Project #9 - Break the Sky: Pearl Jam Live

myra

stateoflove79 wrote:

myra wrote:

tremors wrote:

I still like the one from Version 1 (Albany?), but if people actively don't like it - that's no good!

Me too. I reckon we're merely looking for a stand-in there, right ? Albany is not gone yet, is it ?

It's not Gone (hehe)...but there was a flow issue...but if it's all good with you guys, it's fine with me!

The thing with Chicago is that :
if you guys 'mind the gap', Chicago needs editing just like Albany. If you guys mind the 'beat' and the 'counting', then Chicago is good to go.

uninvited chromosome

stateoflove79 wrote:

mocik wrote:

myra wrote:

So far, it's : Albany or Chicago or Milwaukee or Brisbane, right ?

I like Brisbane a lot because it is a strong version (fucking town and my personal favourite higher 'answers far') but from what I've read you all seem to like more these kind of softer, fragile versions and I get it.
I thought Albany is out for version 2, isn't it for now?
I'm gonna check out the version from Boston.

A fellow Brisbane supporter...YAY!!

I've tried finding these guitar screw ups but I failed

stateoflove79

[/quote]

I like Brisbane a lot because it is a strong version (fucking town and my personal favourite higher 'answers far') but from what I've read you all seem to like more these kind of softer, fragile versions and I get it.
I thought Albany is out for version 2, isn't it for now?
I'm gonna check out the version from Boston.[/quote]
A fellow Brisbane supporter...YAY!! [/quote]



I've tried finding these guitar screw ups but I failed [/quote]
they are honestly so subtle that if I wasn't looking for them, I probably wouldn't even notice.

myra

stateoflove79 wrote:

mocik wrote:

myra wrote:

So far, it's : Albany or Chicago or Milwaukee or Brisbane, right ?

I like Brisbane a lot because it is a strong version (fucking town and my personal favourite higher 'answers far') but from what I've read you all seem to like more these kind of softer, fragile versions and I get it.
I thought Albany is out for version 2, isn't it for now?
I'm gonna check out the version from Boston.

A fellow Brisbane supporter...YAY!!

I added Brisbane to the possible choices only to be nice to you guys, I still don't like it :x

uninvited chromosome

myra wrote:

I added Brisbane to the possible choices only to be nice to you guys, I still don't like it :x

If you don't like the version from Cincinnati say it now!

tremors

myra wrote:

stateoflove79 wrote:

mocik wrote:

I like Brisbane a lot because it is a strong version (fucking town and my personal favourite higher 'answers far') but from what I've read you all seem to like more these kind of softer, fragile versions and I get it.
I thought Albany is out for version 2, isn't it for now?
I'm gonna check out the version from Boston.

A fellow Brisbane supporter...YAY!!

I added Brisbane to the possible choices only to be nice to you guys, I still don't like it :x

This is probably the most involved discussion we've had for any of our projects! I'm not sure if we are any closer to a decision / compromise / definitive version - but I have to go to bed pretty soon, so in the morning I will see what you guys have settled on.....

Gone, eh? Who'd have thought it. I like this song a lot though.

One of the things I have found with doing these compilations and all the comparisons, is just how unique every performance of a lot of songs turns out to be - it's incredible the different range of emotions and the subtleties the band can get out of performing the same song...... unbelievable really. Anyway.... good night!

myra

tremors wrote:

This is probably the most involved discussion we've had for any of our projects! I'm not sure if we are any closer to a decision / compromise / definitive version - but I have to go to bed pretty soon, so in the morning I will see what you guys have settled on.....

Gone, eh? Who'd have thought it. I like this song a lot though.

One of the things I have found with doing these compilations and all the comparisons, is just how unique every performance of a lot of songs turns out to be - it's incredible the different range of emotions and the subtleties the band can get out of performing the same song...... unbelievable really. Anyway.... good night!

Can't keep ??! Ok, this discussion might be 'slightly' longer .
If you have to go now, I think we should all remember you like Albany and Chicago better, huh ? No Brisbane, or such, right ?
:wave:

myra

mocik wrote:

myra wrote:

I added Brisbane to the possible choices only to be nice to you guys, I still don't like it :x

If you don't like the version from Cincinnati say it now!

