Project #5 - The Songs of The Who

TheRealDanPatch · December 2010

myra wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

Version 2??
Is there a need?
Any lingering SQ issues that need to be fixed?
Anything else we can add?
Did Eddie cover any Who songs during his solo tours in '08 & '09?

If we answer 'no' to most or all of these questions, then is this project ready for release?

-> no
-> no
-> no
-> I have no clue ----> where are the boots' ??! :x :(

Add to this :
-> headphone test : checked
-> speakers test : checked
-> in-car test : checked
-> in-office test : checked ..... :?

I reckon it's ready for release, then

The check list is great.

Let's hold off a day in hopes of adding a killer version of "I'm One" by Ed. If we can find it, I will add it to the mix and send a version 2.

myra · December 2010

Cameron4President wrote:

Let's hold off a day in hopes of adding a killer version of "I'm One" by Ed. If we can find it, I will add it to the mix and send a version 2.

Yeah, that'd be great. And it would also adress the "it's a bit short" issue. Besides the '94 Carnegie Hall, I have no Ed solo show. And no idea where to find any. :(

TheRealDanPatch · December 2010

myra wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

Let's hold off a day in hopes of adding a killer version of "I'm One" by Ed. If we can find it, I will add it to the mix and send a version 2.

Yeah, that'd be great. And it would also adress the "it's a bit short" issue. Besides the '94 Carnegie Hall, I have no Ed solo show. And no idea where to find any. :(

The hunt for "I'm One" (Eddie Solo) is on :twisted:

TheRealDanPatch · December 2010

Cameron4President wrote:

myra wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

Let's hold off a day in hopes of adding a killer version of "I'm One" by Ed. If we can find it, I will add it to the mix and send a version 2.

Yeah, that'd be great. And it would also adress the "it's a bit short" issue. Besides the '94 Carnegie Hall, I have no Ed solo show. And no idea where to find any. :(

The hunt for "I'm One" (Eddie Solo) is on :twisted:

"I'm One" has been located and will be added to our compilation. Version 2 to be sent out later tonight or tomorrow.

TheRealDanPatch · December 2010

Version 2 looking like this:

"Pearl Jam: The Kids Are Alright: The Songs of The Who" - Version 2

Track List:

Leaving Here - Columbia, Maryland (9/4/00)
I Can't Explain - San Diego, California (11/7/95)
My Generation - New York City, New York (2/24/94)
The Kids Are Alright - Sacramento, California (10/30/00)
A Quick One, While He’s Away - Torino, Italy (9/19/06)
The Seeker - St. Louis, Missouri (10/5/04)
Let's See Action - The Birdman Sessions - Miami, Florida (Spring 2000)
Baba O'Riley - George, Washington (9/1/05)
Naked Eye - New York City, New York (2/24/94)
I'm One - Chicago, Illinois (8/22/08)
Love Reign O'er Me - Mansfield, Massachusetts (6/28/08)
The Real Me - Seattle, Washington (9/22/09)
Squeeze Box - New York City, New York (2/24/94)
Blue, Red and Grey - San Diego, California (6/5/03)

Gary Carter · December 2010

how you can use any version but love reign o'er me from the who rock honors is beyond me

but

to each is their own

also i would put baba last but midset is what the who do sometimes at concerts, so that not to bad

other then those 2 things it's a good compilation

locked · December 2010

Brilliant mix folks!

Can't wait!

tremors · December 2010

metsfan wrote:

how you can use any version but love reign o'er me from the who rock honors is beyond me

but

to each is their own

also i would put baba last but midset is what the who do sometimes at concerts, so that not to bad

other then those 2 things it's a good compilation

Yeah baba would be good last. The track sequence has come from the order in which the Who released the tracks, which makes some sense. Personally I wouldn't be averse to taking baba out of that sequence and adding it to the end to finish like a good ole PJ show!

TheRealDanPatch · December 2010

tremors wrote:

metsfan wrote:

how you can use any version but love reign o'er me from the who rock honors is beyond me

but

to each is their own

also i would put baba last but midset is what the who do sometimes at concerts, so that not to bad

other then those 2 things it's a good compilation

Yeah baba would be good last. The track sequence has come from the order in which the Who released the tracks, which makes some sense. Personally I wouldn't be averse to taking baba out of that sequence and adding it to the end to finish like a good ole PJ show!

