What song does Eddie f*ck up most live?

october22

jg341 wrote:

october22 wrote:

Man, that's a tough one. There are several. Which is why it kind of bummed me out that he was so hard on Mike about his guitar part on Lightning Bolt at Wrigley.

Yeah, what was that all about? Mike was on fire the whole night and Ed gets pissed at the end of a brand new song.

I know, it was really weird. I was there, one person off the rail, directly in front of Mike watching it in real time. I turned to my brother and said "Ed's pissed about something!" Then I saw it was directed at Mike but Mike didn't seem to notice. Then Ed threw him a a "FUCK" which was even more strange. Then Mike started using the ebow that he finishes that solo with. I'm thinking he either got to that ebow late or was supposed to have been playing another part entirely during the lead up to it. There is a really cool part Mike plays earlier in the song that is so good and defining, I find it strange to only be used once in a five plus minute song. I've been listening to it while playing that part in my head during the Ed tantrum and it seems like it would work and resolve itself perfectly into that ebow solo. Anyway, guess we'll have to see.

sparky_fry

october22 wrote:

jg341 wrote:

october22 wrote:

Man, that's a tough one. There are several. Which is why it kind of bummed me out that he was so hard on Mike about his guitar part on Lightning Bolt at Wrigley.

Yeah, what was that all about? Mike was on fire the whole night and Ed gets pissed at the end of a brand new song.

I know, it was really weird. I was there, one person off the rail, directly in front of Mike watching it in real time. I turned to my brother and said "Ed's pissed about something!" Then I saw it was directed at Mike but Mike didn't seem to notice. Then Ed threw him a a "FUCK" which was even more strange. Then Mike started using the ebow that he finishes that solo with. I'm thinking he either got to that ebow late or was supposed to have been playing another part entirely during the lead up to it. There is a really cool part Mike plays earlier in the song that is so good and defining, I find it strange to only be used once in a five plus minute song. I've been listening to it while playing that part in my head during the Ed tantrum and it seems like it would work and resolve itself perfectly into that ebow solo. Anyway, guess we'll have to see.

I just thought he was pissed with the actual lightning bolts in the sky. All the lightning was coming from the direction he pointed at (Mikes side). I don't think he's ever got pissed with a band members playing on stage?

Spiritual_Chaos

sparky_fry wrote:

october22 wrote:

jg341 wrote:

Yeah, what was that all about? Mike was on fire the whole night and Ed gets pissed at the end of a brand new song.

I know, it was really weird. I was there, one person off the rail, directly in front of Mike watching it in real time. I turned to my brother and said "Ed's pissed about something!" Then I saw it was directed at Mike but Mike didn't seem to notice. Then Ed threw him a a "FUCK" which was even more strange. Then Mike started using the ebow that he finishes that solo with. I'm thinking he either got to that ebow late or was supposed to have been playing another part entirely during the lead up to it. There is a really cool part Mike plays earlier in the song that is so good and defining, I find it strange to only be used once in a five plus minute song. I've been listening to it while playing that part in my head during the Ed tantrum and it seems like it would work and resolve itself perfectly into that ebow solo. Anyway, guess we'll have to see.

I just thought he was pissed with the actual lightning bolts in the sky. All the lightning was coming from the direction he pointed at (Mikes side). I don't think he's ever got pissed with a band members playing on stage?

Stone and he were bitching during Alpine

F5AgainstOne

I don't think deviating from the way the lyrics were written or recorded is necessarily wrong. I mean its their song, they could repeat the same verse over and over if they want. I'm more into the musicality of the whole thing anyway... Its Ed's voice and melodies that make it all work so well anyway. He can still make a song work even if he completely forgets a verse and just hums the melody.

I think its worse when he (or they) mess up the music ... Like Ed starting the first verse of "In My Tree" on the wrong chord at the wrong time like PJ20 Alpine Valley (I think he was having trouble hearing Jeff though).
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oZxBxBiEo3c

Although I do enjoy hearing how they recover from their mistakes.

YourDirtisMyfood

2 bottles of wine will do that to you.

tempo_n_groove

Yellowledbetter. 20 years of singing and he hasn't sung the same song twice...

Eraserhead

Wishlist

vest71

never heard him nail "once" .... there are like two verses or what ever it´s called and he seems to mix them up every time ....
and the 2 or 3 times i have heard "smile" it´s also been f..... up
but that´s the charm of going to concerts right ?

mrluthor9

And fuck me if I say something you don't wanna hear, fuck me
And fuck me if you only hear what you wanna hear
Fuck me if I care, but I'm not leaving here

Anestha

Breath & Come Back

White Discussion

Thanks for posting those videos so funny and it was great

Big Bank Hank wrote:

White Discussion wrote:

He jacked up sometimes at SF 1 in 06'. It was classic they just quit playing it and moved on 8-)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zqsU46DSIUI :crazy:
watch the first few minutes of both videos
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EUTfyE_6tOw

2-feign-reluctance

Immortality

southernmanfan

Definitely Come Back.

I don't think it has anything to do with the wine. As a singer, you can fuck up a song very easily, even if you have sung it a million times. Its just something in the brain that does not click....or over clicks

JonnyPistachio

Bob Ross was also talking about Pearl Jam..

Wobbie

last kiss.

Kathi

I don't know how often that happens, but Smile got butchered badly at a few shows I was at. Copenhagen had a completely new song. I think that was a whole band fuckup though.