The vault CD #1

GratefulJam

Since this was a piece of merch that was give out to 10C members at the time they picked up the tickets. It would seem to me that selling/auctioning these would consitute a violation of the rules...

Any thoughts?

starmap3333

i didn't see a not for resale sticker on them.

totto

the cd cost me $330, the show was free. I think we are ok if we don't sell it for more than $330.

En La Clandestinidad

starmap3333 wrote:

i didn't see a not for resale sticker on them.

Yeah, but the people on Ebay are ripping us off for the CD!! CD's going for over $100 each. Not fair...

Grandmas Jam

Brew Crew Tix wrote:

starmap3333 wrote:

i didn't see a not for resale sticker on them.

Yeah, but the people on Ebay are ripping us off for the CD!! CD's going for over $100 each. Not fair...

how does that happen? how is everything marked up so much? the ames bro poster with mookie on it was sold for 20$, its resale is like 600$ wtf? who is paying this?

Empty Glass

1) who's paying these high prices? Dopes with cash
2) patience. It's numbered. They'll be available. Maybe not this week, or this month but we'll have a chance to buy these.

En La Clandestinidad

Grandmas Jam wrote:

Brew Crew Tix wrote:

starmap3333 wrote:

i didn't see a not for resale sticker on them.

Yeah, but the people on Ebay are ripping us off for the CD!! CD's going for over $100 each. Not fair...

how does that happen? how is everything marked up so much? the ames bro poster with mookie on it was sold for 20$, its resale is like 600$ wtf? who is paying this?

Yeah, sarcastic comment there, can't believe what people are paying for it!

Hugh Freaking Dillon

I'd love to have one. I don't have one. I can't afford to pay eBay prices. But there's nothing unfair about it. how many people on here sell records by this band for way more than they paid initially? I don't see anyone here selling Benny for $40.

afd2036

I'm pretty sure that PJ band members would not like for any of their stuff to be sold for more then what it was sold for! Im sure they'd be pissed!!! IdK I'm just saying that's not what they stand for??

Hugh Freaking Dillon

afd2036 wrote:

I'm pretty sure that PJ band members would not like for any of their stuff to be sold for more then what it was sold for! Im sure they'd be pissed!!! IdK I'm just saying that's not what they stand for??

if they cared, they wouldn't give out limited edition items such as this. they know full well there are going to be a thousand flippers out there that don't give a rats ass about keeping this cd.

totto

Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:

I'd love to have one. I don't have one. I can't afford to pay eBay prices. But there's nothing unfair about it. how many people on here sell records by this band for way more than they paid initially? I don't see anyone here selling Benny for $40.

great point

boyo79

starmap3333 wrote:

i didn't see a not for resale sticker on them.

Is there a difference between people buying 8 posters and people throwing this cd on ebay?

Of The Aggie

Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:

afd2036 wrote:

I'm pretty sure that PJ band members would not like for any of their stuff to be sold for more then what it was sold for! Im sure they'd be pissed!!! IdK I'm just saying that's not what they stand for??

if they cared, they wouldn't give out limited edition items such as this. they know full well there are going to be a thousand flippers out there that don't give a rats ass about keeping this cd.

My sentiments exactly. I've often wondered how this band can go to so much trouble to make sure tickets to its shows are not resold for more than face value, or resold at all, in the case of the fan club tickets, but they have no problem only making 2000 of something, selling it for $35, and then watching it re-sell for $800 a few years later. Or not keeping their vinyl in print so an album that would normally cost $20 is being sold for $150.

Of The Aggie

I'd love to have one of these vault CDs but I'm not going to pay $100 for what is probably a burned CD-R. If they end up selling it through the Ten Club for a reasonable price, I might pick one up, but until then I'll just listen to an audience recording of this show.

AfghanTwilight

Just give it time, people. It's disappointing they cut out the "lights Josh" comment and Baba.

theserialthrilla

give it a few months ..they will be $30 tops...they made 1000 of these cds they are not rare.

pdalowsky

It's not a cdr right? It's a pressed cd I thought?

GratefulJam

yes it pressed.

pdalowsky wrote:

It's not a cdr right? It's a pressed cd I thought?

AfghanTwilight

theserialthrilla wrote:

give it a few months ..they will be $30 tops...they made 1000 of these cds they are not rare.

If it turns out they only made 1000 of them, then it will be VERY rare. That would mean not everyone who attended the Alpine Valley show received one. This would become as rare as the Orange Fixer vinyl; more rare than the Benaroya Hall vinyl.

I have a feeling they just advance-released the boot to people attending. If not, then it's a cool momento for those who were actually able to attend.

JMo

Remember, it wasn't handed out to all that attended, or even all that filled 10C seats. It was one per account.