:silent:

Dazzler

Someone asked for a more intense Life Wasted.

Can't find many, but the only one which I felt was as good a version as Melbourne, was Chicago 15/05.

If chosen, this would free up Severed Hand from Melbourne 13/11 which delivers everything that Antwerp had, but doesn't cut off abruptly.


So my vote...
Life Wasted - Chicago 1
Severed Hand - Melbourne 1
Gone - Chicago 2

Everything else in place and good to go?

uninvited chromosome

myra wrote:

tremors wrote:

This is probably the most involved discussion we've had for any of our projects! I'm not sure if we are any closer to a decision / compromise / definitive version - but I have to go to bed pretty soon, so in the morning I will see what you guys have settled on.....

Gone, eh? Who'd have thought it. I like this song a lot though.

One of the things I have found with doing these compilations and all the comparisons, is just how unique every performance of a lot of songs turns out to be - it's incredible the different range of emotions and the subtleties the band can get out of performing the same song...... unbelievable really. Anyway.... good night!

Can't keep ??! Ok, this discussion might be 'slightly' longer .
If you have to go now, I think we should all remember you like Albany and Chicago better, huh ? No Brisbane, or such, right ?
:wave:

Good night Tremors :wave:

I've given up on Brisbane long time ago. I do think that Milwaukee would be a good compromise between Chicago and Brisbane though!

myra

Dazzler wrote:

Someone asked for a more intense Life Wasted.

Can't find many, but the only one which I felt was as good a version as Melbourne, was Chicago 15/05.

If chosen, this would free up Severed Hand from Melbourne 13/11 which delivers everything that Antwerp had, but doesn't cut off abruptly.


So my vote...
Life Wasted - Chicago 1
Severed Hand - Melbourne 1
Gone - Chicago 2

Everything else in place and good to go?

I take it as a vote for Chicago over Albany for Gone, then ?

stateoflove79

myra wrote:

Dazzler wrote:

Someone asked for a more intense Life Wasted.

Can't find many, but the only one which I felt was as good a version as Melbourne, was Chicago 15/05.

If chosen, this would free up Severed Hand from Melbourne 13/11 which delivers everything that Antwerp had, but doesn't cut off abruptly.


So my vote...
Life Wasted - Chicago 1
Severed Hand - Melbourne 1
Gone - Chicago 2

Everything else in place and good to go?

I take it as a vote for Chicago over Albany for Gone, then ?

If this does happen...that crossfade I talked about earlier may be a big help...

myra

mocik wrote:

myra wrote:

tremors wrote:

This is probably the most involved discussion we've had for any of our projects! I'm not sure if we are any closer to a decision / compromise / definitive version - but I have to go to bed pretty soon, so in the morning I will see what you guys have settled on.....

Gone, eh? Who'd have thought it. I like this song a lot though.

One of the things I have found with doing these compilations and all the comparisons, is just how unique every performance of a lot of songs turns out to be - it's incredible the different range of emotions and the subtleties the band can get out of performing the same song...... unbelievable really. Anyway.... good night!

Can't keep ??! Ok, this discussion might be 'slightly' longer .
If you have to go now, I think we should all remember you like Albany and Chicago better, huh ? No Brisbane, or such, right ?
:wave:

Good night Tremors :wave:

I've given up on Brisbane long time ago. I do think that Milwaukee would be a good compromise between Chicago and Brisbane though!

Ok ...
So it's Albany, Chicago or Milwaukee, right ? Let's put this to the vote and get it sorted out !

uninvited chromosome

myra wrote:

Ok ...
So it's Albany, Chicago or Milwaukee, right ? Let's put this to the vote and get it sorted out !

I vote for Milwaukee, but I like all of them

myra

mocik wrote:

myra wrote:

Ok ...
So it's Albany, Chicago or Milwaukee, right ? Let's put this to the vote and get it sorted out !

I vote for Milwaukee, but I like all of them

I like all those three, and either of those would be fine for me. I'd still vote for Albany, though. I guess Tremors does too. Then Dazzler and Stateoflove79 would vote for Chicago if I got it right.

Dazzler

(Shhh, chicago)

TheRealDanPatch

myra wrote:

mocik wrote:

myra wrote:

Ok ...
So it's Albany, Chicago or Milwaukee, right ? Let's put this to the vote and get it sorted out !

