*** OAKLAND, CA NIGHT 2 - 2022 SETLIST THREAD ***

Wolf359

vedpunk said:

What song(s) is Dave Grohl playing drums on?

Hunger Strike & Lithium or Come As You Are
(since we are talking fantasy anyways...)

vedpunk

PJammer4life said:

Poll Question:
Dave Grohl I
     Or
Dave A.

John Bonham hologram 

gotthebottle

PJammer4life said:

Poll Question:
Dave Grohl 
     Or
Dave A.

which you want? or which you think will play?
I say WANT Grohl,  THINK neither

CO278952

Eddie on drums and vocals throughout 

heartofadog

PJammer4life said:

Poll Question:
Dave Grohl 
     Or
Dave A.

Dave A played all over the place and couldn’t keep time. Grohl is one of the best drummers of the last 30 years. Pretty easy call imo

vedpunk

heartofadog said:

PJammer4life said:

Poll Question:
Dave Grohl 
     Or
Dave A.

Dave A played all over the place and couldn’t keep time. Grohl is one of the best drummers of the last 30 years. Pretty easy call imo

I’m guessing you’re not a musician?  Wow

dimitrispearljam

i Think tonight is the best setlist of the tour so far .lets see how u guys like it 

MM70435

No Way, Who You Are, Hitchhiker, Rival, 1/2 Full, Happy When I'm Crying, Marker in the Sand.  0% chance any of these songs are played.  Like Go Animal said, I'm trying to will them into existence. 

Save Who

MM70435 said:

No Way, Who You Are, Hitchhiker, Rival, 1/2 Full, Happy When I'm Crying, Marker in the Sand.  0% chance any of these songs are played.  Like Go Animal said, I'm trying to will them into existence. 

They’re saving those for Hamilton😉

heartofadog

vedpunk said:

heartofadog said:

PJammer4life said:

Poll Question:
Dave Grohl 
     Or
Dave A.

Dave A played all over the place and couldn’t keep time. Grohl is one of the best drummers of the last 30 years. Pretty easy call imo

I’m guessing you’re not a musician?  Wow

I am, in fact, a musician. Dave A had a lot of personality as a drummer but he was an extremely busy player and not nearly as steady as other drummers the band has had. I’m guessing you’re not a musician.

dimitrispearljam

1.LONG ROAD

dimitrispearljam

JOSH ON DRUMS

opsopcopolis

No Ed Preset?

heartofadog

opsopcopolis said:

No Ed Preset?

Throw Your Arms Around Me

vedpunk

heartofadog said:

vedpunk said:

heartofadog said:

PJammer4life said:

Poll Question:
Dave Grohl 
     Or
Dave A.

Dave A played all over the place and couldn’t keep time. Grohl is one of the best drummers of the last 30 years. Pretty easy call imo

I’m guessing you’re not a musician?  Wow

I am, in fact, a musician. Dave A had a lot of personality as a drummer but he was an extremely busy player and not nearly as steady as other drummers the band has had. I’m guessing you’re not a musician.

Nothing screams excitement like a “steady” drummer.  It’s a rock band not an orchestra.  Fills and personality make a band unique.  At the same time, the drumming in VS is pretty fucking technical and, more importantly, MEMORABLE!!!

opsopcopolis

heartofadog said:

opsopcopolis said:

No Ed Preset?

Throw Your Arms Around Me

Nice

dimitrispearljam

2.GIVEN TO FLY 

DC111483

dimitrispearljam said:

i Think tonight is the best setlist of the tour so far .lets see how u guys like it 

Interesting. I’ll be following along in excitement. I hope for their sake there’s no astronaut requests that scratch some rarities

ForceofNature101

If anyone out there finds a decent stream, keep us posted!  I got some wine and Saratoga 2000 on right now

Freddy Arheehar

DC111483 said:

dimitrispearljam said:

i Think tonight is the best setlist of the tour so far .lets see how u guys like it 

Interesting. I’ll be following along in excitement. I hope for their sake there’s no astronaut requests that scratch some rarities

or play the astronaut request instead of sleeping by myself - junk 

dimitrispearljam

3.ONCE 

NewJPage

heartofadog said:

PJammer4life said:

Poll Question:
Dave Grohl 
     Or
Dave A.

Dave A played all over the place and couldn’t keep time. Grohl is one of the best drummers of the last 30 years. Pretty easy call imo

Yikes this is bad

Save Who

dimitrispearljam said:

3.ONCE 

I love early set Once!

dimitrispearljam

AAZING DRUMMING FROM JOSH 

DC111483

Freddy Arheehar said:

DC111483 said:

dimitrispearljam said:

i Think tonight is the best setlist of the tour so far .lets see how u guys like it 

Interesting. I’ll be following along in excitement. I hope for their sake there’s no astronaut requests that scratch some rarities

or play the astronaut request instead of sleeping by myself - junk 

Yeah, this would’ve been better too. I’ll just have to keep my fingers crossed for In Hiding in Nashville. 

heartofadog

vedpunk said:

heartofadog said:

vedpunk said:

heartofadog said:

PJammer4life said:

Poll Question:
Dave Grohl 
     Or
Dave A.

