I want Benaroya Vinyl, whats it gonna take?

WindowPaine

2 front row tickets to this beacon hall show and my sealed (STILL IN THE MAILER IT CAME IN) vinyl set is yours.

NOTHINGFAN

I'll sell you mine, but I need all cash, I don't want posters. I'm hitting 6 shows this tour and that shit ain't cheap.

However, the spine on the outter box is slightly damaged, but I can provide pics. It was delivered to me that way, the rest is in complete mint condition.

uglybabo

I have a Benaroya, opened but never played...

I've been considering selling it to help fund the upcoming NYC trip. I'm actually not that much of a collector; I'd take seeing the band live over having a vinyl copy of something I have on CD.

wwfairfield

LukinFan wrote:

Some guy on here is offering a trade for a sealed Ben Hall for front row seats at the WPB show

thats me holmes

the deal is still on the table

wwfairfield

let me splain my deal

you get my tickets to the wpb show which should be alright because my 10C number is betwix'd 160k-170k
and !!!!!!!!
A sealed numbered Beneroya vinyl set
on the spot

i get your front row tickets to the wpb show


lets do this

cincinnati dude

NOTHINGFAN wrote:

I'll sell you mine, but I need all cash, I don't want posters. I'm hitting 6 shows this tour and that shit ain't cheap.

However, the spine on the outter box is slightly damaged, but I can provide pics. It was delivered to me that way, the rest is in complete mint condition.

Almost everyone that I've talked to said their Benny was damaged. Mine included.

UndyTaker

cincinnati dude wrote:

Almost everyone that I've talked to said their Benny was damaged. Mine included.

Is that like how everyone's is "opened but never played"?

wwfairfield

mines is perfect

drummerboy_73

cellophane_star wrote:

I can't believe anyone would give up the vinyl. It's so rare.

What if dog shit was rare? Would that be worth some front row tickets? I don't mean to bash on collector's per se - but do you really appreciate the Benaroya vinyl for what it IS...or what it's WORTH? And it's really only WORTH it's collectible value if you sell it, right? Other than that, like burnerben said - it's just "stuff on his shelf". The same can be said for a stamp with an upside-down airplane on it. It's worth a shitload of money in the marketplace because of it's rarity...but all it really is, to me, is a stamp that someone f*cked up on.

I have pretty much all of the vinyls minus Benny. They all get played - no frames, no special cases...they're records to me. That's the only reason I bought 'em.

wwfairfield

drummerboy_73 wrote:

What if dog shit was rare? Would that be worth some front row tickets? I don't mean to bash on collector's per se - but do you really appreciate the Benaroya vinyl for what it IS...or what it's WORTH? And it's really only WORTH it's collectible value if you sell it, right? Other than that, like burnerben said - it's just "stuff on his shelf". The same can be said for a stamp with an upside-down airplane on it. It's worth a shitload of money in the marketplace because of it's rarity...but all it really is, to me, is a stamp that someone f*cked up on.

I have pretty much all of the vinyls minus Benny. They all get played - no frames, no special cases...they're records to me. That's the only reason I bought 'em.

you are the coolest human ever
you're like buddha but bad ass

DarkStar

ballbag wrote:

i'll send you a picture of me holding my benaroya vinyl.

LOL

ds

demetrios

cincinnati dude wrote:

Almost everyone that I've talked to said their Benny was damaged. Mine included.

mine came in mint condition. it's still unopened. i still got it packaged back in the shipping package thing of a jig.

flyinwhole313

Spot In The Sky wrote:

EV Kenyon Hall + Dusseldorf + $$$? How much $$$? Maybe another/different poster? Do people want posters as trade for the vinyl? I really need it- someone tell me what it takes!!

Clever marketing...Coincidence that the first Benaroya in a while showed up on ebay when this post did? I think not.

flyinwhole313

If someone(s) is trying to sell or trade their Benaroya LP, I am interested to get in on the action. PM please. And I do have a mint Dusseldorf available for trade

the wolf

drummerboy_73 wrote:

What if dog shit was rare? Would that be worth some front row tickets? I don't mean to bash on collector's per se - but do you really appreciate the Benaroya vinyl for what it IS...or what it's WORTH? And it's really only WORTH it's collectible value if you sell it, right? Other than that, like burnerben said - it's just "stuff on his shelf". The same can be said for a stamp with an upside-down airplane on it. It's worth a shitload of money in the marketplace because of it's rarity...but all it really is, to me, is a stamp that someone f*cked up on.

I have pretty much all of the vinyls minus Benny. They all get played - no frames, no special cases...they're records to me. That's the only reason I bought 'em.

i agree for the most part. i have all the other vinyl, but not benny. if i ever had a chance to pick one up, i would listen to it all the damn time!!! : )

Spot In The Sky

flyinwhole313 wrote:

Clever marketing...Coincidence that the first Benaroya in a while showed up on ebay when this post did? I think not.

It not a coincidence, douche.
Is it coincidence that I got two highly sought after posters recently? Ill trade what people want for what I want. Ive got all the albums, and lost dogs, and LO2L on vinyl, benny would just be a beautiful listen, and a beautiful edition to the set.

Let me rephrase my question to the board- can i BORROW anyones??? Just for a listen?? Anyone in the DC area have one? Ill come over and listen to it, I promise it wont be wierd, Ill even try to keep my pants on.

leep75

UndieTaker wrote:

Is that like how everyone's is "opened but never played"?

Nope, mine has been played many times.

Gushfest

alright, so im a vinyl guy, but i never quite grasped the idea of having bearoya or any other live show on vinyl (contemporary). the show is recorded onto a hard drive, meaning that the record isnt truly analog in any way... it's already been compressed. i could see if the show was recorded onto tape, but it's not.

so whats the point in having the live vinyl other than some ridiculous necessity of a collector? am i missing something?

we dont buy new vinyl if we know the album was done on pro tools, this just seems to be the same concept.

UndyTaker

leep75 wrote:

Nope, mine has been played many times.

I didn't mean you literally. I was just commenting on how so many people claim to have it open but not played. That's funny to me.

rhinomagic

mwilmot4 wrote:

I have a Benaroya, opened but never played...

I've been considering selling it to help fund the upcoming NYC trip. I'm actually not that much of a collector; I'd take seeing the band live over having a vinyl copy of something I have on CD.

You are ripe for the pickin', my friend.

I predict you will receive several offers, if you haven't already.

I like my Benaroya vinyl set, so don't anyone bother offering

.