Cornell haters.

chris05

yeh i know another Cornell thread im sure you all hate me right now. But i seen this guy friday nite and he was amazing, truly amazing. Anyone who says that he has lost his voice is crazy, when he sang say hello 2 heaven i had goosebumps. It was by far one of the best shows i ever seen. So before u bash him, go see him in concert if you havent already.

Brisk.

i hate anti - cornell thread starters.


yeh i cant wait for my 2nd show but thats in september!

he has played 3 uk dates and only ever played hugner strike so hopefulyl we get more totd!

Ledbetterman10

chris05 wrote:

So before u bash him, go see him in concert if you havent already.

most of us who bash him don't bash him because of his music. It's his Jesus-complex that gets to me

Brisk.

Ledbetterman10 wrote:

most of us who bash him don't bash him because of his music. It's his Jesus-complex that gets to me

you dont like a little jesus christ pose?

oppie1

chris05 wrote:

yeh i know another Cornell thread im sure you all hate me right now. But i seen this guy friday nite and he was amazing, truly amazing. Anyone who says that he has lost his voice is crazy, when he sang say hello 2 heaven i had goosebumps. It was by far one of the best shows i ever seen. So before u bash him, go see him in concert if you havent already.

was he wearing his new $200 pair of jeans?

soulsinging

chris05 wrote:

yeh i know another Cornell thread im sure you all hate me right now. But i seen this guy friday nite and he was amazing, truly amazing. Anyone who says that he has lost his voice is crazy, when he sang say hello 2 heaven i had goosebumps. It was by far one of the best shows i ever seen. So before u bash him, go see him in concert if you havent already.

i never said that he lost his voice, i said his was never all that impressive to begin with and that his mindless worshipers who make 9 threads a day about how much they want to get on their knees to kiss his **** are really annoying and pathetic.

searchlightsoul

soulsinging wrote:

i never said that he lost his voice, i said his was never all that impressive to begin with and that his mindless worshipers who make 9 threads a day about how much they want to get on their knees to kiss his **** are really annoying and pathetic.

So if someone said PJ (or silverchair) had no talent that wouldn't piss you off?

LedZepFan

nice..i'm seeing him next saturday in reading...setlists?

soulsinging

searchlightsoul wrote:

So if someone said PJ (or silverchair) had no talent that wouldn't piss you off?

not in the least. i couldn't care less what you think of silverchair. i also won't made 9 threads a day about them to try jamming their genius down your throat.

Tek Money

soulsinging wrote:

not in the least. i couldn't care less what you think of silverchair. i also won't made 9 threads a day about them to try jamming their genius down your throat.

Zing!

Mike_Muse_Rage

soulsinging wrote:

i never said that he lost his voice, i said his was never all that impressive to begin with and that his mindless worshipers who make 9 threads a day about how much they want to get on their knees to kiss his **** are really annoying and pathetic.

Woah, woah. Can you sing his stuff? Can you write songs in such complex time signatures with such crazy syncopation? This guy is impressive as a singer and a songwriter. Although I agree with you about the Cornell ass-kissers, he does screw up as the jeans incident has proven. He still makes and made great music though and that comes above his personality for me.

soulsinging

Mike_Muse_Rage wrote:

Woah, woah. Can you sing his stuff? Can you write songs in such complex time signatures with such crazy syncopation? This guy is impressive as a singer and a songwriter. Although I agree with you about the Cornell ass-kissers, he does screw up as the jeans incident has proven. He still makes and made great music though and that comes above his personality for me.

i cant sing a green day song and make it sound good. im not a singer. doesn't mean i dont give a shit how many different registers or whatever he can hit. listen to birth ritual from the singles soundtrack. that ungodly screech is one of the most hideous noises ive ever heard from a human voicebox (aside from maybe the kings of leon guy at times). i just dont like it. as to crazy syncopation, i dont give a shit. that doesn't appeal to me. it's why i've never really loved matt cameron in pearl jam... he fit perfectly with soundgarden's style, but his drumming just doesnt fit pearl jam. sure, i like some soundgarden and there are worse evils in life than cornell. but he's not the second coming of beethoven like people round here seem to think. so it's annoying to see half of the other music forum on a regular basis full of ass-kissing for a modelling, walmart playing, punk. cornell is going the way of lenny kravitz... a guy who once showed some promise and has since ridden on those laurels and his looks and style.

vmfury

Ledbetterman10 wrote:

It's his Jesus-complex that gets to me

Well....he IS the next best thing.

oppie1 wrote:

was he wearing his new $200 pair of jeans?

That man has impeccable style...especially his jeans.


I saw him in May and I'm going again 2 weeks from now. I can't wait! His voice is still amazing and he makes it look so easy to hit the incredible pitch he does. His stage presence is nothing less than awesome and let's face it....he's the most beautiful man on the planet. *drool* I don't see arrogance. He's intelligent and extremely talented. He's worked hard to be where he is and I commend him for that. Cheers to Chris Cornell!

Juberoo

I wonder if any of the PJ guys were there.

pjoasisrule

Im not a hater but to think that him or any of the bands he has been in are better than Eddie or Pearl Jam is just crazy. Soundgarden was solid and Audioslave had one or two good songs but I am not crazy about either of them, his voice just does not do it for me.

facepollution

See the thing with Chris Cornell is, whether you like it or not, on a technical basis he has an incredible voice, far far beyond what the vast majority of rock vocalists can do. Whether someone digs his tone or style is completely irrelevent, it would be like saying Aretha Franklin has a bad voice, or can't sing - it's plainly not true. Yet so many of the haters out there will just put him down and say he has a shit voice, proving they can't really know much about the art of singing, and let's be fair, it most certainly is a talent, being able to push your voice to it's extremes, is something that a lot of people will work at their whole lives - and still not get anywhere near what Cornell can do. I guess then it's even more annoying to know that Cornell's ability seems to come to him so very easily.

