PJ Albums. Rank 'em. Again.

PHATJ

I think we should do it again. Let's rank the PJ studio albums (from first to worst) in each of our own humble opinions. Let the bickering begin. Again.

This list changes with the seasons for me. There are really no constants other then Riot Act and Binaural are always at the bottom. At one time or another, I think every other album may have topped this list. So here goes...

1. Ten ~Every song is a classic. Release is my personal all time favorite song. This album truly changed my life. I can't honestly say that about any other PJ record. Also in anticipation of the "deluxe/remastered" edition that is about to be released, this album gets the top spot.

2. Vs. ~Nearly as influential on me personally as TEN and probably has topped my personal list more often then any other PJ album. I LOVE this album. Seriously LOVE it. Leash, Glorified G, Rats. Just so damn good. Every song. A very real rock Masterpiece.

3. NO CODE ~I remember being in my parent's basement with the lights out, and only a couple candles burning, laying in front of my stereo speakers, for hours and hours, as a 16 year old, and just letting this album ooze into my soul. (that was way too many commas). It has really felt like it has been a part of me since. Present Tense, In My Tree and Red Mosquito are brilliant songs. The only song that I don't think works is Habit, but I can forgive one song.

4. YIELD ~I skipped school to be in line at my local record store during my senior year of High School the day this album came out. It was an instant great. Lots of awesome rockers and some cool mellow songs too (like every PJ album I guess). Could easily sit at the top of this list at any time for me.

5. PEARL JAM (Avocado) ~I really enjoy this album. There are a couple songs (Big Wave, World Wide Suicide and Comatose) that I could really do without. That being said, I love the "feel" of the album. It isn't over worked. It almost feels like a live CD to me, and I love that.

6. VITALOGY ~A really great record. PJ's first venture into a "concept" album. Beautifully designed (including the album artwork. PJ's best art design in my opinion.). Some fantastic songs. Some all time classics. But there were also some big misses. Whipping, Pry,to, and especially Stupid Mop (I know that this is/can basically be considered a throw away track and really isn't a song at all, but Pearl Jam put it on the album and must be penalized for such a ridiculous decision). Immortality should have been the perfect closer.

7. BINAURAL ~This is a decent album. It is incredibly well recorded and that is the biggest reason it isn't last on my list (that, and the fact that I absolutely love "Sleight of Hand"). The biggest problem with Binaural isn't the songs that are actually on the album, it's the songs PJ inexplicably left off the album (Sad, Fatal, Hitchhiker, In the Moonlight and Education; to name some). This could have (and should have) been a truly monumental release, but with so many omissions, I can't place it any higher on my list.

8. RIOT ACT ~There are several songs that I like quite a bit on this CD. "I Am Mine", "Can't Keep", and "You Are", to name my favorites. But there are way too many forgettable tracks and an over all inconsistent vibe to this whole album. I would review it favorably in comparison to releases by many of the bands that put out albums during this time period, but when comparing Riot Act to other PJ albums, it absolutely falls far short.

Well, I hope you all enjoy this exercise of reviewing your own opinions of the Pearl Jam catalog. I hope my review didn't bore you to death. I am excited to see what you all have to say...

NewJPage

here i go, quickly...and this is just my opinion today...it often changes

1. yield
2. no code (the top two often change spots)
3. vs.
4. vitalogy
5. riot act (this album gets waaaayyy too much crap. its damn good. how people can hate on cropduster or ghost is beyond me)
6. avocado
7. binaural
8. ten (although the remixed version may bump it up a spot or two...)

BMo-643

This is really like splitting hairs with me however I am bored at work and am willing to do it.

I'm just going to discuss each album chronologically and then list them in order and pick the best four songs on each album.

Ten - honestly I think we all know that every song on this is great, having said that I LOVE 8 of the 11 songs on this album. Release - Once - Why Go - Porch.

V/S - maybe song-for-song the best album. I like every song on this album - number of songs I love - 8 out of 12. Elderly Woman - Go - Animal - Indifference.

