Oasis

pjoasisrule

If you hate them, please explain yourself. I listened to them in the beginning and then just kinda stopped for awhile during what seems to be a backlash against them but after hearing Stop Crying Your Heart Out at the end of Butterfly Effect I went back and listened to the stuff I missed out on and realized that they are actually an amazing band that have constantly produced great music. Do you guys hate them only because of things they said to the media or do you hate their music? If you hate the music, why?

stu gee

This is all personal opinion so if someone likes it and others dont then its no big deal! Doesnt mean eitehr person is right or wrong.

Definitley maybe and Whats the story... are both excellent albums, but since then i havent heard anything that has really grabbed me. The new material is pretty boring in my opinion too.

One of the most over rated bands in recent years in my opinion, although i know loads of my friends love everything they do.

pjoasisrule

stu gee wrote:

This is all personal opinion so if someone likes it and others dont then its no big deal! Doesnt mean eitehr person is right or wrong.

Definitley maybe and Whats the story... are both excellent albums, but since then i havent heard anything that has really grabbed me. The new material is pretty boring in my opinion too.

One of the most over rated bands in recent years in my opinion, although i know loads of my friends love everything they do.

Overrated over there....maybe....but they get no credit at all here

markymark550

I liked Definitely Maybe and (What's the Story) Morning Glory, but starting with Be Here Now, it started sounding like the same songs over and over only with different lyrics. I don't hate them or change the song when they come on, but it's not like I get excited about their music anymore.

stu gee

pjoasisrule wrote:

Overrated over there....maybe....but they get no credit at all here

I didnt know that. They should definitely be credited with writing some fantastic songs, because as i said, DM and WTSMG are both great albums. I just think that since then most of their stuff has been pretty mediocre. The masterplan was ok, but standing on the shoulder of giants was awful in my opinion.

Im sure what i think is awful will be regarded as great by others though, so each to their own.

pjoasisrule

stu gee wrote:

I didnt know that. They should definitely be credited with writing some fantastic songs, because as i said, DM and WTSMG are both great albums. I just think that since then most of their stuff has been pretty mediocre. The masterplan was ok, but standing on the shoulder of giants was awful in my opinion.

Im sure what i think is awful will be regarded as great by others though, so each to their own.

You gotta at least admit that Gas Panic is an amazing song

boxwine_in_hell

pjoasisrule wrote:

If you hate them, please explain yourself. I listened to them in the beginning and then just kinda stopped for awhile during what seems to be a backlash against them but after hearing Stop Crying Your Heart Out at the end of Butterfly Effect I went back and listened to the stuff I missed out on and realized that they are actually an amazing band that have constantly produced great music. Do you guys hate them only because of things they said to the media or do you hate their music? If you hate the music, why?

They never really evolved. It's like the same songs regurgitated over and over again. Maybe it was because they were so successful so early in their careers? PJ is one of the few bands that overcame that pitfall. Also probably has a lot to do with their personas. People just don't generally respond well to arrogance and they were very arrogant at the beginning of their career.

stu gee

Gas Panic is ok, but it all sounds a bit samey to me. Im not saying they are a bad band, i just dont think they are as good as some people will have you believe.

I think with Oasis there are people who overlook them completely and call them rubbish but i think from just listening to DM and WTSMG you can tell that is not true.

On the other hand, over here at least, there are people who wont hear a word against them and claim that they are far better than they really are.

pjoasisrule

boxwine_in_hell wrote:

They never really evolved. It's like the same songs regurgitated over and over again. Maybe it was because they were so successful so early in their careers? PJ is one of the few bands that overcame that pitfall. Also probably has a lot to do with their personas. People just don't generally respond well to arrogance and they were very arrogant at the beginning of their career.

The part about them not evolving isnt true whatsoever, listen to some songs off of Standing on the Shoulders of Giants and Dont Believe The Truth............you would no longer be able to truthfully say that

lowlight10

boxwine_in_hell wrote:

They never really evolved. It's like the same songs regurgitated over and over again. Maybe it was because they were so successful so early in their careers? PJ is one of the few bands that overcame that pitfall. Also probably has a lot to do with their personas. People just don't generally respond well to arrogance and they were very arrogant at the beginning of their career.

not true. check out the last album. Mucky Fingers, Part of the Queue, The Importance of Being Idle--all very unique in style.

I am probably one of the few people who actually hated them during the Live Forever/Wonderwall phase, then caught on during Be Here Now (a VERY underrated album) and have been a devoted fan ever since.

at this point, I am sick to death of Liam. the guy's ego is overinflated, which I dont really care about as long as he performs musically, but his singing has fallen off, and he is the reason that they play the same 10 old songs every freakin night for the last 5 years. Noel needs to ditch Liam, make a solo album or a Liam-less Oasis album, and tour theaters like he did for the promo tour last year.

boxwine_in_hell

pjoasisrule wrote:

The part about them not evolving isnt true whatsoever, listen to some songs off of Standing on the Shoulders of Giants and Dont Believe The Truth............you would no longer be able to truthfully say that

Whatever floats your boat. They just don't excite me in the least. Just being honest.

pjoasisrule

lowlight10 wrote:

not true. check out the last album. Mucky Fingers, Part of the Queue, The Importance of Being Idle--all very unique in style.

