Mcain Supporter Attacked and Mutilated!

Anon

Any of you people ever seen anyone attacked by a knife? You try grabbing someone and holding them still and carving a letter into their face. They don't just lay there and say 'bring it on'. They fight. They have wounds to their hands, arms. Something does not add up here. I've seen many knife attack victims.

digster

The only thing more crazy than this at face value is if it was faked.

If it was, holy smokes.

Anon

I'm not for one minute saying that she was not attacked at the ATM with the motivation being robbery. I have a huge problem with the 'B', for the reasons i have already stated above.

Vedderlution_Baby

If the guy is crazy enough to walk up to her at an atm, rob her, and attack her with a knife I don't get why the knife wounds are so shallow and really, done so well. The "B" is actually curved, from what I can see and that's not easy to do with a straight edged weapon, especially in a quick, accurate fashion.

Just seems odd to me.

g under p

Pj_Gurl wrote:

I'm not for one minute saying that she was not attacked at the ATM with the motivation being robbery. I have a huge problem with the 'B', for the reasons i have already stated above.

OK when I first heard this I believed this hook line and sinker however when I saw the photo this story does not hold water. I love forensic science and this doesn't hold up.

1. If you take a good look at the black eye it looks like make up there are no phases of bruising, different coloration (dark blue-purple-black)

2. No swelling around the eye (this after NOT knowing how long after the incident this photo was taken), no broken blood vessels in the eye therefore a blood shot eye. No surrounding superficial swelling or wounds. It appears to be a perfect punch to her left eye.

3. It matters none to me whether the B was upside or not but more of how superficial the B wound appears to be. It appears to may have been done carefully with a fingernail. It appears she never even bled.

She would have to be unconcious for that B to be carved into her faced and if that robber was so vicious he wouldn't want to take the time it would take to carve that B.

4. This happens outside the view of bank cameras, this fits so well together.

5. Lastly after a robbery like this you're going to cry, from what I can see in that photo it doesn't appear that she even cried.

I say simply give her a lie detector test and break it down from there.

Peace

anotherclone

I think the article above mentions she had a friend with her. What was the friend doing when this attack was going on? I'm not saying if it was a female, she would have been able to do much, but did she run and hide while her friend was attacked? I'm a chick, and I might have tried to whack some dude with my purse or something.

I know. Easy for me to say. I suppose I don't know what I'd do given the circumstances. But I'd like to think I'd try to help a friend who was friggin being cut by some guy.

Austicman

I find it highly unlikely that it was done with a knife. It looks like it was done with a fingernail.

Smartypants

digster wrote:

To be objective, I have to say there would probably not be this much questioning on this board if an Obama supporter had been attacked by some guy in Ohio or something.

I disagree because jimed14 posted a story back on page 3 of an Obama supporter being attacked and I'd never heard it before. I think possibly McCain supporters are feeling unfairly portrayed lately so when they heard this story maybe they jumped to publicize it too quickly when they should've waited on some supporting evidence. This'll be embarrasing for them if it's not true....

Edit: I misread the original quote, I thought you were saying there wouldn't be as much publicity if it happened to an Obama supporter. Sorry!

Vedderlution_Baby

What could've happened is that the attacked DID say something about her Mccain bumper sticker but actually didn't do anything in reacting to it other than verbal abuse and the woman decided to scratch the letter into her face for sympathy/anger.


Some things just aren't adding up for me.

jimed14

When extreme conservative Michelle Malkin is suspicious, you can start to see the possibility of this being a hoax coming to light ...

http://michellemalkin.com/2008/10/23/why-that-mccain-volunteers-mutilation-story-smells-awfully-weird/

Again, I wish no violence on anyone, and if she was truly attacked, I sincerely hope her attacker is found, prosecuted and thrown in jail ...

Vedderlution_Baby

jimed14 wrote:

When extreme conservative Michelle Malkin is suspicious, you can start to see the possibility of this being a hoax coming to light ...

http://michellemalkin.com/2008/10/23/why-that-mccain-volunteers-mutilation-story-smells-awfully-weird/

Again, I wish no violence on anyone, and if she was truly attacked, I sincerely hope her attacker is found, prosecuted and thrown in jail ...

Wow.


And I'm going to go ahead and say that that wound was not created with a knife at all.

blackredyellow

jimed14 wrote:

When extreme conservative Michelle Malkin is suspicious, you can start to see the possibility of this being a hoax coming to light ...

http://michellemalkin.com/2008/10/23/why-that-mccain-volunteers-mutilation-story-smells-awfully-weird/

Again, I wish no violence on anyone, and if she was truly attacked, I sincerely hope her attacker is found, prosecuted and thrown in jail ...

Damn.. she's the kind of person who I thought would jump all over this...

Dirtie_Frank

Could the B be upside down because she was lying down and he was looking at her head closest to him. sorry if mentioned already

SoonForgotten2

Dirtie_Frank wrote:

Could the B be upside down because she was lying down and he was looking at her head closest to him. sorry if mentioned already

Of course it could. The real question is: Is that probable?

Dirtie_Frank

SoonForgotten2 wrote:

Of course it could. The real question is: Is that probable?

What effect would this have on the election? Why would someone vote for McCain because of this? It is not like Obama attacked her. Why is it not probable?

jimed14

Dirtie_Frank wrote:

What effect would this have on the election? Why would someone vote for McCain because of this? It is not like Obama attacked her. Why is it not probable?

Playing conspiracy theorist here ... I think an attack on a white female by a black man in western Pennsylvania on the heels of Frank Murtha's comments about a "racist" constituancy would really start to get some white voters currently supporting Obama to think twice.

Race is certainly at play here.

Dirtie_Frank

jimed14 wrote:

Playnig conspiracy theorist here ... I think an attack on a white female by a black man in western Pennsylvania on the heels of Frank Murtha's comments about a "racist" constituancy would really start to get some white voters currently supporting Obama to think twice.

Race is certainly at play here.

Ok I can buy that. But with that why is noone in an uproar about Murtha's comments?

Edit:I'll make another thread for my question do not want to steal this one.

SoonForgotten2

Dirtie_Frank wrote:

What effect would this have on the election? Why would someone vote for McCain because of this? It is not like Obama attacked her. Why is it not probable?

I'm not even talking about the election here. I'm asking how probable is it that any attacker would scratch out something on a victim's face from such a position? It makes zero sense. Did the attacker knock her out?

You asking me what effect this would have on this race is essentially asking me what this woman would be thinking to fake this. I am certainly not in a position to answer that other than to say 'something terribly misguided.'

in_hiding79

mammasan wrote:

That is fucked up. How can people get so violent and crazy over a presidential election? I can understand arguing but causing physical harm to another human being is beyond disgusting.

Especially when both canidates suck serious ass!!

Brain of J.Lo

I can almost see this girl standing in front of a mirror and scratching it into her face with a key or something. It's too perfect, and why on earth would it be backwards?

If I'm wrong, I apologize. But this story is a little fishy.