The Concept of God

Options
1626365676890

Comments

  • brianlux
    brianlux Moving through All Kinds of Terrain. Posts: 43,658
    Smellyman said:
    Knowing there is no heaven makes me appreciate life NOW and the wonders of the world/universe/nature are a site to behold.  How incredibly lucky we are.

    It's why I value human and animal life.  We all only have a short time here.
    I like this a lot.  Even if I thought there might be a heaven I would like this a lot.
    "It's a sad and beautiful world"
    -Roberto Benigni











  • amethgr8
    amethgr8 Posts: 766
    There is great comfort when going through a trying time, giving 120% and the situation still does not go well for you.  You say, I've done all I can do, it's up to god now.  People of faith will say give it up to god.   Or like at the funeral,"knowing loves ones are in heaven" I never found comfort in that. 

    Now that hat I believe in An energy source is the reason for most things, I still have the comfort of giving 120%, things don't go right, I say I have given it my all, it will either happen or it won't.  Maybe belief in God helped me realize that part of life is accepting things you can't change and we don't control everything.

    death is very hard, I don't think I will see my friends and family in heaven,.  Even when I did believe, it wasn't comforting because I knew it would be so long before I'd get there.  (Then there the whole will I get there, judgement day) I think we are here for the moment and when our moment is up and engery is dispersed we enter the next unknown of the prior state and I'm okay because I am here for now, in the present.

    i still live with confidence that with my free will, the universe will take my spirit as far as it will go in this life and for whatever happens next.
    Amy The Great #74594
    New Orleans LA 7/4/95 reschedule 9/17/95
    Chicago IL 1998, 10/9/00, 06/18/03, 05/16/06, 05/17/06
    08/23/09, 08/24/09, Lolla 08/05/07
    Champaign IL 4/23/03
    Grand Rapids MI VFC 10/03/04
    Grand Rapids MI 19May06
    Noblesville IN 05/07/10 Cleveland OH 05/09/10
    PJ 20 2011
    Baltimore MD, Charlottesville VA, Seattle WA 2013
    St. Louis MO, Milwaukee WI 2014
    Tampa FL, Chicago IL, Lexington KY 2016
    Missoula MT 2018
  • Annafalk
    Annafalk Sweden Posts: 4,004
    RYME said:
    PJ_Soul said:
    I know you don't mean any disrespect. And I guess what I've said might be slightly confusing, in that I expressed a sense of jealousy or whatever over the fact that religious folks have this complete surety about living on after death, and having control over their fate after they die. And at the same time, I say that I have a comparable level of comfort and peace as an Atheist. I know those might seem like conflicting statements. However, the reason they aren't is because I find my own comfort and peace in relying on what I think of as truth. While I understand how comforting faith in Heaven must be, and can say that I'm envious of that particular faith, it is counteracted by the fact that I also see it as false. I find no comfort at all in finding faith in something that isn't real.... Not sure how much sense that makes - I know what I mean, lol. ;)
    I guess that converting is too strong of a word.  I'm trying to straddle the line lol.  I'm not here trying to force anyone.
    I guess my aim is for people who are not satisfied with what they believe.  If you are comfortable with what you believe, then good for you, I respect that and stay put. However, if you are not satisfied with what you believe, or don't exactly know what to believe, than you might, I say might, want to give what I've suggested a try.
    And you are always very kind and respectful :)
  • HughFreakingDillon
    HughFreakingDillon Winnipeg Posts: 39,449
    PJ_Soul said:
    I know you don't mean any disrespect. And I guess what I've said might be slightly confusing, in that I expressed a sense of jealousy or whatever over the fact that religious folks have this complete surety about living on after death, and having control over their fate after they die. And at the same time, I say that I have a comparable level of comfort and peace as an Atheist. I know those might seem like conflicting statements. However, the reason they aren't is because I find my own comfort and peace in relying on what I think of as truth. While I understand how comforting faith in Heaven must be, and can say that I'm envious of that particular faith, it is counteracted by the fact that I also see it as false. I find no comfort at all in finding faith in something that isn't real.... Not sure how much sense that makes - I know what I mean, lol. ;)
    yes, I know I was confused by the seemingly contradictory statements until you explained it this way. 
    Hugh Freaking Dillon is currently out of the office, returning sometime in the fall




  • RYME
    RYME Wisconsin Posts: 1,904
    edited August 2017
    Post edited by RYME on
  • hedonist
    hedonist Posts: 24,524
    Just gonna toss this out there and probably said something similar within the last 43 PAGES!

