Arcade Fire's 'Neon Bible' is as good as 'Ten'

Strangest Tribe

What I want to know is when did Echo and the Bunnymen change to Arcade Fire.

I like em though... but Black Mirror really really sounds like Ian McCollough

Alex_Coe

Todd76 wrote:

this is quite possibly the most stupidest thing I have ever read on this board.....

Post ONE SONG that I could really enjoy. And I don't mean have an introspective look at life through horribly whiny singing, I mean a song you can jam out to. Gimme' a Porch. (Oh, and remember it has to be by Arcade Fire. That's the hard part.)

somebodyelsessky2020

Alex_Coe wrote:

Post ONE SONG that I could really enjoy. And I don't mean have an introspective look at life through horribly whiny singing, I mean a song you can jam out to. Gimme' a Porch. (Oh, and remember it has to be by Arcade Fire. That's the hard part.)

funny shit...give me a porch...LMFAO
get us a garbage can on your way so we can put all these shit neon bible cd's where they belong.

abhi101cru

ok, now I need to go and buy an Arcade Fire album tomorrow. Can someone please give me the names of the albums and the orders in which they have come out?

I dont feel like reading the whole thread

somebodyelsessky2020

abhi101cru wrote:

ok, now I need to go and buy an Arcade Fire album tomorrow. Can someone please give me the names of the albums and the orders in which they have come out?

I dont feel like reading the whole thread

terrible
shitty
shittier
holy fucking shit
arcade fire's shittiest non-hits vol. 1

i like matt.c

abhi101cru wrote:

ok, now I need to go and buy an Arcade Fire album tomorrow. Can someone please give me the names of the albums and the orders in which they have come out?

I dont feel like reading the whole thread

there was an ep (no idea what its called)
then there was funeral and now theres neon bible.

soulsinging

Alex_Coe wrote:

Post ONE SONG that I could really enjoy. And I don't mean have an introspective look at life through horribly whiny singing, I mean a song you can jam out to. Gimme' a Porch. (Oh, and remember it has to be by Arcade Fire. That's the hard part.)

wake up. download it somewhere.

soulsinging

Matty Boy wrote:

You've got to be kidding. Arcade Fire will be forgotten in about two years. Ten and Vs are Pearl Jam's best albums and you're delusional if you think Arcade Fire's shit is better than those albums.

i said it's better than ten, not vs. i dont like ten. the production sounds like shit. i didnt realize it until i listened to the remixes on the greatest hits. but ten sounds as dated and cheesy as a bon jovi record in some places. i dont care for it.

vs. beats anything arcade fire have ever done though. but vs. beats anything most bands will ever do in their entire careers, so...

soulsinging

i like matt.c wrote:

there was an ep (no idea what its called)
then there was funeral and now theres neon bible.

the ep's not that great though. just get funeral.

boroff89

Ten forever changed the way I listened to music. Honestly, Neon Bible is doing the same. It is completely brilliant.

boxwine_in_hell

harmless_little_f*** wrote:

Go on, have at it.

Smoke another bowl because you're really high. Arcade Fire blows chow.

dunkman

harmless_little_f*** wrote:

Go on, have at it.

this reminds me of a certain thread :rolleyes:

dude.. remember the rules of Pearl Jam uberfanship is to never ever suggest that something the band has done is weak, or can be contested!!

someone called you a prick, and yet all you've suggested is another bands album is as good as Ten.. not better than.. as good as.. as Soulsinging has said.. PJ fans can be pretentious at times.

I love the band and its music but their uberfans are beginning to get on my tits... i loathe their sanctimonious drivel.

reeferchief

dunkman wrote:

this reminds me of a certain thread :rolleyes:

dude.. remember the rules of Pearl Jam uberfanship is to never ever suggest that something the band has done is weak, or can be contested!!

someone called you a prick, and yet all you've suggested is another bands album is as good as Ten.. not better than.. as good as.. as Soulsinging has said.. PJ fans can be pretentious at times.

I love the band and its music but their uberfans are beginning to get on my tits... i loathe their sanctimonious drivel.

I wonder what effect Arcade Fire opening for Pearl Jam would have?:)

harmless_little_f***

reeferchief wrote:

I wonder what effect Arcade Fire opening for Pearl Jam would have?:)

:eek:

chimpat

You know, I thought Funeral was a pretty good album. Then I saw Arcade Fire at Webster Hall in NYC and they put on an AWESOME show......I revisited the album and really, really liked it.

Neon Bible is just an amazing album in my opinion, there's not a bad song on the disc. I can't stop listening to it, especially songs like "Ocean of Noise" and "Antichrist TV Blues"......just great stuff.

chris01

No album is better than Ten.

intodeep

Todd76 wrote:

It really blows me away how stagnant many peoples taste in music is on this board.....all the whining about the Lollapalooza lineup, the comments about the 00's in the Favorite band by decade thread, and now the Arcade Fire bashing.....I really have very little in common with most people on this board (I dont even really like PJ much anymore)

.....I think its time to go hang out on the Decemberists message board with all the other indie music snobs

LONG LIVE GRUNGE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I can't read any more post. I agree with a good deal Todd76 said.

I like funeral and neon bible a lot. one of my favorite bands now. I still like ten better though but to each their own.

harmless_little_f***

chimpat wrote:

You know, I thought Funeral was a pretty good album. Then I saw Arcade Fire at Webster Hall in NYC and they put on an AWESOME show......I revisited the album and really, really liked it.

Neon Bible is just an amazing album in my opinion, there's not a bad song on the disc. I can't stop listening to it, especially songs like "Ocean of Noise" and "Antichrist TV Blues"......just great stuff.

This is my point. Comparable to Ten in that there isn't a bad song on there. How many albums can you say that about? Not many.

intodeep

Matty Boy wrote:

You've got to be kidding. Arcade Fire will be forgotten in about two years. Ten and Vs are Pearl Jam's best albums and you're delusional if you think Arcade Fire's shit is better than those albums.

THat is funny people said that about them when they released funeral two and a half years ago.

Obviously not forgoten. Maybe they won't be remembered like a media band like U2 and all but they will be remembered like good quality bands like pixies and pavement.

Todd76

intodeep wrote:

THat is funny people said that about them when they released funeral two and a half years ago.

Obviously not forgoten. Maybe they won't be remembered like a media band like U2 and all but they will be remembered like good quality bands like pixies and pavement.

EXACTLY!!!!!!!!!!