The Great Drummer Debate

hopethatuchoke
hopethatuchoke Posts: 2,927
edited June 2008 in The Porch
I know the "who's the best pearl jam drummer" debate has taken place many times over the years around here, and there is no real answer, but with these recent gems being unearthed (WMA, Who You Are) I feel as though Matt might be slipping in the standings. Those two songs and In My Tree have all had to be reworked presumably to fit his drumming style. I'm not saying he isn't a great drummer but do you remember any Dave songs having to be reworked for Jack?

This is meant for discussion and not fighting. Just wondering people's thoughts on the matter now that we have another re-worked song (that sounds awesome from the short video clip on Spin). And yes there is a strong chance someone else wanted to rework the songs but considering they are all somewhat unique drum songs, Matt is my assumption. Thoughts?
Post edited by Unknown User on
«134

Comments

  • MattyJoe
    MattyJoe Posts: 1,424
    You guys don't seem to understand that as a drummer Cameron can easily learn those songs the way they are meant to be played. Whether or not he does is another thing. But even if he never plays that way, a drummer can learn those patterns. It doesn't even take that much time (a few days at most for something really hard) until you have mastered something. Take my word for it, I'm a drummer. The only thing is it's possible he just didn't take the time to work out the stuff, which has been the case before on other songs.
    I pledge to you a government that will not only work well, but wisely, its ability to act tempered by prudence, and its willingness to do good, balanced by the knowledge that government is never more dangerous than when our desire to have it help us blinds us to its great power to harm us.
    -Reagan
  • Anon
    Anon Posts: 11,175
    I think Jack was their best drummer. His style can be either funky or hard depending on the song. Some of the shows from 95/96, when you listen to them, the drumming is out of this world. I believe he also had some things to due with the band staying together during the harder times....so he gets my nod.

    I like Matt but I think he's too "heavy" for some of PJ's stuff. I think of him in the likeness of Bonham. I liked Dave and think he was a good drummer but he had WAY too many cymbals :-) Dave K and Matt C filled in capably where needed (Dave gets a nice nod for being on 10).

    My rankings:

    Jack
    Dave
    Matt
    Dave K
    Matt C

    My .02
  • Slip Kid
    Slip Kid Posts: 1,175
    yeah Jack Irons was the best drummer
    I just don't trust anything that bleeds for five days and doesn't die.
  • hopethatuchoke
    hopethatuchoke Posts: 2,927
    I agree with both of you. I love Jack but Dave is a close second. I think Matt is technically awesome but when you listen to bootlegs of him compared to the other guys, I don't think his sound is nearly as good. It doesn't have as much "umph" if that makes sense.
  • MattyJoe
    MattyJoe Posts: 1,424
    Dave A was the best drummer. He really gave the band a nice energetic but grungy sound. Jack Irons is too sluggish, don't like him.
    I pledge to you a government that will not only work well, but wisely, its ability to act tempered by prudence, and its willingness to do good, balanced by the knowledge that government is never more dangerous than when our desire to have it help us blinds us to its great power to harm us.
    -Reagan
  • RiotAct10
    RiotAct10 Ohio Posts: 1,639
    I dont think Matt is the reason a lot of these songs have been reworked. I think In My Tree had a lot to do with Ed, and I wouldn't be surprised if the other songs did to. Matt seems like the kind of guy who has no problem doing whatever the band wants him to, and I am sure if they asked him to play Who You Are or WMA like Jack or Dave, he could have done it, but I think the band, or Ed, didn't play these songs for a long time for more reason than just the drumming, and when they finally brought them back, they just decided to take a different approach.

    I know a lot of people love Jack and Dave, and I do to, but to me the current lineup is the true pearl jam lineup, and I wouldn't want it any other way.
    words seem so out of place.

