PJ History - Where does MSG 1 and 2 Rank?

Gary Carter

SVRDhand13 wrote:

metsfan wrote:

bootlegger10 wrote:

Philly '05 needs to be on the list. To say that show doesn't rank close to MSG shows is just a biased opinion.

says the man from philly

Talk about bout bias

Pot meet kettle

BeerBaron wrote:

There was a show at this little club in Chicago in 2007 that has to rank somewhere in the top 10. And Philly 4 wasn't even the best Philly show in '09

chicago HOB 05 was way better then chicago 07 vic theater. Chicago 07 is in the top 15. Def not better then DC 95 or orpium(sp) 94.

You can't make a show a top 10 just cause of a setlist. If you do that then beacon theater 08 or showbox 02 or easy street 05 or toledo 04 would make the top 10 lol.

While I enjoyed the Beacon show I don't see how the setlist can get it anywhere near the top 10 shows.

That's the point I was making when I said you can't make a show a top 10 just cause of a setlist. So I threw out a few odd setlist to make a point to beer baron.

Dirtie_Frank

The greatest thing I could think of is that some of the shows you all mention, I have been too.

Besides that every time I leave a Pearl Jam concert I leave impressed. There was a big gap for me seeing them from 2000 to 2005 since I was in the Army, but they seem to always be in great form when I see them. Right now I think that MSG 2 will rank as the greatest show ever....

at least until next time.