Song Survival - Ten Era "Extras"

JPPJ84

5 Breath -
4 State of Love and Trust -
11 - Wash 
7 Footsteps +

tbergs

Must. Save. Footsteps.

4 Breath -
4 State of Love and Trust
10 - Wash -
8 Footsteps +

rummy

RiotZact said:

So I’m not protesting it’s inclusion in this round or anything, I’m just curious if there’s something I don’t know about the history of the song. But shouldn’t Hold On have been in the next round? It was first performed in 94 and they included the acoustic demo of it on the Vs. reissue. Is there some record of it existing in the Ten era?

Great question/comment and, yes, there's a good argument for having "Hold On" in the next round. However, multiple sources listed it as being a Ten outtake so I listed it here.

I gotta admit, I maybe should have extended this rounds song list to include Angel and HTI (and maybe Bee Girl and Cready Stomp, as well). All will be part of the second set of "extras," of course.

runbirduk

5 - Breath -
6- State of Love and Trust +
10 - Wash -
6 - Footsteps

vito

4 Breath 
3 State of Love and Trust -
11 - Wash +
7 Footsteps -

vito

runbirduk said:

5 - Breath -
6- State of Love and Trust +
10 - Wash -
6 - Footsteps

You need to edit and then I will

vito

Runbirduk is way off

RiotZact

rummy said:

RiotZact said:

So I’m not protesting it’s inclusion in this round or anything, I’m just curious if there’s something I don’t know about the history of the song. But shouldn’t Hold On have been in the next round? It was first performed in 94 and they included the acoustic demo of it on the Vs. reissue. Is there some record of it existing in the Ten era?

Great question/comment and, yes, there's a good argument for having "Hold On" in the next round. However, multiple sources listed it as being a Ten outtake so I listed it here.

I gotta admit, I maybe should have extended this rounds song list to include Angel and HTI (and maybe Bee Girl and Cready Stomp, as well). All will be part of the second set of "extras," of course.

Good call, I just checked the liner notes of Lost Dogs and it says Ten. Ed says that it almost made Vs. My best guess would be they toyed around with it early on but there was so much amazing other stuff that it got ignored. Then probably revisited/reworked once they started Vs. Would love to know the full history if anyone knows it. One of my favorite songs and easily one of the most underplayed in their catalogue.

vito

This is what his should've been
3 - Breath -
5- State of Love and Trust +
9 - Wash -
8 - Footsteps

vito

This is mine
3 Breath 
4 State of Love and Trust -
10 - Wash +
7 Footsteps -
All good!

Spiritual_Chaos

There is somethi g off on the last page, a breath point disapeared after my post

vito

Spiritual_Chaos said:

There is somethi g off on the last page, a breath point disapeared after my post

JJFLASH TOOK AWAY 1 POINT WHEN HE SHOULDN'T HAVE, I WILL ADD IT

vito

THIS IS CORRECT!

4 Breath 
4 State of Love and Trust -
10 - Wash +
7 Footsteps -

JPPJ84

Stop shouting!

vito

JPPJ84 said:

Stop shouting!

yes maam

JPPJ84

vito said:

JPPJ84 said:

Stop shouting!

yes maam

 

Spiritual_Chaos

vito said:

Spiritual_Chaos said:

There is somethi g off on the last page, a breath point disapeared after my post

JJFLASH TOOK AWAY 1 POINT WHEN HE SHOULDN'T HAVE, I WILL ADD IT

CPR7

5 Breath +
4 State of Love and Trust 
9 - Wash -
6 Footsteps -

ChadsStillAlive

6 Breath +
3 State of Love and Trust -
8 - Wash -
6 Footsteps

vito

JPPJ84 said:

Stop shouting!

OR I'M ITALIAN I CAN'T HELP IT