RIP Neil Peart

24

Comments

  • PeterED
    PeterED Posts: 375
    RF283499 said:
    You have to figure Pearl Jam are Rush fans. 
    100%

    Geddy Lee was sitting on stage (with the sound guys) at one of the last PJ Toronto shows. And in a different Toronto show Eddie name-checked him in a Wishlist line.
    Barrie, Ontario (August 05, 1992); Toronto, Ontario (August 18, 1993); Toronto, Ontario (October 05, 2000); Buffalo, New York (May 02, 2003); Toronto, Ontario (May 09, 2006); Toronto, Ontario (May 10, 2006); Toronto, Ontario (August 21, 2009); Buffalo, New York (May 10, 2010); Toronto, Ontario (September 11, 2011); Toronto, Ontario (September 12, 2011); Toronto 1 (May 10, 2016); Toronto 2 (May 12, 2016); Ottawa (September 3, 2022); Hamilton (September 6, 2022); Toronto (September 8, 2022)
  • Lerxst1992
    Lerxst1992 Posts: 8,097
    1ThoughtKnown said:
    RF283499 said:
    You have to figure Pearl Jam are Rush fans. 
    Not too sure about that. I don’t think Rush was too influential on the Seattle music scene as they were a progressive rock act.  In fact, I remember and interview where Kim Thayil said Mark Arm called Soundgarden the “Rush of Seattle” at one time sarcastically as Arm was j own to do. Kind of a shot if you will. 
    Thayil said he responded “what? I don’t even have any of their records” and laughed. 

    I will say, even people who hate Rush will say they are amazing musicians.  I am a huge Rush fan and have 2112 on the turntable right now. RIP Neil. 

    I never thought I'd get news like this on the PJ forum.  

    Died Jan 7th Brain cancer. So sad. Life is a precious gift.

    This might explain why Ged n Alex have done nothing publicly in music together in past 5 years.
  • 1ThoughtKnown
    1ThoughtKnown Posts: 6,155
    edited January 2020
    ...
    Post edited by 1ThoughtKnown on
  • MonkeyDan72
    MonkeyDan72 Posts: 683

  • kaw753
    kaw753 Posts: 941
    1ThoughtKnown said:
    euchrid said:
    1ThoughtKnown said:
    RF283499 said:
    You have to figure Pearl Jam are Rush fans. 
    Not too sure about that. I don’t think Rush was too influential on the Seattle music scene as they were a progressive rock act.  In fact, I remember and interview where Kim Thayil said Mark Arm called Soundgarden the “Rush of Seattle” at one time sarcastically as Arm was j own to do. Kind of a shot if you will. 
    Thayil said he responded “what? I don’t even have any of their records” and laughed. 

    I will say, even people who hate Rush will say they are amazing musicians.  I am a huge Rush fan and have 2112 on the turntable right now. RIP Neil. 
    Geddy Lee was sitting side stage at last Toronto show and https://www.instagram.com/p/B5lpzigpWK8/
    Respecting a fellow musician and being a fan/influence are two different things. All I’m saying. 
    You don’t hear Rush being played on Sirius as an influence but the Stones, Neil Young, Beatles, Zeppelin, the Who, etc. are played constantly.  

    If they are fans, I will happily stand corrected. 🤙.  The early 90s alternative scene was all railing against the “pretentious” rockers with the huge drum sets and wild stage shows... 
    I saw Gene Simmons sitting in the close in 100 level section during the last LA show at the old Sports Arena.
  • boobooliscious
    boobooliscious Hebron, KY Posts: 263
    I'm crushed.
  • RF283499
    RF283499 Posts: 142
    Vedd Hedd said:
    Image result for eddie vedder and rush
    I forgot about that and I was there. Little stoned I suppose. Ed mentioned him, maybe more than once during the show. Didn't somebody play a few bars of a Rush song too??
  • RF283499
    RF283499 Posts: 142
    1ThoughtKnown said:
    euchrid said:
    1ThoughtKnown said:
    RF283499 said:
    You have to figure Pearl Jam are Rush fans. 
    Not too sure about that. I don’t think Rush was too influential on the Seattle music scene as they were a progressive rock act.  In fact, I remember and interview where Kim Thayil said Mark Arm called Soundgarden the “Rush of Seattle” at one time sarcastically as Arm was j own to do. Kind of a shot if you will. 
    Thayil said he responded “what? I don’t even have any of their records” and laughed. 

