Dance of the Clairvoyants VS Mind Your Manners

13

Comments

  • ZeldaZonk
    ZeldaZonk Seattle Posts: 614
    Mind Your Manners
    erocshifty said:
    tbergs said:
    ZeldaZonk said:
    HughFreakingDillon said:
    I dug MYM immediately, for how intense it was. how politically charged it was. and I never got tired of it. DotC took time for me to get used to, and I do like it now, but it's still MYM by a mile for me. 
    I'm with you on that. I was sold on MYM immediately, but unlike you I am having a hard time getting into the new one. It reminds me of when RHCP released "The Getaway" album, and the first single was "The Adventures of Raindance Maggie". It was such an unexpected turn for the band, and everything seemed to change after that and now I'm not as big of a fan as I was before that album. I'll admit that I like the newPJ  song a little more today than I did yesterday, but it's still got a long way to go for me. Maybe I'll be blown away by hearing it live and then I'll feel differently.
    Hmmm, do you mean the I'm With You" album? I didn't like that album at all, but The Getaway is fantastic.
    I liked I'm Beside You a little more than I'm With You. Reading what JK said during the Marc Maron WTF Podcast, he even preferred those songs to IWY. I actually like The Getaway the most out of all 3 of the Josh records. He had a nice little progression as a songwriter with them. But, FROOSH IS BACK - AGAIN, lol. 
    That's funny because I just listened to that podcast late last night. It was really interesting to hear his views and I had no idea he had worked with so many bands prior to joining RHCP. I'm definitely excited about John's return because he was always my favorite, but I thought Josh was a great fit.
    Forever feeling the sting of Raleigh 2016
  • erocshifty
    erocshifty Posts: 1,170
    Dance of the Clairvoyants
    ZeldaZonk said:
    erocshifty said:
    tbergs said:
    ZeldaZonk said:
    HughFreakingDillon said:
    I dug MYM immediately, for how intense it was. how politically charged it was. and I never got tired of it. DotC took time for me to get used to, and I do like it now, but it's still MYM by a mile for me. 
    I'm with you on that. I was sold on MYM immediately, but unlike you I am having a hard time getting into the new one. It reminds me of when RHCP released "The Getaway" album, and the first single was "The Adventures of Raindance Maggie". It was such an unexpected turn for the band, and everything seemed to change after that and now I'm not as big of a fan as I was before that album. I'll admit that I like the newPJ  song a little more today than I did yesterday, but it's still got a long way to go for me. Maybe I'll be blown away by hearing it live and then I'll feel differently.
    Hmmm, do you mean the I'm With You" album? I didn't like that album at all, but The Getaway is fantastic.
    I liked I'm Beside You a little more than I'm With You. Reading what JK said during the Marc Maron WTF Podcast, he even preferred those songs to IWY. I actually like The Getaway the most out of all 3 of the Josh records. He had a nice little progression as a songwriter with them. But, FROOSH IS BACK - AGAIN, lol. 
    That's funny because I just listened to that podcast late last night. It was really interesting to hear his views and I had no idea he had worked with so many bands prior to joining RHCP. I'm definitely excited about John's return because he was always my favorite, but I thought Josh was a great fit.
    Agreed. We're also in agreement on your signature. That still hurts and the past week has brought some of that aggravation back to the forefront in my mind. Oh well, hopefully we'll see a date in the Fall. 
    "It's best to live in grace before you're forced to." EV- 10/09/2014 
  • KN219077
    KN219077 Montana Posts: 1,204
    I’ll have to hear DotC live to decide, studio versions, I’d give it to clairvoyants. Live, MYM translates very well and fits in well alongside classic pj songs
  • 1rogeraspain2
    1rogeraspain2 Posts: 104
    edited January 2020
    Mind Your Manners
    jonsey30 said:
    Am I crazy or wasn’t Sirens the first single from LB?
    You're probably not crazy, but ... no; it was MYM.
    Post edited by 1rogeraspain2 on
  • 1rogeraspain2
    1rogeraspain2 Posts: 104
    Mind Your Manners
    MYM was much better. Not a big fan of "Dance ..."  MYM rocked! "Dance ..." doesn't." Not that everything needs to rock, but I found the first taste of Lightning Bolt much more appetizing and intriguing than I do the first taste of "Gigaton." Since you're asking, I'll take "Who You Are" over "Dance ..." as well. I applaud the "Dance ..." experiment. I'm not shitting on it. Just not that taken with it.
  • igotid88
    igotid88 Posts: 28,909
    jonsey30 said:
    Am I crazy or wasn’t Sirens the first single from LB?
    Mind your manners was first
    I miss igotid88
  • igotid88
    igotid88 Posts: 28,909
    Why is there never a both option?
    I miss igotid88
  • BSully
    BSully Indiana Posts: 1,515
    Mind Your Manners
    It's close for me, but It's been so long ago, it's hard to remember exactly how I felt, but I remember liking it out of the gate and DotC started out slow, but now I love it...
    1998: Noblesville, IN 08-17
    2000: Noblesville, IN 08-18
    2003: Noblesville, IN 06-22
    2006: Cincinnati, OH 06-24
    2010: Noblesville, IN 05-07
    2016: Lexington, KY 04-26, Wrigley Field 2 08-22
    2018: Wrigley Field 1 08-18, Wrigley Field 2 08-20
    2022: St. Louis, MO 09-18
    2024: Noblesville, IN 08-26, Wrigley Field 1 08-29, Wrigley Field 2 08-31
    2025: Pitt 1 05-16, Pitt 2 05-18
  • docsredarmy99
    docsredarmy99 Posts: 34
    edited January 2020
    Mind Your Manners
    DOTC sounds like a song people will go to the bar during when it's played live. 
  • Spiritual_Chaos
    Spiritual_Chaos Posts: 31,727
    Mind Your Manners
    igotid88 said:
    Why is there never a both option?
    Because Sophies Choice wouldn't work if there is one.
    "Mostly I think that people react sensitively because they know you’ve got a point"
  • whoanelly15
    whoanelly15 Posts: 742
    igotid88 said:
    Why is there never a both option?
    Both for me too. When MYM came out, I went nuts. Now I’m gooey for DotC. But if DotC was the first LB single, 7 years ago, I certainly would not have felt the same. I might have liked it, but it would have taken me longer to embrace. Thankfully, I’m a completely different listener than I was then. 

