Whiskey Clique

SVRDhand13

tempo_n_groove said:

SVRDhand13 said:

I don't know who needs to hear this, but I've found the following bottles are not worth more than their MSRP:

Blanton's
Eagle Rare
Any Weller

The hype around these bottles is absurd.  Put Blanton's in a normal looking bottle and it's comparable to most whiskeys in the $30 range.  

Store pick of Eagle Rare for $35 is a great price though.  I laugh when I see it on the shelves in NY for $75-$100.  

A few months back I saw the local had ER.  So I said great I'll take one, wait, how much are you asking?  $95?!?  You can keep it.

Blantons at $60 I could stomach.  Any more than that and I'm out.

Weller and H Taylor stuff has skyrocketed too.  The taters are having at it!

I got a bottle of Blantons at $55 and was happy with that. Don’t feel the need for another bottle

Weller SR I got for $19 at a total wine in Connecticut just 2 years ago lol.

Taylor is another one! Put it in another bottle and the price is at least cut in half. And that includes the rye. 

DavidD

Back when I was able to find eagle rare on the shelf‘s it was a $45 Canadian bottle now they’ve bumped it up to almost $60. 

Blanton’s was $60 and is now $70. 

Weller antique was $45 or $50 Canadian now $65 if you can find it. 

EH Taylor is only available through a lottery and runs $100 Canadian
When ever I have a chance I buy 2-3 bottles of these. 

Bentleyspop

We do our best to keep the Blantons out of the hands of resellers. And way to many people who are looking for Blantons are looking to get the 8 toppers and never even drink the stuff. There are literally tens of thousands of bottles sitting on people's shelves collecting dust. Never being opened or drank.

I've been known to vet customers and their reasons for wanting a bottle. Took a call the other day from a customer looking to spend whatever was necessary to buy a bottle as a wedding present. Asked her some questions and explained allocations and told her not to pay big money just yet. To keep trying back.

SVRDhand13

Bentleyspop said:

We do our best to keep the Blantons out of the hands of resellers. And way to many people who are looking for Blantons are looking to get the 8 toppers and never even drink the stuff. There are literally tens of thousands of bottles sitting on people's shelves collecting dust. Never being opened or drank.

I've been known to vet customers and their reasons for wanting a bottle. Took a call the other day from a customer looking to spend whatever was necessary to buy a bottle as a wedding present. Asked her some questions and explained allocations and told her not to pay big money just yet. To keep trying back.

That’s very cool of you! 

You can also send this this link lol:

https://www.blantonsbourbonshop.com/shop/set-of-8-blantons-bottle-stoppers

exploderball

I got lucky and finished my stopper collection a few years ago when bottles still hit shelves for MSRP. Not sure I'd even bother trying nowadays. Drank every bit of that juice - easily the best part of the chase...

Bentleyspop

For those of you in the San Diego area Belching Beaver Brewery has private barrel selections for resale. I got the VIP treatment at the Vista location and they had an Old Forester,  Woodford Reserve,  and Jack Daniels Barrel Select for retail. I picked the Woodford to bring home.

SVRDhand13

exploderball said:

I got lucky and finished my stopper collection a few years ago when bottles still hit shelves for MSRP. Not sure I'd even bother trying nowadays. Drank every bit of that juice - easily the best part of the chase...

Sweet looking setup! How’s the Lost Monarch? Been meaning to grab a bottle. 

Cliffy6745

exploderball said:

I got lucky and finished my stopper collection a few years ago when bottles still hit shelves for MSRP. Not sure I'd even bother trying nowadays. Drank every bit of that juice - easily the best part of the chase...

That’s an awesome set up 

exploderball

Cliffy6745 said:

That’s an awesome set up 

SVRDhand13 said:

Sweet looking setup! How’s the Lost Monarch? Been meaning to grab a bottle. 

Thanks! I probably spend a little too much time in that corner of the house. Haha.

I really like Lost Monarch. For the price, it's a great bourye. Way better than the batch of High West bourye I had a few years ago, at less than half the cost. Plus, they plant a tree for every bottle sold. On my 3rd bottle...

tempo_n_groove

Bentleyspop said:

For those of you in the San Diego area Belching Beaver Brewery has private barrel selections for resale. I got the VIP treatment at the Vista location and they had an Old Forester,  Woodford Reserve,  and Jack Daniels Barrel Select for retail. I picked the Woodford to bring home.

I'd be inclined to try the JD and see if they are stepping things up like they did w their barrel proof offerings.

SVRDhand13

exploderball said:

Cliffy6745 said:

That’s an awesome set up 

SVRDhand13 said:

Sweet looking setup! How’s the Lost Monarch? Been meaning to grab a bottle. 

