Project #8 - The Whispers of War: Riot Act Live

PilateOfTheStorm · February 2011

chickweed wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

I have to say that "Gimme Some Truth" from Raleigh, NC was an excellent rendition.

oh fuck yes
that's exactly what i was thinking
(and i was there)

and btw
i love riot act

i LOVE that version
the bonus tracks are really great IMO
seriously, like tremors said they may be the best ones yet

PilateOfTheStorm · February 2011

okay, I Am Mine

San Diego 2003-06-05 - I didn't think this one was as good as the one we already have.

Cameron4President wrote:

Are there any songs we can grab from the 2003 Philadelphia Spectrum show? Maybe "I Am Mine"??

I Am Mine wasn't played at that, so we'll have to keep searching

I'll have a listen to a few others from some shows we haven't used, see if I can find another I Am Mine

PilateOfTheStorm · February 2011

Listened to 2003-04-01 Denver, CO - It was okayish

Listened to 2003-07-18 Palacio De Los Deportes, Mexico City, Mexico - starts off strong, I liked it. Oops just seen we already have You Are from that one.

Listened to 2003-04-05 San Antonio, Texas - hmmm not sure about this one, will have to listen again.

Listened to 2003-04-08 New Orleans, Louisiana - Sounded better than the Denver one and Texas one. Don't know if it's better than Oklahoma. Voice sounds stronger maybe?

Listened to 2003-06-16 St Paul, MN - was okay, maybe not as strong as the others?

Okay
I'll have another listen later, can't tell the differences anymore haha

it's hard because the song itself has an element of subdued-ness (is that a word?) so just picking the rockiest one won't do, it has to be special

myra · February 2011

electricxlovex wrote:

Listened to 2003-04-01 Denver, CO - It was okayish

Listened to 2003-07-18 Palacio De Los Deportes, Mexico City, Mexico - starts off strong, I liked it. Oops just seen we already have You Are from that one.

Listened to 2003-04-05 San Antonio, Texas - hmmm not sure about this one, will have to listen again.

Listened to 2003-04-08 New Orleans, Louisiana - Sounded better than the Denver one and Texas one. Don't know if it's better than Oklahoma. Voice sounds stronger maybe?

Listened to 2003-06-16 St Paul, MN - was okay, maybe not as strong as the others?

Okay
I'll have another listen later, can't tell the differences anymore haha
it's hard because the song itself has an element of subdued-ness (is that a word?) so just picking the rockiest one won't do, it has to be special

Great work E.L., I'll take it from there

I agree that we're not just looking for the rockiest there. Pretty tough that one. Don't really know what I'm hoping to find. I reckon I'll just give a listen to a playlist of 2003 I am mine and see if any version sticks out and I'll keep you posted so we can eventually narrow it down to one that we like better that the current version.

myra · February 2011

Newch91 wrote:

Wow...no love for Down.

Quite the opposite actually

Only, it didn't fit within the rest of the bonus tracks, both in flow and mood I reckon, so we had to put it aside for this project. I'm pretty confident it'll show up on another project though. At least I hope so :( .

myra · February 2011

Spiritual_Chaos wrote:

Oh, I'm gonen love this one!

Why did you decide upon that version of Help Help?

We settled on that one when we had to part with Hershey due to SQ issues. I'm still grieving Hershey actually, but we just couldn't keep it. So we had to find a good one in replacement, without using shows we already used.

Eventually, we went for Clarkston and we're happy with this one so far I reckon.

If you have a better suggestion though, from a 2003 show we haven't used already, let me know, I'm all for a little discussion about Help Help considering you seemed to really like it too

myra · February 2011

tremors wrote:

Myra is a Pearl Jam fuelled machine - she doesn't need sleep!

Sleep is a waste of time.

tremors · February 2011

Sorry - was delayed by work and life from contributing today.

Sounds like the hunt for I am Mine is a difficult one. What was the best contender?, and was it better than our current one, which is actually pretty good I think

Newch91 · February 2011

tremors wrote:

Sorry - was delayed by work and life from contributing today.

Sounds like the hunt for I am Mine is a difficult one. What was the best contender?, and was it better than our current one, which is actually pretty good I think

I'm fond of the MSG I version.

tremors · February 2011

Newch91 wrote:

tremors wrote:

Sorry - was delayed by work and life from contributing today.

Sounds like the hunt for I am Mine is a difficult one. What was the best contender?, and was it better than our current one, which is actually pretty good I think

I'm fond of the MSG I version.

What did you and electricx settle on Myra?

PilateOfTheStorm · February 2011

tremors wrote:

Newch91 wrote:

tremors wrote:

Sorry - was delayed by work and life from contributing today.

Sounds like the hunt for I am Mine is a difficult one. What was the best contender?, and was it better than our current one, which is actually pretty good I think

I'm fond of the MSG I version.