Vitalogy - love this album. I love 8 of the 14 songs/weird sounds. I hate that they put those weird songs on this album. Not for you - Tremor Christ - Satan's Bed and Immortality are 4 of my favorite songs ever so for them to all be on the one album makes this album stand out to me.

No Code - I love 7 of the 13 songs on this album. I know its "cool" for most of the fans to consider this their best album, and Its a great, great album but not even in my top 3 from them. - Sometimes - Smile - Red Mosquito and Present Tense.

Yield - I love 8 of the 13 songs on the album. All Those Yesterdays - No Way - Given to Fly - Untitled

Binaural - their weakest album in my eyes (and most peoples) I really love about 5 of the 13 songs. Its not that any of the songs on this album aren't good - they are all good. In my book there just isn't the same number of classics and must have's on this album. Nothing as it Seems - Light Years - Of the Girl - Gods Dice.

Riot Act - I love 8 (maybe 9) of the songs on this album out of the 15 that are on it. I agree this album takes WAYYY too much crap. This was actually the album that got me back into them and turned me into the fanatic that I am today. (I listened to them as a kid - then quit listening to them around 1996 until around 2002 - but have been a fanatical fan ever since) Love Boat Captain - I am Mine - All or None - Thumbing My Way.

Avocado - This album hasn't had time to ferment in our brains and for songs to become classic yet (at least in my opinion) so the fact that I only love 5 of the 13 songs on this album doesn't mean that I don't like the album - I do, I thought it was a great album. I just don't think that these songs have been around enough to become "great" in my book yet, ask me in another 10 years and this may be favorite album - who knows? Life Wasted - Comatose - Severed Hand - Parachutes.

OK pound for pound if I had to rank them in order from my favorite to least strictly based on the number of songs I LOVE on each album. When I say LOVE I mean if I am making a PJ playlist - those songs are going on it. I would rank them.

1. V/S
2. Vitalogy
3. Ten
4. Yield
5. No Code
6. Riot Act
7. Binaural
8. Avocado.

PHATJ

bmo643 wrote:

This is really like splitting hairs with me however I am bored at work and am willing to do it.

I'm just going to discuss each album chronologically and then list them in order and pick the best four songs on each album.

Ten - honestly I think we all know that every song on this is great, having said that I LOVE 8 of the 11 songs on this album. Release - Once - Why Go - Porch.

V/S - maybe song-for-song the best album. I like every song on this album - number of songs I love - 8 out of 12. Elderly Woman - Go - Animal - Indifference.

Vitalogy - love this album. I love 8 of the 14 songs/weird sounds. I hate that they put those weird songs on this album. Not for you - Tremor Christ - Satan's Bed and Immortality are 4 of my favorite songs ever so for them to all be on the one album makes this album stand out to me.

No Code - I love 7 of the 13 songs on this album. I know its "cool" for most of the fans to consider this their best album, and Its a great, great album but not even in my top 3 from them. - Sometimes - Smile - Red Mosquito and Present Tense.

Yield - I love 8 of the 13 songs on the album. All Those Yesterdays - No Way - Given to Fly - Untitled

Binaural - their weakest album in my eyes (and most peoples) I really love about 5 of the 13 songs. Its not that any of the songs on this album aren't good - they are all good. In my book there just isn't the same number of classics and must have's on this album. Nothing as it Seems - Light Years - Of the Girl - Gods Dice.

Riot Act - I love 8 (maybe 9) of the songs on this album out of the 15 that are on it. I agree this album takes WAYYY too much crap. This was actually the album that got me back into them and turned me into the fanatic that I am today. (I listened to them as a kid - then quit listening to them around 1996 until around 2002 - but have been a fanatical fan ever since) Love Boat Captain - I am Mine - All or None - Thumbing My Way.

