Ed Guitar Pick and Note Card

Boxes&Books

:idea:

cowboypjfan

I wish I could sign an index card like you can :roll:

C'mon really? What's the point of selling this when you can't prove it was signed. I don't care how good it may look. If it was real, you wouldn't sell it. Who would!?

ahill721

crazypjfan wrote:

I wish I could sign an index card like you can :roll:

C'mon really? What's the point of selling this when you can't prove it was signed. I don't care how good it may look. If it was real, you wouldn't sell it. Who would!?

If you have nothing nice to say, why say anything at all :?

cowboypjfan

ahill721 wrote:

crazypjfan wrote:

I wish I could sign an index card like you can :roll:

C'mon really? What's the point of selling this when you can't prove it was signed. I don't care how good it may look. If it was real, you wouldn't sell it. Who would!?

If you have nothing nice to say, why say anything at all :?

Did you see him sign it? I wasn't being rude, just stating the obvious when looking at autographs. I don't why to see someone pay $250 for a sig on an index card, that's all.

Also, I'm sure Ed signed this (if it is real) just for someone to make a huge profit from their fellow fans. :roll:

arq

Classic 91 Ed's signature! I'm not going to mention price but Tony doesn't have a single fake signature, all his stuff is legit.

pdalowsky

Totally legit

ahill721

pdalowsky wrote:

Totally legit

flyinwhole313

To fetch that price, I would recommend sending this in to PSA/DNA or JSA for third party authentication from a REPUTABLE company like these 2.
http://www.psacard.com/services/auto_authentication.chtml
or
http://www.spenceloa.com/

flyinwhole313

And for the record, my brother acquires autographs for a living, and he says it is not far off from some older EV sigs, but he would not buy a "vintage" Eddie signature without a cert from PSA or JSA...

arq

flyinwhole313 wrote:

To fetch that price, I would recommend sending this in to PSA/DNA or JSA for third party authentication from a REPUTABLE company like these 2.
http://www.psacard.com/services/auto_authentication.chtml
or
http://www.spenceloa.com/

Sadly REPUTABLE authentication companies are just a joke now :( is better to run it with long time fans

Hugh Freaking Dillon

crazypjfan wrote:

Who would!?

I would.

Boxes&Books

crazypjfan wrote:

Did you see him sign it? I wasn't being rude, just stating the obvious when looking at autographs. I don't why to see someone pay $250 for a sig on an index card, that's all.

Also, I'm sure Ed signed this (if it is real) just for someone to make a huge profit from their fellow fans. :roll:

How do you know I'm making a profit on this? Do you know me? Do you know the provenance of this item?

When you listed the billboard print for your "friend", a few weeks after its release, at a flipping price of 400 dollars you didn't seem to have a problem with profits, huh!?!? Personally I don't care who flips what or what people do with their items; It's your life, your items, your time, and your money!...do whatever the heck you want with them! It's none of my business...But please don't come at me with some holier than thou attitude and attempt to burn me/my listing with out even knowing me or asking any questions...
I'm not looking for conflict or to get into a discussion over this so lets just move on...... I'm just offering an item that I think people on this board might find interesting.

If there is a question simply ask it and let's go from there.

I don't care how good it may look. If it was real, you wouldn't sell it. Who would!? .......... "crazypjfan"

By the way..... the last item I got signed by Ed was this item.....




I gave it away to a fellow member on this board (no profits / no charge)....apparently I'm not only willing to sell a item, but I'm also willing to give one away...



P.S
I didn't go looking into your previous posts regarding the Billboard... I was actually trying to buy/trade you/your friend for it (via pm's).....

arq

Oooh i remember that! I'm gal for your friend, also I'm very thankful for posters you got me, thanks man. I hope I can return te favor!

tonifig8 wrote:

.... the last item I got signed by Ed was this item.....

https://picasaweb.google.com/lh/photo/O ... directlink

fanofzs

By the way..... the last item I got signed by Ed was this item.....

https://picasaweb.google.com/lh/photo/O ... directlink


I gave it away to a fellow member on this board (no profits / no charge)....apparently I'm not only willing to sell a item, but I'm also willing to give one away...

Hey, was this in Santa Barbara last year at the EV solo show? I was there. Were you the lucky fellow at the end of the line? The only one that got an autograph from Eddie? I had my uke, but no dice.

cowboypjfan

Dude, the billboard poster is authentic and it has proof. Your item here has NO proof. That is my point. People are going to question autographs since they are hard to prove real. Good luck!

tonifig8 wrote:

crazypjfan wrote:

Did you see him sign it? I wasn't being rude, just stating the obvious when looking at autographs. I don't why to see someone pay $250 for a sig on an index card, that's all.