    I will say, even people who hate Rush will say they are amazing musicians.  I am a huge Rush fan and have 2112 on the turntable right now. RIP Neil. 
    Geddy Lee was sitting side stage at last Toronto show and https://www.instagram.com/p/B5lpzigpWK8/
    Respecting a fellow musician and being a fan/influence are two different things. All I’m saying. 
    You don’t hear Rush being played on Sirius as an influence but the Stones, Neil Young, Beatles, Zeppelin, the Who, etc. are played constantly.  

    If they are fans, I will happily stand corrected. 🤙.  The early 90s alternative scene was all railing against the “pretentious” rockers with the huge drum sets and wild stage shows... 
    Wild stage shows, like using the lighting rig as a monkey bar set? ;-)
  • jefft
    jefft Posts: 678
    Rip Neil.... really sad news
  • link93
    link93 Posts: 414
    Rush had nothing to do with the 80's and 90's big hair bands. Actually many artists talk about being influenced by Rush. Love both bands.
  • euchrid
    euchrid Posts: 895
    RF283499 said:
    Vedd Hedd said:
    Image result for eddie vedder and rush
    I forgot about that and I was there. Little stoned I suppose. Ed mentioned him, maybe more than once during the show. Didn't somebody play a few bars of a Rush song too??
    Yep they tried to :) .. but just acknowledged him and that was it.


  • F Me In The Brain
    F Me In The Brain this knows everybody from other commets Posts: 31,882
    ski-bum said:
    One of the best diners that ever lived. 

    Indeed.
    He was also one of the best drummers.

    Damn.  Wasn't my favorite band but I loved watching him drum.  Amazing kit!
    The love he receives is the love that is saved
  • pjl44
    pjl44 Posts: 10,586
    1ThoughtKnown said:
    euchrid said:
    1ThoughtKnown said:
    RF283499 said:
    You have to figure Pearl Jam are Rush fans. 
    Not too sure about that. I don’t think Rush was too influential on the Seattle music scene as they were a progressive rock act.  In fact, I remember and interview where Kim Thayil said Mark Arm called Soundgarden the “Rush of Seattle” at one time sarcastically as Arm was j own to do. Kind of a shot if you will. 
    Thayil said he responded “what? I don’t even have any of their records” and laughed. 

    I will say, even people who hate Rush will say they are amazing musicians.  I am a huge Rush fan and have 2112 on the turntable right now. RIP Neil. 
    Geddy Lee was sitting side stage at last Toronto show and https://www.instagram.com/p/B5lpzigpWK8/
    Respecting a fellow musician and being a fan/influence are two different things. All I’m saying. 
    You don’t hear Rush being played on Sirius as an influence but the Stones, Neil Young, Beatles, Zeppelin, the Who, etc. are played constantly.  

    If they are fans, I will happily stand corrected. 🤙.  The early 90s alternative scene was all railing against the “pretentious” rockers with the huge drum sets and wild stage shows... 
    Well we know they're fans of extremely understated performers such as KISS and The Who.
  • 1ThoughtKnown
    1ThoughtKnown Posts: 6,155
    edited January 2020
    ...
    Post edited by 1ThoughtKnown on
  • 1ThoughtKnown
    1ThoughtKnown Posts: 6,155
    It appears he had the same brain cancer as Gord Downie. 
    Fuck Cancer 
  • RF283499
    RF283499 Posts: 142
    1ThoughtKnown said:
    RF283499 said:
    1ThoughtKnown said:
    euchrid said:
    1ThoughtKnown said:
    RF283499 said:
    You have to figure Pearl Jam are Rush fans. 
    Not too sure about that. I don’t think Rush was too influential on the Seattle music scene as they were a progressive rock act.  In fact, I remember and interview where Kim Thayil said Mark Arm called Soundgarden the “Rush of Seattle” at one time sarcastically as Arm was j own to do. Kind of a shot if you will. 
    Thayil said he responded “what? I don’t even have any of their records” and laughed. 

    I will say, even people who hate Rush will say they are amazing musicians.  I am a huge Rush fan and have 2112 on the turntable right now. RIP Neil. 
    Geddy Lee was sitting side stage at last Toronto show and https://www.instagram.com/p/B5lpzigpWK8/
    Respecting a fellow musician and being a fan/influence are two different things. All I’m saying. 
    You don’t hear Rush being played on Sirius as an influence but the Stones, Neil Young, Beatles, Zeppelin, the Who, etc. are played constantly.  

    If they are fans, I will happily stand corrected. 🤙.  The early 90s alternative scene was all railing against the “pretentious” rockers with the huge drum sets and wild stage shows... 
    Wild stage shows, like using the lighting rig as a monkey bar set? ;-)
    Lol. That was awesome. Unplanned shit. 
    The wild stage shows I meant were the pre-planned fire and explosions and monsters and all that shit. Some of it was great to me, but most of the alternative music scene wasn’t doing any of that.
    Now they are all just old rock bands so they respect each other as professionals. Just my opinion. 
    I get all that. I knew what you meant. I am cool with your opinion and I agree. The punk scene in 70s England was the same. They hated on Pink Floyd specifically.

    PJ has there own kind of bombastic rock thing going on too. They are performers as well as musicians. Its show business. 
     

  • pjhawks
    pjhawks Posts: 12,961
    RIP Neal.  One of the greatest.  
  • 1ThoughtKnown
    1ThoughtKnown Posts: 6,155
    edited January 2020
    ...
    Post edited by 1ThoughtKnown on
  • deadendp
    deadendp Northeast Ohio Posts: 10,434
    edited January 2020

    Post edited by deadendp on
    2014: Cincinnati
    2016: Lexington and Wrigley 1
  • RF283499
    RF283499 Posts: 142
    1ThoughtKnown said:
    pjl44 said:
    1ThoughtKnown said:
    euchrid said:
    1ThoughtKnown said:
    RF283499 said:
    You have to figure Pearl Jam are Rush fans. 
    Not too sure about that. I don’t think Rush was too influential on the Seattle music scene as they were a progressive rock act.  In fact, I remember and interview where Kim Thayil said Mark Arm called Soundgarden the “Rush of Seattle” at one time sarcastically as Arm was j own to do. Kind of a shot if you will. 
    Thayil said he responded “what? I don’t even have any of their records” and laughed. 

    I will say, even people who hate Rush will say they are amazing musicians.  I am a huge Rush fan and have 2112 on the turntable right now. RIP Neil. 
    Geddy Lee was sitting side stage at last Toronto show and https://www.instagram.com/p/B5lpzigpWK8/
    Respecting a fellow musician and being a fan/influence are two different things. All I’m saying. 
    You don’t hear Rush being played on Sirius as an influence but the Stones, Neil Young, Beatles, Zeppelin, the Who, etc. are played constantly.  

    If they are fans, I will happily stand corrected. 🤙.  The early 90s alternative scene was all railing against the “pretentious” rockers with the huge drum sets and wild stage shows... 
    Well we know they're fans of extremely understated performers such as KISS and The Who.
    Once again... I’m talking about the progressive rockers. Genesis, Yes, King Crimson.  They aren’t cited as influences by the band (at least not that I’ve ever heard).  90s alternative was a backlash against that and the 80s hair metal. 
    I remember,  I was in Grade 10 the first time I heard Janes Addiction, the Chilis, Dinosaur Jr., etc. All around 1989-90.  
    I’m not arguing, I’d love to be wrong. It’s just how I remember that time period. 
    >>>  90s alternative was a backlash against that and the 80s hair metal. 
     
    For sure, the sound was stripped down and more like rock in the early half of the 70s. Pre-disco era. 

Categories