Song Survival - Ten Era "Extras"

rummy

Final Results
1. Footsteps 
2. Wash
3. Breath
4. State of Love and Trust
5. Yellow Ledbetter
6. Hold On
7. Alone
8. Brother 
9. Just A Girl
10. Let Me Sleep
11. Master/Slave
12. Dirty Frank
13. 2000 Mile Blues
14. Evil Little Goat

Previous Results
Ten: https://community.pearljam.com/discussion/285541/song-survival-ten/p1?new=1
Vs: https://community.pearljam.com/discussion/285556/song-survival-vs/p1?new=1
Vitalogy: https://community.pearljam.com/discussion/285575/song-survival-vitalogy/p1?new=1
No Code: https://community.pearljam.com/discussion/285589/song-survival-no-code/p1
Yield: https://community.pearljam.com/discussion/285602/song-survival-yield/p1
Binaural: https://community.pearljam.com/discussion/285614/song-survival-binaural/p1
Riot Act: https://community.pearljam.com/discussion/285631/song-survival-riot-act/p1
Pearl Jam: https://community.pearljam.com/discussion/285635/song-survival-pearl-jam/p1
Backspacer: https://community.pearljam.com/discussion/285657/song-survival-backspacer/p1?new=1
Lightning Bolt: https://community.pearljam.com/discussion/285671/song-survival-lightning-bolt/p1

General Rules (please abide)
1. You have to deduct two points and add one point. 
2. Only one point may be deducted per song.
3. Please wait at least 30 minutes between each of your own votes.
4. Keeping rule #3 in mind, you may vote again either after six other users have voted or six hours have passed - whichever comes first.
5. Please "double check" after you post and ensure that someone else hasn't posted at the same time. It helps with keeping track of the scores.
6. Please only eliminate one song per post (e.g., if two songs are down to one point each, don't eliminate them both). This will help with final rankings.
7. Once the number of songs is down to two, just subtract one point from one song.
8. The last song remaining wins!

Group – Ten Era "Extras" (1991-1992)
(# points - song title)
10 – Breath
10 – State of Love and Trust
10 – Wash
10 – Dirty Frank
10 – Footsteps
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On
10 – Brother
10 – Just A Girl
10 – Evil Little Goat
10 – 2000 Mile Blues
10 – Let Me Sleep
10 – Master/Slave*

* Since "Hummus" was included in the Yield round, I then felt that I maybe should have included this piece of music in the Ten round. We'll give it a chance here. Disagree? Well then just vote it off! :-)

rummy

I hope the fans of the Lost Dogs compilation won’t be too upset with me as there will be no “Song Survival” rounds for this release. Keep in mind that we will acknowledge most of the songs on Lost Dogs but, as an alternative, I’m grouping the songs chronologically. Within each grouping, I’ll also include essential non-album tracks found on soundtracks, EP’s, reissues, and Christmas singles.

The songs will be separated into three groups as follows:

Group 1: Ten Era (1991-1992) Non-Album Tracks

Group 2: Vs-Yield Eras (1993-1998) Non-Album Tracks

Group 3: Binaural Era and Beyond (1999-present) Non-Album Tracks

Admittedly, some arguments can be made about which era a particular song belongs. For example, both “Alone” and “Hold On” have a connection to both Group 1 and Group 2 but I put them in the former as multiple sources list them as Ten outtakes. Admittedly, placing these two songs in Group 1 also helps “balance” out the three groups.

Keep in mind, there are A LOT of non-album tracks associated with Pearl Jam so I did my best to streamline things.

For a song to be eligible for one of the three groups listed above, it has to meet the following requirements:

1. It must be a PJ original – no covers. Therefore, songs like “Last Kiss” and “Crazy Mary” will not be included.

2. It must be a “Pearl Jam” song according to pearljam.com – no collaborations or solo work. Therefore, songs like “Hunger Strike,” “Real Thing,” and “Setting Forth” will not be included.

3. It must be included in the in the Songs list at pearljam.com. Therefore, demos like “Cold Concession” and “Let it Ride” will not be included since they aren’t listed.

4. It must be an “official release” according to the Songs list at pearljam.com. Therefore, songs like “F**k Me in The Brain” and “Sick o’ Pussies” will not be included. I might make an exception to this, mind you, in Group 3.

