Conclusion: Nickelback blow!...are not inspiring young bands

135

Comments

  • rick1zoo2rick1zoo2 between a rock and a dumb place Posts: 12,632
    In my opinion trying to argue and debate people's tastes in music is an exercize in futility, that's like trying to say I am wrong because I like the color blue and you like red. I won't knock another persons musical tastes except to joke around.

    If Nickelback is successful with what they are doing, then good for them, and good for their fans who seem to be happy with their music. I think it is also a good thing for the music industry to have bands be successful like that - more people listening to music and more people going to concerts.

    Having said that I personally can't stand Nickelback, I think the singers voice is horrible, to me the music is pop song oriented and boring with quitars that have a lot of feed back to give it that metal sound. Any time I hear a song on the radio with those same qualities, it doesn't matter who they are I always say "ew, another Nickelback song" and turn it off.
  • Niko80 wrote:
    vedpunk wrote:
    bootlegger10 - Just because most people have no taste in music, doesn't make it right. Pearl Jam appeals to a higher class of music fan. Pearl Jam never meant to make music for the sole purpose of selling records to the most people. They make music that has integrity and artistic achievement.

    I was waiting for this agruement to come, that pj's music appeals to 'smarter people'. The thought of us belonging to a higher class of music lovers is a stupid and selfish arguement. I put it in the same lame category as the people who sits on the first rows at shows waiting for rare b-sides to wake up. This is a 'hollier than thou' attitude and it belongs nowhere. Surely not all nickleback fans are idiots for listening to them. Come on..

    +2
    Gimli 1993
    Fargo 2003
    Winnipeg 2005
    Winnipeg 2011
    St. Paul 2014
  • gatorjamgatorjam West Palm Beach, Florida Posts: 196
    Nickelback sucks! My girlfriend likes them and asked me why I thought they sucked. I simply stated it is repetitive ridiculous vocals and guitar riffs that make no sense and all their songs sound the same. I don't consider them rock music just manufactured pop.
    2003-Tampa
    2006-East Rutherford
    2008-West Palm Beach
    2009- Philadelphia
    2016- Fort Lauderdale and Miami
    2022-Denver
    2024- Philadelphia
  • vedpunkvedpunk Posts: 929
    I have five points that I can spell out very easily for everyone to understand:

    1) Selling more records and concert tickets does not equal a "better band"
    2) Selling more records does not equal "more relevant"
    3) Nickelback is not what up and coming bands aspire to be like
    4) 4 out of 5 "younger generation" kids will pick Pearl Jam over Nickelback (my brother is in High School in Chicago
    5) Nickelback is now a Pop Band and can't be compared to alternative rock acts like Pearl Jam

    Like I said before, Nickelback will have absolutely no impact on Rock Music in 25 years. Pearl Jam will be viewed as visionaries and be remembered forever.
  • DewieCoxDewieCox Posts: 11,430
    vedpunk wrote:
    I have five points that I can spell out easy for everyone to understand:

    1) Selling more records and concert tickets does not equal a "better band"
    2) Selling more records does not equal "more relevant"
    3) Nickelback is not what up and coming bands aspire to be like
    4) 4 out of 5 "younger generation" kids will pick Pearl Jam over Nickelback (my brother is in High School in Chicago
    5) Nickelback is now a Pop Band and can't be compared to alternative rock acts like Pearl Jam

    Like I said before, Nickelback will have absolutely no impact on Rock Music in 25 years. Pearl Jam will be viewed as visionaries and be remembered forever.

    1) 100% correct
    2) It does to the record buying audience and since they're reaching more people they are influencing more people
    3) Maybe not Nickelback, but I know my band is the only band at the bar we regular that doesn't play Nickelback and the crap like it.
    4) Yeah, in 1994
    5) Shouldn't be, but they are.
  • DewieCox wrote:

    1) 100% correct
    2) It does to the record buying audience and since they're reaching more people they are influencing more people
    3) Maybe not Nickelback, but I know my band is the only band at the bar we regular that doesn't play Nickelback and the crap like it.
    4) Yeah, in 1994
    5) Shouldn't be, but they are.

