How Would You personally Rank the Studio Albums? Updated

STAYSEA

[quote="PJ_Soul"
Fuck, FINE. Just note that this subject to change every 5 minutes. And i do consider Rearviewmirror and Lost Dogs studio albums (Lost Dogs isn't a compilation IMO. Just an album they were saving up for).
G
1. Lost Dogs
2. No Code
3. Vitalogy
4. Yield
5. Riot Act
6. Ten
7. Binaural
8. Avocado
9. Vs.
10. Rearviewmirror
11. Backspacer

:fp: That just feels really wrong.[/quote= PJ_Soul"]


No one has a gun to your head? This is a voluntary fun time that a few here have put several hours into. So it you want trash it. We won't feel bad. :crazy: :problem:

PJ_Soul

STAYSEA wrote:

PJ_Soul wrote:

Fuck, FINE. Just note that this subject to change every 5 minutes. And i do consider Rearviewmirror and Lost Dogs studio albums (Lost Dogs isn't a compilation IMO. Just an album they were saving up for).
G
1. Lost Dogs
2. No Code
3. Vitalogy
4. Yield
5. Riot Act
6. Ten
7. Binaural
8. Avocado
9. Vs.
10. Rearviewmirror
11. Backspacer

:fp: That just feels really wrong.

No one has a gun to your head? This is a voluntary fun time that a few here have put several hours into. So it you want trash it. We won't feel bad. :crazy: :problem:

[/quote]
Huh? I think you are misreading me. I have no problem, was feeling friendly. I wasn't trashing anything at all. Perhaps i should have used an emoticon.

brianlux

It really is just slightly mind numbing to rank PJ's output, isn't it! I get it!

We should do this every few years to see how the trends change. But STAYSEA, we have to make sure you or Dimitris know how to calculate "intervals of favored variances within a chronological framework"... or what ever form of math is required to make the computations. I wouldn't have the foggiest notion.

STAYSEA

brianlux wrote:

It really is just slightly mind numbing to rank PJ's output, isn't it! I get it!

We should do this every few years to see how the trends change. But STAYSEA, we have to make sure you or Dimitris know how to calculate "intervals of favored variances within a chronological framework"... or what ever form of math is required to make the computations. I wouldn't have the foggiest notion.

We all 3 count differently. I want to scan my notes on my printer tomorrow. The results are odd. It's going to be a bunch of fun if we all submit together. It's going to be funky. I sure as heck couldn't have guessed the order myself.

No one else did either. But together we built it?

whispering hands

I wish I'd have voted!!!

moses562

It changes every now and then...it is hard for me to really have a solid list but...

No Code
Yield
Binuaral
Vs.
Riot Act
Ten
Vitalogy
S/T
New Album
.
.
.
.
Backspacer

Listened to Backspacer the other day...such a short album...and there are two or three songs that are just Ed...solo material. I will keep listening though...maybe one of these days I will appreciate it. That is what it took for Binuaual and Riot Act to grow on me.

rearviewross

PJ_Soul wrote:

rearviewross wrote:

PJ_Soul wrote:

I just CAN'T! I tried. Couldn't do it. :oops:

Lol, I know it is hard. I second guess my list every day but with the support of the forum, I get through it and so can you. NOW CHOOSE!

Fuck, FINE. Just note that this subject to change every 5 minutes. And i do consider Rearviewmirror and Lost Dogs studio albums (Lost Dogs isn't a compilation IMO. Just an album they were saving up for).
G
1. Lost Dogs
2. No Code
3. Vitalogy
4. Yield
5. Riot Act
6. Ten
7. Binaural
8. Avocado
9. Vs.
10. Rearviewmirror
11. Backspacer

:fp: That just feels really wrong.

There, now dont you feel worse? Kind of like you just told one of your kids you like the other one better.

Lost Dogs is the definition of a compilation album and Rearview mirror is a greatest hits/best of album. Neither are studio albums.

STAYSEA

I have finished my results.

This is the Order That the Albums are Played 3/29/2013.