Hopefully I won’t make any major errors or omissions over the next three rounds.  Admittedly, I did quite a bit of “fact checking” before I organized these three groups but there is still a chance I didn’t get it quite right. It happens.

 

Enjoy!

 

rummy

Gigaton on Thursday.

vito

Ok well a song like Hard To Imagine goes all the way back to 91-92 but, didn't get released to 98' so is this not getting a listing cause this is a seminal song that has to be available to vote on.

vito

(# points - song title)
10 – Breath
10 – State of Love and Trust
11 – Wash +
9.  – Dirty Frank -
10 – Footsteps
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On
10 – Brother
10   – Just A Girl 
9   – Evil Little Goat -
10 – 2000 Mile Blues
10 – Let Me Sleep
10 – Master/Slave*

rummy

vito said:

Ok well a song like Hard To Imagine goes all the way back to 91-92 but, didn't get released to 98' so is this not getting a listing cause this is a seminal song that has to be available to vote on.

Yeah. Difficult to draw lines. Both HTI and Angel were considered for this category. They are both in the next one.

vito

rummy said:

vito said:

Ok well a song like Hard To Imagine goes all the way back to 91-92 but, didn't get released to 98' so is this not getting a listing cause this is a seminal song that has to be available to vote on.

Yeah. Difficult to draw lines. Both HTI and Angel were considered for this category. They are both in the next one.

Ok

tino_11

11 – Breath +
10 – State of Love and Trust
11 – Wash 
9.  – Dirty Frank 
10 – Footsteps
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On
10 – Brother
10   – Just A Girl 
8  – Evil Little Goat -
9 – 2000 Mile Blues -
10 – Let Me Sleep
10 – Master/Slave*

JPPJ84

11 – Breath
10 – State of Love and Trust
11 Wash 
8 – Dirty Frank -
11 – Footsteps +
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On
10 – Brother
10   – Just A Girl 
7 – Evil Little Goat -
9 2000 Mile Blues
10 – Let Me Sleep
10 – Master/Slave

petted101

11 – Breath
11 – State of Love and Trust +
11 Wash 
9 – Dirty Frank -
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On
10 – Brother
10   – Just A Girl 
6 – Evil Little Goat -
9 2000 Mile Blues
10 – Let Me Sleep
10 – Master/Slave

This is a very strong list making it a harder choice than some of the albums. Gone with State of Love and Trust as the original kicks ass (recent live attempts are very questionable).

vito

petted101 said:

11 – Breath
11 – State of Love and Trust +
11 Wash 
9 – Dirty Frank -
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On
10 – Brother
10   – Just A Girl 
6 – Evil Little Goat -
9 2000 Mile Blues
10 – Let Me Sleep
10 – Master/Slave

This is a very strong list making it a harder choice than some of the albums. Gone with State of Love and Trust as the original kicks ass (recent live attempts are very questionable).

Edit you added on Dirty Frank instead of taking away 

Pap

11 – Breath
11 – State of Love and Trust
11 Wash 
8 – Dirty Frank (+)
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On
10 – Brother
10   – Just A Girl 
5 – Evil Little Goat (-)
9 2000 Mile Blues
10 – Let Me Sleep
9 – Master/Slave (-)

petted101

vito said:

petted101 said:

11 – Breath
11 – State of Love and Trust +
11 Wash 
9 – Dirty Frank -
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On
10 – Brother
10   – Just A Girl 
6 – Evil Little Goat -
9 2000 Mile Blues
10 – Let Me Sleep
10 – Master/Slave

This is a very strong list making it a harder choice than some of the albums. Gone with State of Love and Trust as the original kicks ass (recent live attempts are very questionable).

Edit you added on Dirty Frank instead of taking away 

Apologies. Thanks for fixing.