Back to why I think a lot of people dislike him, I think a lot of it boils down to him being the absolute epitome of alpha male. I think a lot of people might see him as arrogant, cause he has the movie star good looks, and loads of women seem to love him as much for his looks as his voice, but I think it's a great disservice to dismiss him just because of that. For me it's all about the voice, it never ceases to amaze me. I'm not saying every song of his is good, BUT his voice seems to convey so much emotion and power, which I just don't hear in many other singers. I challenge anyone to listen to Say Hello 2 Heaven and not be moved by it.

soulsinging

vmfury wrote:

Well....he IS the next best thing.

That man has impeccable style...especially his jeans.

I saw him in May and I'm going again 2 weeks from now. I can't wait! His voice is still amazing and he makes it look so easy to hit the incredible pitch he does. His stage presence is nothing less than awesome and let's face it....he's the most beautiful man on the planet. *drool* I don't see arrogance. He's intelligent and extremely talented. He's worked hard to be where he is and I commend him for that. Cheers to Chris Cornell!

this is why im a cornell hater... middle aged women creaming their skirts becos he's so gorgeous and dresses so nice. when the fuck did dressing nice become part of rock and roll? i hate that beatlemania segment of his fanbase, girls brought up on grunge who never got over their teenbeat crushes on cornell. add that to the people talking about 'technical skill' like it matters and im just annoyed. most of the best singers in rock had shit for technical skill. then those who do (eddie van halen) doesn't mean shit. all the technical skill in the world can't save you if your wails sound like a baby being spanked.

facepollution

soulsinging wrote:

this is why im a cornell hater... middle aged women creaming their skirts becos he's so gorgeous and dresses so nice. when the fuck did dressing nice become part of rock and roll? i hate that beatlemania segment of his fanbase, girls brought up on grunge who never got over their teenbeat crushes on cornell. add that to the people talking about 'technical skill' like it matters and im just annoyed. most of the best singers in rock had shit for technical skill. then those who do (eddie van halen) doesn't mean shit. all the technical skill in the world can't save you if your wails sound like a baby being spanked.

See I agree with the first part of what you said, but maybe you should give less of a shit about why other people are into a certain band or artist and instead focus on the music itself.

As far as technical skill, I agree that it isn't necessarily important, I like plenty of bands with singers who can't sing, but they have a lot of passion for what they do. So to me, it is even more impressive when someone can combine good lyrics, emotion AND an incredible voice - to me it's as good as it gets.

And as far as his 'wails sound like a baby being spanked', then I would presume you would apply the same statement to Robert Plant, Freddie Mercury, Jeff Buckley etc? And if so, I'm not sure how qualified you are to be talking about rock music

blinddogsdontbelieve

facepollution wrote:

See I agree with the first part of what you said, but maybe you should give less of a shit about why other people are into a certain band or artist and instead focus on the music itself.

As far as technical skill, I agree that it isn't necessarily important, I like plenty of bands with singers who can't sing, but they have a lot of passion for what they do. So to me, it is even more impressive when someone can combine good lyrics, emotion AND an incredible voice - to me it's as good as it gets.

And as far as his 'wails sound like a baby being spanked', then I would presume you would apply the same statement to Robert Plant, Freddie Mercury, Jeff Buckley etc? And if so, I'm not sure how qualified you are to be talking about rock music

Well said. You dont have to like him but you damn well should respect his musical abilities.

soulsinging

facepollution wrote:

See I agree with the first part of what you said, but maybe you should give less of a shit about why other people are into a certain band or artist and instead focus on the music itself.

As far as technical skill, I agree that it isn't necessarily important, I like plenty of bands with singers who can't sing, but they have a lot of passion for what they do. So to me, it is even more impressive when someone can combine good lyrics, emotion AND an incredible voice - to me it's as good as it gets.

And as far as his 'wails sound like a baby being spanked', then I would presume you would apply the same statement to Robert Plant, Freddie Mercury, Jeff Buckley etc? And if so, I'm not sure how qualified you are to be talking about rock music

robert plant annoys me at times, and i never really listen to queen. jeff buckley is good. im not saying cornell is horrible. it's an exaggerated reaction. his voice isn't THAT bad, it just hits some annoying levels at times. but more importantly, it's not that GOOD either. technically, maybe he mops the floor with anyone else in rock. but i don't care. ill take eddie vedder over that any day. or the guy from muse. or james brown. it's just not all that compelling to me. and im tired of being told cornell is jesus fucking christ with a guitar all the time and then being lectured about his technical skill and range any time i disagree.

facepollution

soulsinging wrote:

or the guy from muse. it's just not all that compelling to me.

Fuck me, you don't think Matt Bellamy's voice hits some grating notes?! Don't get me wrong, I'm a huge Muse fan, but seriously......actually in some ways I think Cornell and Bellamy are quite similar, in that they both use their voices as an instrument, which is kind of why they both do the stupidly high stuff, it's essentially the same as a guitarist showing off on a solo.

And also you say his voice isn't that good, but you are using that term completely subjectively. Are we in agreeance that anything beyond power/range/versatility is purely subjective? If so, the term 'good' should surely be reserved for the technical side of singing and not whether you like someone's tone or style of singing? All I'm getting at is give credit where it's due, hell I'll admit Mariah Carey has an astounding voice, despite the fact I can't stand a single song she's done.

For the record, I prefer Ed too, the tone of his voice sends shivers done my spine like no other.