Home› The Porch

Rolling Stone Readers Best Lead Singers #7

Cool Face RyanCool Face Ryan Posts: 1,254
edited April 2011 in The Porch
Eddie Vedder at #7. Kurt Cobain at 10 and Chris Cornell at 9.

http://www.rollingstone.com/music/photo ... er-0979704

In 1990 Eddie Vedder was working at a gas station when his buddy Jack Irons gave him a demo tape of a Seattle band searching for a new singer. While surfing, Vedder came up with lyrics for the three songs and sent the tape back to the band with his contributions. They were blown away and Vedder was soon asked to join what became Pearl Jam. One of the songs on that tape, "Alive," was blaring out of countless bedrooms across America within about a year. Since then Vedder has become one of the most imitated singers in rock, but nobody has come close to matching his ferocious wail.
MSG II 5/21/10
Tres Mts. Gramercy Theatre 3/26/11
*formerly manutd3581
Post edited by Unknown User on
«1

Comments

  • RedMosquito22RedMosquito22 Posts: 8,158
    Excellent!!
    Member 164xxx

    8/15/92, 9/28/96, 8/28/98, 8/29/98, 9/18/98, 8/3/00, 8/9/00, 8/10/00, 8/23/00, 8/25/00, 9/1/00, 9/2/00, 4/28/03, 6/18/03, 7/5/03, 7/6/03, 10/1/04, 10/3/05, 6/19/08, 10/27/09, 10/31/09, 5/21/10, 9/3/11, 9/4/11, 10/21/13

    More to Come....
  • hopethatuchokehopethatuchoke Posts: 2,927
    Awesome. I agree.

    I also look forward to all of the RS haters suddenly liking the magazine again for the next week or so. :lol:
  • Cool Face RyanCool Face Ryan Posts: 1,254
    hopethatuchoke wrote:
    Awesome. I agree.

    I also look forward to all of the RS haters suddenly liking the magazine again for the next week or so. :lol:
    yea but its based on the readers vote
    MSG II 5/21/10
    Tres Mts. Gramercy Theatre 3/26/11
    *formerly manutd3581
  • PapPap Serres, Greece Posts: 29,620
    Very good article. 8-) Thanks for posting.
    Athens 2006 / Milton Keynes 2014 / London 1&2 2022 / Seattle 1&2 2024 / Dublin 2024 / Manchester 2024 / New Orleans 2025
  • 12345AGNST112345AGNST1 Posts: 4,906
    Finally, a list with nirvana/kurt in an understandable position. No way in hell should he be above any of them.
    5/28/06, 6/27/08, 10/28/09, 5/18/10, 5/21/10
    8/7/08, 6/9/09
  • SatansFutonSatansFuton Posts: 5,399
    Bono is above Mick Jagger, Jim Morrison, Roger Daltrey, Eddie Vedder and John Lennon? Oh well, I guess any list is going to generate some sort of debate. I would say John Lennon should probably be above Ed, but when you consider he wasn't really a "lead singer" and shared vocals with the rest of the Beatles I can see why he was a little further down.
    "See a broad to get dat booty yak 'em, leg 'er down, a smack 'em yak 'em!"
  • dimitrispearljamdimitrispearljam Posts: 139,721
    cool
    "...Dimitri...He talks to me...'.."The Ghost of Greece..".
    "..That's One Happy Fuckin Ghost.."
    “..That came up on the Pillow Case...This is for the Greek, With Our Apologies.....”
  • bluerockgirlbluerockgirl Posts: 15
    Eddie will always be # 1 on my list:)
  • fox_mulderXfox_mulderX Posts: 1,134
    another bad list from RS. i know it's trendy to hate on RS, but come on... jim morrison? bono? robert plant (at number one!?)....
    where's brian wilson? he's better than all of them. john lennon at #8? the guy changed the face of music and he's behind jim morrison? what about hendrix?
    and i disagree with eddie at #7. sorry. he's awesome, but there's no way he's in the top 10 of all time.
  • Get_RightGet_Right Posts: 13,802
    fox_mulderX wrote:
    another bad list from RS. i know it's trendy to hate on RS, but come on... jim morrison? bono? robert plant (at number one!?)....
    where's brian wilson? he's better than all of them. john lennon at #8? the guy changed the face of music and he's behind jim morrison? what about hendrix?
    and i disagree with eddie at #7. sorry. he's awesome, but there's no way he's in the top 10 of all time.
    its a readers poll voting for their favorite bands
    zero objectivity, total subjectivity
  • DewieCoxDewieCox Posts: 11,431
    fox_mulderX wrote:
    another bad list from RS. i know it's trendy to hate on RS, but come on... jim morrison? bono? robert plant (at number one!?)....
    where's brian wilson? he's better than all of them. john lennon at #8? the guy changed the face of music and he's behind jim morrison? what about hendrix?
    and i disagree with eddie at #7. sorry. he's awesome, but there's no way he's in the top 10 of all time.

