Help Seattle Musician Shawn Smith *Update 7/15

2-feign-reluctance · July 2016

Maybe her Tweeter account got hacked & this is all fake?

jazzbo26 · July 2016

I feel like the mods should get involved in this. I mean if this is false, and someone is using the board to run a scam, isn't that worse than posting ebay links and talking about BJ's?

pledgeagrievance · July 2016

Where there's smoke there's fire. If u feel it's a scam it probably is. There should b no questions or suspicion. Personally, it's seems off so good luck to Mr. Smith if he truly is in need

my2hands · July 2016

Spoken said:
I feel like Pearl Jam fans are being scammed on Facebook with this GoFundMe

How much is this little charade up to?

lotsalemon · July 2016

10K last I checked.
She kinda calls the band out again in her latest update, which to me, isn't gonna win any sympathy. The whole thing just seems odd to me.

bootlegger10 · July 2016

There has to be some guilt felt when you make it big as a musician and your friends who are musicians don't. Not saying they should feel guilty but just human nature.

ldent42 · July 2016

I haven't looked at the gofundme since yesterday, so IDK if it's been updated, but it was stated that the guy she's doing this for doesn't know about it. That strikes me as fishy, and not really something that I would recommend anyone trust. Personally I know it's not exactly the band's business, but if this guy was a friend or something it would be kind of nice if they got ahold of him to ask about this, since they are explicitly named.

Spoken · July 2016

She keeps calling Stone out...not very nice...

hedonist · July 2016

jazzbo26 said:
I feel like the mods should get involved in this. I mean if this is false, and someone is using the board to run a scam, isn't that worse than posting ebay links and talking about BJ's?

I

'd over this.

Kind of surprised this hasn't been formally addressed, if only being a thread in this forum.

**note - formally addressed as in the actual subject, not BJ's. I'll assume the mods are cool on that front

jeffbr · July 2016

2-feign-reluctance said:
Wasn't Xana Andy Wood's girlfriend?

Yup, she was engaged to Andy. She's a Seattle staple, but a little, um, different. Anyway, I'm sure this was done with the purest of intentions, but she certainly has made a bunch of assumptions generated some confusion, and .comes across as unnecessarily abrasive.

Shawn didn't know she had started the gofundme page, and started getting asked questions about his health, with people thinking he was sick. He isn't. Xana's point is that he's 50 years old without any insurance, any safety net, no savings, etc.. so "if" he got sick he'd be screwed. But while he isn't sick, he does struggle financially. He has almost always been a musician working hand-to-mouth. He's always been just on the cusp of breaking through. He's had some great bands (Brad, Pigeonhed, Satchel), and a great solo career, but none of those things have made him financially stable. It is a shame because I think he's one of the greatest voices to come out of Seattle. Shawn is struggling financially, and is always selling gear, or new music to make ends meet and pay the bills. If Xana had worked with Shawn to set something up, and it was written in a more coherent, less abrasive style, I'm sure the fundraising would be even more successful than it has been thus far.

Is this a scam? I doubt it. Shawn's financial struggles are real, and Xana is a friend of his. Does it come across as shady? Sure.

If you'd like to help Stone's friend Shawn, but don't trust this gofundme campaign then buy his music.
A lot of his home recordings and solo stuff can be found here:
https://shawnsmith.bandcamp.com/

Buy his physical media here:
http://www.soundvssilence.bigcartel.com/

hedonist · July 2016

Thanks for the insight, jeff. I'm not inclined to donate but your view helped (as usual) in understanding a bit better.

jeffbr · July 2016

hedonist said:
Thanks for the insight, jeff. I'm not inclined to donate but your view helped (as usual) in understanding a bit better.

Thanks, Hedo. I haven't decided about this gofundme campaign yet. I still have questions. But I do buy Shawn's music, and donate through bandcamp. He gets some money and I get some great tunes! If he pops up and endorses the gofundme site, I'll jump in, but until then I'll remain cautious like many of you.

mfc2006 · July 2016

jeffbr said:

hedonist said:
Thanks for the insight, jeff. I'm not inclined to donate but your view helped (as usual) in understanding a bit better.
Thanks, Hedo. I haven't decided about this gofundme campaign yet. I still have questions. But I do buy Shawn's music, and donate through bandcamp. He gets some money and I get some great tunes! If he pops up and endorses the gofundme site, I'll jump in, but until then I'll remain cautious like many of you.

