Nirvana or Pearl Jam......who had a better unplugged?

123578

Comments

  • DewieCox
    DewieCox Posts: 11,432
    AiC's is the best.

    Page and Plant's is up there too.

    Nirvana's is really good, but I think they lean too hard on the covers. It's cool that they played a bunch of lesser known songs, but they surely could've done more of their own material.

    PJ's is solid, but they didn't really do anything different with their tunes. The way they played the songs sounded more like an acoustic rehearsal for an electric show, if you know what I mean. I imagine people's minds would've been just as blown had they done a full electric show, where alot of other Unplugged's really benefit from the Unplugged aspect. I think there were just so many people that wanted a rare glimpse of live PJ, and Unplugged was their first big chance.
  • phungi
    phungi Posts: 641
    Nirvana shot their Unplugged performance in December 1993, two years after Nevermind came out and within the year after In Utero came out... they had already been a band for 5 years and had 3 albums...

    Alice In Chains shot their performance in April 1996, after a two-year hiatus of touring... this came four years after Dirt, and they had already been a band for 9 years and had 3 albums...

    Pearl Jam shot their performance in March 1992, six months after Ten was released and before Vs. was even recorded... they had only been a band for a year and had only 1 album...

    All that said, I prefer PJ over Nirvana and AIC as a band but I prefer Nirvana and AIC over PJ for their Unplugged show
    37 PJ Shows, 3 EV Shows, 1134 Total Songs, 24 Different Openers, 9 Different Closers, 252 Unique Songs (never enough)
  • maj4e
    maj4e Posts: 605
    Nirvana just by a hair. They played more songs and they had been together longer.
    If PJ did unplugged in 94 with more material to play from I think they would have the win.
  • Jason P
    Jason P Posts: 19,432
    Nirvana .... and I'm not a huge Nirvana fan, but that show was exceptional.
    Be Excellent To Each Other
    Party On, Dudes!
  • Lament
    Lament Posts: 294
    pdalowsky wrote:
    as a side note i loved the LIVE one too, and REM

    Oh man, how did I forget the REM one? So good...
  • javis el errante
    javis el errante Buenos Aires Posts: 6,147
    I wouldn't know which one is better and on what grounds, but I like the Nirvana better not only because it has twice as much songs, but for the covers as well, I love the Vaselines and the Bowie cover, and the Meat Puppets songs as well, way better than some of the Nirvana songs there, however, my favourite is the Alice In Chains one...
    ... I am not in the business of being liked anymore ...

  • JimmyV
    JimmyV Boston's MetroWest Posts: 19,615
    Lament wrote:
    pdalowsky wrote:
    as a side note i loved the LIVE one too, and REM

    Oh man, how did I forget the REM one? So good...

    I was blown away by the R.E.M. and Neil Young performance on the new Bridge School collection. So amazing. I have a hard time remembering they are no longer a band. Still sad.
    ___________________________________________

    "...I changed by not changing at all..."
  • awang_vedder
    awang_vedder Jakarta, Indonesia Posts: 192
    choose pearl jam for rough, simply, and rocks performance! nirvana unplugged is good and ok but too poppy for me. :P
    - "I wish I was a messenger, and all the news was good" -
  • Off He Goes79
    Off He Goes79 Posts: 14
    It has to be Pearl Jam for me, mainly because I am a much bigger fan of them. They were both great performances though.
  • Lament
    Lament Posts: 294
    JimmyV wrote:
    Lament wrote:
    pdalowsky wrote:
    as a side note i loved the LIVE one too, and REM

    Oh man, how did I forget the REM one? So good...

    I was blown away by the R.E.M. and Neil Young performance on the new Bridge School collection. So amazing. I have a hard time remembering they are no longer a band. Still sad.

    Man, I really need to check that collection out. Just the idea of Country Feedback with Neil Young gives me goosebumps...
  • carolinabeerguy
    carolinabeerguy Kernersville, NC Posts: 2,516
    Nirvana's Unplugged was the best to me and it's not even close. I'd put Alice in Chains' well above Pearl Jam's as well.
    I wish I was as fortunate, as fortunate as me.
  • JimmyV
    JimmyV Boston's MetroWest Posts: 19,615
    Lament wrote:
    JimmyV wrote:

    I was blown away by the R.E.M. and Neil Young performance on the new Bridge School collection. So amazing. I have a hard time remembering they are no longer a band. Still sad.

