Home› Words and Music...Communication

black

maddrummermaddrummer Posts: 93
edited August 2005 in Words and Music...Communication
now i hope sum1 agrees with me that that song is just a peach??!!?? the words and music are soo gud!
Fuck The System
Post edited by Unknown User on

Comments

  • edeneden Posts: 407
    maddrummer wrote:
    now i hope sum1 agrees with me that that song is just a peach??!!?? the words and music are soo gud!

    Its the anthem of my life.

    If you want appreciation for Black, youve come to the right place ;)


    "All five horizons, revolved around her soul
    as the Earth to the sun..
    Now the air I tasted and breathed
    has taken a turn....."

    ^^^ Best lyric in the history of music, in my humble opinion :)
  • stuckinlinestuckinline Posts: 3,386
    black, what else needs to be said but "BLACK"


    a classic!
  • keyinmyhandkeyinmyhand Posts: 29
    No matter what the guys release, or come up with next, this will ALWAYS be my favorite. There is so much emotion and passison in the lyrics and in Eddie's voice! Can never be duplicated!
    " When you want more than you have
    You think you need
    And when you think more than you want
    Your thoughts begin to bleed."
    E.V. Society


    "And by the way, their real and their spectacular!"
  • edeneden Posts: 407
    keyinmyhand wrote:
    No matter what the guys release, or come up with next, this will ALWAYS be my favorite. There is so much emotion and passison in the lyrics and in Eddie's voice! Can never be duplicated!

    Eddie Vedder has the ability to convey emotion through music
    like no one ever has I think.

    Its like in "Release"... the emotion as he is singing about his dead
    father is so raw it has actually brought me to tears.
    Its palpable.
  • E.BloomE.Bloom Posts: 188
    eden wrote:

    "All five horizons, revolved around her soul
    as the Earth to the sun..
    Now the air I tasted and breathed
    has taken a turn....."

    ^^^ Best lyric in the history of music, in my humble opinion :)

    What a verse! One of the best lyrics ever..I think everyone has experienced what Ed is describing in that verse..Beautiful
    we were but stones,your light made us stars

    Dublin 06
    London 07
  • edeneden Posts: 407
    E.Bloom wrote:
    What a verse! One of the best lyrics ever..I think everyone has experienced what Ed is describing in that verse..Beautiful

    Yes, that all consuming love/lust
    where you are constantly aching
    and you feel like if you cant see/ hear/ touch
    that other person you will die.
    You feel like a junkie who needs a hit
    but its a love hit instead.

    So, um...yeh :D
  • LanceUppercutLanceUppercut Posts: 61
    "When blood rolls down my finger tips,
    Like tears from Heeaven"

    Is the best pearl jam lyric on Ten and it's in Black!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • edeneden Posts: 407
    LanceUppercut wrote:
    "When blood rolls down my finger tips,
    Like tears from Heeaven"

    Is the best pearl jam lyric on Ten and it's in Black!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Im lost...thought I knew it by heart *puzzled*

    Anyway I love when he says -

    "And all I taught her was everything..
    I know she gave me all that she wore"

    That line has soooo many layers to it .

    I really think Eddie has a few things to teach me as well :)
  • PJfanaaronPJfanaaron Posts: 15
    I heard once that ed's lyrics for 'black' came from mia zapata (gits vocals) being killed. I also read in the paper (contra costa times) that thay caught the guy like, a year ago or something. But hands down, one of the best songs i've ever heard. Plus the way the band does it live now is PRICELESS!!
    That's one more time around... and there is not a sound. . . he's lying dead, clutching benjamins never put the money down

    He's stiffening. . . we're all whistling

    A man we'll soon forget.
  • edeneden Posts: 407
    PJfanaaron wrote:
    I heard once that ed's lyrics for 'black' came from mia zapata (gits vocals) being killed. I also read in the paper (contra costa times) that thay caught the guy like, a year ago or something. But hands down, one of the best songs i've ever heard. Plus the way the band does it live now is PRICELESS!!


    Ive always heard that it was his first serious GF in high school.
  • E.BloomE.Bloom Posts: 188
    eden wrote:
    Yes, that all consuming love/lust
    where you are constantly aching
    and you feel like if you cant see/ hear/ touch
    that other person you will die.
    You feel like a junkie who needs a hit
    but its a love hit instead.

    So, um...yeh :D


    Yeah...so true..
    Good we have comfort in Black when we are in that situation!:D
    we were but stones,your light made us stars

    Dublin 06
    London 07
  • soapyrowssoapyrows Posts: 235
    eden wrote:
    Its the anthem of my life.


    ^^^ Best lyric in the history of music, in my humble opinion :)

    correction, not the anthem of your life, it is THE anthem of life
    EVENFLOW MEMBER #009 and i'm LOVIN the new PJ!!!! avacado all the way!!

    i know someday you'll have a beautiful life,
    i HOPE you'll be a star,
    in somebody elses sky, but why, why, why can't it be, why can't it be mine?!
  • Urban HikerUrban Hiker Posts: 1,312
    PJfanaaron wrote:
    I heard once that ed's lyrics for 'black' came from mia zapata (gits vocals) being killed. I also read in the paper (contra costa times) that thay caught the guy like, a year ago or something. But hands down, one of the best songs i've ever heard. Plus the way the band does it live now is PRICELESS!!

