Please Pearl Jam, consider a VINYL Benaroya Hall re-issue!

pjradio · June 2012

demetrios wrote:

pjradio wrote:

demetrios wrote:

Love that image snap shot.

curious, what made you take a screen grab of that?....way to look forward

I screen grab every purchase I've made. I remembered somebody was looking for it here so I hook them up.

great idea...i might have to start doing that :thumbup:

still amazed that $46 was the cost of that

Jerome230 · June 2012

texasistheSTEVEN wrote:

People on here collect records, keep them sealed and don't have a record player?!?!?!?! WTF, thats just plain silly

Quoted. For. Truth. That statement is a fact of epic proportion.

PJ_Soul · June 2012

This would be awesome!!! To everyone except those who kept theirs to sell for $1500. :roll: A first pressing would still be special (aren't they numbered by hand or something?), but I'd looooooove a reissue. No way will I ever ever pay $1000+ for Benny Hall, so fingers crossed that they will do this! .... It might help that vinyl is making a big comeback, thank god. Plus, for those good people who actually value their vinyl for the music that they make when you play them rather than for what they're worth on eBay would be happy for reissue too, since surely many of theirs are worn out by now!

Zod · June 2012

pjradio wrote:

still amazed that $46 was the cost of that

Even more amazing was I was a poor student when it came out. I paid the $46 as well but it took me a full day to pull the trigger on buying it (I really couldn't afford it at the time). I'm glad I did

I think it still didn't sellout until the day after that. (Which means it took 2 days to sell the 2000 copies).

sonna · June 2012

One for sale now on ebay. £800.00!!!!!!!!!

Shame on you #154....

texasistheSTEVEN · June 2012

and one for sale in the lost dogs forum.
Its probably been snapped up already though!

Leezestarr313 · August 2012

Bumpity!

I wouldn't mind getting one of these babies as a wedding pressie

It's just one of my essential all-time favourites! Thank you, Pearl Jam :wave:

Pke · August 2012

got it opend it played it love it

get that for a re-release out their wont make much difference to the value of original anyway

an anyone that keeps them sealed are of their head :fp:

their made to be listend to spin spin

YLed2 · August 2012

Holy Hell, yes please!

Would more than likely be my most prized asset if I have had the chance to own it.

youngster · August 2012

Jerome230 wrote:

They should do a pre-order for the re-issues, and give 10 Clubbers fair warning - say, a month in advance, and PJ would only press as many that were pre-ordered - no set "limited to X" amount bullshit.

The problem with that is there would be some people who would complain that a month wasn't enough time and they didn't have the money. After 10C stopped taking pre-orders, you'd have those people complain that they should make more, that now they have the money and are pissed that they aren't available anymore.

It's kinda like what happened to the PJ20 DVD's. They were available for weeks and when they were gone, all of a sudden people were like "WTF?" 10c can't win no matter how they do things.

goldrush · August 2012

Just throwing it out there... what if they added Benaroya to the box set re-issuses program? It would make sense as it's seen by many as just as important a release as some of the studio albums. I know I'm not the only one that already has a Benny vinyl and would still by the re-issue as well (just... can't... resist!!) plus they always re-issue the vinyls on their own at the same time as the box sets.

It would also make sense chronologically as there's a gap between Riot Act and Pearl Jam that needs to be filled. They can always couple it with the full Easy Street set to keep with the 2 albums per box option (I was going to suggest coupling it The Gorge on vinyl but now I'm just getting carried away!)

No Code / Yield 1996-1998
Binaural / Riot Act 2000-2002
Benaroya / Live At Easy Street 2004-2006
Pearl Jam / Backspacer 2006-2009

Oh well, we can all dream can't we?...

Personally, I'd love to see an expanded Lost Dogs box set in there as well but I know I'm just being greedy

kramer73 · August 2012

I support album re-issues, but not this.

pjradio · August 2012

My feeling is...If you get it while its on Sale here, GREAT!...If you don't, sorry. (and I paid mucho bucks for my Benny BTW) I like the fact that there are rare items, it gives me something to strive to get. & thats half the fun of being a fan. I went to my 1st PJ show & had the opportunity to get the poster & didn't...I kick myself everyday for that...now its my grail...I search all the time for it & enjoy the hunt! One day I WILL get it and it will be that much more appreciated. If everything was available to everyone at all times, what kind of fun would that be?

"Lets have a limited sale on XYZ"

"Cool, I'll buy that! It would be awesome to have that limited item!"

(***5 yrs later***)

"HEY NOW!!!!! We're gonna put that limited item up for sale again!...PS: Sorry to those other ppl that bought it earlier, who thought it was limited....but, it is what it is"

"damn..."

my 2cents

PJ_Soul · August 2012

pjradio wrote:

My feeling is...If you get it while its on Sale here, GREAT!...If you don't, sorry. (and I paid mucho bucks for my Benny BTW) I like the fact that there are rare items, it gives me something to strive to get. & thats half the fun of being a fan. I went to my 1st PJ show & had the opportunity to get the poster & didn't...I kick myself everyday for that...now its my grail...I search all the time for it & enjoy the hunt! One day I WILL get it and it will be that much more appreciated. If everything was available to everyone at all times, what kind of fun would that be?
"Lets have a limited sale on XYZ"

"Cool, I'll buy that! It would be awesome to have that limited item!"

