Supernova

theboxerorthebag

I think they are going to pick Toby. He has the perfect cheese factor to go along with what they are looking for. Especially after last night and pulling the women up on stage.

vedderwood

Lukas: I actually have been liking him better and better each week! I don't love him, but the last two weeks I've liked his performances! Also, did anyone pick up on Dave Navarro's loserishness??? When he said "You took a classic song and rearranged it to that? That was awesome"....ah, sorry Dave, but you already used that line on Dilana when she sang "Ring of Fire"...get some new lines..haha!

Storm: As annoying as her facial expressions are and that she always seems completely wacked out, she gets MAJOR credit for singing "Bring Me To Life" last night! That is a hard song to sing and other than the opening lyrics that she sang to deep, the rest of it was actually pretty good! She did show great effort and I think she did pull it off okay! Toby was great with the backups!

Toby: Really, really hot! I agree that he has a cheese factor, but he is really good to look at! He did a pretty good job last night!

Ryan: I'm sorry to all of you that are Ryan-fans, but he is by far the nerdiest, cheesiest contestant between the two seasons! It's like he's only doing "spontaneous" things to look spontaneous when you know that he was alone in his room the night before practicing his piano slide...haha! His voice has gotten better, but he basically is just doing all of the cheesy, hoaky things that Tommy Lee keeps suggesting (smashing the guitar for example) and not really being spontaneous on his own! And why does he have such dark, black circles under his eyes? Sorry, but he must go tonight!

Dilana: I still like her a lot! As someone already stated, I do totally agree that I don't get the chills I got the first couple of episodes, but I'm not ready for her to leave yet!

Magni: I love Magni and he might be my favorite, but I didn't think he was great last night! He was good, but not great! It is weird how much he's like Ed from Live....I've met Ed several times, so it's funny to see someone else kind of look/act like him!

Zayra: I want her to come back to the competition!

Poncier

BrainOfJD wrote:

Maybe Newsted would tell him he should have opened his sphincter more but that would be it.

LOL

theboxerorthebag

So who is going to get the "honor" to sing the new song with Supernova tonight?

PJ Pook

I agree with most on here that Storm will be heading home tonight. I actually don't mind her and was suprised at how many Storm-haters there were out there. But I definitely don't think she is well suited for the band. Seriously, we all knew from the start Storm won't be fronting Supernova.

I still think Lukas will make it to the finals and it will probably be Dilana right there beside him. Toby's hot so looking at him isn't bad but seriously, earlier it was taking off his shirt and now bringing chicks up on stage, just not what I want to see. If that's what people want to see, they would just go to see Motley Crue!

edvedder913

My guilty little embarassing pleasure in life is this show.....

Anyway - I agree - I think Storm is heading home. Loved her in the beginning but now I want to punch her. She gets under my skin big time.

Dilana - great job last night. Well suited for this band. Big deal about what she said. Last season JD pissed on everyone and won it. Get over it and move on Dave N. - who i really swear is gay.

Toby - awww he's so cute. That's about it. Back up on Storm's song was good.

Lucas - hate him. He needs to pull something out of his throat - whatever it may be. I swear he is Dr. Neo Cortex from the Crash Bandicoot video games come to life. I think there was ONE song he did this entire show that I thought was well done and I dont even remember which one it was. Bottom 3 tonight PLEASE - very LONG overdue.

Ryan - like him a lot. The underdog. He is really starting to shine. Don't know if he is the man to front this band of dirtbags though. He seems too kind.

Magni - what can I say? I am smitten. I adore him but know he's not winning this thing.

Face it - it is either Lucas or Dilana.

And week after week I dont know who I dislike more. Navarro or Gilby. Annoying.

offigo

I am actually starting to feel completely dupped by this show. I think Lukas is downright horrible. Everytime he finishes I am completely astounded by Supernovas comments. I sit there with my mouth hanging open. He has no range, no stamina he just basically sucks. I have some favorites and I would hate to see any of the rest go but I know one will tonight. It will probably be Storm even though (annoying or not) she sings rings around Lukas.

edvedder913

offigo wrote:

she sings rings around Lukas.

agreed

theboxerorthebag

definately, I like Storm but she is going tonight. Which won't be that bad because then I can go down to Portland to see her play with her band

edvedder913 wrote:

agreed

she sings rings around Lukas.

offigo

icarus wrote:

may be true, but its still not a singing competition. the winner is the best performer/singer/personality/songwriter(?) that fits the band. you could be the best singer or performer and the world and it doesnt mean you would be a good fit in supernova.

Also true, and I do not think that Storm would fit. I also think if you really want a successful band you need to start with some talent. I also feel that have to be kidding with the praise after he sings, did they already sign a contract and they are just pushing him?

pjalive21

Ryan goes home but not Storm???

WTF were they thinking?????

caifan82

Fucking hell!?!

Stupid show has lost all credibility.
Well, actually this might be better for Ryan. I just can't see him singing in Supernova. Would be like Thom Yorke singing with Bon Jovi or something.