    Robert Plant deserves to be in the top 2, right behind Freddy Mercury, without question. Had an enormous range and more vocal power than any rock singer ever(he could keep up with John Bonham without a mic). Also, huge range of styles he could sing covincingly, with tons of dynamics.


    Ed deserves to be top 10, based on vocal recognition alone. I think you could put somebody like Axl Rose in there for a similar reason.

    The Beatles all work against each other. I always thought George had the nicest voice.

    Brian Wilson should be there, but maybe some don't think of him as a singer. Conversations about him usually just involve his overall creativity.


    I'd get rid of Jagger and Morrison if we're talkin singers and not front men.
  • fox_mulderXfox_mulderX Posts: 1,134
    Get_Right wrote:
    fox_mulderX wrote:
    another bad list from RS. i know it's trendy to hate on RS, but come on... jim morrison? bono? robert plant (at number one!?)....
    where's brian wilson? he's better than all of them. john lennon at #8? the guy changed the face of music and he's behind jim morrison? what about hendrix?
    and i disagree with eddie at #7. sorry. he's awesome, but there's no way he's in the top 10 of all time.
    its a readers poll voting for their favorite bands
    zero objectivity, total subjectivity

    okay that makes more sense. lol i guess i could have figured that out by reading the title of this thread
  • fox_mulderXfox_mulderX Posts: 1,134
    DewieCox wrote:
    fox_mulderX wrote:
    another bad list from RS. i know it's trendy to hate on RS, but come on... jim morrison? bono? robert plant (at number one!?)....
    where's brian wilson? he's better than all of them. john lennon at #8? the guy changed the face of music and he's behind jim morrison? what about hendrix?
    and i disagree with eddie at #7. sorry. he's awesome, but there's no way he's in the top 10 of all time.

    Robert Plant deserves to be in the top 2, right behind Freddy Mercury, without question. Had an enormous range and more vocal power than any rock singer ever(he could keep up with John Bonham without a mic). Also, huge range of styles he could sing covincingly, with tons of dynamics.


    Ed deserves to be top 10, based on vocal recognition alone. I think you could put somebody like Axl Rose in there for a similar reason.

    The Beatles all work against each other. I always thought George had the nicest voice.

    Brian Wilson should be there, but maybe some don't think of him as a singer. Conversations about him usually just involve his overall creativity.


    I'd get rid of Jagger and Morrison if we're talkin singers and not front men.


    i don't know how anyone could have a conversation about brian wilson and not appreciate his voice... him and carl had two of the nicest voices from the 60s.
    and yes, george harrison had an amazing voice.
  • SatansFutonSatansFuton Posts: 5,399
    fox_mulderX wrote:

    i don't know how anyone could have a conversation about brian wilson and not appreciate his voice... him and carl had two of the nicest voices from the 60s.
    and yes, george harrison had an amazing voice.

    Well The Beach Boys were mainly a harmony band, I know they had great individual voices and didn't harmonize on every song, but for most people when they think of them they think of them harmonizing, so to that maybe hurt his chances. Everybody in CS&N (and sometimes Y) had beautiful voices, but it's hard to pick one of them out as the lead singer because I always think of how beautiful they sounded together.
    "See a broad to get dat booty yak 'em, leg 'er down, a smack 'em yak 'em!"
  • RedMosquito22RedMosquito22 Posts: 8,158
    I think Bono is a few spots to high up the list. He should be around where Ed is.
    Member 164xxx

    8/15/92, 9/28/96, 8/28/98, 8/29/98, 9/18/98, 8/3/00, 8/9/00, 8/10/00, 8/23/00, 8/25/00, 9/1/00, 9/2/00, 4/28/03, 6/18/03, 7/5/03, 7/6/03, 10/1/04, 10/3/05, 6/19/08, 10/27/09, 10/31/09, 5/21/10, 9/3/11, 9/4/11, 10/21/13

    More to Come....
  • SatansFutonSatansFuton Posts: 5,399
    RedMosquito22 wrote:
    I think Bono is a few spots to high up the list. He should be around where Ed is.

    I personally wouldn't have him on the top 10 at all, but that's just my opinion.
    "See a broad to get dat booty yak 'em, leg 'er down, a smack 'em yak 'em!"
  • pdalowskypdalowsky Doncaster,UK Posts: 15,113
    As it's a popularity contest Bono will always do well...

    Really he's an average singer...

    Based on a readers poll it's great to see Eddie is well thought of.. And with my bug rose tinteds on he damn well deserves it
  • cincybearcatcincybearcat Posts: 16,670
    Not a terrible list...but there is no doubt in my mind that Freddie Mercury needs to be in the #1 spot of any list of lead singers.
    hippiemom = goodness
  • pjfan021pjfan021 Posts: 684
    elvis, eddie, plant, mercury, cornell, orbison, paul rodgers, marvin gaye, aretha franklin....in no particular order
  • RYEzupSFRYEzupSF Posts: 6,003
    cincybearcat wrote:
    Not a terrible list...but there is no doubt in my mind that Freddie Mercury needs to be in the #1 spot of any list of lead singers.