(***5 yrs later***)

"HEY NOW!!!!! We're gonna put that limited item up for sale again!...PS: Sorry to those other ppl that bought it earlier, who thought it was limited....but, it is what it is"

"damn..."

my 2cents

Yeah, it's great to have a much desired and very limited album... if you have the album. Sucks for the thousands and thousands who don't have it and will never have it. It's really the two thousand (or is it three thousand) people vs many more than that who don't. Obviously no one who has the album wants it reissued. I don't have it though, and I really want it!

Of course, a reissue would be just that. The original numbered album would still be a limited edition collectors item.

pjradio · August 2012

PJ_Soul wrote:

Of course, a reissue would be just that. The original numbered album would still be a limited edition collectors item.

just curious...do you own any "Limited" items?

Newch91 · August 2012

goldrush wrote:

Just throwing it out there... what if they added Benaroya to the box set re-issuses program? It would make sense as it's seen by many as just as important a release as some of the studio albums. I know I'm not the only one that already has a Benny vinyl and would still by the re-issue as well (just... can't... resist!!) plus they always re-issue the vinyls on their own at the same time as the box sets.

It would also make sense chronologically as there's a gap between Riot Act and Pearl Jam that needs to be filled. They can always couple it with the full Easy Street set to keep with the 2 albums per box option (I was going to suggest coupling it The Gorge on vinyl but now I'm just getting carried away!)

No Code / Yield 1996-1998
Binaural / Riot Act 2000-2002
Benaroya / Live At Easy Street 2004-2006
Pearl Jam / Backspacer 2006-2009

Oh well, we can all dream can't we?...

Personally, I'd love to see an expanded Lost Dogs box set in there as well but I know I'm just being greedy

They said their not doing a PJ/Backspacer reissue.

YLed2 · August 2012

goldrush wrote:

Just throwing it out there... what if they added Benaroya to the box set re-issuses program? It would make sense as it's seen by many as just as important a release as some of the studio albums. I know I'm not the only one that already has a Benny vinyl and would still by the re-issue as well (just... can't... resist!!) plus they always re-issue the vinyls on their own at the same time as the box sets.

It would also make sense chronologically as there's a gap between Riot Act and Pearl Jam that needs to be filled. They can always couple it with the full Easy Street set to keep with the 2 albums per box option (I was going to suggest coupling it The Gorge on vinyl but now I'm just getting carried away!)

No Code / Yield 1996-1998
Binaural / Riot Act 2000-2002
Benaroya / Live At Easy Street 2004-2006
Pearl Jam / Backspacer 2006-2009

Oh well, we can all dream can't we?...

Personally, I'd love to see an expanded Lost Dogs box set in there as well but I know I'm just being greedy

Love where your head is at......and what's wrong with being a little greedy? I would LOVE to see a Benaroya/Gorge re-issue together in one package....shortly after they release the Alpine set.

goldrush · August 2012

Newch91 wrote:

goldrush wrote:

Just throwing it out there... what if they added Benaroya to the box set re-issuses program? It would make sense as it's seen by many as just as important a release as some of the studio albums. I know I'm not the only one that already has a Benny vinyl and would still by the re-issue as well (just... can't... resist!!) plus they always re-issue the vinyls on their own at the same time as the box sets.

It would also make sense chronologically as there's a gap between Riot Act and Pearl Jam that needs to be filled. They can always couple it with the full Easy Street set to keep with the 2 albums per box option (I was going to suggest coupling it The Gorge on vinyl but now I'm just getting carried away!)

No Code / Yield 1996-1998
Binaural / Riot Act 2000-2002
Benaroya / Live At Easy Street 2004-2006
Pearl Jam / Backspacer 2006-2009

Oh well, we can all dream can't we?...

Personally, I'd love to see an expanded Lost Dogs box set in there as well but I know I'm just being greedy

They said their not doing a PJ/Backspacer reissue.

Well that's even more reason for the Benaroya Box Set to be the grand finale of the box set releases then!

Leezestarr313 · August 2012

I don't care if they put it in a special box or not, I just want to listen to this baby on vinyl. Of course some people will be pissed, but this is like an every day event amongst PJ fans :P You can't please everyone! I totally get the collector's point of view, but this would be different, theirs would still be highly sought after and special. I don't know, I just think this album is tooooooo good to be only available to 2000 people (yes, I know that there is a CD available to everyone and I also have it). And it isn't even that! To think that there are people who even own more than one, keeping one copy sealed and having an opened one that they are playing ... :roll:

I haven't been a fan club member when this album was released, so I didn't have a chance to get it back then, does that make me a lesser fan or constitutes that I don't deserve to listen to it on vinyl as well?

Leezestarr313 · August 2012

goldrush wrote:

Personally, I'd love to see an expanded Lost Dogs box set in there as well but I know I'm just being greedy

:thumbup:

Please Pearl Jam, consider a VINYL Benaroya Hall re-issue!

Comments

Categories