Thanks! I probably spend a little too much time in that corner of the house. Haha.

I really like Lost Monarch. For the price, it's a great bourye. Way better than the batch of High West bourye I had a few years ago, at less than half the cost. Plus, they plant a tree for every bottle sold. On my 3rd bottle...

Thanks. I have High West now and while it’s tasty, the price is way too high. 

tempo_n_groove

SVRDhand13 said:

exploderball said:

Cliffy6745 said:

That’s an awesome set up 

SVRDhand13 said:

Sweet looking setup! How’s the Lost Monarch? Been meaning to grab a bottle. 

Thanks! I probably spend a little too much time in that corner of the house. Haha.

I really like Lost Monarch. For the price, it's a great bourye. Way better than the batch of High West bourye I had a few years ago, at less than half the cost. Plus, they plant a tree for every bottle sold. On my 3rd bottle...

Thanks. I have High West now and while it’s tasty, the price is way too high. 

Mid Winters Dram has been on my radar for a bit now and the price keeps rising...  It sucks when you want to drink something and prices get so high it's just not worth it.

SVRDhand13

tempo_n_groove said:

SVRDhand13 said:

exploderball said:

Cliffy6745 said:

That’s an awesome set up 

SVRDhand13 said:

Sweet looking setup! How’s the Lost Monarch? Been meaning to grab a bottle. 

Thanks! I probably spend a little too much time in that corner of the house. Haha.

I really like Lost Monarch. For the price, it's a great bourye. Way better than the batch of High West bourye I had a few years ago, at less than half the cost. Plus, they plant a tree for every bottle sold. On my 3rd bottle...

Thanks. I have High West now and while it’s tasty, the price is way too high. 

Mid Winters Dram has been on my radar for a bit now and the price keeps rising...  It sucks when you want to drink something and prices get so high it's just not worth it.

Its delicious but the price is too high on that too.  I had it in a bar a few times, but have not had it in a while now.  

Double Rye is the way to go for High West.  Affordable and delicious.  

tempo_n_groove

SVRDhand13 said:

tempo_n_groove said:

SVRDhand13 said:

exploderball said:

Cliffy6745 said:

That’s an awesome set up 

SVRDhand13 said:

Sweet looking setup! How’s the Lost Monarch? Been meaning to grab a bottle. 

Thanks! I probably spend a little too much time in that corner of the house. Haha.

I really like Lost Monarch. For the price, it's a great bourye. Way better than the batch of High West bourye I had a few years ago, at less than half the cost. Plus, they plant a tree for every bottle sold. On my 3rd bottle...

Thanks. I have High West now and while it’s tasty, the price is way too high. 

Mid Winters Dram has been on my radar for a bit now and the price keeps rising...  It sucks when you want to drink something and prices get so high it's just not worth it.

Its delicious but the price is too high on that too.  I had it in a bar a few times, but have not had it in a while now.  

Double Rye is the way to go for High West.  Affordable and delicious.  

I am a buyer at $130.  Just to have it on hand.  Buying a second one is not in the cards though.

So this and the William Larue Weller AC are my white whales.

mca47

SVRDhand13 said:

tempo_n_groove said:

SVRDhand13 said:

exploderball said:

Cliffy6745 said:

That’s an awesome set up 

SVRDhand13 said:

Sweet looking setup! How’s the Lost Monarch? Been meaning to grab a bottle. 

Thanks! I probably spend a little too much time in that corner of the house. Haha.

I really like Lost Monarch. For the price, it's a great bourye. Way better than the batch of High West bourye I had a few years ago, at less than half the cost. Plus, they plant a tree for every bottle sold. On my 3rd bottle...

Thanks. I have High West now and while it’s tasty, the price is way too high. 

Mid Winters Dram has been on my radar for a bit now and the price keeps rising...  It sucks when you want to drink something and prices get so high it's just not worth it.

Its delicious but the price is too high on that too.  I had it in a bar a few times, but have not had it in a while now.  

Double Rye is the way to go for High West.  Affordable and delicious.  

Yeah, I used to like High West's Rendezvous Rye, but the last bottle I got was off (new blend?) and was def not worth the price.  Double Rye is just as good these days and way cheaper.
Midwinter is still one I keep my eyes out for.  Got lucky last year to nab one at retail.  I'm in SLC a lot for work, maybe I'll drive up to Park City and see if I can grab this years release.  

SVRDhand13

tempo_n_groove said:

SVRDhand13 said:

tempo_n_groove said:

SVRDhand13 said:

exploderball said:

Cliffy6745 said:

That’s an awesome set up 

SVRDhand13 said:

Sweet looking setup! How’s the Lost Monarch? Been meaning to grab a bottle. 