Same here. Such a huge talent..

Hoping for a better outcome soon

JWPearl · July 2016

While the go fund is doing well I choose not to fund this time even if it is genuine
Something tells me not to this time

demetrios · July 2016

I hope Shawn is doing ok. There hasn't been an update on his Facebook pages but on Twitter he did re tweeted a video hours ago .. https://twitter.com/theeshawnsmith

AO253126 · July 2016

Thanks jeffbr for the insight and the links. I ordered the four CD bundle from http://www.soundvssilence.bigcartel.com/ and will head over to bandcamp to pick up more.

my2hands · July 2016

so he is healthy and has a roof over his head... why are people sending him money? he cant access social services and health insurance? I have no problem helping out a fellow human, but this is ridiculous in my opinion for people just to send money... I like the idea of buying his music, I think that is a much better idea... or maybe he can get a job like the rest of the world maybe?

just because a musician is down on his luck a little doesn't mean people should just send $ to some gofundme account... how about the millions of regular folks out there struggling to get by? i'm sure there of plenty people right on this board that could use a gofundme account to help them get by... there are kids eating out of garbage dumps and i'm supposed to send money to a Seattle musician in good health?

I hope everything works out, but i'm worried about paying my own bills

Spoken · July 2016

Xana update #8 "Keep It Coming".

2-feign-reluctance · July 2016

jeffbr said:

2-feign-reluctance said:
Wasn't Xana Andy Wood's girlfriend?
Yup, she was engaged to Andy. She's a Seattle staple, but a little, um, different. Anyway, I'm sure this was done with the purest of intentions, but she certainly has made a bunch of assumptions generated some confusion, and .comes across as unnecessarily abrasive.

Shawn didn't know she had started the gofundme page, and started getting asked questions about his health, with people thinking he was sick. He isn't. Xana's point is that he's 50 years old without any insurance, any safety net, no savings, etc.. so "if" he got sick he'd be screwed. But while he isn't sick, he does struggle financially. He has almost always been a musician working hand-to-mouth. He's always been just on the cusp of breaking through. He's had some great bands (Brad, Pigeonhed, Satchel), and a great solo career, but none of those things have made him financially stable. It is a shame because I think he's one of the greatest voices to come out of Seattle. Shawn is struggling financially, and is always selling gear, or new music to make ends meet and pay the bills. If Xana had worked with Shawn to set something up, and it was written in a more coherent, less abrasive style, I'm sure the fundraising would be even more successful than it has been thus far.

Is this a scam? I doubt it. Shawn's financial struggles are real, and Xana is a friend of his. Does it come across as shady? Sure.

If you'd like to help Stone's friend Shawn, but don't trust this gofundme campaign then buy his music.
A lot of his home recordings and solo stuff can be found here:
https://shawnsmith.bandcamp.com/

Buy his physical media here:
http://www.soundvssilence.bigcartel.com/

How do you know all this - and speak with certainties in spots?

BLACK35 · July 2016

my2hands said:
so he is healthy and has a roof over his head... why are people sending him money? he cant access social services and health insurance? I have no problem helping out a fellow human, but this is ridiculous in my opinion for people just to send money... I like the idea of buying his music, I think that is a much better idea... or maybe he can get a job like the rest of the world maybe?

just because a musician is down on his luck a little doesn't mean people should just send $ to some gofundme account... how about the millions of regular folks out there struggling to get by? i'm sure there of plenty people right on this board that could use a gofundme account to help them get by... there are kids eating out of garbage dumps and i'm supposed to send money to a Seattle musician in good health?

I hope everything works out, but i'm worried about paying my own bills

Well said, my thoughts exactly

Help Seattle Musician Shawn Smith *Update 7/15

Comments

Categories