most overrated artists..in your opinion

Newch91

mookeywrench wrote:

Newch91 wrote:

Bushleaguer28 wrote:

This is precisely WHY U2 is overrated. Mass appeal doesn't mean something is good. Again I cite Taylor Swift, Justin Beiber etc. How many millions of people went and saw T-Swift? Yes, theyre doing something right in terms of mass appeal, but were talking overrated here

U2 are not overrated. They never have been. They've had some of the biggest tours in music history. They changed and redefined stadium shows. They've sold over 150 million albums. They have some of the biggest selling albums in music history. They've won 22 Grammy's, tied with Stevie Wonder for the most.

I guess you believe Elvis, The Beatles, Led Zeppelin, and The Rolling Stones are not good because, as you say, "Mass appeal doesn't mean something is good".

Not all bands with mass appeal are over rated (such as elvis, beatles, zeppelin, stones) but all over-rated bands have an elements of mass appeal (such as U2)

According to bushleaguer28, bands and artists with mass appeal (bands I listed and you listed and I like them all) are not good.

You and bushleaguer28 say U2 is overrated and I disagree with that. I say My Morning Jacket and Arcade Fire are overrated and people disagree with me.

12345AGNST1

im happy that no one was insane enough to say Jimi Hendrix.

Dissidentman

So having immense popularity without immense talent?

Korn


But Nickelback wins this contest every time.

pjamaholic

This is precisely WHY U2 is overrated. Mass appeal doesn't mean something is good. Again I cite Taylor Swift, Justin Beiber etc. How many millions of people went and saw T-Swift? Yes, theyre doing something right in terms of mass appeal, but were talking overrated here[/quote]

U2 are not overrated. They never have been. They've had some of the biggest tours in music history. They changed and redefined stadium shows. They've sold over 150 million albums. They have some of the biggest selling albums in music history. They've won 22 Grammy's, tied with Stevie Wonder for the most.

200 million albums actually. Never understood why there is so much hate for U2 on this board (aside from Bono himself). Nothing wrong with mass appeal, it means they're doing something right. They've been going for years and still selling albums. What's worse are bands with promise who go break up after only a few years and could have gone on for much longer. U2 are definitely not overrated, imo.

Newch91

pjamaholic wrote:

This is precisely WHY U2 is overrated. Mass appeal doesn't mean something is good. Again I cite Taylor Swift, Justin Beiber etc. How many millions of people went and saw T-Swift? Yes, theyre doing something right in terms of mass appeal, but were talking overrated here

U2 are not overrated. They never have been. They've had some of the biggest tours in music history. They changed and redefined stadium shows. They've sold over 150 million albums. They have some of the biggest selling albums in music history. They've won 22 Grammy's, tied with Stevie Wonder for the most.

200 million albums actually. Never understood why there is so much hate for U2 on this board (aside from Bono himself). Nothing wrong with mass appeal, it means they're doing something right. They've been going for years and still selling albums. What's worse are bands with promise who go break up after only a few years and could have gone on for much longer. U2 are definitely not overrated, imo.[/quote]
Good point about them lasting this long. They've been together for 35 years with essentially the same members (The Edge's brother was in it and then he left).

Bushleaguer28

According to bushleaguer28, bands and artists with mass appeal (bands I listed and you listed and I like them all) are not good.

You and bushleaguer28 say U2 is overrated and I disagree with that. I say My Morning Jacket and Arcade Fire are overrated and people disagree with me.

In what world did I say any band with mass appeal was overrated? I'm simply saying that you can't just end a story by saying they have mass appeal therefore not overrated. That's just silly - the two aren't mutually exclusive. Some AMAZING bands don't have any mass appeal. Some shit bands have tons of mass appeal. And PLEASE for the LOVE OF GOD don't cite grammy's as proof for your argument.

