Project #5 - The Songs of The Who

TheRealDanPatch

tremors wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

Version 1 looks like this with a different "My Generation"

"Pearl Jam: The Kids Are Alright: The Songs of The Who" - Version 1

Track List:

Leaving Here - Columbia, Maryland (9/4/00)
I Can't Explain - San Diego, California (11/7/95)
My Generation - New York City, New York (2/24/94)
The Kids Are Alright - Sacramento, California (10/30/00)
A Quick One, While He’s Away - Torino, Italy (9/19/06)
The Seeker - St. Louis, Missouri (10/5/04)
Let's See Action - The Birdman Sessions - Miami, Florida (Spring 2000)
Baba O'Riley - George, Washington (9/1/05)
Naked Eye - New York City, New York (2/24/94)
Love Reign O'er Me - Mansfield, Massachusetts (6/28/08)
The Real Me - Seattle, Washington (9/22/09)
Squeeze Box - New York City, New York (2/24/94)
Blue, Red and Grey - San Diego, California (6/5/03)

Myra & Tremors - Version 1 link just PM'd.

-"My Generation" swapped out.

Thanks mate, will listen today on my trudge to the supermarket in the frost!!

I like this change. The SQ on Generation is a 100% better.

Pap

Leaving Here - Heerlen, 12-06-00. Check it out guys!

tremors

Cameron4President wrote:

I like this change. The SQ on Generation is a 100% better.

Yes, it's better all round. Works well. Enjoyed the whole thing a lot....What next?

myra

Cameron4President wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

Version 1 looks like this with a different "My Generation"

"Pearl Jam: The Kids Are Alright: The Songs of The Who" - Version 1

Track List:

Leaving Here - Columbia, Maryland (9/4/00)
I Can't Explain - San Diego, California (11/7/95)
My Generation - New York City, New York (2/24/94)
The Kids Are Alright - Sacramento, California (10/30/00)
A Quick One, While He’s Away - Torino, Italy (9/19/06)
The Seeker - St. Louis, Missouri (10/5/04)
Let's See Action - The Birdman Sessions - Miami, Florida (Spring 2000)
Baba O'Riley - George, Washington (9/1/05)
Naked Eye - New York City, New York (2/24/94)
Love Reign O'er Me - Mansfield, Massachusetts (6/28/08)
The Real Me - Seattle, Washington (9/22/09)
Squeeze Box - New York City, New York (2/24/94)
Blue, Red and Grey - San Diego, California (6/5/03)

Myra & Tremors - Version 1 link just PM'd.

-"My Generation" swapped out.

Downloading it now to enjoy it on my drive back

TheRealDanPatch

tremors wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

I like this change. The SQ on Generation is a 100% better.

Yes, it's better all round. Works well. Enjoyed the whole thing a lot....What next?

I had a feeling that you were going to ask me that. Really the next step is figuring out if other changes need to be made and if there are any SQ issues that we can improve. I say that because half of the disc is not SBD and not much can be done to those songs, but it is still worth trying if you have any issues with those songs (Non-SBD).

Overall this project is tight and the it sounds really good regardless of the fact that have of it is from an audience source. I believe that everybody will be pleased with the finished project. I know that this has been my favorite one to listen too so far.

TheRealDanPatch

myra wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

Version 1 looks like this with a different "My Generation"

"Pearl Jam: The Kids Are Alright: The Songs of The Who" - Version 1

Track List:

Leaving Here - Columbia, Maryland (9/4/00)
I Can't Explain - San Diego, California (11/7/95)
My Generation - New York City, New York (2/24/94)
The Kids Are Alright - Sacramento, California (10/30/00)
A Quick One, While He’s Away - Torino, Italy (9/19/06)
The Seeker - St. Louis, Missouri (10/5/04)
Let's See Action - The Birdman Sessions - Miami, Florida (Spring 2000)
Baba O'Riley - George, Washington (9/1/05)
Naked Eye - New York City, New York (2/24/94)
Love Reign O'er Me - Mansfield, Massachusetts (6/28/08)
The Real Me - Seattle, Washington (9/22/09)
Squeeze Box - New York City, New York (2/24/94)
Blue, Red and Grey - San Diego, California (6/5/03)

Myra & Tremors - Version 1 link just PM'd.

-"My Generation" swapped out.

Downloading it now to enjoy it on my drive back

It kicks ass:D

tremors

Cameron4President wrote:

tremors wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

I like this change. The SQ on Generation is a 100% better.

Yes, it's better all round. Works well. Enjoyed the whole thing a lot....What next?

I had a feeling that you were going to ask me that. Really the next step is figuring out if other changes need to be made and if there are any SQ issues that we can improve. I say that because half of the disc is not SBD and not much can be done to those songs, but it is still worth trying if you have any issues with those songs (Non-SBD).

Overall this project is tight and the it sounds really good regardless of the fact that have of it is from an audience source. I believe that everybody will be pleased with the finished project. I know that this has been my favorite one to listen too so far.

Yeah this one has come together pretty quickly, it sounded awesome to me, regardless of the source. An old adage comes to mind..... 'if it ain't broke, don't fix it!!'

I will have a complete detailed listen to Version1 right now, and say if I can hear any problem areas etc

myra

Pap wrote:

Leaving Here - Heerlen, 12-06-00. Check it out guys!

Do you mean the Pinkpop June 12, 2000 version ?
If so, it's a pretty good version indeed.

myra

Cameron4President wrote:

myra wrote:

Downloading it now to enjoy it on my drive back

It kicks ass:D

Yeaaaah !!!!

I like this 'generation' much better.
Giving it one more listen, but I don't really see what should / could be changed there.

The only thing is .... it's a bit short

tremors

myra wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

myra wrote:

Downloading it now to enjoy it on my drive back

It kicks ass:D

Yeaaaah !!!!

I like this 'generation' much better.
Giving it one more listen, but I don't really see what should / could be changed there.

The only thing is .... it's a bit short

Sounded great! Yeah but it is a little short. What about I'm a boy? DId we discover they were tags?

I have to go out for a bit now, but will check in later!

Pap

myra wrote:

Pap wrote:

Leaving Here - Heerlen, 12-06-00. Check it out guys!

Do you mean the Pinkpop June 12, 2000 version ?
If so, it's a pretty good version indeed.

Exactly.

TheRealDanPatch

tremors wrote:

Sounded great! Yeah but it is a little short. What about I'm a boy? DId we discover they were tags?

I have to go out for a bit now, but will check in later!

Tags

myra

Cameron4President wrote:

tremors wrote:

Sounded great! Yeah but it is a little short. What about I'm a boy? DId we discover they were tags?

I have to go out for a bit now, but will check in later!

Tags

So I guess we may just wait for all those cool new Who covers Ed will do when he visits Europe on his way back from Oz then ?

Edit : hope he won't be crazy enough to 'shun the South of France' this time

TheRealDanPatch

myra wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

tremors wrote:

Sounded great! Yeah but it is a little short. What about I'm a boy? DId we discover they were tags?

I have to go out for a bit now, but will check in later!

Tags

So I guess we may just wait for all those cool new Who covers Ed will do when he visits Europe on his way back from Oz then ?

Edit : hope he won't be crazy enough to 'shun the South of France' this time

or Maybe he will do some cool Who covers when he comes back to tour the States

(East Coast, DC) :twisted:

myra

Cameron4President wrote:

myra wrote:

So I guess we may just wait for all those cool new Who covers Ed will do when he visits Europe on his way back from Oz then ?