Believe it or not, I am not a huge fan of the Rock Honors version of "love reign o'er me", sorry

I know that a lot of people will disagree with me on that and that's cool. I also believe that the Rock Honors version would not fit well into our compilation because it is too polished.

Baba actually sounds real good midset. At first when we arranged the track listing, I didn't think that it was going to fly (As PJ fans we are all use to it at the end), but it sounds great in the middle and I think that a lot of people will appreciate it there.

TheRealDanPatch · December 2010

locked wrote:

Brilliant mix folks!

Can't wait!

Thanks for the "I'm One" call. The compilation is much improved because of it. We may let the train leave the station later today or early tomorrow.

myra · December 2010

Cameron4President wrote:

tremors wrote:

Yeah baba would be good last. The track sequence has come from the order in which the Who released the tracks, which makes some sense. Personally I wouldn't be averse to taking baba out of that sequence and adding it to the end to finish like a good ole PJ show!

Baba actually sounds real good midset. At first when we arranged the track listing, I didn't think that it was going to fly (As PJ fans we are all use to it at the end), but it sounds great in the middle and I think that a lot of people will appreciate it there.

I actually like Baba where it is right now, I was more disturbed at first by Leavin' here being at the beginning. Let's face it anyway : most of those songs would be expected at the end of a PJ show ... the whole compilation feels like a 2nd encore ! However, I feel Blue, red and grey would not fit elsewhere but at the end of the track list.

tremors · December 2010

myra wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

tremors wrote:

Yeah baba would be good last. The track sequence has come from the order in which the Who released the tracks, which makes some sense. Personally I wouldn't be averse to taking baba out of that sequence and adding it to the end to finish like a good ole PJ show!

Baba actually sounds real good midset. At first when we arranged the track listing, I didn't think that it was going to fly (As PJ fans we are all use to it at the end), but it sounds great in the middle and I think that a lot of people will appreciate it there.

I actually like Baba where it is right now, I was more disturbed at first by Leavin' here being at the beginning. Let's face it anyway : most of those songs would be expected at the end of a PJ show ... the whole compilation feels like a 2nd encore ! However, I feel Blue, red and grey would not fit elsewhere but at the end of the track list.

Yeah I listened through to Version 2 today, and I enjoyed it immensely, with the tracks where they are, and with the addition of I'm One. Overall I think it is first class, and more than ready to share

TheRealDanPatch · December 2010

tremors wrote:

Yeah I listened through to Version 2 today, and I enjoyed it immensely, with the tracks where they are, and with the addition of I'm One. Overall I think it is first class, and more than ready to share

Excellent. Unless if I hear any objections or calls to "stop the train"

, then it will be released tomorrow morning east coast time (approx. between 8:45am-9:00am). I will post a link on this thread, and Tremors you will update the other one. A big "Thank You" to everyone who offered suggestions. This has been my favorite project so far. (Theory is a close second)

myra · December 2010

Cameron4President wrote:

tremors wrote:

Yeah I listened through to Version 2 today, and I enjoyed it immensely, with the tracks where they are, and with the addition of I'm One. Overall I think it is first class, and more than ready to share

Excellent. Unless if I hear any objections or calls to "stop the train" , then it will be released tomorrow morning east coast time (approx. between 8:45am-9:00am). I will post a link on this thread, and Tremors you will update the other one. A big "Thank You" to everyone who offered suggestions. This has been my favorite project so far. (Theory is a close second)

I can totally hear Version 2 scream "Release me (tomorrow) !" now

TheRealDanPatch · December 2010

myra wrote:

Cameron4President wrote:

tremors wrote:

Yeah I listened through to Version 2 today, and I enjoyed it immensely, with the tracks where they are, and with the addition of I'm One. Overall I think it is first class, and more than ready to share

Excellent. Unless if I hear any objections or calls to "stop the train" , then it will be released tomorrow morning east coast time (approx. between 8:45am-9:00am). I will post a link on this thread, and Tremors you will update the other one. A big "Thank You" to everyone who offered suggestions. This has been my favorite project so far. (Theory is a close second)

I can totally hear Version 2 scream "Release me (tomorrow) !" now

tremors · December 2010

Cameron4President wrote:

tremors wrote:

Yeah I listened through to Version 2 today, and I enjoyed it immensely, with the tracks where they are, and with the addition of I'm One. Overall I think it is first class, and more than ready to share

Excellent. Unless if I hear any objections or calls to "stop the train" , then it will be released tomorrow morning east coast time (approx. between 8:45am-9:00am). I will post a link on this thread, and Tremors you will update the other one. A big "Thank You" to everyone who offered suggestions. This has been my favorite project so far. (Theory is a close second)

No objections!! I will do my bit and update the other thread. Sounding great. Thanks!