My opinion is that U2 is overrated in terms of the quality of their music. My argument doesn't even consider how many tickets they've sold because that's simply not a good barometer to judge music by. See - Beiber, Jonas's, T-Swift etc. Do good bands sell lots of tickets? Yes that's inevitable. But shit bands sell tons of tickets too. You can't just say "lots of tickets therefore not overrated."

eeriepadave

Phish (sorry I never understood all the hype on them)
Kiss
AC/DC

Thoughts_Arrive

U2

peacefrompaul

eeriepadave wrote:

Phish (sorry I never understood all the hype on them)

Oh my God I hate Phish too

peacefrompaul

chadwick wrote:

check this...
...modest mouse, smashing pumpkins....

Oh you sadden me....

Both are in my top 5

Oh well.... All opinion of course

peacefrompaul

Dissidentman wrote:

So having immense popularity without immense talent?

Korn

The little slice of talent they had left the band.

EdsonNascimento

U2 - wait, I'll play you one of their songs on my guitar - dinka, dinka, dinka, dinka, dinka. How was I? Yes, correct - which song was that? Most of them!!!


Bruce Springsteen - populist crap. Here, I'll sing you one of his songs - in bad raspy, crappy voice where a rich performer (I can't call him a singer) and his middle class fans pretend they're downtrodden - "I was born in a poor neighborhood, Go USA, Go USA, Go!" Which song was that? Most of them!!!


Thank you. Begin flaming.....Now.

DewieCox

EdsonNascimento wrote:

U2 - wait, I'll play you one of their songs on my guitar - dinka, dinka, dinka, dinka, dinka. How was I? Yes, correct - which song was that? Most of them!!!


Bruce Springsteen - populist crap. Here, I'll sing you one of his songs - in bad raspy, crappy voice where a rich performer (I can't call him a singer) and his middle class fans pretend they're downtrodden - "I was born in a poor neighborhood, Go USA, Go USA, Go!" Which song was that? Most of them!!!


Thank you. Begin flaming.....Now.

I now feel like I know their entire catalogs.

pjhawks

Radiohead - pure drivel to me. feel they are a band people say they like to show how much they 'get' music or something

Beck - horrible. never understood the appeal of anything he did

Tool - just don't get it at all

g under p

Newch91 wrote:

pjamaholic wrote:

This is precisely WHY U2 is overrated. Mass appeal doesn't mean something is good. Again I cite Taylor Swift, Justin Beiber etc. How many millions of people went and saw T-Swift? Yes, theyre doing something right in terms of mass appeal, but were talking overrated here

U2 are not overrated. They never have been. They've had some of the biggest tours in music history. They changed and redefined stadium shows. They've sold over 150 million albums. They have some of the biggest selling albums in music history. They've won 22 Grammy's, tied with Stevie Wonder for the most.

200 million albums actually. Never understood why there is so much hate for U2 on this board (aside from Bono himself). Nothing wrong with mass appeal, it means they're doing something right. They've been going for years and still selling albums. What's worse are bands with promise who go break up after only a few years and could have gone on for much longer. U2 are definitely not overrated, imo.

Good point about them lasting this long. They've been together for 35 years with essentially the same members (The Edge's brother was in it and then he left).[/quote]

This argument is pointless....they are just going to be some music fans who are NOT going to appreciate any music the the band U2 will create plain and simple. Just like they're some fans that can't stand anything Michael Jackson, Pearl Jam or RUSH has created and produced. I say let it be all of these bands and artists have their fans and their fans love and appreciate their music. Personally I love the band since the Boy album and when I first saw them on the WAR Tour.

PS...I know some friends music who have their own bands who believe there's no difference between
Pearl Jam and Creed.

Peace

Olivavu

Coldplay.

Olivavu

g under p wrote:

Newch91 wrote:

pjamaholic wrote:

This is precisely WHY U2 is overrated. Mass appeal I know some friends music who have their own bands who believe there's no difference between
Pearl Jam and Creed.

Peace

Then they clearly haven't listened to either band.

Indifference71

Radiohead
Tool
Alice in Chains

Jason P

:shock: :shock: :shock:

Indifference71 wrote:

Radiohead
Tool
Alice in Chains

peacefrompaul

Indifference71 wrote:

Tool
Alice in Chains

:shock: :shock: