Which upcoming album by these once-legendary bands will be a bigger disaster?

We All Believe

Pearl Jam and toast wrote:

Oh shut up, his solo record was not a disaster. It didn't sell and it wasn't as good as the Pumpkins' records but it wasn't anywhere close to bad. The new record is going to be incredible.

Anyway, Axl Rose's dickishness has just risen since 10 years ago, so I have a big feeling it's gonna be horrible.

It was a disaster to me. I don't listen to it, or Zwan, that much.

That being said, I do look forward to Zeitgeist. Some Pumpkins is better than no Pumpkins.

elmer

GnR were/are a much bigger draw than the smashing pumpkins ever have been and for sure it will be analysed far greater.

as for chinese democracy, I agree with the thread starter.......... seeing the setlists from recent shows aint too encouraging,,,like isnt there more new material to debut?

facepollution

We All Believe wrote:

It's also a joke for either of these bands to use their old names, given their current respective lineups. But maybe we'll be surprised.

Well NIN have a constantly revolving line-up, but they are still considered NIN when they record and play live. Like someone else said, all they really need is Billy and Jimmy, it would be awesome to have James Iha back in the band, but I doubt it's gonna happen.

P.s The new Pumpkins record will be great - Billy's ready to rock again!

releeseme

facepollution wrote:

Well NIN have a constantly revolving line-up, but they are still considered NIN when they record and play live. Like someone else said, all they really need is Billy and Jimmy, it would be awesome to have James Iha back in the band, but I doubt it's gonna happen.

P.s The new Pumpkins record will be great - Billy's ready to rock again!

Trent IS NIN, just as Billy IS the Pumpkins. I am not too sure the Same can be said for Axl. He is just no where near as talented musically as either of them IMO.