    Friendly FYI: Mia Zapata was killed July '93; I graduated from high school that year & was living near the neighborhood. The killer, Jesus Mezquia, was recently sentenced to 37 years in prison. http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/171551_zapata01.html He's 49, so I guess that's adequate.

    I agree with you that the way they perform it live these days is priceless. I like the way the crowd sings it. Nice that Ed has essentially given it to his fans, especially since he once confronted hikers asking them not to sing it. It is such a wonderful gift.
    Walking can be a real trip
    ***********************
    "We've laid the groundwork. It's like planting the seeds. And next year, it's spring." - Nader
    ***********************
    Prepare for tending to your garden, America.
  • Jam over hamJam over ham Posts: 1
    yeah, pansy pearl i was wondering about that...I thought I had read somewhere a while back about him encountering fans who were singing it and he asked them not to...do you know where that article is that mentions that?

    Words are just too feeble to describe what this song is for me. I wish I could know exactly who or what inspired the lyrics and how he felt after he wrote it.
    "Pearl Jam will break your heart...if you let 'em"
    ~ L.A. Weekly
  • edeneden Posts: 407
    Jam over ham wrote:

    Words are just too feeble to describe what this song is for me. I wish I could know exactly who or what inspired the lyrics and how he felt after he wrote it.


    He wrote it in high school about a girlfriend is what Ive ALWAYS read.
    If its true then imagine so young a mind creating such beauty from the
    well of pain he must have had inside of him.


    And yes some thing are beyond mere feeble words, agreed.
    Trying to describe the impact of Black on ones soul is one of them :)
  • SquidgeSquidge Posts: 145
    Pearl Jam - Black.


    For me, the most complete song ever written, from incredible lyrics, tempo and rythmn. I actually don't believe anyone who says they don't like it. Even a hardened punk-rocker would be brought to tears.

    Live is also incredible. Live on two legs version is awe-inspiring.

    My favourite notion of the song is when he changes the lyrics of the chorus, firstly it is 'my bitter hands, shake beneath the clouds'
    Secondly it goes 'my bitter hands, shed on broken glass'

    The guy is a genius, they all are.

    Peace
  • pejaypejay Posts: 14
    Black is very special song for me. This is the first Pearl Jam I've heard, it's been about 2 years ago. I've listened to it after the recommendation of my penfriend, he introduced it to me as "best song ever". So after I listened to it I've been so delighted. I truly find it very great. Lately I've got hooked up on Pearl Jam but Black is still my favorite! Both the lyrics and music are splendid! Sorry for this type of “blah-blah” message, maybe some of you will find it boring, but I couldn’t resist of posting it!
    mushers do it in the snow
  • stuckinlinestuckinline Posts: 3,386
    i agree black is such a multi layered song. i bet just about everyone can relate to the lyrics. i know personally i have felt that way at one point in my life. such raw emotion and vulnerability.
  • Gallant88Gallant88 Posts: 58
    I love this song, and I'm not going to bother explain why because so many others have already... but anyone who comes on here and says something like, "Oh, you just like it because its 1 of their more popular songs... go listen to blah blah blah... then you can be a real Pearl Jam fan" anyways, I know there's assholes like that on this board, so be warned...

    muahahaha
    September 22, 2005 - Halifax.. ahhh
    .
    ..
    ...
    ..
    .
  • edeneden Posts: 407
    Gallant88 wrote:
    I love this song, and I'm not going to bother explain why because so many others have already... but anyone who comes on here and says something like, "Oh, you just like it because its 1 of their more popular songs... go listen to blah blah blah... then you can be a real Pearl Jam fan" anyways, I know there's assholes like that on this board, so be warned...

    muahahaha

    This bothers me as well.
    Two of my all time fave songs are
    Release and Black .. just because they
    happen to both be on Ten Im still
    making no apologies for it.
  • reachdown12reachdown12 Posts: 693
    There is oh so much to be said about this song...yet I find just one word that comes to mind...




    Timeless.
    "Everyone wants to be the sun that lights up your life, but I'd rather be your moon so I can shine on you during your darkest hour when your sun's not around."
  • Urban HikerUrban Hiker Posts: 1,312
    Jam over ham wrote:
    yeah, pansy pearl i was wondering about that...I thought I had read somewhere a while back about him encountering fans who were singing it and he asked them not to...do you know where that article is that mentions that?

    Words are just too feeble to describe what this song is for me. I wish I could know exactly who or what inspired the lyrics and how he felt after he wrote it.

    Here you go: http://www.cameroncrowe.com/eyes_ears/articles/crowe_jrl_5_aganst_wrld.html

    If you pull the little scroll bar on the right down about an inch you'll be right at it. :)
    Walking can be a real trip
    ***********************
    "We've laid the groundwork. It's like planting the seeds. And next year, it's spring." - Nader
    ***********************
    Prepare for tending to your garden, America.
  • HJGhoopsHJGhoops Posts: 10
    thanks for the link
    If I knew where it was, I would take you there, but there's much more than this...

    10/3 Philly
Sign In or Register to comment.