Song Survival - Vitalogy

mcgruff10

RE658041 said:

Sorry.

All good.  I messed up about a dozen times lol. 

PJNB

RE658041 said:

Sorry.

We are good your vote counted. I tagged you with the correction. You can edit yours back now if you want and Abe is back on track.

vito

6 - Corduroy -

10 - Immortality 

mcgruff10

Studio this is a tough call.  Live....corduroy has been lacking lately with that bridge.  I played the shit out of that studio version back in high school. Number 8 was my number 1!!

vito

mcgruff10 said:

Studio this is a tough call.  Live....corduroy has been lacking lately with that bridge.  I played the shit out of that studio version back in high school. Number 8 was my number 1!!

Yep 2 of my favorites live RVM and Corduroy have just not been the same lately.

mcgruff10

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

Studio this is a tough call.  Live....corduroy has been lacking lately with that bridge.  I played the shit out of that studio version back in high school. Number 8 was my number 1!!

Yep 2 of my favorites live RVM and Corduroy have just not been the same lately.

Agree.  Rvm was at its pinnancle during the 2006 tour imo.  
And I think you are voting too early.

vito

mcgruff10 said:

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

Studio this is a tough call.  Live....corduroy has been lacking lately with that bridge.  I played the shit out of that studio version back in high school. Number 8 was my number 1!!

Yep 2 of my favorites live RVM and Corduroy have just not been the same lately.

Agree.  Rvm was at its pinnancle during the 2006 tour imo.  
And I think you are voting too early.

Ooops, my bad but, it makes up for the 2 hours I fell asleep in the middle of this or this would've been over a long time ago!👍

PJNB

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

Studio this is a tough call.  Live....corduroy has been lacking lately with that bridge.  I played the shit out of that studio version back in high school. Number 8 was my number 1!!

Yep 2 of my favorites live RVM and Corduroy have just not been the same lately.

Agree.  Rvm was at its pinnancle during the 2006 tour imo.  
And I think you are voting too early.

Ooops, my bad but, it makes up for the 2 hours I fell asleep in the middle of this or this would've been over s long time ago!👍

All good! If it comes to your vote again just wait until its 8 turns and it should be evened out. 

mcgruff10

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

Studio this is a tough call.  Live....corduroy has been lacking lately with that bridge.  I played the shit out of that studio version back in high school. Number 8 was my number 1!!

Yep 2 of my favorites live RVM and Corduroy have just not been the same lately.

Agree.  Rvm was at its pinnancle during the 2006 tour imo.  
And I think you are voting too early.

Ooops, my bad but, it makes up for the 2 hours I fell asleep in the middle of this or this would've been over a long time ago!👍

Lol.  All good. No code is gonna be fun. 

tbergs

Vacate is the word...

5 - Corduroy -

10 - Immortality

PJNB

4 - Corduroy -

10 - Immortality

vito

mcgruff10 said:

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

Studio this is a tough call.  Live....corduroy has been lacking lately with that bridge.  I played the shit out of that studio version back in high school. Number 8 was my number 1!!

Yep 2 of my favorites live RVM and Corduroy have just not been the same lately.

Agree.  Rvm was at its pinnancle during the 2006 tour imo.  
And I think you are voting too early.

Ooops, my bad but, it makes up for the 2 hours I fell asleep in the middle of this or this would've been over a long time ago!👍

Lol.  All good. No code is gonna be fun. 

Absolutely I'm gonna say Present Tense in a long, long thread.

PJNB

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

Studio this is a tough call.  Live....corduroy has been lacking lately with that bridge.  I played the shit out of that studio version back in high school. Number 8 was my number 1!!

Yep 2 of my favorites live RVM and Corduroy have just not been the same lately.

Agree.  Rvm was at its pinnancle during the 2006 tour imo.  
And I think you are voting too early.

Ooops, my bad but, it makes up for the 2 hours I fell asleep in the middle of this or this would've been over a long time ago!👍

Lol.  All good. No code is gonna be fun. 

Absolutely I'm gonna say Present Tense in a long, long thread.

You and I have some very similar taste. 

mcgruff10

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

Studio this is a tough call.  Live....corduroy has been lacking lately with that bridge.  I played the shit out of that studio version back in high school. Number 8 was my number 1!!

Yep 2 of my favorites live RVM and Corduroy have just not been the same lately.

Agree.  Rvm was at its pinnancle during the 2006 tour imo.  
And I think you are voting too early.