Also, I'm sure Ed signed this (if it is real) just for someone to make a huge profit from their fellow fans. :roll:

How do you know I'm making a profit on this? Do you know me? Do you know the provenance of this item?

When you listed the billboard print for your "friend", a few weeks after its release, at a flipping price of 400 dollars you didn't seem to have a problem with profits, huh!?!? Personally I don't care who flips what or what people do with their items; It's your life, your items, your time, and your money!...do whatever the heck you want with them! It's none of my business...But please don't come at me with some holier than thou attitude and attempt to burn me/my listing with out even knowing me or asking any questions...
I'm not looking for conflict or to get into a discussion over this so lets just move on...... I'm just offering an item that I think people on this board might find interesting.

If there is a question simply ask it and let's go from there.

I don't care how good it may look. If it was real, you wouldn't sell it. Who would!? .......... "crazypjfan"

By the way..... the last item I got signed by Ed was this item.....

https://picasaweb.google.com/lh/photo/O ... directlink


I gave it away to a fellow member on this board (no profits / no charge)....apparently I'm not only willing to sell a item, but I'm also willing to give one away...



P.S
I didn't go looking into your previous posts regarding the Billboard... I was actually trying to buy/trade you/your friend for it (via pm's).....

100 Pacer

crazypjfan wrote:

Dude, the billboard poster is authentic and it has proof. Your item here has NO proof. That is my point. People are going to question autographs since they are hard to prove real. Good luck!

There's nothing wrong with questioning autographs, but to add an element of disrespectful tone in a thread created by a reliable source and respected collector that many of us in the small-ish bubble of collecting/obtaining/documenting legitimate examples of PJ signatures know to be a stand-up guy isn't warranted. If you don't agree with the man's methods/terms/objectives you are entitled to your opinions; however, you could have at least inquired about the item/signature you were bashing to at least educate yourself with some facts before blindingly criticizing the signature's validity.

What's ultimately most ironic is that, as you said so yourself, "people are going to question autographs since they are hard to prove real." What you may not realize is that in today's digital age in little to no time at all people are creating and selling fake signatures with PSA/DNA authentication and unsuspecting PJ enthusiasts/collectors are purchasing them because they take comfort in the "authentication" when in reality on a forum such as this and/or by inquiring with fellow devoted fans many have obtained legitimate, authentic PJ signatures for far cheaper and with zero risk. The OP is one of those legitimate, cheaper sources one can take comfort in dealing with.

eldarion75

When I see people jumping on threads selling high end items, and complaining or calling them out, I usually put it down to jealousy. You can be guaranteed these people wouldn't do this or be so high horsed about it if they owned whatever it is and were looking to sell it.

it's his stuff, he has a good reputation and can ask for whatever he wants for it. Get over it.

cmalisze

I will have to say that after attempting to purchase a PJ signed guitar and posting pictures on here I would much rather have fellow 10c members authenticate signatures that companies. UNLESS there is a picture of them signing the item. I have no doubt that the item in "question" is 100% legit due to the collecting history, of which I was given a lesson in when tonifig8 helped me in NOT buying the guitar. I am sure this thread will be locked unless it takes a nicer turn. Let's keep it cordial and helpful!!! On a more awesome note, I am only a few days away from receiving 2 signed pictures from EV from a personal friend that just spent the week with EV. These I KNOW are legit and I will post pictures of those upon obtaining them. I am so excited.

cowboypjfan

eldarion75 wrote:

When I see people jumping on threads selling high end items, and complaining or calling them out, I usually put it down to jealousy.

That must be it!

flyinwhole313

By the way..... the last item I got signed by Ed was this item.....

https://picasaweb.google.com/lh/photo/O ... directlink


I gave it away to a fellow member on this board (no profits / no charge)....apparently I'm not only willing to sell a item, but I'm also willing to give one away...

STRANGE, that uke alone is about $200, unsigned...who would give that away for free???? Additionally, I have been in front of ED 7 times since 2008 solo tour, and he has refused to sign any ukes or guitars EVERY time, though he has signed a couple records for me, and gave me a pick out of his pocket...

Boxes&Books

crazypjfan wrote:

Dude, the billboard poster is authentic and it has proof. Your item here has NO proof. That is my point. People are going to question autographs since they are hard to prove real. Good luck!

You haven't asked me for proof or provenance of my item...you just attacked my listing with out knowing anything about it.... And I wasn't questioning the billboard

crazypjfan wrote:

I don't why to see someone pay $250 for a sig on an index card, that's all.

It simply seems to me that your sol purpose for posting on this thread is to make sure no one buys my item. I don't know why if I don't know you and you don't know anything about my item. It just doesn't make sense to me.... Oh well... I'm moving on.

thanks,