I vote for Milwaukee, but I like all of them

I like all those three, and either of those would be fine for me. I'd still vote for Albany, though. I guess Tremors does too. Then Dazzler and Stateoflove79 would vote for Chicago if I got it right.

After being away for a few hours and trying to catch up on the posts, it seems like we have come down to Albany vs. Chicago.

My vote right now would go with Chicago just on the basis of trying it and seeing how it fits. I love the version from Albany, but I can't get over the whole flow issue.

TheRealDanPatch

Project #9 - "Break the Sky: Pearl Jam Live" **Version 2**

Track List:

Life Wasted - Melbourne, Australia (November 13, 2006)
World Wide Suicide - Vitoria, Spain (September 2, 2006)
Comatose - Auburn Hills, Michigan (May 22, 2006)
Severed Hand - Antwerp, Belgium (August 30, 2006)
Marker In The Sand - Paris, France (September 11, 2006)
Parachutes - Portland, Oregon (July 20, 2006)
Unemployable - San Francisco, California (July 15, 2006)
Big Wave - San Diego, California (July 7, 2006)
Gone
Wasted Reprise - Toronto, Ontario (May 10, 2006)
Army Reserve - Sydney, Australia (November 8, 2006)
Come Back - Santa Barbara, California (July 13, 2006)
Inside Job - Lisbon, Portugal (September 4, 2006)
Masters of War - Washington DC (May 30, 2006)
Throw Your Hatred Down - Adelaide, Australia (November 22, 2006)
I Believe In Miracles - Marseille, France (September 9, 2006)
All Along the Watchtower - San Francisco, California (July 18, 2006)


I am going to have a very busy day at work tomorrow and I will not be able to send Version 2 out for another 24 hours so I left "Gone" blank. You guys figure out which is the best version and if anything else needs to be changed and I will send it out tomorrow.

Great work and discussion. I really think that this one is going to be the best sounding project we have put together.

tremors

This place is full of overweight jobless geeks wrote:

May i suggest some new user names for the EGC?
"Gone", it doesn't sound as bad as I initially thought it would” – Cameron/head geek
“definitely a "flow" issue” – stateoflove/ ultimate critic
“least favourite Pearl Jam album” – tremors/ least favourite
“speech can stay or go. If it stays, it's a bit longish” Myra/new coat needed
“A few minor...very minor guitar screw ups” – stateoflove/ ultimat critic

Don't I know you from the poetry forum? You're the one who throws around hostility - and in one case some cryptic abuse which I strongly believe was actually some very nasty racism. Nobody else seemed to pick up on your racism, but let me tell you - I noticed it.

So now you think it's time to come and be hostile out on the Porch. Why don't you get a life - go and find a good book to read if you don't like the forum and any of the people in it.

tremors

Cameron4President wrote:

Project #9 - "Break the Sky: Pearl Jam Live" **Version 2**

Track List:

Life Wasted - Melbourne, Australia (November 13, 2006)
World Wide Suicide - Vitoria, Spain (September 2, 2006)
Comatose - Auburn Hills, Michigan (May 22, 2006)
Severed Hand - Antwerp, Belgium (August 30, 2006)
Marker In The Sand - Paris, France (September 11, 2006)
Parachutes - Portland, Oregon (July 20, 2006)
Unemployable - San Francisco, California (July 15, 2006)
Big Wave - San Diego, California (July 7, 2006)
Gone
Wasted Reprise - Toronto, Ontario (May 10, 2006)
Army Reserve - Sydney, Australia (November 8, 2006)
Come Back - Santa Barbara, California (July 13, 2006)
Inside Job - Lisbon, Portugal (September 4, 2006)
Masters of War - Washington DC (May 30, 2006)
Throw Your Hatred Down - Adelaide, Australia (November 22, 2006)
I Believe In Miracles - Marseille, France (September 9, 2006)
All Along the Watchtower - San Francisco, California (July 18, 2006)


I am going to have a very busy day at work tomorrow and I will not be able to send Version 2 out for another 24 hours so I left "Gone" blank. You guys figure out which is the best version and if anything else needs to be changed and I will send it out tomorrow.

Great work and discussion. I really think that this one is going to be the best sounding project we have put together.

Looks great!