Edit : hope he won't be crazy enough to 'shun the South of France' this time

or Maybe he will do some cool Who covers when he comes back to tour the States

(East Coast, DC) :twisted:

I suggest we leave it to Tremors to decide whether he should tour Europe or the States next :angel:

tremors

myra wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

myra wrote:

So I guess we may just wait for all those cool new Who covers Ed will do when he visits Europe on his way back from Oz then ?

Edit : hope he won't be crazy enough to 'shun the South of France' this time

or Maybe he will do some cool Who covers when he comes back to tour the States

(East Coast, DC) :twisted:

I suggest we leave it to Tremors to decide whether he should tour Europe or the States next :angel:

He's only playing London and Seattle, and I'm going to both. This is just a rumour though (that I made up)

TheRealDanPatch

myra wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

myra wrote:

So I guess we may just wait for all those cool new Who covers Ed will do when he visits Europe on his way back from Oz then ?

Edit : hope he won't be crazy enough to 'shun the South of France' this time

or Maybe he will do some cool Who covers when he comes back to tour the States

(East Coast, DC) :twisted:

I suggest we leave it to Tremors to decide whether he should tour Europe or the States next :angel:

I reckon I know what he will decide

locked

Cameron4President wrote:

locked wrote:

Ok I can't resist..

"Naked eye" is an all time favorite who cover and there is a bit of a mystery to the track I am goig to recommend:

There is a similar complitation called "squeeze box" on this pj fan site:

http://www.pearljamonline.it/mp3.htm

scroll down the page and you will find the "squeeze box" compilation and links.

This version of Naked eye is credited to the 11/5/96 solo show Ed did with the fastbacks but its not from that show.
I have heard that version and this version side by side and its a different performance from some other show.
I have never been able to ID the source.
The good news is that its excellent sound quality with just one minor goof in Ed's vocal (cracks his voice once)..
If you download the compilation you will posess this rare gem..
very few people have this clip..

I realize you do not want to rip off this person's compliation but there is one other good choice (specifically "I'm one" from 11/27/00.. Ed solo.. its the best version there is out there)

Finally, check out the 7/3/03 Mansfield version of Baba..

I think its superior to your pick , crowd is louder too..

Just my opinion, you guys seem to have the best instincts so keep doing what you do best!

Cool, thank you for that suggestion. I will have to check it out.

TheRealDanPatch

Did Eddie cover any Who songs during his solo tours in '08 & '09?

tremors

locked wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

locked wrote:

Ok I can't resist..

"Naked eye" is an all time favorite who cover and there is a bit of a mystery to the track I am goig to recommend:

There is a similar complitation called "squeeze box" on this pj fan site:

http://www.pearljamonline.it/mp3.htm

scroll down the page and you will find the "squeeze box" compilation and links.

This version of Naked eye is credited to the 11/5/96 solo show Ed did with the fastbacks but its not from that show.
I have heard that version and this version side by side and its a different performance from some other show.
I have never been able to ID the source.
The good news is that its excellent sound quality with just one minor goof in Ed's vocal (cracks his voice once)..
If you download the compilation you will posess this rare gem..
very few people have this clip..

I realize you do not want to rip off this person's compliation but there is one other good choice (specifically "I'm one" from 11/27/00.. Ed solo.. its the best version there is out there)

Finally, check out the 7/3/03 Mansfield version of Baba..

I think its superior to your pick , crowd is louder too..

Just my opinion, you guys seem to have the best instincts so keep doing what you do best!

Cool, thank you for that suggestion. I will have to check it out.

We had some discussion about the 'squeeze box' collection, and I think we concluded that since quite a few people knew of it already, we would try and do something a bit different, and try and use some different versions too

TheRealDanPatch

tremors wrote:

We had some discussion about the 'squeeze box' collection, and I think we concluded that since quite a few people knew of it already, we would try and do something a bit different, and try and use some different versions too

and to add a little bit to what Tremors said, we also do not what to use tracks that have actual members of The Who in them. Most all of the current Who compilations have this and it is a way of just filling space (IMO). We want our compilation to be different from the others. Our compilation pays tribute to The Who, that's one reason we don't include songs that have members of The Who on them, and our compilation is short and sweet. When I say "short and sweet", I mean that it gets to the point, pays tribute, embodies the spirit of The Who, and clocks in (currently) under 50 minutes. I do believe that when everybody gets this compilation, they will be very pleased at the outcome.

