Vitalogy vs VS

2»

Comments

  • Ms. HaikuMs. Haiku Posts: 7,265
    Vs. is my favorite of the two, but it is close.
    There is no such thing as leftover pizza. There is now pizza and later pizza. - anonymous
    The risk I took was calculated, but man, am I bad at math - The Mincing Mockingbird
  • heaveheave Posts: 159
    vitalogy for sure!
  • I think Vitalogy would be my favorite hands down... except I think Pry, To and Bugs break up the flow of the album too much. Take those two out and I think it has more soul than Vs.

    Vs. is still great, but IMHO it has a little less backbone than Vitalogy.
    "No time to be void or save up on life...
    You got to spend it all."
  • heaveheave Posts: 159
    LightYear wrote:
    I think Vitalogy would be my favorite hands down... except I think Pry, To and Bugs break up the flow of the album too much. Take those two out and I think it has more soul than Vs.

    Vs. is still great, but IMHO it has a little less backbone than Vitalogy.


    I'll have to agree with you on that.... to bad for those 'filler' tracks (pry, to... aye davanita, stupid mop), really breaks up the flow
  • r2g2r2g2 Posts: 66
    vitalogy!!!!!!
    I said Yeaaaaaaah!
  • Last Exit--My favorite opening song on a PJ album.
    Spin The Black Circle--Viva la Vinyl...'nuff said.
    Not For You--speaks for itself.
    Tremor Christ--makes me wanna go surfing...too bad I live in the Midwest.
    Nothingman--oh. my. god.
    Whipping--I got to hear it live for the first time last year(6/26/03)...I will NEVER EVER forget it...EVER.
    pry,to--p.r.i.v.a.c.y.
    Corduroy--some may think it's a bit overplayed/burnt out, but I still keep it close to my heart...such a personal song, I can never get enough of it.
    Bugs--a song most don't like, but I enjoy the little 'weirdos' on the records.
    Satan's Bed--another one of those 'lost treasures'...should've been on Lost Dogs it's so rare to hear these days. Shame too.
    Better Man--I like it so much better live w/ a tag, but still a good one IMO.
    aye davanita--'the song without words'
    Immortality--the solo says it all... :D
    hey foxymophandlemama, that's me--I have to say, I don't know what to say.

    Don't get me wrong...'vs.'/'five against one' is an almost equally awesome record in my book, but 'Vitalogy' will always be my favorite album by anyone, forever...and ever. It just holds so much meaning to me, I would be selfish if I took the space up on this board to explain it. But then again, you are all PJ fans...you all understand I'm sure of it.
    PJ: Toledo-9/22/96. E. Lansing-8/18/98. Detroit-8/23/98. Detroit-10/7/00. Detroit-6/25 & 6/26/03. Toledo-10/2/04 [VFC]. Detroit-5/22/06. Chicago-8/5/07 [Lolla]. Cleveland-5/9/10. Baltimore-10/27/13.

    EV: Honolulu-4/21 & 4/22/07 [Kokua]. Detroit-6/26/11.
  • Vitalogy! Immortality and Nothingman are in my pj top 10
    makes much more sense to live in the present tense
  • vs. is the best pearl jam cd.
    "Remember that extremism in the defence of liberity is no vice ,and moderation in the time of parell is no virture" -goldwater
  • SENROCKSENROCK Posts: 10,736
    i dont know....they are completely different but both just as great. I think i might have to go with VS. Mainly because of Animal, Indifference, Go, LEASH!!! but then theres Vitalogy....Corduroy, nothingman, betterman, Tremor. k i'm not choosing!
    ~~~~~~ALWAYS HAVE A GOOD TIME~~~~~~
    Sir Mike McCready is....THE MASTER!!! WAHHH!!!
    EVENFLOW PSYCHOS H.N.I.C~FEEL THE FLOW!!!

    "Pearl Jam fans are obsessed, they'd see the boys in HELL if tickets were sold."-CROJAM95

    It takes balls to put out a UKE album!
  • Personally I prefer Vitalogy, I do love VS for the likes of Go Animal RVM and Indifference, but I think Vitalogy has more depth. both great albums though,any new band around nowadays couldn't make an album close to one of these in greatness.
  • Immortality....Corduroy......Spin the Black circle...
    V I T A L O G Y ! ! !
  • While its tough to pick between the two, I think Vs. edges out Vitalogy by a hair.
    "Leash for '05"
Sign In or Register to comment.