is this move going to be the death knell for peace talks??

Byrnzie

catefrances wrote:

so you think the israelis will just up and abandon their settlements to implement a 2 state solution?

I don't know. I hope so.

catefrances wrote:

should they be expected to simply because the settlements are illegal under international law...

Yes, unless they wish to continue living in a dangerous rogue state.

catefrances wrote:

will palestinians living and working in israel be expected to relocate to palestinian territory?

I don't know.

catefrances wrote:

can you possibly get past the sins of the past in order that there be a peaceful future?

I think you possibly can.

catefrances wrote:

do you think a 2 state plan can be implemented equitably?

Depends what you mean by 'equitably'.

catefrances

Byrnzie wrote:

catefrances wrote:

so....
no thoughts then???

*shrugs*

I don't like being bombarded with multiple questions. My Mum does that and I ignore her when she does it too. One question at a time please. :thumbup:

im not your mum steve and the questions tumbled out cause it was what i was thinking at the time. you couldve just separated the questions and answered them one at a time.... oh looky thats what you did anyway. :roll:

catefrances

Byrnzie wrote:

catefrances wrote:

so you think the israelis will just up and abandon their settlements to implement a 2 state solution?

I don't know. I hope so.

why do you hope so?

Byrnzie wrote:

catefrances wrote:

should they be expected to simply because the settlements are illegal under international law...

Yes, unless they wish to continue living in a dangerous rogue state.

if israel-palestine become a single state then to whose advantage would it be to maintain hostilities? by making that comment youre underestimating the palestinians. to me, what you are saying is the palestinians cant get past what has happened in the past and that even if they were a part of a single equitable state that wouldnt be enough.

Byrnzie wrote:

catefrances wrote:

will palestinians living and working in israel be expected to relocate to palestinian territory?

I don't know.

would that be part of your plan, if you support a 2 state solution steve? do you think its reasonable to expect it?

Byrnzie wrote:

catefrances wrote:

can you possibly get past the sins of the past in order that there be a peaceful future?

I think you possibly can.

i do too. i also think for a one state solution to work, its a requirement. otherwise both sides are just gonna be locked in perpetual hatred and people are gonna continue to die.

Byrnzie wrote:

catefrances wrote:

do you think a 2 state plan can be implemented equitably?

Depends what you mean by 'equitably'.

equal rights in all areas. personally i dont think a 2 state plan can be implemented equitably. and that is why i support a 1 state solution. what about you all?