Tremors, Myra, and I could have not done this again without the help of everybody on this thread who has lent their suggestions and support for this project. We have all created this project.

TheRealDanPatch

Version 2??
Is there a need?
Any lingering SQ issues that need to be fixed?
Anything else we can add?
Did Eddie cover any Who songs during his solo tours in '08 & '09?

If we answer 'no' to most or all of these questions, then is this project ready for release?

tremors

Cameron4President wrote:

Version 2??
Is there a need?
Any lingering SQ issues that need to be fixed?
Anything else we can add?
Did Eddie cover any Who songs during his solo tours in '08 & '09?

If we answer 'no' to most or all of these questions, then is this project ready for release?

No time like the present. Let me have one full run through right now, just to hear the vibe, and I'll see you in 50 minutes! If you can't wait, set it loose. The Who were always a bit rough and ready anyways!

tremors

tremors wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

Version 2??
Is there a need?
Any lingering SQ issues that need to be fixed?
Anything else we can add?
Did Eddie cover any Who songs during his solo tours in '08 & '09?

If we answer 'no' to most or all of these questions, then is this project ready for release?

No time like the present. Let me have one full run through right now, just to hear the vibe, and I'll see you in 50 minutes! If you can't wait, set it loose. The Who were always a bit rough and ready anyways!

Awesome! Ed's doing us proud. Let's set him loose.....

myra

Cameron4President wrote:

Version 2??
Is there a need?
Any lingering SQ issues that need to be fixed?
Anything else we can add?
Did Eddie cover any Who songs during his solo tours in '08 & '09?

If we answer 'no' to most or all of these questions, then is this project ready for release?

-> no
-> no
-> no
-> I have no clue ----> where are the boots' ??! :x :(

Add to this :
-> headphone test : checked
-> speakers test : checked
-> in-car test : checked
-> in-office test : checked ..... :?

I reckon it's ready for release, then

locked

Ed did "I'm One" quite a bit on his solo tour of 2008.

The chicago show has the best sound quality and a great pre-song Ed sepak but if the train has already left the station let 'er rip!

locked

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mxUaTsIp ... re=related

locked

wow!

This version of the Seeker from 2005 has great sound quality (I'm just sayin)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5fD5h2Z7MR4

tremors

locked wrote:

Ed did "I'm One" quite a bit on his solo tour of 2008.

The chicago show has the best sound quality and a great pre-song Ed sepak but if the train has already left the station let 'er rip!

hahaha - I'm not sure if the train has quite left the station yet, but it's getting dangerously close! Cam4Pres is ably driving so we'll see what he thinks when he gets here! This time around I can't keep track of all the versions and sources suggested. All I know is that the current mix kicks ass

TheRealDanPatch

tremors wrote:

locked wrote:

Ed did "I'm One" quite a bit on his solo tour of 2008.

The chicago show has the best sound quality and a great pre-song Ed sepak but if the train has already left the station let 'er rip!

hahaha - I'm not sure if the train has quite left the station yet, but it's getting dangerously close! Cam4Pres is ably driving so we'll see what he thinks when he gets here! This time around I can't keep track of all the versions and sources suggested. All I know is that the current mix kicks ass

Hey Locked,

The train has not left the station (I'm standing in front of the train and the engineer is getting pissed ).

I know that this is kind of taboo on here, but do you know where I can find that Ed solo version of I'm One. I have several of his shows, but not that one. If you would like, you can PM myself, Tremors or Myra with that info. I don't mind holding up the train little longer if I can add a good Ed solo version of I'm One.