Offical St. Paul 1 Setlist thread

upina2001 wrote:

My buddies are super huge Phishheads and they are SUPER SPOILED!!!

"Ah, man, not Harry Hood! I wanted to hear them play Dogs stole things; they havent played that since they were in Fishmans basement in 89!!"---Spoiled.

Exactly my point - and I'm a HUGE Phish fan...definately tied w/ PJ for my favorite band...Yeah, Phish fas make PJ fans look like they don't care. Just putting it in perspective.

upina2001 wrote:

My buddies are super huge Phishheads and they are SUPER SPOILED!!!

"Ah, man, not Harry Hood! I wanted to hear them play Dogs stole things; they havent played that since they were in Fishmans basement in 89!!"---Spoiled.

thats what we sound like or are staring to sound like... take away the Phish songs in that quote and Hard To Imagine and Given To Fly.

Zoso wrote:

good point.. people said it was a crappy set because it featured 3 RA and 3 No code songs etc.... tonight is the opposite and still bagged. This doesnt happen with any other band. We just seem to complain easily.

Cinci was a crappy setlist. Easily the worst that I've seen (Camden II '03 being a close second because of the encores). Look at fucking Pittsburgh the night before.

Dissident, In Hiding, Garden, I Got Shit, State of Love and Trust, Man of the Hour, Waiting on a Friend, Why Go, Smile

Those songs right there blow Cinci's setlist out of the water. They aren't extreme rarities (never asked for those), but they are songs that are either new for the tour (Why Go, Garden) or not played too often (I Got Shit, Smile, In Hiding).

Cinci got Leash and Long Road, and every other song could be heard by goiing to two shows in a row from any shows since 2003 (minus the Avocado songs). The set lacked personality. Pittsburgh had personality.

Hell, look at Pitt's second encore: Go, Why Go, Comatose (how freaking awesome). That's a fucking run of songs. Cinci's first encore we got five 6+ minute songs in a row. How freaking dull. Who the hell wants to hear Wishlist in a freaking encore?

Sorry, the Cinci setlist was just utterly dissapointing. I'm not sugarcoating it anymore. It was unbelievable dull. Crowd and band were high energy. But the set left me wanting more. A friend from work who sees about one show a tour brought it up to me without even me asking. Just look at Pitt's setlist, and tell me while sober that Cinci's setlist was great.

Edit: But then you say, well you got LBC and Green Disease. Well, who wants to hear those when you have Why Go, Go, Animal, Dissident, Low LIght, I Got Shit, Garden, Rats, Satan's Bed, All those Yesterdays, Bushleaguer, Come Back, In Hiding, Man of the Hour, Smile, etc....that could have been played.

bootlegger10 wrote:

Cinci was a crappy setlist. Easily the worst that I've seen (Camden II '03 being a close second because of the encores). Look at fucking Pittsburgh the night before.

Dissident, In Hiding, Garden, I Got Shit, State of Love and Trust, Man of the Hour, Waiting on a Friend, Why Go, Smile

Those songs right there blow Cinci's setlist out of the water. They aren't extreme rarities (never asked for those), but they are songs that are either new for the tour (Why Go, Garden) or not played too often (I Got Shit, Smile, In Hiding).

Cinci got Leash and Long Road, and every other song could be heard by goiing to two shows in a row from any shows since 2003 (minus the Avocado songs). The set lacked personality. Pittsburgh had personality.

Hell, look at Pitt's second encore: Go, Why Go, Comatose (how freaking awesome). That's a fucking run of songs. Cinci's first encore we got five 6+ minute songs in a row. How freaking dull. Who the hell wants to hear Wishlist in a freaking encore?

Sorry, the Cinci setlist was just utterly dissapointing. I'm not sugarcoating it anymore. It was unbelievable dull. Crowd and band were high energy. But the set left me wanting more. A friend from work who sees about one show a tour brought it up to me without even me asking. Just look at Pitt's setlist, and tell me while sober that Cinci's setlist was great.

who wants to hear Wishlist period...lol.

I already faxed my prefered setlist to the band for Vegas. I also have a case of wine as a bribe being delivered to the MGM, sent to Ed V. requiring a signature.

Zoso wrote:

PJ can't win with its fans... they set a standard in 2003 and now everyone expects that standard to be carried out night after night.

Every show so far this tour has had fresh songs (3-4 songs that don't get played at every other show, or every tour). Cinci got 99% tour standards. Nothing exciting if you've seen more than 2 shows this tour, or 2 shows in 2005, or 2 shows in 2004, or 2 shows in 2003.

Wow, he is a whore for his hits. I bet all the college girls with pink ipod minis are loving the Petty set.