Home› The Porch

Song Survival - Vitalogy

1…457910…12

Comments

  • JV267526JV267526 Posts: 203
    edited April 2020
    6 - Last Exit -
    0 - Spin The Black Circle -
    10 - Not For You
    2 - Tremor Christ 
    4 - Nothingman 
    16 - Corduroy +
    15 - Immortality

    Eliminated
    7. Spin the Black Circle
    8. Better Man
    9. Satan's Bed
    10. Whipping
    11. Bugs
    12. Aye Davanita
    13. Pry, To
    14. Stupid Mop
    Post edited by JV267526 on
  • JPPJ84JPPJ84 Hamburg, Germany Posts: 3,464
    ^^ that doesn’t look right?! 
  • JV267526JV267526 Posts: 203
    fixing mine 1 sec
  • mcgruff10mcgruff10 New Jersey Posts: 28,737
    JV267526 said:
    It is crazy, but with the exception of Better Man, imo every song on Gigaton is better than what has been eliminated on Vitalogy so far. I can't find myself ranking any song Gigaton below any of 9-14. We lucked out with this new album.
    I think I agree with you. 
    I'll ride the wave where it takes me......
  • FiveBelowFiveBelow Posts: 1,308
    Nothingman almost has nothing left to subtract.

  • JV267526JV267526 Posts: 203
    edited April 2020
    It is now fixed above. Did mine at the same time as two others which messed it up. But it is all good now.
  • FiveBelowFiveBelow Posts: 1,308
    6 - Last Exit 
    9 - Not For You (-)
    2 - Tremor Christ 
    3 - Nothingman (-)
    16 - Corduroy 
    16 - Immortality (+)

    Eliminated
    7. Spin the Black Circle
    8. Better Man
    9. Satan's Bed
    10. Whipping
    11. Bugs
    12. Aye Davanita
    13. Pry, To
    14. Stupid Mop
  • Sobelberg8Sobelberg8 Posts: 984
    6 - Last Exit 
    9 - Not For You 
    3 - Tremor Christ (+)
    2 - Nothingman (-)
    16 - Corduroy 
    15 - Immortality (-)

    Eliminated
    7. Spin the Black Circle
    8. Better Man
    9. Satan's Bed
    10. Whipping
    11. Bugs
    12. Aye Davanita
    13. Pry, To
    14. Stupid Mop
    Hi, I host a Pearl Jam Podcast. We go back to some of the classic shows in their history and break down the entire setlist front to back. From historic perspective, to performances, to setlist construction, to fan stories. We do our best to capture the magic that is their live act and help you relive those memories, or if you weren't there, maybe turn you on to a show you've never heard before.

    Live On 4 Legs can be found on Apple Podcast, Spotify and any other major podcast platform. But please support our website and check out the episodes archived there. Oh, and the Concertpedia as well (for you Five Horizons and Two Feet Thick fans, we've picked up where they've left off)

    http://liveon4legs.com
  • Jules WinnfieldJules Winnfield Posts: 64
    mcgruff10 said:
    JV267526 said:
    It is crazy, but with the exception of Better Man, imo every song on Gigaton is better than what has been eliminated on Vitalogy so far. I can't find myself ranking any song Gigaton below any of 9-14. We lucked out with this new album.
    I think I agree with you. 
    I kind of agree also, but can you rank any song on Gigaton ahead of the 6 remaining songs on Vitalogy? I don’t think I can at this point.
  • Abe FromanAbe Froman Posts: 5,319
    6 - Last Exit 
    10 - Not For You (+)
    3 - Tremor Christ
    1 - Nothingman (-)
    16 - Corduroy 
    14 - Immortality (-)

    Eliminated
    7. Spin the Black Circle
    8. Better Man
    9. Satan's Bed
    10. Whipping
    11. Bugs
    12. Aye Davanita
    13. Pry, To
    14. Stupid Mop
  • mcgruff10mcgruff10 New Jersey Posts: 28,737
    Jules Winnfield said:
    mcgruff10 said:
    JV267526 said:
    It is crazy, but with the exception of Better Man, imo every song on Gigaton is better than what has been eliminated on Vitalogy so far. I can't find myself ranking any song Gigaton below any of 9-14. We lucked out with this new album.
    I think I agree with you. 
    I kind of agree also, but can you rank any song on Gigaton ahead of the 6 remaining songs on Vitalogy? I don’t think I can at this point.
    To me nothingman is nothing special.  Just a slow song that could be on any album.  

    I'll ride the wave where it takes me......
  • Abe FromanAbe Froman Posts: 5,319
    edited April 2020
    mcgruff10 said:
    Jules Winnfield said:
    mcgruff10 said:
    JV267526 said:
    It is crazy, but with the exception of Better Man, imo every song on Gigaton is better than what has been eliminated on Vitalogy so far. I can't find myself ranking any song Gigaton below any of 9-14. We lucked out with this new album.
    I think I agree with you. 
    I kind of agree also, but can you rank any song on Gigaton ahead of the 6 remaining songs on Vitalogy? I don’t think I can at this point.
    To me nothingman is nothing special.  Just a slow song that could be on any album.  