    Son of a bitch you beat me to it :lol: My thoughts exactly
    2006: Albany
    2008: MSG I, MSG II, Newark(EV)
    2009: Albany 1-2(EV), Philly 3
    2010: Boston, MSG I
    2013: Buffalo, Brooklyn II, Hartford
    2016: MSG 1, MSG II, Fenway 1
  • gatorjamgatorjam West Palm Beach, Florida Posts: 196
    I propose the billboard come up with a new section for quality music. We can make it sound cool and call it quali top 10. :lol:

    I went to a Radiohead concert in West Palm and I had an extra ticket for row 12. I couldn't sell it at all!! That shows you that no one cares about quality music just the music people tell them is good and is overplayed on the radio.
    2003-Tampa
    2006-East Rutherford
    2008-West Palm Beach
    2009- Philadelphia
    2016- Fort Lauderdale and Miami
    2022-Denver
    2024- Philadelphia
  • vedpunkvedpunk Posts: 929
    4) is a fact (sorry, my High School brother and his friends are over all the time and they can't stand Nickelback. They think Nickelback is for old mothers. They may not buy Pearl Jam but they sure as hell respect them and love their live records)
  • vedpunk wrote:
    4) is a fact (sorry, my High School brother and his friends are over all the time and they can't stand Nickelback. They think Nickelback is for old mothers. They may not buy Pearl Jam but they sure as hell respect them and love their live records)

    So you are saying that just because the 5 high schoolers that you know who prefer PJ over Nickleback means that the millions of teens feel the same way?
    2006: Albany
    2008: MSG I, MSG II, Newark(EV)
    2009: Albany 1-2(EV), Philly 3
    2010: Boston, MSG I
    2013: Buffalo, Brooklyn II, Hartford
    2016: MSG 1, MSG II, Fenway 1
  • PJ_LukinPJ_Lukin Posts: 2,055
    Hey these guys will sell the places out too .... and they aren't even real!
    http://gorillaz.com/

    3d6ab4adbd0619de
    ~!~ Peace ~!~ Love ~!~ Pearl Jam ~!~
  • vedpunkvedpunk Posts: 929
    Drop1The0Leash - Do you work for Nickelback or something? I am extremely confident that most high schoolers today will prefer Pearl Jam over Nickelback.

    Nickelback now appeals to 30-45 year old women and are not the cool band you think they are. Wow, you are way off man.
  • Paul AndrewsPaul Andrews Posts: 2,489
    edited April 2010
    Nickelback are like reality TV - shit but lots of people like it. There are so many ways Nickelback being more popular, tour more, pull more girls, whatever floats the boat doesn't bother me at all.

    "It's like he wants us to be liked by everyone. I mean Led Zeppelin didn't write tunes everybody liked. They left that to the Bee Gees." Wayne Campbell

    Or it's like burgers, you can go to McDonalds and get a McShit Sandwich - and the majority are happy to - or you can go and get one custom made to order at a quality place or do it yourself and really appreciate it as a good meal rather than a quick fix. When i was a kid, I ate at at Macca's, but luckily I learnt better - some never do.

    Do I care that so many people don't appreciate a good burger? No - it's their loss but I'll continue to have my burger made with Scotch Fillet on wholegrain bread, BBQ sauce (eta brand only - am I right Aussies???) with fried egg, jarlsberg cheese, fried onions, baby spinach, beetroot and avocado. On the odd occasion I often like a slice or two of eye bacon. I hope the masses enjoy their McSlopburgers because while there is a market for crap, someone will serve it up. They're happy and having their needs met and by Macca's providing this product, I'm not having to stand behind them in line for a burger.