CrazyJD

caifan82 wrote:

Would be like Thom Yorke singing with Bon Jovi or something.

Thats the thing.... Ryan was too intense and "piano driven" to lead this pop-rock band... he is talented, MIGHT make a career out of it... his parting comments sort of reinforced my feeling he is pretty arrogant and was purely in this to boost his solo career. As much as he improved, nobody could see him as the lead singer of a party band with Tommy Lee...

Storm has no shot either, but at least she is a bit crazy, outspoken and will party the guys under the table...

Dilana's song and performance was very blah tonight IMO.

jezebeloria

Kinda bummed Ryan was sent home :( Enjoyed watching him grow from week to week. Storm needs to go bye bye!

canucklehead

My brother watches this show religiously and I can't understand why. I think its total crap... watching all these people piss all over these great songs. WTF was with that dude crapping all over Baba.

brainofPJ

imagine this...there is nothing on basic cable and when there is it's usually According To Jim.

so ok, i watch the show. maybe i should have waited to watch tonight before posting, because now i know.

never thought Ryan was that good like some people say here. he's just got this cheezy look on his face when he's trying too hard.

mookie blaylock 10

civ_eng_girl wrote:

I finally pegged what bugs me about Lucas.... (only now, you ask?)..... he looks and sounds like a Muppet. I liked his arrangement of Lithium, but the faux-growl in his voice is starting to sound a little "Grover-esque"... :rolleyes:

I thought Magni was strong, as usual.... that guy's got some pipes! I honestly think he deserves better than fronting anything with Tommy Lee in it....

Ryan's slide was pretty badass... for a piano player... hahaha j/k... i agree that he's a better solo artist though.

Storm has a nice voice, but she's not Supernova material.

I think Toby jumped into the running last night, with his groupie stunt. He's got a strong voice too... I think, personality wise, he's the best fit for the group.

Dilana's performance was cool.... my favorite part was when she head-butted the mic at the end.... hahaha...

you can go visit lukas at hooters in T.O. when the show is over ceg! it would be fun to meet a muppet in person.

i agree with you about 95% on your points...haha...i was also liking the mic head butt at the end of dilana's performance.

mookie blaylock 10

BrainOfJD wrote:

It's obvious that this guy already won. They might as well stop the show now. Lukas could walk up there and fart the Star Spangled Banner and they'd tell him he blew everybody away. Maybe Newsted would tell him he should have opened his sphincter more but that would be it. At first I didn't believe in the Dliana "conspiracy" theory but now I'm thinking that's exactly what it was - she probably gets the most votes but for whatever reason the band wants skunkboy to win so they're trying to make Dilana look bad and Puke-ass look good. That's why they had that ridiculous segment out of nowhere last night where they tried to make him look like a "regular guy," where he's shooting baskets (that looked like the first time he ever touched a basketball BTW), drinking beer, shooting pool, and talking about how he worked at Hooters. Oh, and putting on eyeliner (?)

But hopefuly Storm will get kicked off this week and our long natiional nightmare will finally come to a close. The dewy-eye look was getting on my last nerve last night, holy cripes. "Caveman stance" - LOL!

i would say you're probably right about the lukas thing.

mookie blaylock 10

offigo wrote:

I am actually starting to feel completely dupped by this show. I think Lukas is downright horrible. Everytime he finishes I am completely astounded by Supernovas comments. I sit there with my mouth hanging open. He has no range, no stamina he just basically sucks. I have some favorites and I would hate to see any of the rest go but I know one will tonight. It will probably be Storm even though (annoying or not) she sings rings around Lukas.

totally agree. i feel the same way...after each horrible performance, i go...ok, they are finally going to say something negative, and it's always praise. it makes no sense.

mookie blaylock 10

can't say that i was surprised to see ryan go tonight. i have to say i have enjoyed some of his performances, but they are usuualy the ones that are more serious and usually involve the piano. anything where he is out of that comfort zone for him always seems contrived. good luck to him on the solo career.

the guys from supernova didn't seem interested in any of the three performances at the end. didn't even seem like they were paying attention.

i do agree with gilby saying that dilana kind of got lost in the middle of the talking heads tune, but otherwise i really ejoyed it. nice to hear somebody sing something different for a change. her performance of mother, mother certainly didn't warrant a bottom three vote, so it just goes to show how fickle the voters are, i guess, and how gullible they are to buy into the spin from the last couple of shows.

i really only started watching this show because i'm a big fan of the newkid...since he was with flotsam & jetsam, when he joined metallica, and his involvement with voivod. i was pleasantly surprised to see dialana on the show and so i kept watching.

at this point, though, i'm almost hoping she doesn't get the job and goes out and does her own stuff. she is obviously the most talented performer this season. i would remain interested in the supernova thing if she does get the lead and i'd definitely give it a shot, but i get the feeling as many have said that they have made their choice in lukas for whatever reason, i don't know?!?!?! so they will make a record...deal with lukas' bad attitude, his alcoholism, and his "voice" blowing out after a few shows and start cancelling tour dates.