    Man, I really need to check that collection out. Just the idea of Country Feedback with Neil Young gives me goosebumps...

    The collection is so worth checking and for a great cause,too. Until then...enjoy!

    http://youtu.be/8ezNjJyD4rY
    ___________________________________________

    "...I changed by not changing at all..."
  • Nami
    Nami Newfoundland Posts: 5,998
    I see AIC has been thrown in the link....

    PJ-AIC-Nirvana... PJ/AIC toss up for first- All classics....
    Hamilton 9-13-05; Toronto 5-9-06, Toronto 8-21-09, Toronto 9-12-11, Hamilton 9-15-11....
  • shadowcast
    shadowcast Posts: 2,384
    JP33 wrote:
    To me.....No brainer.......Nirvana
    Love PJ but that Nirvana unplugged is tough to beat. That was album of the year in my book.
  • Lament
    Lament Posts: 294
    JimmyV wrote:
    Lament wrote:
    JimmyV wrote:

    I was blown away by the R.E.M. and Neil Young performance on the new Bridge School collection. So amazing. I have a hard time remembering they are no longer a band. Still sad.

    Man, I really need to check that collection out. Just the idea of Country Feedback with Neil Young gives me goosebumps...

    The collection is so worth checking and for a great cause,too. Until then...enjoy!

    http://youtu.be/8ezNjJyD4rY

    Wow...speechless.

    (Thanks, I may need to buy this even sooner than I had previously thought!)
  • mzklvspj
    mzklvspj Chicago Posts: 55
    Pearl Jam for me... Ed's voice cannot be beat. Love both but, Kurt's voice does not sound as good "unplugged"...
  • theJawas
    theJawas Posts: 395
    I'd go-
    1. Nirvana
    2. AIC
    3. PJ
    4. LIVE
    As others have CD, PJ were relatively new and only had one album under their belts. The entire Unplugged show raises its stock, but Nirvana's was so different than their studio albums, and AIC's built on the vibe from Jar of Flies. LIVE's is also a forgotten classic, never seen Uncle Neil's, so maybe he'd be higher otherwise.
  • aspoonfulweighsaton
    aspoonfulweighsaton Posts: 2,066
    I think Nirvana is as overrated as the next guy, but their Unplugged does pretty much destroy PJ's. I haven't read every post and I'm sure it was mentioned, but the fact that everything was one take is the most impressive thing to me. Not that Pearl Jam played everything five times like AIC did before they got it right, but to play as many songs completely out of their element and nail every one is tough to beat.

    Now I will take Black and Porch individually over pretty much any one song from Nirvana's set, but as a whole it's not even close.
  • javis el errante
    javis el errante Buenos Aires Posts: 6,147
    REM was very good as well, but I like the last one better than the first one, though the last one wasn't exactly an "MTV Unplugged" show, I think, or something of the sort, it was kind of an unplugged set for MTV, but not exactly the show... Korn MTV Unplugged sucked big time, but Tony Bennett MTV Unplugged was completely awesome...
    ... I am not in the business of being liked anymore ...

  • eeriepadave
    eeriepadave West Chester, PA Posts: 43,773
    Nirvana definitely.

    Then AIC then Pearl Jam next.

    STP, 10,000 Maniacs, Eric Clapton were also very good IMO
    8/28/98- Camden, NJ
    10/31/09- Philly
    5/21/10- NYC
    9/2/12- Philly, PA
    7/19/13- Wrigley
    10/19/13- Brooklyn, NY
    10/21/13- Philly, PA
    10/22/13- Philly, PA
    10/27/13- Baltimore, MD
    4/28/16- Philly, PA
    4/29/16- Philly, PA
    5/1/16- NYC
    5/2/16- NYC
    9/2/18- Boston, MA
    9/4/18- Boston, MA
    9/14/22- Camden, NJ
    9/7/24- Philly, PA
    9/9/24- Philly, PA
    Tres Mts.- 3/23/11- Philly. PA
    Eddie Vedder- 6/25/11- Philly, PA
    RNDM- 3/9/16- Philly, PA

Categories