Avocado - This album hasn't had time to ferment in our brains and for songs to become classic yet (at least in my opinion) so the fact that I only love 5 of the 13 songs on this album doesn't mean that I don't like the album - I do, I thought it was a great album. I just don't think that these songs have been around enough to become "great" in my book yet, ask me in another 10 years and this may be favorite album - who knows? Life Wasted - Comatose - Severed Hand - Parachutes.

OK pound for pound if I had to rank them in order from my favorite to least strictly based on the number of songs I LOVE on each album. When I say LOVE I mean if I am making a PJ playlist - those songs are going on it. I would rank them.

1. V/S
2. Vitalogy
3. Ten
4. Yield
5. No Code
6. Riot Act
7. Binaural
8. Avocado.

This is a well thought out post! Although I am not in complete agreement with your final analysis (mainly Avocado placing last), I definitely appreciate your well thought input. Well done indeed.

BMo-643

This is a well thought out post! Although I am not in complete agreement with your final analysis (mainly Avocado placing last), I definitely appreciate your well thought input. Well done indeed.[/quote]

I could talk about lists of anything for days and make up lists for just about anything on earth so posts like these are my favorite. Yeah I just can't rank the Avocado album any higher simply because its not been around long enough for me and doesn't have the memories associated with it like the other albums do - especially Vitalogy. About the only list I couldn't make is a list of my favorite Pearl Jam songs - thats impossible.

Lostdogsinthegarden

1) No Code.
2) Vitalogy.
3) Vs.
4) Yield.
5) Binaural.
6) Ten.
7) Riot Act.
8) Pearl Jam.

That's my list with about 10 seconds of thought put into it. The only one I feel confident about is No Code. Doesn't matter much anyways, as I love them all

Vedderman51

YIELD
Vs.
No Code
Ten
Vitalogy
Binaural
Pearl Jam
Riot Act

U R A Crazy Breed

No Code
Binaural
Yield
Ten
Vitalogy
VS
Riot Act
Pearl Jam

mfc2006

NO CODE
Binaural
Yield
Pearl Jam
VS
Vitalogy
Riot Act
Ten

Gibson

I am only doing this because Avocado is getting the low rank from everyone:

1. Avocado
2. Vs.
3. Vitalogy
4. Yield
5. No Code
6. Ten
7. Riot Act
8. Binural

Brisk.

what's the need?

They are all good.

SPEEDY MCCREADY

rank the pearl jam albums????

the first 3 were KICK ASS!!!!!
the next 3 were FUCKING GOOD!!!!!!!!!!

the last 2 were BLAH...........

Fatal

1. Vitalogy
2. Ten
3. Vs.
4. No Code
5. Pearl Jam
6. Yield
7. Binaural
8. Riot Act

QuarterToTen

Ten
Vs
No Code
Yield
Binaural
Vitalogy
Riot Act





Pearl Jam

i have high hopes for the new album.

bernmodi

1. Vs
2. Yield
3. Ten
4. Avocado
5. Vitalogy
6. No Code
7. Binaural
8. Riot Act

Kraven

1)Ten
2)No Code
3)Vs
4)Vitalogy
5)Pearl Jam
6) Binaural
7)Riot Act
8) Yield

I just never got into Yield as much as everything else, all the albums are great, but if someone put the eight albums out in front of me and said pick 7 of these to put into your CD player, Yield would always be the one left out.

And depending on the mood the top 5 are all interchangeable

I have really high hopes for the new album, especially after the descriptions of some of the songs in that Rolling Stone article.

Flagg

OK, like everyone else, this changes from time to time.

1) YIELD - This is the album that cemented them as my favorite band and began the obsession. From the opening shot of Brain of J, to the contemplative ending of All Those Yesterdays, to me this is a flawless record. I think it captures their sound and their potential better than any other record. Given to Fly says all you need to know about this great band.

2) Vs. - The first album I can remember where I actually stood in line to buy it on the sale date. Solid follow-up to their breakthrough record, this is PJ at their heaviest but also contains some of thier best ballads (Daughter, Small Town). Go, Animal, Blood and RVM show they can hang with anyone but Indifference sets them apart.