    Raised Jewish, now agnostic.  I am not fierce in what I believe or not - moreso in saying "yeah, I don't know shit....probably will never know".

    My mother had a brain stent inserted last evening after a series of small strokes, and within the agonizing hours we were waiting to know whatinthefuck was happening, a very sweet family member offered me a passage from the Torah.  A prayer for someone in my mom's position, and for those pulling so fucking hard for that person.

    I read the words, and took comfort in them.  Cried too.  Not so much in the higher power or whatever aspect of it, but the intent.  And it helped, despite how unexpectedly choked up I became in the process.  That's how I take anyone's prayers offered to me.  No arrogance on their part, but, to me at least, an extension of love, and care.  Same as "good thoughts".  Who am I to refuse that?  I think I'd be an asshole to do so.

    Offer and receive with grace, even if spectrums differ.

    Find a way through and to peace vs preaching.  Let others find their way; offer help but back off when needed or when asked.  Most do, in my experience.

    Again, intent.   Just be kind and decent, and give others the room to be as you wish for yourself.
  • FoxyRedLa
    FoxyRedLa Lauren / MI Posts: 4,810
    Hedo, wow. 

    I have had a few visits to the hospital for my Dad. A few scary ones a few controlled ones. 

    I'm not going to act like I know what you're going thru. I know your intent was not to focus on your mom. Sending beautiful healing vibes to your mom.

    Thank you for your post. Thank you for sharing. Xoxo
    Oh please let it rain today.
    Those that can be trusted can change their mind.
  • hedonist
    hedonist Posts: 24,524
    Cheers, Foxy.  So many of us in similar positions.  Thank YOU.
  • brianlux
    brianlux Moving through All Kinds of Terrain. Posts: 43,658
    Hedo, I suck at praying but am good at sending out love and good thoughts.   Definitely sending them to you and yours.
    "It's a sad and beautiful world"
    -Roberto Benigni











  • Smellyman
    Smellyman Asia Posts: 4,528
    edited September 2017
    hedonist said:
    Just gonna toss this out there and probably said something similar within the last 43 PAGES!

    Raised Jewish, now agnostic.  I am not fierce in what I believe or not - moreso in saying "yeah, I don't know shit....probably will never know".

    My mother had a brain stent inserted last evening after a series of small strokes, and within the agonizing hours we were waiting to know whatinthefuck was happening, a very sweet family member offered me a passage from the Torah.  A prayer for someone in my mom's position, and for those pulling so fucking hard for that person.

    I read the words, and took comfort in them.  Cried too.  Not so much in the higher power or whatever aspect of it, but the intent.  And it helped, despite how unexpectedly choked up I became in the process.  That's how I take anyone's prayers offered to me.  No arrogance on their part, but, to me at least, an extension of love, and care.  Same as "good thoughts".  Who am I to refuse that?  I think I'd be an asshole to do so.

    Offer and receive with grace, even if spectrums differ.

    Find a way through and to peace vs preaching.  Let others find their way; offer help but back off when needed or when asked.  Most do, in my experience.

    Again, intent.   Just be kind and decent, and give others the room to be as you wish for yourself.
    Awesome it gave you comfort and hope all is well with you and Mom.  How did it go?

    Many things could give comfort though.  A poem, lyrics, prophetic words from a friend etc.  In this case something from the Torah.
  • hedonist
    hedonist Posts: 24,524
    Thank you both - she's a bit off (moreso than usual) but the woman is still rocking it at 88.

    Been a rough road, so if some kind of faith in something, anything, her husband and children? have gotten her through a very dark tunnel, hell to the yeah.

    Whatever gets you through the night (or day, or moment), it's alright.........it's alright :)
  • HughFreakingDillon
    HughFreakingDillon Winnipeg Posts: 39,449
    hedonist said:
    Just gonna toss this out there and probably said something similar within the last 43 PAGES!

    Raised Jewish, now agnostic.  I am not fierce in what I believe or not - moreso in saying "yeah, I don't know shit....probably will never know".

    My mother had a brain stent inserted last evening after a series of small strokes, and within the agonizing hours we were waiting to know whatinthefuck was happening, a very sweet family member offered me a passage from the Torah.  A prayer for someone in my mom's position, and for those pulling so fucking hard for that person.

    I read the words, and took comfort in them.  Cried too.  Not so much in the higher power or whatever aspect of it, but the intent.  And it helped, despite how unexpectedly choked up I became in the process.  That's how I take anyone's prayers offered to me.  No arrogance on their part, but, to me at least, an extension of love, and care.  Same as "good thoughts".  Who am I to refuse that?  I think I'd be an asshole to do so.

    Offer and receive with grace, even if spectrums differ.

    Find a way through and to peace vs preaching.  Let others find their way; offer help but back off when needed or when asked.  Most do, in my experience.

    Again, intent.   Just be kind and decent, and give others the room to be as you wish for yourself.
    first: strength to you, your mother, and your family. 
    second: excellent post
    third: someone praying for you because of a life crisis of some kind is not arrogance, you are correct. when I refer to the arrogance of it, I mean when the intent is rather "oh, you don't believe in god, I will pray for you/your soul" kind of thing. like they somehow believe that they are better off than me, or know better than I do, that they can save me (hero complex), that sort of thing. certainly not in the context that you described. 


    Hugh Freaking Dillon is currently out of the office, returning sometime in the fall




  • hedonist
    hedonist Posts: 24,524
    hedonist said:
    Just gonna toss this out there and probably said something similar within the last 43 PAGES!

    Raised Jewish, now agnostic.  I am not fierce in what I believe or not - moreso in saying "yeah, I don't know shit....probably will never know".

    My mother had a brain stent inserted last evening after a series of small strokes, and within the agonizing hours we were waiting to know whatinthefuck was happening, a very sweet family member offered me a passage from the Torah.  A prayer for someone in my mom's position, and for those pulling so fucking hard for that person.

    I read the words, and took comfort in them.  Cried too.  Not so much in the higher power or whatever aspect of it, but the intent.  And it helped, despite how unexpectedly choked up I became in the process.  That's how I take anyone's prayers offered to me.  No arrogance on their part, but, to me at least, an extension of love, and care.  Same as "good thoughts".  Who am I to refuse that?  I think I'd be an asshole to do so.

    Offer and receive with grace, even if spectrums differ.

    Find a way through and to peace vs preaching.  Let others find their way; offer help but back off when needed or when asked.  Most do, in my experience.

    Again, intent.   Just be kind and decent, and give others the room to be as you wish for yourself.
    first: strength to you, your mother, and your family. 
    second: excellent post
    third: someone praying for you because of a life crisis of some kind is not arrogance, you are correct. when I refer to the arrogance of it, I mean when the intent is rather "oh, you don't believe in god, I will pray for you/your soul" kind of thing. like they somehow believe that they are better off than me, or know better than I do, that they can save me (hero complex), that sort of thing. certainly not in the context that you described. 


    I totally get what you're saying, HFD.  And thank you :)
  • evsgjamm
    evsgjamm Posts: 2,108
    1) Do believers in God include species other than human? Or do believers "believe" FOR those species... ?  Can an inanimate object also believe in an afterlife? example: "When I get torn down, I'll be rebuilt in heaven and will see all the previous buildings that used to stand here before me." 

    2) And when I read discussion about "if you find peace in your belief, then good on ya", does the same reasoning apply to the people on this planet who believe in the 72 virgins they'll receive in heaven if they crash airplanes into occupied buildings with intent on killing Christians?
    Let's go deep. Enough of this kumbaya balogna sandwich, hold the mustard. You NEED mustard! Let's try to put our feet into the shoes of some of the most extreme believers in God (general term implying all gods) and see how we come out on the other end.
    I can't fathom any of you saying "ya, if they are happy believing that, then good on them. Who am I to judge?" then there is something seriously wrong.

    Vancouver '03, Paramount Theatre '05, Saskatoon '05, Calgary '05, Edmonton '05, Saskatoon '11, Calgary '11, Calgary '13

    2010 WATCH IT GO TO FIRE!!
  • evsgjamm
    evsgjamm Posts: 2,108
    Smellyman said:

    If you have 20 minutes give it a watch.  If you have another 20 minutes watch Hitchens' speech at the same event.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1SJ6AV31MxA

    AMEN!
    Vancouver '03, Paramount Theatre '05, Saskatoon '05, Calgary '05, Edmonton '05, Saskatoon '11, Calgary '11, Calgary '13

    2010 WATCH IT GO TO FIRE!!
  • evsgjamm
    evsgjamm Posts: 2,108
    Smellyman, I ended up finding & watching that entire debate. Thanks for showing this to us. 
    Vancouver '03, Paramount Theatre '05, Saskatoon '05, Calgary '05, Edmonton '05, Saskatoon '11, Calgary '11, Calgary '13

    2010 WATCH IT GO TO FIRE!!
  • HughFreakingDillon
    HughFreakingDillon Winnipeg Posts: 39,449
    evsgjamm said:
    1) Do believers in God include species other than human? Or do believers "believe" FOR those species... ?  Can an inanimate object also believe in an afterlife? example: "When I get torn down, I'll be rebuilt in heaven and will see all the previous buildings that used to stand here before me." 

    2) And when I read discussion about "if you find peace in your belief, then good on ya", does the same reasoning apply to the people on this planet who believe in the 72 virgins they'll receive in heaven if they crash airplanes into occupied buildings with intent on killing Christians?
    Let's go deep. Enough of this kumbaya balogna sandwich, hold the mustard. You NEED mustard! Let's try to put our feet into the shoes of some of the most extreme believers in God (general term implying all gods) and see how we come out on the other end.
    I can't fathom any of you saying "ya, if they are happy believing that, then good on them. Who am I to judge?" then there is something seriously wrong.

    you missed the ending to that statement, it is "if you find peace in your belief, then good on ya....AS LONG AS IT HARMS NO ONE ELSE". 
    Hugh Freaking Dillon is currently out of the office, returning sometime in the fall




  • RYME
    RYME Wisconsin Posts: 1,904
    edited September 2017
    evsgjamm said:
    1) Do believers in God include species other than human? Or do believers "believe" FOR those species... ?  Can an inanimate object also believe in an afterlife? example: "When I get torn down, I'll be rebuilt in heaven and will see all the previous buildings that used to stand here before me." 

    2) And when I read discussion about "if you find peace in your belief, then good on ya", does the same reasoning apply to the people on this planet who believe in the 72 virgins they'll receive in heaven if they crash airplanes into occupied buildings with intent on killing Christians?
    Let's go deep. Enough of this kumbaya balogna sandwich, hold the mustard. You NEED mustard! Let's try to put our feet into the shoes of some of the most extreme believers in God (general term implying all gods) and see how we come out on the other end.
    I can't fathom any of you saying "ya, if they are happy believing that, then good on them. Who am I to judge?" then there is something seriously wrong.