What did you and electricx settle on Myra?

nothing yet :?

it's a very tough song to pick out which one is the best
if you check the PM I agree with Myra in how they all sound the same-ish, especially when you listen to it quite a few times.

Out of the ones I listened to - and I may be able to listen to some more while I do some work -
I liked the New Orleans, Louisiana one (2003-04-08) a lot
Will have to listen again and compare. Maybe the San Antonio one too, but I'm not sure if they are better than Oklahoma

tremors · February 2011

electricxlovex wrote:

tremors wrote:

Newch91 wrote:

I'm fond of the MSG I version.

What did you and electricx settle on Myra?

nothing yet :?

it's a very tough song to pick out which one is the best
if you check the PM I agree with Myra in how they all sound the same-ish, especially when you listen to it quite a few times.

Out of the ones I listened to - and I may be able to listen to some more while I do some work -
I liked the New Orleans, Louisiana one (2003-04-08) a lot
Will have to listen again and compare. Maybe the San Antonio one too, but I'm not sure if they are better than Oklahoma

Oklahoma is really good for the second half I think, and leads us really well into Thumbing My Way. So if we have say a possible two other contenders, we should make sure they work as well as our current one - or we could decide just to stick with it I guess

TheRealDanPatch · February 2011

tremors wrote:

Oklahoma is really good for the second half I think, and leads us really well into Thumbing My Way. So if we have say a possible two other contenders, we should make sure they work as well as our current one - or we could decide just to stick with it I guess

Have we decided to keep Oklahoma or are we going to try San Antonio or New Orleans?

tremors · February 2011

Cameron4President wrote:

tremors wrote:

Oklahoma is really good for the second half I think, and leads us really well into Thumbing My Way. So if we have say a possible two other contenders, we should make sure they work as well as our current one - or we could decide just to stick with it I guess

Have we decided to keep Oklahoma or are we going to try San Antonio or New Orleans?

I think myra was going to do some checking, but I will have a listen to the three right now and give you my reaction

PilateOfTheStorm · February 2011

tremors wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

tremors wrote:

Oklahoma is really good for the second half I think, and leads us really well into Thumbing My Way. So if we have say a possible two other contenders, we should make sure they work as well as our current one - or we could decide just to stick with it I guess

Have we decided to keep Oklahoma or are we going to try San Antonio or New Orleans?

I think myra was going to do some checking, but I will have a listen to the three right now and give you my reaction

yeah I feel like she will probably be the best to decide as she's listened to the most

New Orleans was my favourite out of San Antonio and New Orleans.
Just don't know if it's better than Oklahoma.

TheRealDanPatch · February 2011

electricxlovex wrote:

yeah I feel like she will probably be the best to decide as she's listened to the most

New Orleans was my favourite out of San Antonio and New Orleans.
Just don't know if it's better than Oklahoma.

If it's that close, then we should probably keep the one we have.

PilateOfTheStorm · February 2011

Cameron4President wrote:

electricxlovex wrote:

yeah I feel like she will probably be the best to decide as she's listened to the most

New Orleans was my favourite out of San Antonio and New Orleans.
Just don't know if it's better than Oklahoma.

If it's that close, then we should probably keep the one we have.

that's what I was also thinking, probably best thing to do unless myra has anything to add

I've got to say, I love it so far. Been listening to the bonus songs again and again.-- they are great

TheRealDanPatch · February 2011

electricxlovex wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

electricxlovex wrote:

yeah I feel like she will probably be the best to decide as she's listened to the most

New Orleans was my favourite out of San Antonio and New Orleans.
Just don't know if it's better than Oklahoma.

If it's that close, then we should probably keep the one we have.

that's what I was also thinking, probably best thing to do unless myra has anything to add

I've got to say, I love it so far. Been listening to the bonus songs again and again.-- they are great

Too bad they didn't play that song in Philly, that was a great sounding show.

tremors · February 2011

tremors wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

tremors wrote:

Oklahoma is really good for the second half I think, and leads us really well into Thumbing My Way. So if we have say a possible two other contenders, we should make sure they work as well as our current one - or we could decide just to stick with it I guess

Have we decided to keep Oklahoma or are we going to try San Antonio or New Orleans?

I think myra was going to do some checking, but I will have a listen to the three right now and give you my reaction

I think San Antonio sounds really good - why don't we try that in place of Oklahoma? Out of the three I think that may work best

PilateOfTheStorm · February 2011

tremors wrote:

tremors wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

Have we decided to keep Oklahoma or are we going to try San Antonio or New Orleans?

I think myra was going to do some checking, but I will have a listen to the three right now and give you my reaction

I think San Antonio sounds really good - why don't we try that in place of Oklahoma? Out of the three I think that may work best

really?
I'll have to listen again, give me a second

I remember one of them I thought sounded good, but wasn't sure. Maybe it was San Antonio? maybe I got that mixed up with New Orleans because I felt like I had mixed them up at the time

Project #8 - The Whispers of War: Riot Act Live

Comments

Categories