I am probably one of the few people who actually hated them during the Live Forever/Wonderwall phase, then caught on during Be Here Now (a VERY underrated album) and have been a devoted fan ever since.

at this point, I am sick to death of Liam. the guy's ego is overinflated , which I dont really care as long as he performs musically, but his singing has fallen off, and he is the reason that they play the same 10 old songs every freakin night for the last 5 years. Noel needs to ditch Liam, make a solo album or a Liam-less Oasis album, and tour theaters like he did for the promo tour last year.

Did you go to the show at UIC a couple summers ago?

soulsinging

stu gee wrote:

I didnt know that. They should definitely be credited with writing some fantastic songs, because as i said, DM and WTSMG are both great albums. I just think that since then most of their stuff has been pretty mediocre. The masterplan was ok, but standing on the shoulder of giants was awful in my opinion.

Im sure what i think is awful will be regarded as great by others though, so each to their own.

it is pretty amazing. form what i understand they are HUGE in the uk and get more ass-kissing than any other band. over here in the states, nobody can name a single oasis song besides wonderwall. all those legendary singles from definitely maybe... i've only heard live forever on the radio here and that happened once. it's unbelievable how different the band is treated here. i like it though cos i love oasis. yeah, they haven't really topped what's the story (though their last album was excellent) but they always release solid albums. plus, not being so hyped over here has meant i dont get annoyed with them the way brit fans seem to...

Housing Jim

Oasis peaked with Definitely Maybe. It was and still is one of the finest albums of all time, let alone one of the finest debuts.

Sadly, it all went downhill from there, or at least after the Some Might Say single which was the last really good song they ever released.

Be Here Now had one or two nice moments at best but was lazy for the most part and too clogged down in look at me I'm a celebrity, I can get Johnny Depp to play guitar on my album type nonsense.

Standing on the Shoulders of Giants is definitely the lowest point in Oasis' career. Anyone who says they've listened to this album in the last 5 years is probably lying. Noel should never have let Liam write songs....Little James was an embarrassment! Maybe he only agreed to it being on there to make his own songs look better cos all of SOTSOG is rubbish.

Heathen Chemistry.....you'd be hard pushed to find many people who can even name a song from that record.

Don't Believe The Truth was heralded as a return to form for Oasis......yeah, it was okay-ish but a return to form it certainly was not.

I saw them play in late 2005 and it was obvious that even the abnd want to forget their middle albums. The set comprised only songs from the latest album and the first two.....they obviously, quite rightly know, no one is interested in hearing them play anything else.

stu gee

I much prefer WTSMG to DM.

pjoasisrule

Housing Jim wrote:

Oasis peaked with Definitely Maybe. It was and still is one of the finest albums of all time, let alone one of the finest debuts.

Sadly, it all went downhill from there, or at least after the Some Might Say single which was the last really good song they ever released.

Be Here Now had one or two nice moments at best but was lazy for the most part and too clogged down in look at me I'm a celebrity, I can get Johnny Depp to play guitar on my album type nonsense.

Standing on the Shoulders of Giants is definitely the lowest point in Oasis' career. Anyone who says they've listened to this album in the last 5 years is probably lying. Noel should never have let Liam write songs....Little James was an embarrassment! Maybe he only agreed to it being on there to make his own songs look better cos all of SOTSOG is rubbish.

Heathen Chemistry.....you'd be hard pushed to find many people who can even name a song from that record.

Don't Believe The Truth was heralded as a return to form for Oasis......yeah, it was okay-ish but a return to form it certainly was not.

I saw them play in late 2005 and it was obvious that even the abnd want to forget their middle albums. The set comprised only songs from the latest album and the first two.....they obviously, quite rightly know, no one is interested in hearing them play anything else.

Why would you see them in concert if you dislike their music so much?

Housing Jim

pjoasisrule wrote:

Why would you see them in concert if you dislike their music so much?

Foo Fighters were supporting....they were the reason we went.

I don't dislike all of Oasis' music......like I said, Definitely Maybe is one of the greatest albums ever, and that night they were really good because they played their best stuff. Oasis gigs these days are a bit like karaoke.....you go to sing along to the old songs, and it's great fun.

pjoasisrule

I find the Foo Fighters to be much more average than Oasis

norm

Well I'll be the hater here. I can't stand them. Horrible singing. Unoriginal music. Sorry guys I just don't see what you like about them but hey that's cool. We all have different tastes but our common denominator is PJ so all is good.

smarchee

it's pretty obvious the original poster has a huge Oasis-bias.

Tell me, who do you consider a better songwriter: Noel Gallagher or Eddie Vedder. If you believe Noel is a better songwriter, please tell me why

Thanks

pjoasisrule

smarchee wrote:

it's pretty obvious the original poster has a huge Oasis-bias.

Tell me, who do you consider a better songwriter: Noel Gallagher or Eddie Vedder. If you believe Noel is a better songwriter, please tell me why

Thanks

I like both equally