    For the most part I believe that God just lets his animals be animals.. But He did create them all and can communicate with any animal at their level if He needs to. He created them all, so in doing so, he created, knows and understands all the unique and complex communications of animals birds insects ext..I've been around a lot of animals I have been around a lot of horses and cattle.  It's an almost spiritual thing for me at the end of my hectic work day in the evening when I feed my horses and refill their water tub, it is a relaxing and humbling experience that I never get tired of, to watch them come up just because I'm there with the hydrant on, they eagerly anticipating a fresh gulp of water.  I can tell you that when a horse comes to drink water, they often suck down 4 or 5 gallons really fast and then pause in total contentment, and sigh, and then take on one last mouthful and kind of walk around and hold it in their mouth for a little bit and they indeed savor that life sustaining water.  And while they don't verbally pray, I get the sense that they know who their creator is.
      Years ago, I was working on a cattle ranch in West Texas and we were training a bunch of young colts.  The initial training process takes about a week, you get them under saddle, you work getting on and getting off, trying to establish trust.  You know before you start a horse typically they've been with their mommy for a year and a half doing whatever they please.  So when you try to get on their back for the first time they look at you like maybe you might want to eat them. So it's all about gaining trust & respect. About Day 2 or 3, there's about 12 of us doing this in a relatively small arena.  And everybody was on the back of a somewhat nervous colt for the first or second time basically kindergarten for horses. A really good horse trainer was  in the center of the arena kind of working with everyone that's on a horse.  Everyone's working on developing a relationship with their horse they're on trying to gain confidence.  The guy in the center has a flag on a stick, kind of directing traffic, this is day two or three..  Going clockwise then counter-clockwise changing the speed from walk to jog back to walk.  You on the horse are working on your horse, neck reining foot cues and hand cues, leg cues.  It's great fun.  I'm laying the groundwork for what I'm trying to say here.  So we're all jogging around the arena counterclockwise and one of the horses spooks gets jumpy & jerky and throws a little fit. The guy on this horse (whose name was Woody Allen not the actor)  what's going along right in front of me, got tossed off went up about 2 ft above the horse and then landed flat on his back. It sounded like a 175lb bag of potatoes landing on the ground.  Now you've got 12 colts jogging around in a relatively tight space (they're all skittish at this stage) The guy lands on the ground (crunch) and all 12 of the horses stopped on a dime. Including the one that tossed him off.  Logically one would think that more horses could easily freak out, or scatter every witch way and the guy might get trampled.  But they all stopped and we're calm while a couple guys went in to help Woody up and get him out of there.  This is an outdoor fenced-in Arena not like PRCA Rodeo Arenas that have beautiful ground up soft dirt hauled in.  The ground that we had to work with was not that nice, made out hard-packed red clay.(much like concrete) Woody suffered a couple of fractured ribs and a stiff sore neck.  We were all grateful that that was all it was.  Later at the end of the day, we' are all sitting around the campfire drinking a few cold ones, talking about the day.  Woody is sitting there right with us, stiff and really sore.  We were all amazed how calm the horses became when he hit the ground, and we all agreed that The Good Lord intervened & calmed them all at once, until we could resume. I tried to move my horse forward a little bit out of the way and he would not budge.  Other guys said the same thing. That was proof enough for me and all of us that our Lord can communicate with animals when he needs to.
    Furthermore as it says in Matthew chapter 10 verse 29 not one Sparrow shall fall on the ground with out your Father.  (And then a few comforting verses) verse 30 but the very hairs on your head are all numbered.
    31 Fear ye not therefore ye are all of more value than many sparrows.
    Read it for yourself here if you choose. He is saying that He is aware even when any bird falls on the ground and that you are much more important to that to Him.

    https://www.kingjamesbibleonline.org/Matthew-Chapter-10/

    Post edited by RYME on
  • RYME
    RYME Wisconsin Posts: 1,904
    Waylon Jennings said it this way...

    https://youtu.be/bpmuXHoySGA
  • HughFreakingDillon
    HughFreakingDillon Winnipeg Posts: 39,449
    so if god can intervene when he chooses, why does he let so many people suffer much more often than not? why not communicate with a person when they are about to get murdered or in a car accident?
    Hugh Freaking Dillon is currently out of the office, returning sometime in the fall