Ooops, my bad but, it makes up for the 2 hours I fell asleep in the middle of this or this would've been over a long time ago!👍

Lol.  All good. No code is gonna be fun. 

Absolutely I'm gonna say Present Tense in a long, long thread.

Agree. Killer song live.  

tbergs

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

Studio this is a tough call.  Live....corduroy has been lacking lately with that bridge.  I played the shit out of that studio version back in high school. Number 8 was my number 1!!

Yep 2 of my favorites live RVM and Corduroy have just not been the same lately.

Agree.  Rvm was at its pinnancle during the 2006 tour imo.  
And I think you are voting too early.

Ooops, my bad but, it makes up for the 2 hours I fell asleep in the middle of this or this would've been over a long time ago!👍

Lol.  All good. No code is gonna be fun. 

Absolutely I'm gonna say Present Tense in a long, long thread.

I will be putting a plus by Present Tense every time I vote.

vito

Release, Indifference,  Immortality, Present Tense...nobody does this type of song better than PJ and yet, their all very different if that makes any sense. Slow building that just crushes your emotions. And that's just 1 song from the first 4 albums, many more in the catalog that fit this narrative. 

mcgruff10

tbergs said:

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

vito said:

mcgruff10 said:

Studio this is a tough call.  Live....corduroy has been lacking lately with that bridge.  I played the shit out of that studio version back in high school. Number 8 was my number 1!!

Yep 2 of my favorites live RVM and Corduroy have just not been the same lately.

Agree.  Rvm was at its pinnancle during the 2006 tour imo.  
And I think you are voting too early.

Ooops, my bad but, it makes up for the 2 hours I fell asleep in the middle of this or this would've been over a long time ago!👍

Lol.  All good. No code is gonna be fun. 

Absolutely I'm gonna say Present Tense in a long, long thread.

I will be putting a plus by Present Tense every time I vote.

The first time I saw them live They played present tense in the second encore.  I would love for them to put that song back in that spot.  

PJNB

vito said:

Release, Indifference,  Immortality, Present Tense...nobody does this type of song better than PJ and yet, their all very different if that makes any sense. Slow building that just crushes your emotions. And that's just 1 song from the first 4 albums.

I would add Parting Ways and Inside Job for me as well for that style. No wheres near the level of those 4 but still amazing songs. Then if we include Lost Dogs holy shit!

mcgruff10

PJNB said:

vito said:

Release, Indifference,  Immortality, Present Tense...nobody does this type of song better than PJ and yet, their all very different if that makes any sense. Slow building that just crushes your emotions. And that's just 1 song from the first 4 albums.

I would add Parting Ways and Inside Job for me as well for that style. No wheres near the level of those 4 but still amazing songs. Then if we include Lost Dogs holy shit!

Parting ways definitely. I feel like retrograde could be that same type of song live.  Add hti and long road to that list.  Never got into inside job, not my cup of tea. 

vito

PJNB said:

vito said:

Release, Indifference,  Immortality, Present Tense...nobody does this type of song better than PJ and yet, their all very different if that makes any sense. Slow building that just crushes your emotions. And that's just 1 song from the first 4 albums.

I would add Parting Ways and Inside Job for me as well for that style. No wheres near the level of those 4 but still amazing songs. Then if we include Lost Dogs holy shit!

We certainly do have similar taste cause Parting Ways is in my top 5 songs. It's almost criminal how few times it's been played live.

D-Rod

Are we still voting ?  If so 

5 - Corduroy 

9- Immortality -

rummy

Hahahahaha!!!!

rummy

Just got back from a walk. We live on a relatively remote area.

rummy

4 - Corduroy -

9- Immortality 

mcgruff10

4 - corduroy -
9 - immortality 

rummy

I actually think Corduroy should be down to 2.

Edit: Yup.
2 - Corduroy 
9 - Immortality 

vito

rummy said:

I actually think Corduroy should be down to 2.

2 or 3?

tbergs

vito said:

rummy said:

I actually think Corduroy should be down to 2.

2 or 3?

3

rummy

vito said:

rummy said:

I actually think Corduroy should be down to 2.

2 or 3?

2. If you go back a bit you’ll see that D-Rod (sorry) put it back up to 5.

PJNB

rummy said:

I actually think Corduroy should be down to 2.

Edit: Yup.
2 - Corduroy 
9 - Immortality 

correct I had it at 4 then it moved back up to 5 by accident I think.