    agreed! and shannon hoon should be on there somewhere imo
    BrowserPreview_tmp_zps26eff4aa.gif

    Don't fuck sheep. -EV 7/11/11
    You can never have enough Neil in the mix. -EV 10/24/10
    There's only one commandment: Don't be an asshole. -EV 5/6/10
  • geckogecko Posts: 1,712
    You can always count on Rolling Stone - 100 greatest singers of all time:
    http://www.rollingstone.com/music/lists/100-greatest-singers-of-all-time-19691231/aretha-franklin-19691231
  • robthepjfanrobthepjfan Posts: 647
    wheres Scott Stapp on this list? kidding
  • SatansFutonSatansFuton Posts: 5,399
    robthepjfan wrote:
    wheres Scott Stapp on this list? kidding

    He's one spot above William Hung and one spot below that alien singer with the crazy looking lips that performed in Jabba's Palace.
    "See a broad to get dat booty yak 'em, leg 'er down, a smack 'em yak 'em!"
  • josevolutionjosevolution Posts: 30,747
    The only three i never got see live are .

    Lennon
    Morrison
    Mercury

    I'm going with Plant ....
    jesus greets me looks just like me ....
  • Tboz51Tboz51 Posts: 2,808
    ...and no Joe Cocker or Yoko Ono?

    This RS list was obviously fixed!

    :-)
    "Honesty will always be construed as negative to a dumbass"
    :-)
  • PilateOfTheStormPilateOfTheStorm Posts: 4,319
    i mostly agree with the list

    Robert Plant is #1,no one can top him IMO
    Jim Morrison, Roger Daltry, Freddie Mercury, Mick Jagger - all great singers, great frontmen too
    Eddie completely deserves to be in the list, should be higher than Bono

    cool list
  • Cool Face RyanCool Face Ryan Posts: 1,254
    and the vid they use for Eddie is Alive from MSG night 2 2010. :thumbup:
    MSG II 5/21/10
    Tres Mts. Gramercy Theatre 3/26/11
    *formerly manutd3581
  • Ledbetterman10Ledbetterman10 Posts: 16,956
    manutd3581 wrote:
    Eddie Vedder at #7. Kurt Cobain at 10

    Nice to see things are finally starting to swing Eddie's way in this debate. It would have swung years ago if Kurt didn't kill himself.
    2000: Camden 1, 2003: Philly, State College, Camden 1, MSG 2, Hershey, 2004: Reading, 2005: Philly, 2006: Camden 1, 2, East Rutherford 1, 2007: Lollapalooza, 2008: Camden 1, Washington D.C., MSG 1, 2, 2009: Philly 1, 2, 3, 4, 2010: Bristol, MSG 2, 2011: PJ20 1, 2, 2012: Made In America, 2013: Brooklyn 2, Philly 2, 2014: Denver, 2015: Global Citizen Festival, 2016: Philly 2, Fenway 1, 2018: Fenway 1, 2, 2021: Sea. Hear. Now. 2022: Camden, 2024: Philly 2

    Pearl Jam bootlegs:
    http://wegotshit.blogspot.com
  • bicyclejoebicyclejoe USA Posts: 1,203
    RedMosquito22 wrote:
    I think Bono is a few spots to high up the list. He should be around where Ed is.

    You folks are hilarious. Love Eddie, but Bono, Jim Morrison and Plant are just about where they should be. I never really got the U2 hate around here. When it comes to selling out stadiums and keeping rock alive in the mainstream (face it, most people beyond are jamily don't even know PJ is still making music), Bono and his voice will always get my respect.
    My Pearl Jam Road: 10/22/90 Seattle | 12/22/90 Seattle, Moore Theater | 9/29/92 Seattle, Magnusson Park, Drop in the Park | 9/5/93 The Gorge, with Neil Young and Blind Melon | 7/20/06 Portland, Arlene Schnitzer Concert Hall with Sleater-Kinney | 7/22/06 The Gorge, 10/21/06 Mountain View, Shoreline Ampitheatre, Bridge School Benefit | 9/21/09 Seattle | 9/22/09 Seattle | 9/26/09 Portland, OR | 7/14/2011 Eddie Vedder, Portland, OR | 11/29/13 Portland, OR
  • fox_mulderXfox_mulderX Posts: 1,134
    bicyclejoe wrote:
    RedMosquito22 wrote:
    I think Bono is a few spots to high up the list. He should be around where Ed is.

    You folks are hilarious. Love Eddie, but Bono, Jim Morrison and Plant are just about where they should be. I never really got the U2 hate around here. When it comes to selling out stadiums and keeping rock alive in the mainstream (face it, most people beyond are jamily don't even know PJ is still making music), Bono and his voice will always get my respect.


    because bono all of a sudden cares about africa when u2 is releasing a cd. i'm sure pearl jam would still be in the news if they hopped on the donating bandwagon before every album release.
    sadly, they do it 24/7 with no media coverage. stupid pearl jam.

    (edit: this sarcasm is in no way directed towards you. it's just my annoyance with the praise bono gets)
Sign In or Register to comment.