Angrier than Rage Against the Machine?

drivingrl

If you had to explain to someone how angry Rage's music is by using a hypothetical angry music scale from 1 to 5 - with 1 being bubblegum pop - what would be 5?

corduroy10

I don't know, I would put RATM as a 3 or a 4. They're agressively political, but not frothing at the mouth angry like slipknot's Iowa, or the lunatic rantings of Serj from Sytem of a Down, or even the restrained calculated anger of Tool.

Those three IMO are 5's.

Joe2TheRevenge

i just find RATM to be really complaining more than angry.

People who are truly "angry" usually have the balls to do something about it, rather than just spend all their time making rap-rock talking about what they are going to do about it.

FinsburyParkCarrots

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=XKLIxTFNLIk&feature=related

PearlJamaholic

id put ratm at maybe 4, but system of downs is probably a 3 at best, they have always seemed pretty tame to me....that band is nowhere near ratm. i think a 5 would have to be a real metal band or laughable punk band. so maybe some gg alin crap might be 5, or something.

to max out on anger you'd also have to be pretty stupid, i dont mean that in a harsh way, but like unfocused and everything. if your political rants are thought out well, youre focused by some intelligence which would keep you from maxing out the anger meter.

warden

Joe2TheRevenge wrote:

i just find RATM to be really complaining more than angry.

People who are truly "angry" usually have the balls to do something about it, rather than just spend all their time making rap-rock talking about what they are going to do about it.

Yep, Rage never does anything about it. They never protest. They never donate money. They do absolutely nothing, right?

Joe2TheRevenge

warden wrote:

Yep, Rage never does anything about it. They never protest.

80 year old ladies protest every day. i would expect for all the calls for revolution, they would actually maybe perhaps try and lead one being young educated able-bodied human beings

although Zach singing Bulls on Parade A capella at the RNC really seemed to change the entire tide of this year's election.

They never donate money.

i am sure they do. they probably leave their large mansions, drive down hollywood boulevard in their hummers, donate 2000 dollars to a soup kitchen, then go to the recording studio and write a furious anthem about how horrible the wealthy are and how we all need to rage against them.

They do absolutely nothing, right?

they complain alot. sure are damn good at it too.


At Lollapalooza Zach made some comment like "if the Republicans win this next election, i know some people who are going to start some shit"

Sure you do Zach. Sure you do. i am sure they (and you) have just been waiting around the LAST 8 YEARS planning it, right? right.

Big talk, no action.

They are good at 2 things

1. Writing songs about extreme change

2. walking in parades.

muppet

I think Rage do a lot more than your typical "Bush sucks" bandwagon band. It's not always publicisied but they're certinally active.

Having said that, Zack's talk of burning the Senate down is just stupid. Beware the army of suburban white kids...

warden

Joe2TheRevenge wrote:

80 year old ladies protest every day. i would expect for all the calls for revolution, they would actually maybe perhaps try and lead one being young educated able-bodied human beings

although Zach singing Bulls on Parade A capella at the RNC really seemed to change the entire tide of this year's election.



i am sure they do. they probably leave their large mansions, drive down hollywood boulevard in their hummers, donate 2000 dollars to a soup kitchen, then go to the recording studio and write a furious anthem about how horrible the wealthy are and how we all need to rage against them.




they complain alot. sure are damn good at it too.


At Lollapalooza Zach made some comment like "if the Republicans win this next election, i know some people who are going to start some shit"

Sure you do Zach. Sure you do. i am sure they (and you) have just been waiting around the LAST 8 YEARS planning it, right? right.

Big talk, no action.

They are good at 2 things

1. Writing songs about extreme change

2. walking in parades.

I've read that Zack hasn't even had a vehicle most of his life because he wants to help the environment or whatever. So you sound like a complete idiot to those people who know about this with your "I'm sure they donate money when they leave their mansions in their hummers" comment.

Tom has peacefully protested and gotten arrested with blue collar citizens protesting with him. They show up and protest and perform for many different causes, some of them very obscure and absolutely not impacting their lives (e.g. protesting for mistreatment of hotel maids, mistreatment of tomato farm workers in Latin America, etc.).

So I'm not sure what more they could do unless, ya know, you actually want them to assassinate somebody or something. They have beliefs and they go about expressing their beliefs THE RIGHT WAY.

You sound whinier with your RATM angst than other Rage song "whining" about politics.

Jeremy1012

Rage are like, a 2. Seriously. "Fuck you, I won't do what you tell me"... it's like a 14 year-old who won't tidy his bedroom.

I'd put this closer to a 5 but then the band were actually teenagers, it'd sound ridiculous if they were still playing it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lk5ThPdSDp4&feature=related

kitfoo

Downset came out around the time of RATM. I think they're angrier more for the fact that they were all in LA street gangs before they formed the band. RATM are just a bunch of suburban kids who thought it was cool to protest.

Joe2TheRevenge

warden wrote:

I've read that Zack hasn't even had a vehicle most of his life because he wants to help the environment or whatever. So you sound like a complete idiot to those people who know about this with your "I'm sure they donate money when they leave their mansions in their hummers" comment.

Tom has peacefully protested and gotten arrested with blue collar citizens protesting with him. They show up and protest and perform for many different causes, some of them very obscure and absolutely not impacting their lives (e.g. protesting for mistreatment of hotel maids, mistreatment of tomato farm workers in Latin America, etc.).

