra

electricxlovex wrote:

bonus section :
someone suggested using stuff from Eddie's solo gig in Rome

I haven't listened to this one, familiar with it but never got round to listen so i don't have an opinion on it other than it's just Eddie and not the whole band

:shock: E.V. ? Solo ?!

Don't know if that's ok. I mean EV solo generally isn't. But that's something else. I guess. Or isn't it ? I don't know if it's ok or not.