    This is the same way I rationalise rubbish like dance/house music, Celine Dion, Britney Spears, lady gaga, creed, reality tv, and any other rubbish that could be replaced by something of a much higher quality. Those who like it are welcome to it, I'll continue to have my Pearl Jam with the works and enjoy it. Just imagin
    Post edited by Paul Andrews on
  • Drop1The0LeashDrop1The0Leash Posts: 954
    edited April 2010
    vedpunk wrote:
    Drop1The0Leash - Do you work for Nickelback or something? I am extremely confident that most high schoolers today will prefer Pearl Jam over Nickelback.

    Nickelback now appeals to 30-45 year old women and are not the cool band you think they are. Wow, you are way off man.


    No i fucking hate Nickleback with a passion. I just know that you are wrong, I actually know that most high schoolers prefer neither nickleback or pearl jam but other garbage such as Lady Gaga, Justin Bieder, etc
    Post edited by Drop1The0Leash on
    2006: Albany
    2008: MSG I, MSG II, Newark(EV)
    2009: Albany 1-2(EV), Philly 3
    2010: Boston, MSG I
    2013: Buffalo, Brooklyn II, Hartford
    2016: MSG 1, MSG II, Fenway 1
  • vedpunkvedpunk Posts: 929
    Right on, Paul Andrews!
  • DewieCoxDewieCox Posts: 11,430
    vedpunk wrote:
    Drop1The0Leash - Do you work for Nickelback or something? I am extremely confident that most high schoolers today will prefer Pearl Jam over Nickelback.

    Nickelback now appeals to 30-45 year old women and are not the cool band you think they are. Wow, you are way off man.


    No i fucking hate Nickleback with a passion. I just know that you are wrong, I actually know that most high schoolers prefer neither nickleback or pearl jam but other garbage such as Lady Gaga, Justin Bieder, etc

    But he asked his brothers' 5 friends? :roll:
  • vedpunkvedpunk Posts: 929
    Justin Bieder, are you kidding me? The fact that you said High Schoolers prefer Justin Bieder disproves anything you say. Justin Bieder = middle school buddy.


    Also, we are talking about Nickelback vs Pearl Jam.....get your facts straight bro.
  • vedpunk wrote:
    Justin Bieder, are you kidding me? The fact that you said High Schoolers prefer Justin Bieder disproves anything you say. Justin Bieder = middle school buddy.


    Also, we are talking about Nickelback vs Pearl Jam.....get your facts straight bro.

    Just Bieber just played SNL this weekend. Hes obviously reaching many demographics there slothnuts. And I realize we are talking about pearl jam vs nickleback, BRO I'm just proving ur point #4 wrong. I would bet my life that if you surveyed every teen in the US that Nickleback would beat Pearl Jam by a large margin. Its really sad that it would work out that way but thats how it goes. Teens are so ignorant to good music its ridiculous.
    2006: Albany
    2008: MSG I, MSG II, Newark(EV)
    2009: Albany 1-2(EV), Philly 3
    2010: Boston, MSG I
    2013: Buffalo, Brooklyn II, Hartford
    2016: MSG 1, MSG II, Fenway 1
  • vedpunkvedpunk Posts: 929
    As Ron Burgandy once said, "agree to disagree".

    At the end of the day we both prefer Pearl Jam over Nickelback. (and I still bet most High Schoolers would say the same :)
  • vedpunk wrote:

    At the end of the day we both prefer Pearl Jam over Nickelback. (and I still bet most High Schoolers would say the same :)


    Im going to disregard that parentheses but yes i prefer Pearl Jam over any band obviously. Nickleback can suck a fart outta my ass, I'll listen to Justin Bieber before I listen to them
    2006: Albany
    2008: MSG I, MSG II, Newark(EV)
    2009: Albany 1-2(EV), Philly 3
    2010: Boston, MSG I
    2013: Buffalo, Brooklyn II, Hartford
    2016: MSG 1, MSG II, Fenway 1
  • LikeAnOceanLikeAnOcean Posts: 7,718
    . Teens are so ignorant to good music its ridiculous.


