Canadian Politics Redux

HughFreakingDillon · April 23

Read the link. Answers both your questions

Parksy · April 24

HughFreakingDillon said:

Read the link. Answers both your questions

So yeah this is what I never quite understood.... Pierre has always said that he didnt want clearance because then he wouldn't be able to discuss things. (correct me if I'm wrong)

But.. if he doesn't have clearance, he wouldn't be privy to anything TO discuss.... so that never made sense to me.

HughFreakingDillon · April 24

Parksy said:

HughFreakingDillon said:

Read the link. Answers both your questions

So yeah this is what I never quite understood.... Pierre has always said that he didnt want clearance because then he wouldn't be able to discuss things. (correct me if I'm wrong)

But.. if he doesn't have clearance, he wouldn't be privy to anything TO discuss.... so that never made sense to me.

And why does he think he should be openly discussing things with the public that are only privy to those with a security clearance??

DarthMaeglin · April 24

You all know that one of PP’s staff gets a briefing on these matters and is allowed to pass on important information to the party leader?

Please stop posting as if PP getting the clearance is the only option.

HughFreakingDillon · April 24

DarthMaeglin said:

You all know that one of PP’s staff gets a briefing on these matters and is allowed to pass on important information to the party leader?

Please stop posting as if PP getting the clearance is the only option.

Please stop posting as if you wouldn’t be outraging about this ad nauseum if this were a liberal.

DarthMaeglin · April 24

HughFreakingDillon said:

DarthMaeglin said:

You all know that one of PP’s staff gets a briefing on these matters and is allowed to pass on important information to the party leader?

Please stop posting as if PP getting the clearance is the only option.

Please stop posting as if you wouldn’t be outraging about this ad nauseum if this were a liberal.

Again, you ignore the post and attack the poster.

HughFreakingDillon · April 24

DarthMaeglin said:

HughFreakingDillon said:

DarthMaeglin said:

You all know that one of PP’s staff gets a briefing on these matters and is allowed to pass on important information to the party leader?

Please stop posting as if PP getting the clearance is the only option.

Please stop posting as if you wouldn’t be outraging about this ad nauseum if this were a liberal.

Again, you ignore the post and attack the poster.

I’m debating your position. I already made my case.

And give me a fucking break. You told me recently to “wrap your gums around my plums”. Save it, hypocrite.

DarthMaeglin · April 24

HughFreakingDillon said:

DarthMaeglin said:

HughFreakingDillon said:

DarthMaeglin said:

You all know that one of PP’s staff gets a briefing on these matters and is allowed to pass on important information to the party leader?

Please stop posting as if PP getting the clearance is the only option.

Please stop posting as if you wouldn’t be outraging about this ad nauseum if this were a liberal.

Again, you ignore the post and attack the poster.

I’m debating your position. I already made my case.

And give me a fucking break. You told me recently to “wrap your gums around my plums”. Save it, hypocrite.

So you disagree with my statement (fact ) that PP can receive any relevant information without getting the full security clearance?

DarthMaeglin · April 24

I guess no one wanted to talk about Carney’s brilliant brilliancy in announcing his government would legislate that anyone convicted of a violent offence, especially domestic violence, would have their firearms license revoked?

Great idea, maybe that’s why it was passed into law 40 years ago.

Damn those inconvenient facts!

dignin · April 24

DarthMaeglin said:

I guess no one wanted to talk about Carney’s brilliant brilliancy in announcing his government would legislate that anyone convicted of a violent offence, especially domestic violence, would have their firearms license revoked?

Great idea, maybe that’s why it was passed into law 40 years ago.

Damn those inconvenient facts!

This is what grasping at straws looks like.

Nobody cares.

dignin · April 24

Pierre Poilievre in a horse race in Carleton as gap with Liberal candidate tightens

Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre’s long-held riding of Carleton has turned into a horse race in the final days of the election campaign

https://ottawacitizen.com/news/pierre-poilievre-tight-race-ottawa-riding

One can dream.

DarthMaeglin · April 25

dignin said:

DarthMaeglin said:

I guess no one wanted to talk about Carney’s brilliant brilliancy in announcing his government would legislate that anyone convicted of a violent offence, especially domestic violence, would have their firearms license revoked?