3) Pearl Jam - This record restored my faith in them. That is why I rank it so high. I felt they (especially Ed) had begun to mail it in with Riot Act. I think PJ was a consious step by them to regain their edge and get their message back out. The songs are punchy, melodic and Mike hasn't played leads like this since Vs. More Mike!! And Ed is back with his story-telling method of writing. The entire album (except maybe Big Wave) is tied together with the theme of war, loss, and the anxiousness people felt living in America during the difficult years just after the Iraq war begin. And there is a thread of hope too. I said my list changes, and sometimes this moves to the top.

4) Vitalogy - So many great songs. So much anger. Pearl Jam at their pissed off at the world best. I sometimes listen to this record just to hear Ed unleash those blood-curlding screams in Spin the Black Circle and Tremor Christ. If you ever want to blow off steam, you can hardly do better than Last Exit, STBC, Not For You, Tremor Christ. What an opening. Then throw in Whipping. Add in Better Man, Immortality and their unofficial theme song, Corduroy and you have a near perfect snapshot of a band in crisis. The only drawback is too many fillers and silly crap.

5) Ten - The PJ elitist puts 10 at the bottom but really, can you really do that? I hope the remixes sound better. I hate the way this record sounds. We've heard these songs a million times, but Alive still pumps you up. Even Flow still makes you want to pogo. Black still makes you sad. Why Go still makes you pump your fist in the air. Release still puts you in a state of awe when they open with it.

6) Binaural - As above, I hate this sound of this record, even with headphones. I can barely tolerate it. However, that doesn't affect the love I have for most of the songs. When people talk about which songs sound better live than in studio, Binaural is the poster child. Never mind this record, just listen to the 2000 boots to hear the way it was meant to be. That way you can hear Mike kick ass on Breakerfall instead of the aural mess of the record. Also, this is the first record that has a song I can't stand (Evacuation) and the first where I think B sides would have made the album better (Sad).

7) No Code - No Code is a mood record for me. If I am in a good mood, I never play it. If I am sad or something it moves way up. I lost interest in Pearl Jam when this record came out. I thought, well that's it, they will never capture the magic again. 10 years later I figured I was wrong and have grown to like, if not love it. I still think the track-listing is disjointed. It just lacks something. It doesn't flow well and the songs have a distinct lack of hook or in some cases even a chorus. I appreciate it now, but everyone should understand why at the time even big PJ fans gave up on them.

8) Riot Act - I don't want to get into another Riot Act bash, but this album is not very good (to me). The B-sides are better than the album tracks. It doesn't flow well at all. How do you leave off Down? How about Undone? They claim this to be a political statement but leave off two of the most political songs they have? How about Other Side? Give me that over 40 Help Helps, Get Rights, Cropdusters, etc. To may other people contributed lyrics and the songs suffer for it. The best are the ones Ed wrote himself and I think he mailed his vocal performance in. Save You takes on a whole new life live. For the first time, I was really disappointed in Eddie's performance. Outside of Arc, Can't Keep, I Am Mine and All or None, he doesn't really bring anything to the table. There are no "wow" moments. Its also too much of a downer. Not a single uplifting song or a thread of hope on here.

CHRISJ898

Here's my list, i've always been a fan of later pearl jam.

Yield
No Code
Riot Act
Pearl Jam
Binaural
Vitalogy
VS.
Ten

The list is always changing depending on what i listen to, but i never really got into the first two albums. And for a while during the 06 tour all i listened to was self-titled and it was my favorite.

SPEEDY MCCREADY

Flagg wrote:

OK, like everyone else, this changes from time to time.

1) YIELD - This is the album that cemented them as my favorite band and began the obsession. From the opening shot of Brain of J, to the contemplative ending of All Those Yesterdays, to me this is a flawless record. I think it captures their sound and their potential better than any other record. Given to Fly says all you need to know about this great band.