    Music is all relative and subjective.. "good" is an opinion. Most people aren't looking for a deep personal connection with it. If they are happy listening to simplistic, light-hearted music sold by image and popularity, than so be it. People take music with different levels of seriousness... I wouldn't worry about what other people are listening to. It's not going to alter your life. We have choices.

    To say they are ignorant, is being ignorant. Why are you so concerned with what is making them happy?

    Personally, Nickelback makes me want to vomit, but some people are into that.
  • Why are you so concerned with what is making them happy?

    I'm not really sure where you're getting this from? Could careless what makes them happy, I was simply saying that they have no clue what else is out there besides Top 40 music
    2006: Albany
    2008: MSG I, MSG II, Newark(EV)
    2009: Albany 1-2(EV), Philly 3
    2010: Boston, MSG I
    2013: Buffalo, Brooklyn II, Hartford
    2016: MSG 1, MSG II, Fenway 1
  • LikeAnOceanLikeAnOcean Posts: 7,718
    edited April 2010
    Why are you so concerned with what is making them happy?

    I'm not really sure where you're getting this from? Could careless what makes them happy, I was simply saying that they have no clue what else is out there besides Top 40 music
    OK, that I can understand. Exposure.. unfortunately, cheaper catchy stuff catches on better becuase people have short attention spans. Most people don't like to be challenged by music and even you and I have a limit of how much we want to be challenged.

    To me, most, not all, but most pop music is just god awful boring. I still need something relatively familiar, but with just enough of an edge to it that it can still paint a new imaginary landscape for me.
    Post edited by LikeAnOcean on
  • Why are you so concerned with what is making them happy?

    I'm not really sure where you're getting this from? Could careless what makes them happy, I was simply saying that they have no clue what else is out there besides Top 40 music
    OK, that I can understand. Exposure.. unfortunately, cheaper catchy stuff catches on better becuase people have short attention spans.


    I thought the word ignorant would have gotten my point across which by definition means lacking in knowledge; unlearned. But yes that goddamn pop music is catchy and hooks those little teen bastards in. Thats the way it rolls ma dude
    2006: Albany
    2008: MSG I, MSG II, Newark(EV)
    2009: Albany 1-2(EV), Philly 3
    2010: Boston, MSG I
    2013: Buffalo, Brooklyn II, Hartford
    2016: MSG 1, MSG II, Fenway 1
  • LikeAnOceanLikeAnOcean Posts: 7,718

    I thought the word ignorant would have gotten my point across which by definition means lacking in knowledge; unlearned. But yes that goddamn pop music is catchy and hooks those little teen bastards in. Thats the way it rolls ma dude
    I think its ignorant to assume they'll all learn something off the music we like. I'm sure you could find a lot who would open their minds to a new musical spectrum if exposed, but still many would not make the connection.
  • Honestly, who gives a shit about how many people like Nickelback. I never understood why posts like this pop up all the time. Does it make you guys feel good calling down Nickelback fans? Man, there are a lot of elitist pricks on this board.

    Oh, and for the record, I don't like Nickelback.

  • I thought the word ignorant would have gotten my point across which by definition means lacking in knowledge; unlearned. But yes that goddamn pop music is catchy and hooks those little teen bastards in. Thats the way it rolls ma dude
    I think its ignorant to assume they'll all learn something off the music we like. I'm sure you could find a lot who would open their minds to a new musical spectrum if exposed, but still many would not make the connection.