I was there, in a 10C, but I did not get one. Although, my PJ20 buddy and I must have listened to that boot 30 times over the course of the weekend!

afd2036

Of The Aggie wrote:

Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:

afd2036 wrote:

I'm pretty sure that PJ band members would not like for any of their stuff to be sold for more then what it was sold for! Im sure they'd be pissed!!! IdK I'm just saying that's not what they stand for??

if they cared, they wouldn't give out limited edition items such as this. they know full well there are going to be a thousand flippers out there that don't give a rats ass about keeping this cd.

My sentiments exactly. I've often wondered how this band can go to so much trouble to make sure tickets to its shows are not resold for more than face value, or resold at all, in the case of the fan club tickets, but they have no problem only making 2000 of something, selling it for $35, and then watching it re-sell for $800 a few years later. Or not keeping their vinyl in print so an album that would normally cost $20 is being sold for $150.

Does this look familiar

Welcome to the Pearl Jam Message Pit's trading forum. Please remember that the spirit of the policy here is meant to keep the trading activities on a fan-to-fan and personal basis, not to create a side business.

You can trade and set a reasonable price here for Pearl Jam memorabilia as long as the item is not available elsewhere on the site.

No flipping* posters, or selling illegal items such as illegal bootlegs from bootleggers, homemade CDs and DVDs, items purchased marked "not for resale", etc.

No auctions are allowed. Links to yours or others' eBay auctions or stores are not ok.

Please see the Posting Guidelines and Ten Club rules to be sure you are in compliance with all site rules/legalities.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=91525
http://www.pearljam.com/content/legal-disclaimer

* Flipping is buying items (from Ten Club or merch booth, etc.) with the intent to resell for a profit.

Ty

Hugh Freaking Dillon wrote:

I'd love to have one. I don't have one. I can't afford to pay eBay prices. But there's nothing unfair about it. how many people on here sell records by this band for way more than they paid initially? I don't see anyone here selling Benny for $40.

Hilarious, and fucking true!

theserialthrilla

AfghanTwilight wrote:

theserialthrilla wrote:

give it a few months ..they will be $30 tops...they made 1000 of these cds they are not rare.

If it turns out they only made 1000 of them, then it will be VERY rare. That would mean not everyone who attended the Alpine Valley show received one. This would become as rare as the Orange Fixer vinyl; more rare than the Benaroya Hall vinyl.

I have a feeling they just advance-released the boot to people attending. If not, then it's a cool momento for those who were actually able to attend.

opps missed the 's off 1000 i was 1000's...they had boxs of them..

Of The Aggie

afd2036 wrote:

Of The Aggie wrote:

My sentiments exactly. I've often wondered how this band can go to so much trouble to make sure tickets to its shows are not resold for more than face value, or resold at all, in the case of the fan club tickets, but they have no problem only making 2000 of something, selling it for $35, and then watching it re-sell for $800 a few years later. Or not keeping their vinyl in print so an album that would normally cost $20 is being sold for $150.

Does this look familiar

Welcome to the Pearl Jam Message Pit's trading forum. Please remember that the spirit of the policy here is meant to keep the trading activities on a fan-to-fan and personal basis, not to create a side business.

You can trade and set a reasonable price here for Pearl Jam memorabilia as long as the item is not available elsewhere on the site.

No flipping* posters, or selling illegal items such as illegal bootlegs from bootleggers, homemade CDs and DVDs, items purchased marked "not for resale", etc.

No auctions are allowed. Links to yours or others' eBay auctions or stores are not ok.

Please see the Posting Guidelines and Ten Club rules to be sure you are in compliance with all site rules/legalities.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=91525
http://www.pearljam.com/content/legal-disclaimer

* Flipping is buying items (from Ten Club or merch booth, etc.) with the intent to resell for a profit.

They can post these rules all they want but I don't see them shutting down the threads on here where someone is selling a Benny Hall vinyl for $600-$800. I don't know about you, but I don't think that constitutes a "reasonable price" for an item that was originally sold for $35. And posters are sold on here all the time for way more than what they cost at the show and the Ten Club has no idea who bought the posters so I don't see the relevance of the flipping thing and again they aren't shutting down these sales or the ones where the band's studio albums on vinyl are being sold for $150 when they were originally sold for $20.

afd2036

I see what your saying, sucks but true

randallanddarcy

The Vault Number 1 CD will be released here. Just give it time. Half the band's staff are on tour for starters! I'd like to thank our kid Barb for sending me a JA disc. She is a legend and has filled a gap in my collection.

Pearl Jam_ie

randallanddarcy wrote:

The Vault Number 1 CD will be released here. Just give it time. Half the band's staff are on tour for starters! I'd like to thank our kid Barb for sending me a JA disc. She is a legend and has filled a gap in my collection.

Yup, give it time. TIm said yesterday on AET that it will be available to everyone. Just got to give it time. The JA disc, however, is something only given out at the show and is part of something larger that will be put out in the future.