    Agreed. Plus I think I might like Quick Escape more than a couple of these remaining six. 
  • Jules WinnfieldJules Winnfield Posts: 64
    6 - Last Exit 
    9 - Not For You (-) 
    2 - Tremor Christ (-)
    2 - Nothingman (+)
    16 - Corduroy
    14 - Immortality

    Eliminated
    7. Spin the Black Circle
    8. Better Man
    9. Satan's Bed
    10. Whipping
    11. Bugs
    12. Aye Davanita
    13. Pry, To
    14. Stupid Mop

    Not ready to let go of Nothingman
  • JV267526JV267526 Posts: 203
    edited April 2020
    Imo, I think you could rank all of Seven O'Clock, DOTC, Who Ever Said, Quick Escape an Retrograde ahead of Tremor Christ, Nothingman and Last Exit.
    Post edited by JV267526 on
  • PJNBPJNB Posts: 13,595
    6 - Last Exit 
    9 - Not For You 
    1 - Tremor Christ (-)
    1 - Nothingman (-) 
    16 - Corduroy
    15 - Immortality (+)

    Eliminated
    7. Spin the Black Circle
    8. Better Man
    9. Satan's Bed
    10. Whipping
    11. Bugs
    12. Aye Davanita
    13. Pry, To
    14. Stupid Mop
  • RE658041RE658041 Sweden Posts: 410
    6 - Last Exit 
    9 - Not For You 
    0 - Tremor Christ (-)
    2 - Nothingman (+) 
    16 - Corduroy
    14 - Immortality (-)

    Eliminated
    6. Tremor Christ
    7. Spin the Black Circle
    8. Better Man
    9. Satan's Bed
    10. Whipping
    11. Bugs
    12. Aye Davanita
    13. Pry, To
    14. Stupid Mop
  • Glorified KCGlorified KC KCMO Native Posts: 2,759
    5 - Last Exit (-)
    9 - Not For You 
    2 - Tremor Christ (+) 
    16 - Corduroy
    15 - Immortality

    Eliminated
    6. Nothingman
    7. Spin the Black Circle
    8. Better Man
    9. Satan's Bed
    10. Whipping
    11. Bugs
    12. Aye Davanita
    13. Pry, To
    14. Stupid Mop
    I wish I was a sacrifice, but somehow still lived on.
  • JPPJ84JPPJ84 Hamburg, Germany Posts: 3,464
    edited April 2020
    5 - Last Exit 
    8 Not For You -
    2 - Nothingman (+)
    15 - Corduroy -
    15 - Immortality

    Eliminated
    6. Tremor Christ
    7. Spin the Black Circle
    8. Better Man
    9. Satan's Bed
    10. Whipping
    11. Bugs
    12. Aye Davanita
    13. Pry, To
    14. Stupid Mop
    Post edited by JPPJ84 on
  • JPPJ84JPPJ84 Hamburg, Germany Posts: 3,464
    Uh oh! Stop, we need to fix here
  • JPPJ84JPPJ84 Hamburg, Germany Posts: 3,464
    edited April 2020
    @cdthomas1981 , your Nothingman vote puts it at 1, mine back to 2
    and Tremor Christ is gone so you get a new + vote
    Post edited by JPPJ84 on
  • JV267526JV267526 Posts: 203
    edited April 2020
    last exit should be at 5 as well and tremor christ is eliminated
    Post edited by JV267526 on
  • JV267526JV267526 Posts: 203
    Just about to vote and will fix it.
  • JPPJ84JPPJ84 Hamburg, Germany Posts: 3,464
    edited April 2020
    JV267526 said:
    last exit should be at 5 as well and tremor christ at 2
    Re65... voted Tremor Christ off though (not that I‘m happy about it)
  • JV267526JV267526 Posts: 203
    4 - Last Exit (-)
    7 -Not For You (-)
    2 - Nothingman
    16 - Corduroy (+)
    15 - Immortality

    Eliminated
    6. Tremor Christ
    7. Spin the Black Circle
    8. Better Man
    9. Satan's Bed
    10. Whipping
    11. Bugs
    12. Aye Davanita
    13. Pry, To
    14. Stupid Mop
  • JV267526JV267526 Posts: 203
    Thanks for fixing it JPPJ84
  • Abe FromanAbe Froman Posts: 5,319
    4 - Last Exit
    8 -Not For You (+)
    1 - Nothingman (-)
    16 - Corduroy 
    14 - Immortality (-)

    Eliminated
    6. Tremor Christ
    7. Spin the Black Circle
    8. Better Man
    9. Satan's Bed
    10. Whipping
    11. Bugs
    12. Aye Davanita
    13. Pry, To
    14. Stupid Mop
  • rummyrummy British Columbia, Canada Posts: 4,458
    edited April 2020
    4 - Last Exit
    7 - Not For You (-)
    0 - Nothingman (-)
    16 - Corduroy 
    15 - Immortality (+)

    Eliminated
    5. Nothingman
    6. Tremor Christ
    7. Spin the Black Circle
    8. Better Man
    9. Satan's Bed
    10. Whipping
    11. Bugs
    12. Aye Davanita
    13. Pry, To
    14. Stupid Mop
    Post edited by rummy on
  • rummyrummy British Columbia, Canada Posts: 4,458
    Aside from Better Man being too low, this outcome makes sense to me thus far.
  • JPPJ84JPPJ84 Hamburg, Germany Posts: 3,464
    rummy said:
    Aside from Better Man being too low, this outcome makes sense to me thus far.
    Yeah what’s up with that?
  • JV267526JV267526 Posts: 203
    edited April 2020
    JPPJ84 said:
    rummy said:
    Aside from Better Man being too low, this outcome makes sense to me thus far.
    Yeah what’s up with that?
    Kept trying to vote it back up, but people kept voting it down.
Sign In or Register to comment.