Please Pearl Jam, consider a VINYL Benaroya Hall re-issue!

P-Jam

...LOL this thread's got me dreaming now...

Newch91

P-Jam wrote:

Newch91 wrote:

mfc2006 wrote:

i just want to SPIN IT!!!!!!

period. no bullshit. records are meant to be played, not stored. that's my take. and if i ever own a BH vinyl, i will take a video of me spinning it.

I completely agree Matt. I just got the ITW reissue the other day, spun it yesterday, loved it so much. It sounds great on vinyl.

+1
Totally agree!!!! I always get my vinyl with every intention on LISTENING to it! I love viyl for what it was meant to be!

...And I really want to score and listen to a copy of ITW vinyl myself...

Do you live in the US or in Europe? In the US, you can get it from Soundstage Direct and the UK you can get it from What Records.

P-Jam

In the US. Yea, I will be getting it soon, just want to make sure I got money saved up for the PJ Fest too

2-feign-reluctance

whgarrett wrote:

Just to let you know, the Benny vinyl doesn't sound all that better than the compact disc especially if you have a decent stereo.

Uh, no. That is all.

Leezestarr313

BUMP for a Benny Hall reissue!

Leezestarr313

This thread needs a bump!

Newch91

Leeze wrote:

This thread needs a bump!

Good thinking. :thumbup:

pjfan021

agreed...being able to spin that record would be an eargasm...re-issue it!

Leezestarr313

Listening to that CD right now ... And I think this thread needs another BUMP!

I want to listen to this absolute beauty on vinyl, like so many others. And I don't care about the collector's value, I just want to spin it Make it happen, PJ!

mfc2006

Leeze wrote:

Listening to that CD right now ... And I think this thread needs another BUMP!

I want to listen to this absolute beauty on vinyl, like so many others. And I don't care about the collector's value, I just want to spin it Make it happen, PJ!

totally agree!!! i want to spin this vinyl!!

Leezestarr313

It's sooooooo good ...

AndySlash

jmk wrote:

whgarrett wrote:

Just to let you know, the Benny vinyl doesn't sound all that better than the compact disc especially if you have a decent stereo.

As a format the vinyl always have a warmer, more human sound and remember that what you hear with your ears is an analog sound wave, so when the music is turned into digital 1:s & 0:s the analog sound wave that you hear is altered on it's way to your ears. And the dynamics of music on vinyl is something the cd can only dream of...

:think:

AndySlash

but i agree with the sentiment of this thread. let music on vinyl do it.

Suziemay

I would get one now that I started buying vinyl. Need to catch up!

Leezestarr313

AndySlash wrote:

but i agree with the sentiment of this thread. let music on vinyl do it.

:thumbup: Bumpity :shifty:

demetrios

Leeze wrote:

This thread needs a bump!

SVRDhand13

I'd buy it.

And I wouldn't feel bad about all those previous Bennys losing their value because if someone has not opened it by now then they are just trying to make a profit off it anyway. Let the true fans take a listen.

Newch91

SVRDhand13 wrote:

I'd buy it.

And I wouldn't feel bad about all those previous Bennys losing their value because if someone has not opened it by now then they are just trying to make a profit off it anyway. Let the true fans take a listen.

+1 :thumbup:

Leezestarr313

Newch91 wrote:

SVRDhand13 wrote:

I'd buy it.

And I wouldn't feel bad about all those previous Bennys losing their value because if someone has not opened it by now then they are just trying to make a profit off it anyway. Let the true fans take a listen.

+1 :thumbup:

+2 BU-HUMP!

tremors

I support this idea :thumbup:

Don't know why - but I never saw this thread on it's first and second times around.

I enjoyed reading the 'break the seal and spin' comments too. Wouldn't it be great if we formed a 'Vinyl Mafia', and snuck into collectors' houses late at night - rooted out their sealed vinyl, unsealed it, took it down to their fancy turntable - started the sucker spinning at maximum volume, and then exited, pronto. That would be cool. And if they didn't own a turntable their goods would simply be confiscated

Leezestarr313

tremors wrote:

I support this idea :thumbup:

Don't know why - but I never saw this thread on it's first and second times around.

I enjoyed reading the 'break the seal and spin' comments too. Wouldn't it be great if we formed a 'Vinyl Mafia', and snuck into collectors' houses late at night - rooted out their sealed vinyl, unsealed it, took it down to their fancy turntable - started the sucker spinning at maximum volume, and then exited, pronto. That would be cool. And if they didn't own a turntable their goods would simply be confiscated

:thumbup: (For me, the old "can I show you my stamps collection?" is ruled out since I discovered vinyl )

tremors

Leeze wrote:

:thumbup: (For me, the old "can I show you my stamps collection?" is ruled out since I discovered vinyl )

Indeed - I have an alternative vinyl friendly line, but it might get me in trouble with the mods - it uses the word 'inches'

elvistheking44

I am for this....sort of. My wife paid 500 bucks for mine as a valentines day present a few years back. The first thing I did was crack it open and play it non stop for a few days. I still spin it from time to time. I don't want a re issue to "cheapen" the original thrills people have with the first pressing.

If they repress it, I think it should completely different from the original. No wine colored vinyl!

I know, Im selfish.

Leezestarr313

ofthegirl99 wrote:

I am for this....sort of. My wife paid 500 bucks for mine as a valentines day present a few years back. The first thing I did was crack it open and play it non stop for a few days. I still spin it from time to time. I don't want a re issue to "cheapen" the original thrills people have with the first pressing.

If they repress it, I think it should completely different from the original. No wine colored vinyl!

I know, Im selfish.

I know what you mean and I'm totally with you. Black vinyl is fine with me ... as long as the sound quality is as gorgeous as in the original RE-ISSUE it already! Please, with a thousand of cherries on top :shifty:

magga1976

BUMP!

TunnelThroughDenial

If I bought a copy of Benny for $900 I'd need this to play it on:

http://www.needledoctor.com/Clearaudio- ... ategory=45

You ever seen a $170,000 record player before?

WOW

Leezestarr313

TunnelThroughDenial wrote:

If I bought a copy of Benny for $900 I'd need this to play it on:

http://www.needledoctor.com/Clearaudio- ... ategory=45

You ever seen a $170,000 record player before?

WOW

:shock: *droooool*

Leezestarr313

Time for a post-PJ20 BUMP

Please re-issue this baby, I wanna listen to it on vinyl too without becoming poor! Thx.

Leezestarr313

I just discovered the Benny Hall #s thread today, cause someone bumped it up and it was interesting, but sad at the same time to see the development of the price from 2005 to now :?

So I bump this thread again Please PJ, do consider a re-issue for all the vinyl lovers who cannot afford to sell body parts to own this lovely record ... A regular black edition would be fine!

Newch91

Leeze wrote:

I just discovered the Benny Hall #s thread today, cause someone bumped it up and it was interesting, but sad at the same time to see the development of the price from 2005 to now :?

So I bump this thread again Please PJ, do consider a re-issue for all the vinyl lovers who cannot afford to sell body parts to own this lovely record ... A regular black edition would be fine!

:thumbup: And for those of us who were unaware of who PJ was when this was released (that would be me).