Great idea, maybe that’s why it was passed into law 40 years ago.

Damn those inconvenient facts!

This is what grasping at straws looks like.

Nobody cares.

How is pointing out either incompetence or manipulation grasping at straws? This was a serious policy announcement by the Liberal Party during an election.

Has PP said he won’t get his security clearance upgraded if he becomes PM? Because otherwise THAT’S grasping at straws as far as I know and can tell.

DarthMaeglin · April 25

dignin said:

Pierre Poilievre in a horse race in Carleton as gap with Liberal candidate tightens

Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre’s long-held riding of Carleton has turned into a horse race in the final days of the election campaign

https://ottawacitizen.com/news/pierre-poilievre-tight-race-ottawa-riding

One can dream.

Maybe if he’s elected PM and doesn’t hold a seat he’ll actually make an attempt at governing the country, unlike Carney who couldn’t even be bothered to table a Throne Speech.

DarthMaeglin · April 25

The sky is blue, according to the Conservative Party of Canada. Pundits then focus on the announcement being made at night.

This is AMT now.

PJ_Soul · April 25

Ugh, I am already so sick of an election campaign season, and what has it been? Like less than 2 months? It just got me thinking about how fucking lucky we are - I cannot even imagine how it must feel to be an American, with their mindbending 2-year election campaigns. It's bad enough dealijg with it from another country. Yay Canada, seriously.

Parksy · April 25

DarthMaeglin said:

You all know that one of PP’s staff gets a briefing on these matters and is allowed to pass on important information to the party leader?

Please stop posting as if PP getting the clearance is the only option.

I personally did not know that... and it still raises a handful of questions. Again, treat me like I'm stupid on this subject because I am lol

Liberal types criticize Pierre because he doesn't have clearance.

Pierre says he doesn't want clearance because he feels it will muzzle him. (Makes no sense to me.)

You're saying his staff have this clearance and tell him (brief him) on these subjects anyways. (Seems illegal to me.)

I'm confused... because it still seems super dumb to me as to why Pierre doesn't just get the clearance. ?

Are you able to explain it to me again so it makes any sense?

DarthMaeglin · April 25

Parksy said:

DarthMaeglin said:

You all know that one of PP’s staff gets a briefing on these matters and is allowed to pass on important information to the party leader?

Please stop posting as if PP getting the clearance is the only option.

I personally did not know that... and it still raises a handful of questions. Again, treat me like I'm stupid on this subject because I am lol

Liberal types criticize Pierre because he doesn't have clearance.

Pierre says he doesn't want clearance because he feels it will muzzle him. (Makes no sense to me.)

You're saying his staff have this clearance and tell him (brief him) on these subjects anyways. (Seems illegal to me.)

I'm confused... because it still seems super dumb to me as to why Pierre doesn't just get the clearance. ?

Are you able to explain it to me again so it makes any sense?

I don’t really have more specifics off the top of my head, but what I do recall reading several times is that it functions the same as the briefings the PM receives.

An assistant with clearance reads the report, triages the information and delivers what they have determined is relevant in a briefing to the leader. Nothing illegal about it unless all the parties have been breaking the rules but I do trust the reporting in this case. There’s guidelines that need to be followed and we, the citizens, are left to trust that they’re followed and the information is acted on appropriately.

Again, unless Poilievre has said he’ll refuse his clearance if he’s elected Prime Minister, this strikes me as grasping at straws. Especially given the Liberals tacit acceptance of Chinese interference on their behalf in this election.

I don’t think anyone here is stupid, by the way. Some, just like myself, aren’t always aware of all the relevant facts. And I do accept and believe that it’s possible to understand the other side while continuing to disagree with their views.

DarthMaeglin · April 25

If this man was so upset, why the seemingly gleeful grin in the picture?

Clearly he reacted instead of responding.

https://torontosun.com/news/local-news/liberal-candidate-defends-campaign-worker-amid-middle-finger-photo-fallout/wcm/2d506df2-3610-4730-9045-84ee63d072f1

Edit: Here’s CBC’s version of the story.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/brantford-boomer-1.7517995

Canadian Politics Redux

Comments