    I'm not saying everyone should like the music I like. There is so much amazing music out there and you gotta explore and find out what fits you and doesnt fit you. I don't like all music but explored and found what I liked and disliked. You cant let top 40 radio and TV be you're main source for what kinda music is out there.
    2006: Albany
    2008: MSG I, MSG II, Newark(EV)
    2009: Albany 1-2(EV), Philly 3
    2010: Boston, MSG I
    2013: Buffalo, Brooklyn II, Hartford
    2016: MSG 1, MSG II, Fenway 1
  • Honestly, who gives a shit about how many people like Nickelback. I never understood why posts like this pop up all the time. Does it make you guys feel good calling down Nickelback fans? Man, there are a lot of elitist pricks on this board.

    Oh, and for the record, I don't like Nickelback.

    Yes that is exactly what we are trying to do, talk down to the thousands of Nickleback fans that come and read the Pearl Jam forum so we can feel good about our elitist selves :roll:
    2006: Albany
    2008: MSG I, MSG II, Newark(EV)
    2009: Albany 1-2(EV), Philly 3
    2010: Boston, MSG I
    2013: Buffalo, Brooklyn II, Hartford
    2016: MSG 1, MSG II, Fenway 1
  • Niko80 wrote:
    vedpunk wrote:
    bootlegger10 - Just because most people have no taste in music, doesn't make it right. Pearl Jam appeals to a higher class of music fan. Pearl Jam never meant to make music for the sole purpose of selling records to the most people. They make music that has integrity and artistic achievement.

    I was waiting for this agruement to come, that pj's music appeals to 'smarter people'. The thought of us belonging to a higher class of music lovers is a stupid and selfish arguement. I put it in the same lame category as the people who sits on the first rows at shows waiting for rare b-sides to wake up. This is a 'hollier than thou' attitude and it belongs nowhere. Surely not all nickleback fans are idiots for listening to them. Come on..

    +2

    +3!
    IF YOU HATE SOMETHING,.. DONT YOU DO IT TOO
  • LikeAnOceanLikeAnOcean Posts: 7,718

    I thought the word ignorant would have gotten my point across which by definition means lacking in knowledge; unlearned. But yes that goddamn pop music is catchy and hooks those little teen bastards in. Thats the way it rolls ma dude
    I think its ignorant to assume they'll all learn something off the music we like. I'm sure you could find a lot who would open their minds to a new musical spectrum if exposed, but still many would not make the connection.

    I'm not saying everyone should like the music I like. There is so much amazing music out there and you gotta explore and find out what fits you and doesnt fit you. I don't like all music but explored and found what I liked and disliked. You cant let top 40 radio and TV be you're main source for what kinda music is out there.
    It's still all relative.

    Last night while hanging out with my buddy's younger buddy, he thought I was so musically informed because I knew who a handful of popular 70s rock bands were.. I mean, he got excited when I recognized Boston.. I was tempted to start quizzing him on a handful of Indie artists I love.. It's weird because of all my friends, I'm the only person who listens to Indie and unpopular music. I've been finding them on my own thanks to the internet and streaming independant radio stations. They're all stuck replaying and loving the same 90s alternative radio hits, which I got tired of years ago.
  • larabi74larabi74 Posts: 8
    I can't believe so many people waste so much time even thinking about something like this...who f#$%ng cares?!?!?!?
    music, the best thing on earth, goes down to one simple matter: you like it or you don't. period. all the rest of anyone's thoughts or arguments are born from there (realted to harmony, inspiration, energy, romance, activism...whatever...).
    and when it comes down to that (liking something or not), you just don't go arround classifying people for their musical taste...that's just as disgusting as racism. Enjoy what you like and let the others do the same.
    Pearl Jam is my favourite band by far...but I mean, really by far, in every sense. And I like Nickelback too. Yeah, they make some catchy, more "commercial type" tunes, but I still like their riffs and enjoy listening to them...so what? Do I have to feel awkward because of that????
    gimme a break...just let anyone listen to whatever they like...and if you don't like something in particular, you're all free souls, you just can choose not to listen to it, and that's it...big deal!
    I'm sure that Ed and the rest of the guys think pretty much this way...
    peace to all!
    what the f*%# is this world turning to....?
Sign In or Register to comment.