2) Vs. - The first album I can remember where I actually stood in line to buy it on the sale date. Solid follow-up to their breakthrough record, this is PJ at their heaviest but also contains some of thier best ballads (Daughter, Small Town). Go, Animal, Blood and RVM show they can hang with anyone but Indifference sets them apart.

3) Pearl Jam - This record restored my faith in them. That is why I rank it so high. I felt they (especially Ed) had begun to mail it in with Riot Act. I think PJ was a consious step by them to regain their edge and get their message back out. The songs are punchy, melodic and Mike hasn't played leads like this since Vs. More Mike!! And Ed is back with his story-telling method of writing. The entire album (except maybe Big Wave) is tied together with the theme of war, loss, and the anxiousness people felt living in America during the difficult years just after the Iraq war begin. And there is a thread of hope too. I said my list changes, and sometimes this moves to the top.

4) Vitalogy - So many great songs. So much anger. Pearl Jam at their pissed off at the world best. I sometimes listen to this record just to hear Ed unleash those blood-curlding screams in Spin the Black Circle and Tremor Christ. If you ever want to blow off steam, you can hardly do better than Last Exit, STBC, Not For You, Tremor Christ. What an opening. Then throw in Whipping. Add in Better Man, Immortality and their unofficial theme song, Corduroy and you have a near perfect snapshot of a band in crisis. The only drawback is too many fillers and silly crap.

5) Ten - The PJ elitist puts 10 at the bottom but really, can you really do that? I hope the remixes sound better. I hate the way this record sounds. We've heard these songs a million times, but Alive still pumps you up. Even Flow still makes you want to pogo. Black still makes you sad. Why Go still makes you pump your fist in the air. Release still puts you in a state of awe when they open with it.

6) Binaural - As above, I hate this sound of this record, even with headphones. I can barely tolerate it. However, that doesn't affect the love I have for most of the songs. When people talk about which songs sound better live than in studio, Binaural is the poster child. Never mind this record, just listen to the 2000 boots to hear the way it was meant to be. That way you can hear Mike kick ass on Breakerfall instead of the aural mess of the record. Also, this is the first record that has a song I can't stand (Evacuation) and the first where I think B sides would have made the album better (Sad).

7) No Code - No Code is a mood record for me. If I am in a good mood, I never play it. If I am sad or something it moves way up. I lost interest in Pearl Jam when this record came out. I thought, well that's it, they will never capture the magic again. 10 years later I figured I was wrong and have grown to like, if not love it. I still think the track-listing is disjointed. It just lacks something. It doesn't flow well and the songs have a distinct lack of hook or in some cases even a chorus. I appreciate it now, but everyone should understand why at the time even big PJ fans gave up on them.

8) Riot Act - I don't want to get into another Riot Act bash, but this album is not very good (to me). The B-sides are better than the album tracks. It doesn't flow well at all. How do you leave off Down? How about Undone? They claim this to be a political statement but leave off two of the most political songs they have? How about Other Side? Give me that over 40 Help Helps, Get Rights, Cropdusters, etc. To may other people contributed lyrics and the songs suffer for it. The best are the ones Ed wrote himself and I think he mailed his vocal performance in. Save You takes on a whole new life live. For the first time, I was really disappointed in Eddie's performance. Outside of Arc, Can't Keep, I Am Mine and All or None, he doesn't really bring anything to the table. There are no "wow" moments. Its also too much of a downer. Not a single uplifting song or a thread of hope on here.

flagg???

ya know i love ya my man....
and you are my favorite person here....

but i think you had WAY TOO MUCH coffee this morning.....hehehehe

DAMN!!!! you put some thought in to that post.....

hehehehehehehehehehehe....................................

ER182263

1. Vitalogy

2. No Code

3. Ten

4. Yield

5. Binaural

6. VS

7. Riot Act

8. Pearl Jam

tunodamai

My list...as it stands at the moment

1. Yield
2. No Code
3. Ten
4. Avocado
5. VS
6. Riot Act
7. Vitalogy
8. Binaural