    8.21.00 Columbus | 6.24.03 Columbus | 7.9.03 NYC | 10.2.04 Toledo | 9.11.05 Kitchener | 5.20.06 Cleveland | 8.5.07 Chicago | 5.6.10 Columbus | 5.7.10 Noblesville | 5.9.10 Cleveland | 9.3.11 East Troy | 9.4.11 East Troy | 7.19.13 Chicago | 10.11.13 Pittsburgh | 10.1.14 Cincinnati | 4.8.16 Ft. Lauderdale | 4.9.16 Miami | 8.8.18 Seattle | 8.10.18 Seattle | 9.26.21 Dana Point | 10.1.21 Dana Point | 10.2.21 Dana Point | 9.16.22 Nashville | 9.17.22 Louisville | 9.18.22 St. Louis | 9.2.23 St. Paul | 9.15.23 Ft. Worth | 6.22.24 Dublin | 8.26.24 Noblesville | 9.27.24 Dana Point | 9.29.24 Dana Point | 4.24.25 Hollywood | 4.26.25 Hollywood | 5.18.25 Pittsburgh
    6.26.11 Detroit (EdVed) | 9.23.17 Louisville (EdVed) | 9.25.21 Dana Point (EdVed) | 10.01.22 Dana Point (EdVed) | 2.6.22 Newark (EdVed)
  • UpSideDown
    UpSideDown Posts: 1,966
    Matt wins again; Jack wasn't as strong of a live performer and Dave was only a good drummer for hard songs. He wouldnt have matured with the band.
  • hopethatuchoke
    hopethatuchoke Posts: 2,927
    Corey Erven wrote:
    Matt wins again; Jack wasn't as strong of a live performer and Dave was only a good drummer for hard songs. He wouldnt have matured with the band.

    That is a good point. Dave primarily drummed on harder songs. That is a big reason I liked his sound so much. He might not have worked with some of the post Vitalogy stuff.
  • UpSideDown
    UpSideDown Posts: 1,966
    hopethatuchoke wrote:
    That is a good point. Dave primarily drummed on harder songs. That is a big reason I liked his sound so much. He might not have worked with some of the post Vitalogy stuff.

    exactly.......he was good for the early stuff, but i can't see him doing well on much past that. I like Jack as well (he had a nice creative vibe) but I think Matt is just a stronger live performer.
  • Kilgore_Trout
    Kilgore_Trout Posts: 7,334
    hopethatuchoke wrote:
    do you remember any Dave songs having to be reworked for Jack?
    thats cause Dave was a heavy hitting gorilla... not much to his drumming rythmically... not to say he wasnt a good fit for that stage of PJ's career... he just cant shine a light to jack OR matt... havent heard the new versions of the songs yet though so ill get back to you when i have
    "Senza speme vivemo in disio"

    http://seanbriceart.com/
  • 12345AGNST1
    12345AGNST1 Posts: 4,906
    dave a had absolutely no style whatsoever. He played every song the exact same way. It didnt matter if it were soft or heavy, all he did was hit a shitload of cymbals. His drum fills were so generic. Matt cameron rapes dave a. Matt plays a different fill all the time and never plays a song the same way.

    people complain yada yada yada, matt cant play in my tree, who you are and now WMA the sam way. are you kidding me? of COURSE he can play those songs the same way. He just CHOSES not to, its called having your own style. Matt couldve easily just learned the pattern for those songs, but instead he played it his own way. Thats a real drummer. and if anyone doubts themselves on matts ability in PJ, listen to any boot from 2000, i mean reallllly listen to his playing. its incredible. I will admit he has toned down since then though.
    5/28/06, 6/27/08, 10/28/09, 5/18/10, 5/21/10
    8/7/08, 6/9/09
  • hopethatuchoke
    hopethatuchoke Posts: 2,927
    12345AGNST1 wrote:
    people complain yada yada yada, matt cant play in my tree, who you are and now WMA the sam way. are you kidding me? of COURSE he can play those songs the same way. He just CHOSES not to, its called having your own style. Matt couldve easily just learned the pattern for those songs, but instead he played it his own way. Thats a real drummer. and if anyone doubts themselves on matts ability in PJ, listen to any boot from 2000, i mean reallllly listen to his playing. its incredible. I will admit he has toned down since then though.

    So you have talked to him and been there while they are rehearsing and know for a fact he can play WMA and In My Tree the same way Dave and Jack did? If it's simply a case of having his own style then why aren't more songs changed up? It just find it peculiar that the only songs they rearrange are those with complex drum parts.
  • slightofjeff
    slightofjeff Posts: 7,762
    Corey Erven wrote:
    Matt wins again; Jack wasn't as strong of a live performer and Dave was only a good drummer for hard songs. He wouldnt have matured with the band.