Starting with the first album you play ending with the album you play the least

#1 Ten

#2 Yield

#3 Vitalogy

#4 No Code

#5 Vs

#6 Binaural Is the dominating number 6 spot by a landslide.

#7 Riot Act

#8 Avocado/ ST/ Pearl Jam

#9 Backspacer


So, in theory if any one of us went over to a ten club members house for tea. This is the most popular order they "we" play Pearl Jam's albums, and now we know. ... For now



(I scanned my notes but I didn't feel the need to post them, but I will if you want.)

whispering hands

Wow!! That's awesome!!

Dr. Delight

How is Vs tied for both #1 and #2 and #5?

Not sure I get the list and how you numbered it.

whispering hands

Dr. Delight wrote:

How is Vs tied for both #1 and #2 and #5?

Not sure I get the list and how you numbered it.

First place is.. Ten high play time over VS. low play time..
And so on.. Was how I was reading it.. Am I wrong STAYSEA?

rearviewross

STAYSEA wrote:

I have finished my results.

This is the Order That the Albums are Played 3/29/2013.

Starting with the first album you play ending with the album you play the least

#1 Ten and Vs

#2 Yield and Vs

#3 Yield and Vitalogy

#4 No Code and Vitalogy

#5 No code and Vs

#6 Binaural Is the dominating number 6 spot by a landslide.

#7 Riot Act and Avocado/ ST/ Pearl Jam

#8 Avocado/ ST/ Pearl Jam and Riot Act

#9 Backspacer


So, in theory if any one of us went over to a ten club members house for tea. This is the most popular order they "we" play Pearl Jam's albums, and now we know. ... For now



(I scanned my notes but I didn't feel the need to post them, but I will if you want.)

I don't get it. :?

JB128716

STAYSEA wrote:

So, in theory if any one of us went over to a ten club members house for tea. This is the most popular order they "we" play Pearl Jam's albums, and now we know. [/i])

Wait, I didn't know this was a list that I would play in order if I had a ten club member over my house for some tea. That changes everything!!!

brianlux

I knew all along two of my three favorites, self-titled and Riot Act, would score low. What can I say- I dance to a different tune.

Dr. Delight

rearviewross wrote:

I don't get it. :?

I still dont.

How I'm reading it, Ten and Vs are tied at #1 for being people favorite.
I dont understand how Vs can also be tied with Yield for #2 and then again at #5? :crazy:

STAYSEA

brianlux wrote:

Okay Dimi ,and Brains... How do we score this one?

When I started setting up a tally chart I listed the 9 studio albums with halves like this:
1
1 1/2
2
2 1/2
3
3 1/2
4
4 1/2
5
5 1/5
6
6 1/2
7
7 1/2
8
8 1/2
9

So if someone rated two albums a tie after, lets say, their third choice, those two would each get 4 1/2 points instead of a 4 and 5 and then move on to 6 though 9.

For the situation with the last three being a tie, I would count all three as an 8 since 8 is the average of 7, 8 and 9. If someone rated the first three 1, 2, and 3 and then the next three a tie, those three would each get a 5 because the average of 4, 5 and 6 is 5.

Or you could tell anyone that uses ties to please try again.

Now you see why I got burned out fast trying to tally these scores. I would recommend everyone try to just list the 9 studio albums in a strict 1 to 9 order with no ties. If you feel two albums tie, flip a coin?[/quote]

STAYSEA

dimitrispearljam wrote:

the one with the lower number is leading,with the system i count them..

1.Yield 223
2.Ten 234
3.No Code 254
4.Vs 263
5.Vitalogy 321
6.Binaural 411
7.Riot Act 462
8.S/T 491
9.Backspacer 587

my head hurts..

ill do later a better count at 3 first,in case i miss anything..the rest are clear the difference

STAYSEA

All three of us had a different way to keep score.

pledgeagrievance

1. Yield
2. No Code
3. Vitalogy
4. Binaural
5. Riot Act
6. Vs.
7. Ten
8. Avacodo
9. Backspacer

october22

Eh... what happened here?