Pap · December 2010

Cameron4President wrote:

A big "Thank You" to everyone who offered suggestions. This has been my favorite project so far. (Theory is a close second)

Thank you (Myra, Cameron4President and Tremors for putting together such a nice project and also letting us all participate! I'm also glad to hear that you enjoyed "the ride" and of course for putting my suggestion (Love Reign O'er Me) in the track list!

Very nice job! :thumbup: Congratulations!

:wave:

TheRealDanPatch · December 2010

Pearl Jam: The Kids Are Alright: The Songs of The Who

http://dp-rearviewmirror.blogspot.com/2 ... f-who.html

tremors · December 2010

Cameron4President wrote:

Pearl Jam: The Kids Are Alright: The Songs of The Who

http://dp-rearviewmirror.blogspot.com/2 ... f-who.html

Most excellent! Well done! Thanks. I will update the overall thread properly later once back on my laptop. Has been fun.

Enjoy it people!

Black73 · December 2010

Cameron4President wrote:

Empty Glass wrote:

thefixer9 wrote:

I love the love reign o'er me from Philly last year!

MSG 1 '10 pretty damn good version as well

Both are great, and are definitely worthy of consideration. Thanks.

Holy SHIT - my son and I can't wait for this melding of the two greatest bands EVER!

I might consider The Real Me or Love Reign O'er Me from night 1 Chicago 2009...in a word, incredible.

TheRealDanPatch · December 2010

Black73 wrote:

Holy SHIT - my son and I can't wait for this melding of the two greatest bands EVER!

I might consider The Real Me or Love Reign O'er Me from night 1 Chicago 2009...in a word, incredible.

I Hope that the both of you enjoy it.

jjflash · December 2010

VNice. Thanks for putting this together. My dad loves The Who as they helped define his generation yet has never really shown any interest it tapping into PJ's music. I'm gonna burn him a copy of this and look forward to hearing what he thinks about their treatment of The Who's music. Hope you have a good weekend.

TheRealDanPatch · December 2010

jjflash wrote:

VNice. Thanks for putting this together. My dad loves The Who as they helped define his generation yet has never really shown any interest it tapping into PJ's music. I'm gonna burn him a copy of this and look forward to hearing what he thinks about their treatment of The Who's music. Hope you have a good weekend.

I am actually going to do the same for my Dad. He is a huge Who fan and the one that has made me a huge Who fan. I hope that you and your Dad enjoy the compilation.

TheRealDanPatch · December 2010

Thread for all of our projects:

viewtopic.php?f=4&t=143822

TheRealDanPatch · December 2010

The Kids Are Alright: The Songs of The Who

http://dp-rearviewmirror.blogspot.com/2 ... f-who.html

(Keeping things short and snappy - just like the Who - This 14 song collection takes us on a tour of Who 'covers', sequenced in the order in which songs were written (Who said rock and roll can't be educational?). Another favourite of ours.... the sound quality is high, the performances are tight, the mood is good. This is a little different from some of the other PJ Who compilations floating around out there - we didn't want to duplicate those, and tried to come up with something a bit special, drawing on the help and suggestions from the message board. These versions feature no musicians other than the members of Pearl Jam. Another rocking slice of of music to download in time for Xmas!! Enjoy!)

tremors · December 2010

There's a lot of Who been played by Pearl Jam over the years, and a lot that's had an influence. Listening today it was the intensity of the lyrics that hit me as much as anything. Good stuff!!

Dirty Bubba · December 2010

Awesome Job!! Thanks for the early Christmas present!!!

Pap · December 2010

Dirty Bubba wrote:

Awesome Job!! Thanks for the early Christmas present!!!

tremors · December 2010

Pap wrote:

Dirty Bubba wrote:

Awesome Job!! Thanks for the early Christmas present!!!

Glad you like it guys!

TheRealDanPatch · December 2010

tremors wrote:

Pap wrote:

Dirty Bubba wrote:

Awesome Job!! Thanks for the early Christmas present!!!

Glad you like it guys!

Ditto Here, I am glad that you are enjoying. Thanks..

Project #5 - The Songs of The Who

Comments