Spiritual_Chaos

11 – Breath
11 – State of Love and Trust
10 Wash -
8 – Dirty Frank 
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
11 – Hold On +
10 – Brother
10   – Just A Girl 
4 – Evil Little Goat (-)
9 2000 Mile Blues
10 – Let Me Sleep
9 – Master/Slave 

PJNB

11 – Breath
11 – State of Love and Trust
11 Wash +
8 – Dirty Frank 
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
11 – Hold On
10 – Brother
10   – Just A Girl 
3 – Evil Little Goat (-)
8 - 2000 Mile Blues (-)
10 – Let Me Sleep
9 – Master/Slave 

ChadsStillAlive

12 – Breath +
11 – State of Love and Trust
11 Wash
8 – Dirty Frank 
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
11 – Hold On
10 – Brother
10   – Just A Girl 
2 – Evil Little Goat (-)
7 - 2000 Mile Blues (-)
10 – Let Me Sleep
9 – Master/Slave 

NewfieintheUSA

12 – Breath 
11 – State of Love and Trust
11 Wash
8 – Dirty Frank 
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On -
10 – Brother
11  – Just A Girl +
2 – Evil Little Goat 
7 - 2000 Mile Blues 
9 – Let Me Sleep -
9 – Master/Slave 

NewfieintheUSA

This is going to be super tough, so many great  songs and favorites of mine on this list.

JPPJ84

12 – Breath 
11 – State of Love and Trust
12 Wash +
7 Dirty Frank -
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On 
10 – Brother
11  – Just A Girl 
1 – Evil Little Goat -
7 - 2000 Mile Blues 
9 – Let Me Sleep 
9 – Master/Slave 

PJNB

NewfieintheUSA said:

This is going to be super tough, so many great  songs and favorites of mine on this list.

Ya this is going to be nuts having to decide when this gets down to 5 left. So many deserve the top spot. 

Spiritual_Chaos

I SUGGEST YOU STEP OUT ON YOUR PORCH
YEEAA-AAH. MMHEEEEEH

https://youtu.be/Nq97jqVnOsA

stuckinline

12 – Breath 
11 – State of Love and Trust
12 Wash 
6 Dirty Frank (-)
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On 
10 – Brother
12  – Just A Girl (+)
0 – Evil Little Goat (-)
7 - 2000 Mile Blues 
9 – Let Me Sleep 
9 – Master/Slave 

D-Rod

12 – Breath 
12 State of Love and Trust + 
12 Wash 
5 Dirty Frank (-)
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On 
10 – Brother
12  – Just A Girl 
0 – Evil Little Goat 
6 - 2000 Mile Blues  -
9 – Let Me Sleep 
9 – Master/Slave 

Spiritual_Chaos

13 – Breath +
12 State of Love and Trust 
11 Wash -
5 Dirty Frank
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On 
10 – Brother
12  – Just A Girl 
5 - 2000 Mile Blues -
9 – Let Me Sleep 
9 – Master/Slave 

GONE:

ELG

JPPJ84

What’s wrong with Wash?! I mean really, with all these songs left, this is what you deduct from?!   

Spiritual_Chaos

JPPJ84 said:

What’s wrong with Wash?! I mean really, with all these songs left, this is what you deduct from?!   

It's good.

But definitely the least great song on the album Ten.

CPR7

14 – Breath +
12 State of Love and Trust 
11 Wash 
4 - Dirty Frank -
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On 
10 – Brother
12  – Just A Girl 
4 - 2000 Mile Blues -
9 – Let Me Sleep 
9 – Master/Slave 

GONE:

ELG

nicknyr15

15 – Breath +
12 State of Love and Trust 
11 Wash 
4 - Dirty Frank 
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On 
10 – Brother
12  – Just A Girl 
3-2000 Mile Blues -
8– Let Me Sleep -
9 – Master/Slave 

GONE:

ELG

Pap

15 – Breath
12 State of Love and Trust 
11 Wash 
4 - Dirty Frank 
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On 
10 – Brother
12  – Just A Girl 
4 - 2000 Mile Blues (+)
7 – Let Me Sleep (-)
8 – Master/Slave (-)

GONE:

ELG

ChadsStillAlive

15 – Breath 
12 State of Love and Trust 
12 Wash +
4 - Dirty Frank 
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
10 – Alone
10 – Hold On 
10 – Brother
12  – Just A Girl 
3 - 2000 Mile Blues -
7 – Let Me Sleep
7 – Master/Slave -

GONE:

ELG

Gern Blansten

15 – Breath 
12 State of Love and Trust 
12 Wash
4 - Dirty Frank 
11 – Footsteps 
10 – Yellow Ledbetter
11 – Alone +
10 – Hold On 
10 – Brother
11  – Just A Girl -
2 - 2000 Mile Blues -
7 – Let Me Sleep
7 – Master/Slave