Top 10 Favorite and Disliked Songs

Get_Right

RatherStarved said:

I’m not going to make my lists but it’s amazing how some of my likes are on other people’s dislikes and vice versa.  Very shocked people dislike Immortality, Unthought Known, DOTC, to name a few.  Overall this thread has me excited for the tour.  

Also I don’t dislike Even Flow and Alive but they are at 95% and 100% play rate for my shows and I’d be fine not to hear either of them live in 2025.  

Just saying. Shelve Ten and play more Binaural you pussies.

drfox

Poncier said:

drfox said:

Disliked 

Footsteps

DM282158 said:

Dislikes:
 
Insignificance
 
Nothing As it Seems 
 

ST66483 said:

Dislikes

Nothing As It Seems
 
Deep 
Garden
Immortality
 

jondu003 said:

Dislikes:

3. Deep

10. Porch

pjhawks said:

Dislikes:

Tremor Christ
 

While I realize it's all subjective, the above dislikes are astoundingly perplexing to me.

The world would be boring if everyone liked and disliked the same. 

drfox

HailHailVitalogy said:

Hard To Imagine is on most of these lists. It’s overwhelming in the first dozen comments

I am so fucking sick of Alive, but if they moved it around I would react differently. Porch 5th song at MSG 2022 was insane and I’m sick of that too. Close with Porch or Even Flow over Alive. I prefer Jeremy and Daughter over Betterman and Small Town. 

Lots of love for Release, Setting Sun, In Hiding, Parting Ways and In My Tree as well! 

RatherStarved

Get_Right said:

RatherStarved said:

I’m not going to make my lists but it’s amazing how some of my likes are on other people’s dislikes and vice versa.  Very shocked people dislike Immortality, Unthought Known, DOTC, to name a few.  Overall this thread has me excited for the tour.  

Also I don’t dislike Even Flow and Alive but they are at 95% and 100% play rate for my shows and I’d be fine not to hear either of them live in 2025.  

Just saying. Shelve Ten and play more Binaural you pussies.

I’m in for Oceans and Garden all day long.  Binaural, meh.

Pap

Top 10 Favs:
Education
Animal
Corduroy
Grievance
Won't Tell
Leatherman
State of Love and Trust
Quick Escape
Once
Hail, Hail

Top 10 Disliked:
The End
Yellow Moon
Army Reserve
Glorified G
My Father's Son
Help Help
Speed of Sound
Seven O'Clock
Got to Give
Retrograde

Get_Right

RatherStarved said:

Get_Right said:

RatherStarved said:

I’m not going to make my lists but it’s amazing how some of my likes are on other people’s dislikes and vice versa.  Very shocked people dislike Immortality, Unthought Known, DOTC, to name a few.  Overall this thread has me excited for the tour.  

Also I don’t dislike Even Flow and Alive but they are at 95% and 100% play rate for my shows and I’d be fine not to hear either of them live in 2025.  

Just saying. Shelve Ten and play more Binaural you pussies.

I’m in for Oceans and Garden all day long.  Binaural, meh.

Release. And done. Play grievance, insignificance, breakerfall, rival, of the girl, nothing as it seems etc.

Shaindli1

Get_Right said:

RatherStarved said:

Get_Right said:

RatherStarved said:

I’m not going to make my lists but it’s amazing how some of my likes are on other people’s dislikes and vice versa.  Very shocked people dislike Immortality, Unthought Known, DOTC, to name a few.  Overall this thread has me excited for the tour.  

Also I don’t dislike Even Flow and Alive but they are at 95% and 100% play rate for my shows and I’d be fine not to hear either of them live in 2025.  

Just saying. Shelve Ten and play more Binaural you pussies.

I’m in for Oceans and Garden all day long.  Binaural, meh.

Release. And done. Play grievance, insignificance, breakerfall, rival, of the girl, nothing as it seems etc.

Exactly. Don't let Binaural fade away, not on its 25th anniversary!

PJNB

Forgot Something Special as a dislike 


Maybe at the very top for me

RatherStarved

Get_Right said:

RatherStarved said:

Get_Right said:

RatherStarved said:

I’m not going to make my lists but it’s amazing how some of my likes are on other people’s dislikes and vice versa.  Very shocked people dislike Immortality, Unthought Known, DOTC, to name a few.  Overall this thread has me excited for the tour.  

Also I don’t dislike Even Flow and Alive but they are at 95% and 100% play rate for my shows and I’d be fine not to hear either of them live in 2025.  

Just saying. Shelve Ten and play more Binaural you pussies.

I’m in for Oceans and Garden all day long.  Binaural, meh.

Release. And done. Play grievance, insignificance, breakerfall, rival, of the girl, nothing as it seems etc.

Good with Insignificance and Nais.

BSully

Ok, as usual this is a hard list to make because my top ten songs change out a lot depending on my mood, I also don't like using the word dislike with a PJ song, but instead I will give you 10 songs that are my least favorite... at least as of right now:

Favs (not in order):
1. Black
2. Glorified G
3. Tremor Christ
4. Red Mosquito
5. Corduroy
6. Insignificance
7. Not For You
8. SOLAT
9. Immortality
10. I Got Shit
*man that was hard to choose

Least fav (also not in order):
1. Push Me, Pull Me
2. You Are
3. Yellow Moon
4. DOTC
5. Comes Then Goes
6. River Cross
7. Upper Hand
8. Future Days
9. My Father's Son
10. Stupidmop

pymusy

Favorite 
1 Garden
2 RVM
3 Immortality 
4 No Way
5 Rival
6 insignificance 
7 Of The Earth
8 Black
9 All or None
10 Present Tense

Least
Most of Gigaton excepting Retrograde
Most of Backspacer

Go Beavers

drfox said:

Poncier said:

drfox said:

Disliked 

Footsteps

DM282158 said:

Dislikes:
 
Insignificance
 
Nothing As it Seems 
 

ST66483 said:

Dislikes

Nothing As It Seems
 
Deep 
Garden
Immortality
 

jondu003 said:

Dislikes:

3. Deep

10. Porch

pjhawks said:

Dislikes:

Tremor Christ
 

While I realize it's all subjective, the above dislikes are astoundingly perplexing to me.

The world would be boring if everyone liked and disliked the same. 

The world would be better off if everyone had Dirty Frank on their dislike list. 

pymusy

And since I feel like a traitor for leaving these off, some honorable mentions:
Rats
Go
Animal
Indifference 
Faithfull
In Hiding
Grievance
You Are
SOLAT
Hard to imagine 
Alone