So I'm not sure what more they could do unless, ya know, you actually want them to assassinate somebody or something. They have beliefs and they go about expressing their beliefs THE RIGHT WAY.

You sound whinier with your RATM angst than other Rage song "whining" about politics.

THEY ARE JUST MUSICIANS.

With no real motivation to actually change anything, or else they would have been politicians instead.

Every band has something to say, and contributes to causes they believe in. RATM yells louder, but there's plenty of bands who make a bigger impact. As big of a douche as Bono is, at least he knows the way to make change is to work WITH politicians instead of just complaining how none of them listen.

RATM are a bunch of immature little boys who read too many Malcom X books.

15 years of "revolution" and all they have accomplished is putting 20 million of their albums into the hands of metal fans who won't do shit to help anyone.

Someone should tell RATM that eventually the spoiled baby who cries all the time starts to be ignored.

Joe2TheRevenge

Also, i would like to submit all those racist nazi punk bands as angriest FTW

KingofFunk412

I can't believe some of you... you guys don't think RATM are activists just because you don't like their music. Seriously... have you only listened to Killing in the Name and just made your judgment right there? So ignorant...

And Joe2TheRevenge, you're retarded.

Jeremy1012

KingofFunk412 wrote:

I can't believe some of you... you guys don't think RATM are activists just because you don't like their music. Seriously... have you only listened to Killing in the Name and just made your judgment right there? So ignorant...

And Joe2TheRevenge, you're retarded.

Nah, I've heard every song on every album.

There's these things called opinions. You're allowed one, Joe2TheRevenge is allowed one, I'm allowed one.

Plenty of Rage's songs are political in nature but, as someone has already said, however much a tosser he is, Bono actually makes progressive attempts to change things and works in a political atmosphere, often to the detriment to his music because, for better or worse, he feels compelled to. It's VERY easy to talk the talk but it's just cheap and meaningless if you don't walk the walk. Rage playing against a backdrop of Che portraits and shouting "Impeach the president" is nothing to get excited about. Every stoner in every university in the world with an unthumbed copy of Das Kapital can do that. If Rage want to use their stage to be a political force, that's fine. I'm in favour of bands speaking their minds. They need to be a little less naive about it all though, the only people who are listening are Rage fans.

catefrances

Jeremy1012 wrote:

Nah, I've heard every song on every album.

There's these things called opinions. You're allowed one, Joe2TheRevenge is allowed one, I'm allowed one.

Plenty of Rage's songs are political in nature but, as someone has already said, however much a tosser he is, Bono actually makes progressive attempts to change things and works in a political atmosphere, often to the detriment to his music because, for better or worse, he feels compelled to. It's VERY easy to talk the talk but it's just cheap and meaningless if you don't walk the walk. Rage playing against a backdrop of Che portraits and shouting "Impeach the president" is nothing to get excited about. Every stoner in every university in the world with an unthumbed copy of Das Kapital can do that. If Rage want to use their stage to be a political force, that's fine. I'm in favour of bands speaking their minds. They need to be a little less naive about it all though, the only people who are listening are Rage fans.

you have got to shitting me. plenty of rage's songs are political??? ALL of RATM songs are poltical as far as i can see. the only one that might be seen as not, cause its such a personal song for zach, is born of a broken man. but then if you look at it, the song of his father's breakdown and the role zach sees the church as having in that, can be classed as political.


this band so freaked out the establishment that the NYSE was shut down because of their presence. and as i recall though the band werent arrested that day, the director of the film clip they were making at the time, michael moore, was.

warden

KingofFunk412 wrote:

And Joe2TheRevenge, you're retarded.

Agreed!

warden

Jeremy1012 wrote:

Nah, I've heard every song on every album.

There's these things called opinions. You're allowed one, Joe2TheRevenge is allowed one, I'm allowed one.

Plenty of Rage's songs are political in nature but, as someone has already said, however much a tosser he is, Bono actually makes progressive attempts to change things and works in a political atmosphere, often to the detriment to his music because, for better or worse, he feels compelled to. It's VERY easy to talk the talk but it's just cheap and meaningless if you don't walk the walk. Rage playing against a backdrop of Che portraits and shouting "Impeach the president" is nothing to get excited about. Every stoner in every university in the world with an unthumbed copy of Das Kapital can do that. If Rage want to use their stage to be a political force, that's fine. I'm in favour of bands speaking their minds. They need to be a little less naive about it all though, the only people who are listening are Rage fans.

Talk the talk but not walking the walk? What does that even mean? What do they need to do to walk the walk?

You just sound like a tired old cliche.

The only people listening are not Rage fans. I saw Rage at RNC and they had literally hundreds of cops in full swat gear, tons of swat vans, etc. But I'm sure they just do this for any old concert, right?

randallanddarcy

Eighties/early 90's Rollins is where it's at. Go listen to Lifetime, Do It, Turned On, or the End of Silence. He makes RATM sound like angry gerbils.

drivingrl

You guys are gettin' really off topic with the whether-or-not-they're-politically-active-enough talk.

Jeremy1012

warden wrote:

Talk the talk but not walking the walk? What does that even mean? What do they need to do to walk the walk?

You just sound like a tired old cliche.

The only people listening are not Rage fans. I saw Rage at RNC and they had literally hundreds of cops in full swat gear, tons of swat vans, etc. But I'm sure they just do this for any old concert, right?

Yeah, sure, I sound like the tired old cliche here.

I'm sure they do that for every concert they suspect to be full of rowdy, angry kids who think they're revolutionaries, yes.