    Yet another great example of how this band has grown with me as a listener, and as a fan... or is it vice verse... or maybe BOTH. 

    I haven’t felt that way as often about any other band. That’s why I’m still here. And I could not be any more excited for this album!
  • HughFreakingDillon
    HughFreakingDillon Posts: 40,365
    Mind Your Manners
    igotid88 said:
    Why is there never a both option?
    cause sitting in the middle of the road can be dangerous. 
    Your boos mean nothing to me, for I have seen what makes you cheer



  • Spunkie
    Spunkie i come from downtown. Posts: 7,095
    Dance of the Clairvoyants
    I just can't get behind MYM. Has anyone ever told you to MYM? It's kinda rude. For example: Imagine if you are poor, hungry and eating like you hadn't seen proper food for a few months. Then Ed tells you to "mind your manners" because your social skills aren't fitting the charity meal, which no one eats. wtf? 

    DotC. No contest.
    I was swimming in the Great Barrier Reef 
    Animals were hiding behind the Coral 
    Except for little Turtle
    I could swear he's trying to talk to me 
    Gurgle Gurgle
  • mattcoz
    mattcoz Chicago Posts: 2,243
    Too hard to compare, just too different. I guess it really depends on my mood.
    1998: East Troy 2000: East Troy, Rosemont 2003: Champaign 2006: Chicago (UC), Milwaukee 2007: Chicago (Lolla) 2009: Chicago (UC), Chicago (UC) 2010: Noblesville 2011: East Troy (PJ20), East Troy (PJ20) 2013: Chicago (WF), Seattle 2014: St. Louis 2016: Chicago (WF), Chicago (WF) 2018: Chicago (WF), Chicago (WF) 2022: St. Louis 2023: Chicago (UC), Chicago (UC) 2024: Chicago (WF), Chicago (WF)
    2025: Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh
  • HughFreakingDillon
    HughFreakingDillon Posts: 40,365
    Mind Your Manners
    tish said:
    I just can't get behind MYM. Has anyone ever told you to MYM? It's kinda rude. For example: Imagine if you are poor, hungry and eating like you hadn't seen proper food for a few months. Then Ed tells you to "mind your manners" because your social skills aren't fitting the charity meal, which no one eats. wtf? 

    DotC. No contest.
    i think you need to re-read the lyrics to MYM. Ed isn't saying it. the antagonist in the story is. 
    Your boos mean nothing to me, for I have seen what makes you cheer



  • Spunkie
    Spunkie i come from downtown. Posts: 7,095
    Dance of the Clairvoyants
    ^ . Ya, I'm not basing my comment on the lyrics and song meaning because I just can't get passed the three MYM words. bleaeeeaach. Maybe, I'll give that a go one of these day and try to get passed the chastising notion that phrase evokes.
    I was swimming in the Great Barrier Reef 
    Animals were hiding behind the Coral 
    Except for little Turtle
    I could swear he's trying to talk to me 
    Gurgle Gurgle
  • kotton_crown
    kotton_crown Posts: 214
    igotid88 said:
    Why is there never a both option?
    Can’t be neutral on a moving train  ;)
  • HesCalledDyer
    HesCalledDyer Maryland Posts: 16,501
    edited February 2020
    Dance of the Clairvoyants
    Initially I liked Mind Your Manners quite a bit. Then I saw it live and that dropped it down quite a few pegs. (Yeah, sorry, but this is one of their songs that gets much worse live than studio).
    The difference is that with MYM, while I did like it a good bit initially, it never hyped me up for Lightning Bolt the way Dance is hyping me up for Gigaton (and the subsequent tour).  Dance wins easily here.
    Star Lake 00 / Pittsburgh 03 / State College 03 / Bristow 03 / Cleveland 06 / Camden II 06 / DC 08 / Pittsburgh 13 / Baltimore 13 / Charlottesville 13 / Cincinnati 14 / St. Paul 14 / Hampton 16 / Wrigley I 16 / Wrigley II 16 / Baltimore 20 / Camden 22 / Baltimore 24 / Raleigh I 25 / Raleigh II 25 / Pittsburgh I 25
  • Spiritual_Chaos
    Spiritual_Chaos Posts: 31,727
    Mind Your Manners
    Mind your Manners will be no ones rival.
    "Mostly I think that people react sensitively because they know you’ve got a point"
  • HughFreakingDillon
    HughFreakingDillon Posts: 40,365
    Mind Your Manners
    tish said:
    ^ . Ya, I'm not basing my comment on the lyrics and song meaning because I just can't get passed the three MYM words. bleaeeeaach. Maybe, I'll give that a go one of these day and try to get passed the chastising notion that phrase evokes.
    gotcha
    Your boos mean nothing to me, for I have seen what makes you cheer



Categories