    I mean, could you imagine Dave drumming on something like, say, Sleight of Hand?
    everybody wants the most they can possibly get
    for the least they could possibly do
  • slightofjeff
    slightofjeff Posts: 7,762
    hopethatuchoke wrote:
    So you have talked to him and been there while they are rehearsing and know for a fact he can play WMA and In My Tree the same way Dave and Jack did?

    I just don't see any reason why Matt couldn't play those songs that way if he so chose. It's not like Jack invented some new sound never heard before for Who You Are.

    Any professional, half-competent drummer could learn the pattern if given time. There has to be another reason they were re-worked.

    I don't mean to denigrate Jack. Who You Are is very cool and very creative. But once something like that is created, anybody with a modicum of talent can copy it if they want to.
    everybody wants the most they can possibly get
    for the least they could possibly do
  • Evolution6579
    Evolution6579 Posts: 624
    hopethatuchoke wrote:
    So you have talked to him and been there while they are rehearsing and know for a fact he can play WMA and In My Tree the same way Dave and Jack did? If it's simply a case of having his own style then why aren't more songs changed up? It just find it peculiar that the only songs they rearrange are those with complex drum parts.
    Have you heard Jesus Christ Pose, Rhinosaur, Burden In My Hand? Hell...the drum part in Evacuation is more complex than Who You Are.
    Chicago 8-23-09

  • 12345AGNST1
    12345AGNST1 Posts: 4,906
    hopethatuchoke wrote:
    So you have talked to him and been there while they are rehearsing and know for a fact he can play WMA and In My Tree the same way Dave and Jack did? If it's simply a case of having his own style then why aren't more songs changed up? It just find it peculiar that the only songs they rearrange are those with complex drum parts.


    Go on youtube and watch random teenagers play rush songs, or really hard tool songs. Ive seen kids not even in their twenties play some real hard songs, do u seriously for one second think matt cant play a song like wma? it really ISNT a hard song, neither is who you are. the only song thats tricky is in my tree. Matt has been a drummer for what? almost 30 years?

    Matt plays his own way. its pretty obvious.
    5/28/06, 6/27/08, 10/28/09, 5/18/10, 5/21/10
    8/7/08, 6/9/09
  • LONGRD
    LONGRD Posts: 6,036
    MattyJoe wrote:
    Dave A was the best drummer. He really gave the band a nice energetic but grungy sound. Jack Irons is too sluggish, don't like him.
    That's why he got fired. PJ isn't a grunge anymore after '93. ;)

    Jack's my favorite, Matt, then Dave K. I usually exclude Krusen and Chamberlain from the discuss b/c their time were brief.
    PJ- 04/29/2003.06/24,25,27,28,30/2008.10/27,28,30,31/2009
    EV- 08/09,10/2008.06/08,09/2009
  • Evolution6579
    Evolution6579 Posts: 624
    12345AGNST1 wrote:
    Go on youtube and watch random teenagers play rush songs, or really hard tool songs. Ive seen kids not even in their twenties play some real hard songs, do u seriously for one second think matt cant play a song like wma? it really ISNT a hard song, neither is who you are. the only song thats tricky is in my tree. Matt has been a drummer for what? almost 30 years?

    Matt plays his own way. its pretty obvious.
    Exactly. And Matt played the hell out of it on the 2000 tour. I hate having to repeat this: Put in Touring Band 2000 and watch the Matt Cam version of In My Tree. He puts so much emotion into that performance, it gives me chills. Dare I say he played it better than Jack could ever dream?

    I may be stirring the pot a little but Matt has WAY better chops than Jack.
    Chicago 8-23-09

  • Brisk.
    Brisk. Posts: 11,581
    matt or dave.

    /END.
  • Mr Zelx
    Mr Zelx Posts: 18
    Check out Pearl Jam's Gimli 1993 show on youtube and you will see how good Dave A is. He is an amazing drummer and when Jack replaced him, I was shocked at how bad he was.

    Jack Irons is by far the worst drummer Pearl Jam have had. I cant believe some people on here claim he is their favourite. Each to their own I guess. Thank god Matt took over and rejuvenated the band and gave them stability.

Categories