Thanks! I probably spend a little too much time in that corner of the house. Haha.

I really like Lost Monarch. For the price, it's a great bourye. Way better than the batch of High West bourye I had a few years ago, at less than half the cost. Plus, they plant a tree for every bottle sold. On my 3rd bottle...

Thanks. I have High West now and while it’s tasty, the price is way too high. 

Mid Winters Dram has been on my radar for a bit now and the price keeps rising...  It sucks when you want to drink something and prices get so high it's just not worth it.

Its delicious but the price is too high on that too.  I had it in a bar a few times, but have not had it in a while now.  

Double Rye is the way to go for High West.  Affordable and delicious.  

I am a buyer at $130.  Just to have it on hand.  Buying a second one is not in the cards though.

So this and the William Larue Weller AC are my white whales.

I hear you.  I passed on bottles at $90 winter 2019.  Probably should have grabbed one then.  

tempo_n_groove

SVRDhand13 said:

tempo_n_groove said:

SVRDhand13 said:

tempo_n_groove said:

SVRDhand13 said:

exploderball said:

Cliffy6745 said:

That’s an awesome set up 

SVRDhand13 said:

Sweet looking setup! How’s the Lost Monarch? Been meaning to grab a bottle. 

Thanks! I probably spend a little too much time in that corner of the house. Haha.

I really like Lost Monarch. For the price, it's a great bourye. Way better than the batch of High West bourye I had a few years ago, at less than half the cost. Plus, they plant a tree for every bottle sold. On my 3rd bottle...

Thanks. I have High West now and while it’s tasty, the price is way too high. 

Mid Winters Dram has been on my radar for a bit now and the price keeps rising...  It sucks when you want to drink something and prices get so high it's just not worth it.

Its delicious but the price is too high on that too.  I had it in a bar a few times, but have not had it in a while now.  

Double Rye is the way to go for High West.  Affordable and delicious.  

I am a buyer at $130.  Just to have it on hand.  Buying a second one is not in the cards though.

So this and the William Larue Weller AC are my white whales.

I hear you.  I passed on bottles at $90 winter 2019.  Probably should have grabbed one then.  

I couldn't find them for that.  Passed on $120 back then...

Last two years I have passed on BTAC bottes of $400 for the Stagg and the Handy.  I would get those for under $200 and to me that was worth it.

I would pay $400 for the Larue though as they are always $800 and up.  Just once though!

Bentleyspop

Went to Ohana last weekend and stayed with friends in San Clemente. Went hunting for some Pliny and came upon this convenience store with a great selection of allocated bottles but notice the prices...

tempo_n_groove

$300 for 12yo Weller?  Go kick rocks...

SVRDhand13

tempo_n_groove said:

SVRDhand13 said:

tempo_n_groove said:

SVRDhand13 said:

tempo_n_groove said:

SVRDhand13 said:

exploderball said:

Cliffy6745 said:

That’s an awesome set up 

SVRDhand13 said:

Sweet looking setup! How’s the Lost Monarch? Been meaning to grab a bottle. 

Thanks! I probably spend a little too much time in that corner of the house. Haha.

I really like Lost Monarch. For the price, it's a great bourye. Way better than the batch of High West bourye I had a few years ago, at less than half the cost. Plus, they plant a tree for every bottle sold. On my 3rd bottle...

Thanks. I have High West now and while it’s tasty, the price is way too high. 

Mid Winters Dram has been on my radar for a bit now and the price keeps rising...  It sucks when you want to drink something and prices get so high it's just not worth it.

Its delicious but the price is too high on that too.  I had it in a bar a few times, but have not had it in a while now.  

Double Rye is the way to go for High West.  Affordable and delicious.  

I am a buyer at $130.  Just to have it on hand.  Buying a second one is not in the cards though.

So this and the William Larue Weller AC are my white whales.

I hear you.  I passed on bottles at $90 winter 2019.  Probably should have grabbed one then.  

I couldn't find them for that.  Passed on $120 back then...

Last two years I have passed on BTAC bottes of $400 for the Stagg and the Handy.  I would get those for under $200 and to me that was worth it.

I would pay $400 for the Larue though as they are always $800 and up.  Just once though!

Stagg was the best bourbon I ever had (2018).  2oz pours for something like $20 each.  Never tried another BTAC, but Laurue would be my top pick.  

Weller 12 is worth $75 tops if you really want to own a bottle.

Anyone try the Barrel Seagrass?  I highly recommend.  Let the bottle open up a few weeks after the first pour and you have a complex, unique rye that keeps you coming back for more.