Dave A played all over the place and couldn’t keep time. Grohl is one of the best drummers of the last 30 years. Pretty easy call imo

I’m guessing you’re not a musician?  Wow

I am, in fact, a musician. Dave A had a lot of personality as a drummer but he was an extremely busy player and not nearly as steady as other drummers the band has had. I’m guessing you’re not a musician.

Nothing screams excitement like a “steady” drummer.  It’s a rock band not an orchestra.  Fills and personality make a band unique.  At the same time, the drumming in VS is pretty fucking technical and, more importantly, MEMORABLE!!!

If I’m not mistaken one of the reasons he was let go from the band was he couldn’t rein that shit in, ever. Like literally didn’t know how to not play that busy. Liking that style or not is a personal preference but objectively, he was a very busy drummer and didn’t always keep time well. Give me Jack or Matt any day and if the question is Dave A or Dave Fucking Grohl, that’s a pretty easy one for me to answer.

He did play great on Vs though, and there’s no “Go” without him. Important part of the band while he was in it, for sure.

NewJPage

vedpunk said:

heartofadog said:

vedpunk said:

heartofadog said:

PJammer4life said:

Poll Question:
Dave Grohl 
     Or
Dave A.

Dave A played all over the place and couldn’t keep time. Grohl is one of the best drummers of the last 30 years. Pretty easy call imo

I’m guessing you’re not a musician?  Wow

I am, in fact, a musician. Dave A had a lot of personality as a drummer but he was an extremely busy player and not nearly as steady as other drummers the band has had. I’m guessing you’re not a musician.

Nothing screams excitement like a “steady” drummer.  It’s a rock band not an orchestra.  Fills and personality make a band unique.  At the same time, the drumming in VS is pretty fucking technical and, more importantly, MEMORABLE!!!

Best test of this is listen to dave play blood vs. Matt. It's not close how much better dave is

bbiggs

DC111483 said:

dimitrispearljam said:

i Think tonight is the best setlist of the tour so far .lets see how u guys like it 

Interesting. I’ll be following along in excitement. I hope for their sake there’s no astronaut requests that scratch some rarities

Still can’t believe they scratched it. A fantastic  show nonetheless. The band is firing on all cylinders. 

vedpunk

heartofadog said:

vedpunk said:

heartofadog said:

vedpunk said:

heartofadog said:

PJammer4life said:

Poll Question:
Dave Grohl 
     Or
Dave A.

Dave A played all over the place and couldn’t keep time. Grohl is one of the best drummers of the last 30 years. Pretty easy call imo

I’m guessing you’re not a musician?  Wow

I am, in fact, a musician. Dave A had a lot of personality as a drummer but he was an extremely busy player and not nearly as steady as other drummers the band has had. I’m guessing you’re not a musician.

Nothing screams excitement like a “steady” drummer.  It’s a rock band not an orchestra.  Fills and personality make a band unique.  At the same time, the drumming in VS is pretty fucking technical and, more importantly, MEMORABLE!!!

If I’m not mistaken one of the reasons he was let go from the band was he couldn’t rein that shit in, ever. Like literally didn’t know how to not play that busy. Liking that style or not is a personal preference but objectively, he was a very busy drummer and didn’t always keep time well. Give me Jack or Matt any day and if the question is Dave A or Dave Fucking Grohl, that’s a pretty easy one for me to answer.

He did play great on Vs though, and there’s no “Go” without him. Important part of the band while he was in it, for sure.

Fair enough. 🤘🏼

ForceofNature101

heartofadog said:

vedpunk said:

heartofadog said:

vedpunk said:

heartofadog said:

PJammer4life said:

Poll Question:
Dave Grohl 
     Or
Dave A.

Dave A played all over the place and couldn’t keep time. Grohl is one of the best drummers of the last 30 years. Pretty easy call imo

I’m guessing you’re not a musician?  Wow

I am, in fact, a musician. Dave A had a lot of personality as a drummer but he was an extremely busy player and not nearly as steady as other drummers the band has had. I’m guessing you’re not a musician.

Nothing screams excitement like a “steady” drummer.  It’s a rock band not an orchestra.  Fills and personality make a band unique.  At the same time, the drumming in VS is pretty fucking technical and, more importantly, MEMORABLE!!!

If I’m not mistaken one of the reasons he was let go from the band was he couldn’t rein that shit in, ever. Like literally didn’t know how to not play that busy. Liking that style or not is a personal preference but objectively, he was a very busy drummer and didn’t always keep time well. Give me Jack or Matt any day and if the question is Dave A or Dave Fucking Grohl, that’s a pretty easy one for me to answer.

He did play great on Vs though, and there’s no “Go” without him. Important part of the band while he was in it, for sure.

Was there a confirmation on that if I may ask? On the departure of Dave A.  I always got the impression from the books and stories that is was purely a personality clash at that point